Jake Barber's UAP 'dog whistle': why no public demonstration?
The UAP whistleblower told Ross Coulthart the objects show up every time in broad daylight, so why hasn't anyone staged a public demonstration?
Jake Barber is back, and he's making a bold claim: he told Ross Coulthart that when his team runs what he calls the dog whistle, the objects show up 100% of the time. If that's true, it's extraordinary. But I keep coming back to one question. If you can do this every single time, why isn't the whole world pointing its cameras at the sky while you do it?
For anyone who doesn't know Barber, he's another potential UAP whistleblower Coulthart has talked to. Coulthart did a big exclusive with him on NewsNation. I think the aim was to get the same impact David Grusch had when he came forward. It didn't really work. They talked about the egg-shaped object, and Coulthart showed a clip (Barber didn't release that one himself) that got significant pushback because nobody knew what it was.
Jake Barber tells Ross Coulthart the dog whistle works 100% of the time
Since then, I think Barber appeared at a conference, though I can't remember which one, and I believe he and Jesse Michels went back and forth on some things. I haven't caught up on that. Now he's back talking with Coulthart, and he made an interesting claim about these UAPs and what he can do with them.
Coulthart asked whether the objects come every time they sound the dog whistle, the electromechanical signaling. Barber said he was going to be "very bold" and answered: "100% of the time when we run our operation with the dog whistle, we get results in broad daylight" visible from multiple observation posts.
He also argued that the things they see are so anomalous that they work as their own control. Not only do they fail to appear when the team runs what he described as a technological placebo, he said nobody has seen these things anywhere else. If they weren't responding to the dog whistle, he argued, we'd see phone images from airliners of the jellyfish he says people will be shown. He said this doesn't exist in the public domain, the only exception being the Tic Tac, and of those accounts he said: "Those are not to be dismissed as random events."
The optimistic case: if Barber can summon UAPs, it's a research tool
I want to look at this from both the skeptical side and the optimistic side, so let's start optimistic. Barber had a program running for a while. They looked like they were pushing episodes and shows that were coming out, and I don't know why it went under, but it did.
If they can do what they say they can do, then this is extraordinary, because they'd have the data and the knowledge that comes with it. When they first launched, I saw one clip where they appeared to be doing exactly what he describes: running tests over and over and summoning these craft, or whatever they were. I think that was one where Garry Nolan was present. If they can do that, it becomes a significant asset.
The other thing that stands out is that they're now talking about this openly, going on news programs and explaining what they can do. Barber isn't alone. I think Bledsoe and other people have talked about how they were able to do these types of things. Having that tool, and someone who can use it, could be beneficial for the research overall: finding out what these things are, where they come from, how they do what they do and, as Barber mentioned with the Tic Tac data, what exactly we're dealing with.
The skeptical case: why not invite NewsNation, CNN and Fox News to film it?
Now the skeptical side. If you can do this and you can prove it, why did the clips stop? Why aren't there more of them? Why doesn't Coulthart say, "I'm going to get a NewsNation team out. I'm going to come with you and do it"? If it works 100% of the time, there should be no problem getting the best images possible.
I'd go further. If you can do this 100% of the time, you call in every favor you have with the media: NewsNation, CNN, Fox News, everyone. You tell them you're going to put on a display and settle this. Everybody point your very valuable cameras into the sky and be ready. Make it a big event, and put the speculation and the grainy images to rest.
The fact that this doesn't happen is the side of it where I think, okay, it's more talk. And I think the problem is that everything in this space is more talk.
Why clear evidence matters: the kite problem
A recent case shows exactly what I mean. I looked at a clip people were talking about, and many people said it was a kite. They might have been right. It's a very good possibility. Other people then put together kite images that looked similar.
My point with all this is about clear-cut evidence, the kind that lets you say it's not a kite, this is a metal object, it's moving this way, it's too far away. And here's someone saying he can do this 100% of the time.
I come at this as a casual observer from the outside, following the stories that are going around. I don't want to ignore what the mainstream media neglects, because if I got my news only from them, I'd know nothing about this topic. So I don't know how Barber is perceived by the people who dig into this every day. When he first came out, everyone was taking him pretty seriously.
Where Barber lands next to David Grusch and Stratton
There are names where, when you hear them, you think, let's hear what they're going to say next. To me, that was Grusch. Since I'm not as locked into this as some people, I don't even know how Grusch is perceived anymore. He's going to be seen as a genius or a prophet of some sort if everything he said on Joe Rogan's show comes true. There's no doubt about that. But there are many wild claims out there, and I think in the follow-up even Rogan wasn't completely sold on everything he said. Still, Grusch seems to be the one where people ask what he said next.
Jay Stratton was always the other one I was curious to hear from, especially with his new book, which I haven't gotten yet but probably will soon. Apparently Stratton was asked to testify in front of Congress and said no. I know people have answers for why. I don't know how long ago that was. But if it was recent and he's still saying no while they're offering whistleblower protection and making sure he's taken care of, then I don't know how much I'm going to listen to him anymore. That's an issue. If none of that protection is on offer, then it's the same old dance and nothing has moved forward.
So Grusch and Stratton are the ones people listen to, alongside figures like Jesse Michels. Where does Barber land on that scale? When someone says they can summon these things 100% of the time, my instinct is to skip the sit-down interview. Let's go outside, summon them and show me. I'll take my iPhone out and we'll get the images ourselves.
I'm sure the answer would be that they have tons of it. But that's always the answer: it exists, but you're not going to see it. Barber isn't the only person to say he can potentially summon these things, and if that's really the case, I want to know what it means. It's frustrating and fascinating.
What other creators are saying
More on Jake Barber →I think Burlison reportedly hiring Jake Barber after Grusch is a disaster that sets the investigation backwards, and I suspect Barber's team was behind the odd RFK Jr. UAP story. I've lost confidence in government disclosure and now back citizen and scientific disclosure instead.
A conversation about UFOs raises the idea that science as an institution faces an embargo on investigating them.
Watch the original
@downtoearthkh · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Down To Earth With Kristian Harloff's video of 12 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @downtoearthkh
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

