SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
TheoryMarvel

Avengers: Doomsday theory: is Tony Stark a Doom variant?

New Empire images, Russo brothers comments on a grieving Victor von Doom, and a case that Tony Stark is the real variant ahead of Avengers: Doomsday

Colton Ogburn (AI-assisted)18 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2014 · more than 80,000 subscribers 1,820 words · 8 min read
Avengers: Doomsday theory: is Tony Stark a Doom variant?

Kevin Feige has seemingly shut down the idea that Robert Downey Jr.'s Doctor Doom is a variant of Tony Stark. I don't think that debunks my biggest theory about Avengers: Doomsday. If anything, I think his comment makes it clearer that the more accurate way to describe what Marvel is doing is that Tony Stark is a variant of Victor von Doom.

While we wait for the next Avengers: Doomsday trailer, Empire magazine has released new images of the film's characters, along with comments from the cast, the Russo brothers and Feige himself. There's a lot in there about Doom, his past and his connection to Tony, so let's go through it.

Empire's Avengers: Doomsday images line up Magneto, Cyclops and Steve Rogers

Before getting into Doom and Tony, I want to appreciate how good these new images are. There's a big lineup of characters. Cyclops looks great, Magneto looks great, and Steve Rogers looks incredible. So does everyone else. I say this all the time, but I genuinely can't believe we're getting this movie, with Ian McKellen's Magneto and Chris Evans' Steve Rogers in the same film.

Some characters who are in Doomsday were missing from the lineup: Mystique, Nightcrawler, Beast, Professor Xavier, Ben Grimm, Johnny Storm, Namor, M'Baku, Ant-Man, the new Falcon, Ghost, John Walker, Alexei and Bob. That's more than a few, but I get it. You can only fit so many characters into one image. I would have thought Xavier would make the cut, though I'm not sure why he didn't.

Pedro Pascal on Reed Richards and Victor von Doom's history

There were many new quotes from the actors, and one that stood out came from Pedro Pascal. He talks about Reed Richards and Victor von Doom and their relationship as scientists, and how having somebody who can match your intellect can create a unique bond. As we know, that can also create a unique rivalry.

I'm glad we're hearing that, because I want this movie to establish that Reed and Victor have a history together. That's a key relationship from the comics, and I know Avengers: Doomsday is going to honor it, even though some have feared it wouldn't.

I also like that it appears the Fantastic Four haven't fought Doctor Doom yet. He isn't one of their rogues. That makes sense, because we didn't see Doom at the start of First Steps, when we got the history of the Fantastic Four. As of this moment before Doomsday, Doom is a friend, and Doomsday will be the first time we see the Fantastic Four and Doom fight.

The Russo brothers say Doom lost a child and is driven by ego

We're also getting a clearer picture of what broke Doom and made him turn bad. Joe Russo confirmed that this version of Victor von Doom has lost a child. So Doom is a father who has experienced a tremendous amount of trauma, and the character is profoundly damaged because of it.

Joe Russo also described Doom as a gothic character, someone with powerful dark magic who isn't above selling his own soul to get what he wants. Anthony Russo made the distinction that Doom is much more driven by his ego than Thanos ever was.

That's what I find interesting when we start comparing Victor von Doom to Tony Stark. Throughout the MCU, Tony became increasingly obsessed with protecting the world. Whether it was creating Ultron, building a suit of armor around the world or trying to prevent another alien invasion, he was constantly trying to solve enormous problems by himself. I think it's fair to say Tony had a big ego.

What Tony Stark and Doctor Doom have in common

Many times, Tony's attempts to protect the world wound up making things worse. I think that's something he and Victor will have in common: their intelligence, their ego, their obsession with controlling the things around them, and an almost pathological need to protect the people they love. We can see that in both characters.

The difference is that Tony ultimately learned to let go and sacrifice himself, to be the one to lie down on the wire, as Steve says. That's something Doom, in most cases, would never do. I think Victor in Doomsday is an example of what happens when somebody with the same kind of personality as Tony simply can't accept loss.

Kevin Feige says Doom is not a Tony Stark variant

Feige was asked about Robert Downey Jr. playing Doctor Doom and whether that means Victor is somehow a variant of Tony Stark. He essentially shut that idea down. He even brought up Chris Evans playing both Johnny Storm and Steve Rogers as an example of how one actor can play two characters without them having to be variants of each other.

To that I say: that's not the same thing. I think Feige is using it as a distraction, and I get why. The Chris Evans Johnny Storm appearance in Deadpool and Wolverine was a gag for a Deadpool movie. Having the man who played Iron Man come in as Doctor Doom, in a sequel to the movie where Iron Man died, to fight the same Avengers Iron Man helped form, is a very different thing.

We've heard the Russos say multiple times that there's a narrative reason for the casting and a duality between these characters. They've played into it in the marketing too, like the trailer moment with Doom holding his arms up, echoing "I am Doom" and "I am Iron Man," and the new post-credits scene for Endgame Encore, which takes the sound of Iron Man clanking at his mask and puts it to Doom making his mask. They know what they're doing.

Why Downey's Doom is Victor von Doom through and through

Feige and the Russos seem to want to make clear something I've been saying for years: Downey's Doom is Victor von Doom through and through. He isn't Tony Stark turned bad or Iron Man turned bad. He's a very comic-accurate Victor von Doom.

I've always been perplexed by the idea that connecting Downey's Doom to Tony across the multiverse would be a disservice to Doctor Doom, or would stop Doom from being Doom. I think that's an inaccurate characterization. This Doom will be 100% Doom from birth. If anyone's character is going to have everything we thought we knew about them change, it's Tony Stark. Even then, I don't think this hurts the character of Doom or Tony Stark.

I know some people will accuse me of coping and refusing to accept what Feige is telling us because I've spent so much time on this theory. You can disagree with me all you want, and I welcome it, but I'll never lie to you. I'm not afraid to admit when I'm wrong, and if I thought my theory was wrong, I'd say so. I've been wrong plenty of times. That's part of the fun of theorizing. But I genuinely believe Tony Stark is a variant of Victor von Doom.

Tony Stark is a variant of Doom, not the other way around

The wording matters here. In the past I've said the difference between "Tony Stark is a Victor von Doom variant" and "Victor von Doom is a Tony Stark variant" was just semantics. But I think Feige's quote makes it clear that saying Tony Stark is a Doctor Doom variant is a far more accurate description of what they're doing.

There's also no way they would reveal that before the movie comes out. They're probably not going to reveal it until Secret Wars. I think in that movie we'll see Downey play Iron Man again and have to cope with the fact that he never was the person he thought he was.

How Vision could help Tony Stark in Secret Wars

I think Tony could then be told by someone like Vision, who just had a master class in dealing with an identity crisis in Vision Quest, that you are who you are. You're a collection of your experiences, your memories, what you've done and what you want to do. Therefore he is Tony Stark, whether he was supposed to be or not, and he is Iron Man.

I think that would be a great conversation to see in Secret Wars. Maybe it happens out in the void. Maybe we see Tony there, knowing he was never supposed to be this and was supposed to be Doctor Doom, and he's falling apart. Then someone like Vision brings him back and he joins the fight against Doom.

My theory: He Who Remains turned Victor von Doom into Tony Stark

My theory has never been that Robert Downey Jr. is playing some evil alternate universe Tony Stark who decided to call himself Doctor Doom. I think this man is Victor von Doom. That's his name, his history and who he has always been. What I've been suggesting, and others have too, is that the Tony Stark we know from Earth 616, the mainline MCU and the Sacred Timeline, was the anomaly, and I think that anomaly was created by He Who Remains, the Kang variant from the Loki series.

He Who Remains created and maintained the Sacred Timeline, which existed separately from the rest of the Marvel multiverse. Within it there are multiple timelines, but they run parallel and follow a very strict story. Outside of it was chaos. As I've theorized before, I think He Who Remains may have deliberately manipulated events to ensure Victor von Doom and Latveria never came into existence in his mini multiverse. If one character in the whole Marvel multiverse could pose a threat to He Who Remains, it was Doctor Doom. So what if he decided the easiest way to protect the Sacred Timeline was to prevent Victor from ever becoming Doom?

Here's where my theory comes in. Howard and Maria Stark were supposed to have a son they would name Tony. I think He Who Remains manipulated events so Maria suffered a miscarriage and the child who would have become Tony was never born. Instead, Howard and Maria adopted a baby who should have become Victor von Doom, who under normal circumstances would have grown up to be Doctor Doom and, I think, would have transformed Sokovia into Latveria. Instead he was raised by the Starks, named Tony, given a completely different environment and opportunities, and became Iron Man. That would mean the man we know as Tony Stark isn't really Tony Stark at all, but a Victor von Doom variant whose life was rewritten before he could become the man he was supposed to be.

How the theory fits the Multiverse Saga's theme

That ties in with the theme of the Multiverse Saga as I see it: you don't have to be what the world tells you to be. I think by the end of Secret Wars we'll see Tony realize he maybe was supposed to become Doctor Doom, but didn't. Even raised by a different family, he could still have gone down that darker path, and with Tony, he almost did. But he decided to pave a different path and become a hero.

You see that theme across the saga. Loki decided he wasn't going to be a villain. Vision decided yes, he is Vision. Sam decided he is Captain America and accepted the shield. Shuri became the Black Panther. The Thunderbolts accepted themselves and became the new Avengers.

Think about how much this could explain, given how similar Tony and Doom are. Both are extraordinarily intelligent men who built advanced suits of armor and are more comfortable behind a mask. Both have enormous egos and a tendency to believe they're the smartest person in the room. Both believe the world needs saving, and more importantly, that they're the ones who need to save it. And for both, their greatest strengths are also their greatest weaknesses.

If my theory is correct, Feige isn't necessarily lying when he says Doctor Doom isn't a Tony Stark variant. To borrow from Obi-Wan Kenobi, what Feige is telling us could be true from a certain point of view. And let's not pretend Kevin Feige and the Russo brothers have never misdirected audiences before.

What other creators are saying

More on Tony Stark →
Chaos · more than 3,000 subscribers
I rank Tony Stark's death in Endgame as the worst in the MCU, mainly because of Morgan and the cheeseburger moment with Happy, though Vision's death hit me harder on rewatch since I already knew Wanda would lose him again.

Worst MCU deaths ranked: why Tony Stark's tops the list →

New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
I predict Doomsday will give us a Doom armor up montage powered by glowing green runes instead of arc reactor tech, a magic heads up display, Doombots resembling the Iron Legion, and a hammering scene echoing Iron Man, possibly teased in the Endgame re-release credits.

Avengers: Doomsday theory: is Doom's task Tony Stark's? →

Everything Always · more than 1 million subscribers
I think Victor von Doom taking Tony Stark's face is likely deliberate manipulation rather than Tony creating a variant, and that Robert Downey Jr. will return as Iron Man in Secret Wars, battling his own Doctor Doom, with Secret Wars serving as the franchise's reboot.

Doctor Doom theory: why does he have Tony Stark's face? →

GIQUE · more than 25,000 subscribers · Snippet
A rifle built to end the Civil War sends this version of Tony Stark into a long downward spiral

How Timely's Tony Stark Went From Greatest Inventor to Town Drunk in Marvel Rivals →

Watch the original

@coltonogburnchannel · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Colton Ogburn's video of 17 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Avengers: DoomsdayDoctor DoomRobert Downey Jr.Tony StarkKevin FeigeRusso BrothersMarvel TheorySecret Wars

More from @coltonogburnchannel

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →