SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreGaming

Warhammer 40,000: should Eisenhorn lead Henry Cavill's show?

An Inquisitor who starts out following the rules and slowly breaks them is, in my view, the best way into the grim far future

Alex (AI-assisted)19 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2024 · more than 41,000 subscribers 2,150 words · 10 min read
Warhammer 40,000: should Eisenhorn lead Henry Cavill's show?

I think Henry Cavill's Warhammer adaptation needs to focus on either Gaunt's Ghosts or Eisenhorn, and here I'm making the case for Gregor Eisenhorn. He's an Inquisitor whose career runs from strict rule follower to radical, and his story is the most accessible way I can see to bring newcomers into Warhammer 40,000 without drowning them in war.

Warhammer 40,000 is a huge science fiction universe set in a dark, dangerous far future, where humanity is constantly at war with aliens, mutants and supernatural threats. At the time of writing, Cavill has the job of bringing all of that to life without it flopping. Good luck to him.

Who Gregor Eisenhorn is in Warhammer 40,000

In this world there's a powerful organization called the Inquisition. Think of it like a secret police force mixed with religious investigators. Its job is to protect humanity from anything that could destroy it from within, such as alien influence, forbidden technology and demonic corruption. Eisenhorn is one of these investigators, known as an Inquisitor, and he works in a branch called the Ordo Xenos, which focuses on fighting and studying aliens.

At the start of his career he followed a strict, traditional set of beliefs. He belonged to the Amalathians, a group that believed in preserving the current order of things and avoiding radical change. Over time, as he faced more complicated and terrifying threats, his thinking shifted. He began using some of the forbidden tools and ideas he had once sworn to destroy, particularly those tied to Xanthism, a belief system built on turning dark powers and alien knowledge against their own kind.

That put him at odds with other Inquisitors, and some came to see him as dangerously close to being a heretic, someone who betrays the core beliefs of the Imperium. The Imperium is the massive human empire ruled by the godlike Emperor of Mankind. Eisenhorn has officially been declared a traitor at least twice, but both times it turned out he was doing what he believed was best for humanity, and each time he was eventually cleared and recognized as a loyal servant of the Emperor. In short, he's a space detective priest who starts by following the rules, then gradually bends them as he learns the universe is too complex and too dangerous for simple answers.

Eisenhorn's early years: from the black ship to youngest Inquisitor

As a child, Eisenhorn was taken aboard a black ship, which sounds ominous because it is. The Inquisition uses black ships to collect people with psychic powers from across the galaxy. Most are taken for testing and only a few survive. Those who do are chosen for higher roles, and Eisenhorn was one of them.

He became an acolyte, a kind of apprentice (think Padawan if you're Star Wars inclined), serving an Inquisitor named Hapshant. During his training he studied alongside another future Inquisitor, Titus Endor. By the age of 24, which is incredibly young for such a role, he was promoted to full Inquisitor. His first big mission was to hunt down a heretic, and he succeeded. For a while his career was solid and steady, taking on threats to the Imperium without stepping outside the usual rules.

Pontius Glaw and the Necroteuch set Eisenhorn on a darker path

Things changed when he went after a brutal mass murderer. The case proved far more complicated than expected, and it brought important people into his life: Godwyn Fischig, a tough enforcer, and Alizebeth Bequin, a mysterious woman with unusual abilities. Some readers think there's something romantic between her and Eisenhorn. Either way, both become key members of his team.

The same investigation put him on the trail of two major threats: a powerful heretic named Pontius Glaw, and an ancient forbidden book called the Necroteuch, known to corrupt minds and summon terrible powers. Those leads took him to a secret group of heretics on the planet Gudrun, who were involved in dark rituals and dangerous technology. He was captured and tortured by them, then rescued by another Inquisitor, and a full purge followed. In 40K, a purge is a massive cleansing operation to wipe out heretical groups.

In the aftermath, Eisenhorn recovered a strange device from the cult containing preserved brain patterns, something like a download of a mind. The mind was Pontius Glaw's, and the cult had been trying to bring him back from the dead. This is going very Black Mirror. Instead of destroying it, Eisenhorn kept it and interrogated it for information, eventually handing it to a tech priest of the Adeptus Mechanicus, the powerful, secretive group that handles all advanced technology in the Imperium. Preserving the heretic's essence would come back to haunt him, and it marks the beginning of his slow drift away from strict, traditional methods.

The Necroteuch affair and the arrival of Cherubael

After Gudrun, he was pulled into one of the most dangerous investigations of his career: the infamous affair of the Necroteuch, a terrifying book of forbidden knowledge tied to Chaos. Chaos is the corrupting supernatural force at the heart of many of the universe's worst horrors. Eisenhorn tracked the last members of the heretical group to a remote colony world inhabited by an alien species called the Saruthi, who had obtained a copy of the book and translated it into their own language. That meant two versions now existed, plus a tool to convert between them.

Eisenhorn found and destroyed the High Gothic version. High Gothic is an official ancient language used by the Imperium. Most Inquisitors, especially the traditional Puritans, praised him, but some of the more extreme, rule bending radical Inquisitors accused him of heresy for burning the book, arguing he should have studied it. The Puritan side had more support in the area at the time, so his actions were approved by the majority. Not only was he cleared, he helped plan a full assault on the Saruthi homeworld, where the remaining copies and translation tools were destroyed.

The mission had consequences. During the raid, Eisenhorn encountered Cherubael, a terrifying daemonhost, meaning a person possessed by a demon, created through forbidden rituals. That creature would go on to haunt Eisenhorn and the Imperium for years.

A lost hand and the death of Midas Betancore

The following year, Eisenhorn investigated what looked like ritual murders. He first suspected Chaos worshipers, but the killers were former soldiers of the Astra Militarum, the Imperium's massive human army, driven insane by the horrors of war. With help from the local Adeptus Arbites, essentially futuristic law enforcers, he tracked them to a crumbling abandoned building. In the brutal shootout, he lost his left hand to a former sniper. He refused a mechanical prosthetic and used a fused stump until he could have a new hand grown in a lab two years later. Think Captain Hook, without the hook.

A deeply personal loss followed when his closest friend, a fellow acolyte named Midas Betancore, was killed by a heretic who escaped. Eisenhorn vowed to look after Midas's daughter, and years later she joined his team as his pilot, following in her father's footsteps. That's quite cool.

The hunt for Quixos made Eisenhorn famous, and an outcast

Twenty six years after Betancore's death, Eisenhorn began the investigation that would make him famous across the Imperium: the hunt for Quixos, a once loyal Inquisitor who had gone rogue and started using forbidden powers. It began after the Thracian Primaris Triumph, a supposed Imperial celebration that ended in disaster. It had been a cover for the escape of extremely dangerous alpha plus level psykers, people with psychic powers strong enough to tear holes in reality. Eisenhorn's own apprentice, Gideon Ravenor, was horribly wounded.

Going undercover as mutants, Eisenhorn and his team discovered that members of the Inquisition itself had helped orchestrate the escape. One Inquisitor was even found working alongside Cherubael. That lead took Eisenhorn to Cadia, a heavily fortified key military planet, where he uncovered another daemonhost, Prophaniti, and more evidence tying these creatures to the missing Quixos. Just as he was getting close, Inquisitor Osma arrested him on charges of consorting with demons. He escaped custody but was declared an outcast, no longer recognized by the Inquisition and forced to operate outside the law.

In exile he took refuge with his tech priest ally, a Magos Biologis, continued his secret work and even consulted the trapped mind of Pontius Glaw. He also defeated a Chaos cult on that world and acquired rare master crafted force weapons, powerful tools only usable by trained psykers like himself. Finally, working with three other Inquisitors, he led the charge against Quixos and struck the final blow, killing him, seizing his heretical book and banishing Prophaniti and Cherubael back to the warp, the chaotic dimension demons come from. He was cleared of all charges and welcomed back to the Inquisition, for the moment.

Eisenhorn crosses the line: a sacrifice and Pontius Glaw's revenge

The story didn't stop there. Eisenhorn secretly summoned Cherubael back from the warp to trap and study him, hoping to better understand how to fight Chaos. A decade later he dealt with a small outbreak of demonic activity on Gudrun again. He finally avenged Midas Betancore by killing the heretic responsible, but at a devastating cost. Several team members were killed, Alizebeth was left in a coma, and he lost his personal ship and gun cutter, a smaller transport craft.

Worst of all, in a moment of desperation he chose to use Cherubael as an ally, which meant performing a forbidden Chaos ritual that involved sacrificing a fellow Inquisitor. The one he chose was young, idealistic and innocent. That dark act marked a major turning point and a step toward the very corruption he had once fought.

Soon after, Pontius Glaw escaped and orchestrated a calculated revenge campaign, attacking Eisenhorn's life from every angle. He destroyed his career, killed much of his team and left him seriously injured, and Eisenhorn was again declared an outcast, this time by Osma and Heldane. He called in a favor from Ravenor, by then an Inquisitor himself, and with his help finally destroyed Glaw. But the Pontius affair broke Eisenhorn's last moral barriers. From then on he embraced only radical methods, and he began traveling permanently with Cherubael as a companion in his secret war.

Is Eisenhorn dead? The mystery after his disappearance

After that, Eisenhorn largely disappeared. His outcast status was quietly dropped, but he stayed in the shadows, reappearing only occasionally to recruit new acolytes or warn old allies like Ravenor about looming threats. One was a Chaos cult whose members mentioned that Eisenhorn had confronted them and was inside a building they later bombed. After that, they couldn't detect him with psychic powers anymore. Some believed he died in the blast, but no one really knows for sure. Eisenhorn has always been hard to kill, and in the murky world of the Inquisition, truth is never simple.

Why Eisenhorn is the right entry point for Cavill's Warhammer series

I think what makes him so interesting is that he's a hero who slowly becomes morally gray. He starts with good intentions, wanting to protect the Imperium from Chaos, but ends up making compromises that chip away at his soul. His story explores a key theme in Warhammer 40K: "can you fight monsters without becoming one yourself?"

If you're looking for a way to introduce people to the Warhammer universe without immediately throwing them into galaxy wide wars and armies of super soldiers, I think Eisenhorn is your best bet. At its heart, it's a sci-fi detective story, more space noir than battlefield epic. What makes it such a great entry point, I think, is that it keeps the focus tight. It's one man's story told from the ground level, but through his eyes you glimpse the broader universe and all the weird, grim, fascinating stuff that comes with it. Watching a loyal, disciplined man slowly cross the lines makes for an incredibly compelling character arc, and it eases newcomers into the moral complexity that defines the setting.

The story also gives a natural way to explore many parts of the 40K universe without it being overwhelming: alien species, demonic threats, secretive cults, powerful psychic characters and the Adeptus Mechanicus, plus factions of the Inquisition that range from strict and traditional to dangerously flexible. It's a tour of the setting, seen through the lens of a murder mystery and one man's fall from grace.

Season 1 could adapt Xenos, the first Eisenhorn novel

At the time of writing, I'm hoping it's a show, not a movie, and for a show I think it's perfect. I see it as The Expanse meets Blade Runner, with a bit of The Witcher for that ancient world in space feel. It's gritty and stylish, but also layered and character focused.

I think season 1 could follow the plot of Xenos, the first Eisenhorn novel, starting with a murder investigation and gradually revealing a conspiracy that spans the galaxy. Each episode would bring in a new layer: cults, alien worlds, dark magic, internal power struggles. Because it's all tied to Eisenhorn's personal choices and emotional journey, it would never be one massive lore dump, and audiences would feel connected.

He has a great supporting cast too, and if it works, spinoffs would come easily. There's Ravenor, his former apprentice turned psychic Inquisitor, and Bequin, whose story eventually branches into its own mysterious journey, and the Inquisition is full of characters you could build entire shows around. I think Eisenhorn is Warhammer's version of a smart, gritty, slightly tragic detective series. It keeps things personal, introduces the setting in a way that makes sense, and still leaves room to grow into the terrifying scale that 40K fans love.

What other creators are saying

More on Henry Cavill →
Heavy Spoilers · more than 1.6 million subscribers
A full rundown of who showed up, why it matters to the old Fox movies, and the behind the scenes history behind the biggest surprises

Deadpool & Wolverine cameos: does Chris Evans play Johnny Storm? →

GIQUE · more than 25,000 subscribers
There's no doubt in my mind that Titus, once exiled and presumed dead, will continue to make his mark on the Warhammer 40,000 universe, reclaiming his place among the Ultramarines' greatest heroes.

Space Marine 2: who is Titus and what happened to him? →

Watch the original

@ajm_nerdcore · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Alex's video of 10 May 2025 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Warhammer 40,000EisenhornHenry CavillGregor EisenhornInquisitionPontius GlawCherubaelGideon Ravenor

More from @ajm_nerdcore

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →