SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreMarvel

Iron Man casting: how Nicolas Cage and Tom Cruise nearly led

From Universal and Fox to New Line and finally Marvel itself, the 2008 film passed through Nicolas Cage, Tom Cruise, Quentin Tarantino and Joss Whedon before Jon Favreau landed his star.

New Rockstars (AI-assisted)17 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2011 · more than 4.4 million subscribers 1,560 words · 7 min read
Iron Man casting: how Nicolas Cage and Tom Cruise nearly led

Iron Man nearly didn't happen the way we remember it. It spent more than a decade bouncing between studios, stars and directors, and Marvel finally made it by betting other characters as collateral. Iron Man (2008), starring Robert Downey Jr., Gwyneth Paltrow and Jeff Bridges, is definitely in the top five most important movies to revisit before Downey's return.

As of February 2026, Downey was set to come back to the Marvel Cinematic Universe as Victor von Doom in Avengers: Doomsday. The marketing for that film centered on the phrase "new mask, same task." That makes this a good moment to figure out what this man's original task was. Downey's performance as Tony Stark gave the MCU the backbone and the edge it needed 18 years ago. Even his famous ad-libbed line, "I am Iron Man," came back in Tony's final breaths in Avengers: Endgame.

Jessica Clemons joined me to go back through it. She admitted she didn't know anything about how the film was made. The source I'd recommend is our friend Joanna Robinson's book with Gavin Edwards and Dave Gonzales, MCU: The Reign of Marvel Studios. Its chapter on Iron Man is fascinating.

Iron Man started at Universal, then went to Fox and Nicolas Cage

An Iron Man movie was in development at Universal Studios in the early 1990s, with Re-Animator director Stuart Gordon attached. The idea drew laughs in our conversation. One suggestion was that this version would have made Tony a nerdy, Peter Parker type rather than someone cool. My feeling was that an early '90s take would have landed closer to armored suit films of that era like Steel or Star Kid. Another suggestion in our conversation was that it would have felt a little like Power Rangers.

Part of why this project could have been so unusual is that Iron Man was considered one of Marvel's lesser known characters. The first Marvel films to get made were properties like X-Men and Spider-Man. Then in 1996, Marvel was facing bankruptcy and sold off the rights to its bigger characters to other studios. Iron Man went to Fox along with the X-Men and the Fantastic Four.

Fox tried to develop an Iron Man film first with Nicolas Cage in 1997. By then he was an action movie star, after films like Con Air and The Rock. I think it could have worked; it just would have been a different movie. The other view in the discussion was that Cage lacks the swagger Downey has. I also floated the idea that a late '90s version might have kept Tony's Vietnam origin, and that a gearhead Cage, who went on to make Gone in 60 Seconds, could have had a lot of fun with the role.

Tom Cruise wanted to produce and star in a Fox Iron Man

The following year, Tom Cruise came onto the scene, expressing interest in both producing and starring in the movie. This was Cruise after the first Mission: Impossible, and after The Firm, Days of Thunder and Top Gun. You could totally imagine him crushing the role. The reaction in our conversation was that he would have been great, though there was also some relief he didn't get it, since we might not have gotten the rest of the Mission: Impossible films.

Instead he went on to Mission: Impossible 2, and that had a ripple effect. Dougray Scott, the villain in that film, was originally going to play Wolverine. He wanted to leave production early to go play the part for Fox, and Cruise wanted him to stay on his movie in Sydney. That's how Hugh Jackman became Wolverine.

In this Fox version, Stan Lee and Jeff Vintar were working on a story, and MODOK would have been the villain. That idea got a firm no in our discussion. The visual effects of the time weren't at a point where MODOK would have looked good at all.

Quentin Tarantino was approached to write and direct in October 1999

In October 1999, Quentin Tarantino was approached to write and direct Iron Man. This was after Jackie Brown and before Kill Bill. It reminds me of the idea of Tarantino doing Star Trek. It's weird to imagine him as a franchise guy, because he does his own revisionist history kind of thing. The thought in the discussion was that he would have hated having so many people telling him what to do.

There's a pattern here, though. Many of these people went on to make car movies. Tarantino did Death Proof after this. So all of them could have made a version of this movie that works. I think it just would have been very weird.

New Line brought in Joss Whedon and the Nick Fury cameo

In December 1999, Fox decided it didn't need Iron Man alongside X-Men and everything else, and sold the rights to New Line. New Line already had the Blade films; it had done the first and was working on the second. It brought in Ted Elliott, Terry Rossio and Tim McCanlies for a new draft. McCanlies is the one who brought in the idea of Nick Fury cameoing at the end to set up a bigger franchise, and that idea stayed with the project in every version after. This was before Samuel L. Jackson, so it would have been the David Hasselhoff looking Nick Fury.

In June 2001, Joss Whedon was attached to direct. He had already done punch-ups on X-Men, had written Marvel comics, was known for Buffy and its spin-off Angel, and was a script doctor everyone loved.

David Hayter's draft brought in Pepper Potts and the Mandarin

New Line then hired a new writing team: David Hayter, David S. Goyer and Mark Protosevich. Hayter had the sole writing credit on 2000's X-Men, and Goyer wrote and would later direct the Blade movies. These were the guys doing Marvel movies at the time. It was Hayter's draft that brought in Pepper Potts, and his pitch to use the Mandarin as the villain. Howard Stark would have been in the movie and would have become War Machine.

The reaction in our conversation was that every option except Pepper Potts was bad, and that Howard as War Machine meant another father villain arc. The point I raised was that, looking at the comics then, the Mandarin is Iron Man's biggest arch villain. Ultron, Thanos and Kang are Avengers villains. For an Iron Man solo villain you have the Mandarin, Whiplash and a few others. The counterpoint was to save the Mandarin for a sequel and open with a business partner selling Tony's weapons to the other side. They ended up making all the right choices.

Marvel took Iron Man back and put up Black Panther and Doctor Strange as collateral

In 2004, New Line wanted Nick Cassavetes to direct, aiming for a 2006 release, but the deal fell through. After about 10 years without an Iron Man movie, the rights reverted to Marvel. By then David Maisel was chief operating officer of Marvel Studios, and he was advocating for the company to stop licensing characters to other studios and make films itself. So Marvel started over.

Kevin Feige, Jon Favreau and Avi Arad had met while working on 2003's Daredevil. Favreau was the guy from Swingers. He directed Elf, which didn't have the biggest opening but became a huge hit on DVD, then Zathura, which came out in 2005, punched above its weight and showed he could make a spectacle movie. Marvel made Iron Man its first independent, self financed feature, with Paramount distributing.

To fund it, Marvel took a loan of $525 million from Merrill Lynch, and had to put up other properties like Black Panther and Doctor Strange as collateral. Those weren't the only ones. If Iron Man had not hit, Feige would have lost everything. I guess he would still have had Sony with Spider-Man and Fox with X-Men and Fantastic Four to fall back on. It shows what you have to do in Hollywood to have a hit: you've got to bet big.

Iron Man's script was merged from two writing rooms

The scariest part is that Feige wasn't betting on a script he loved. I think that's why Marvel would later get heat for starting to shoot without a finished script. Here they had to say yes to the project first. They assembled about 30 writers to come up with story ideas, then settled on two teams: Mark Fergus and Hawk Ostby in one room, Art Marcum and Matt Holloway in another. Favreau went back and forth between rooms, taking elements from both and merging them. I don't know how you write a screenplay that way.

One guess raised in the discussion was that one team wrote the business partner betrayal story and the other wrote Tony as a hostage realizing he was the monster all along, which would be easy enough to combine. I will also say the story structure isn't that innovative; it's a color by numbers origin story. What works are the sequences: previs, the work with Stan Winston, and Downey's hook on the character.

Favreau also had help from John August, who had written Big Fish and the Charlie's Angels movies and hosts the podcast Scriptnotes with Craig Mazin. We don't know exactly what August did; he didn't get a screenplay credit, but he got paid. Drafts at this stage updated Tony's Vietnam origin to Afghanistan, and one unused idea made Tony the creator of Otto Octavius's arms from Spider-Man 2. That's so cool to me, and in my head, those movies still connect.

Clive Owen was the studio's top choice for Tony Stark

Feige said Clive Owen was the studio's top choice. Owen was offered the project but wasn't interested, and did Children of Men instead. The point made in our conversation was that Owen was on a roll during the 2000s, much like Keira Knightley around Pirates of the Caribbean, when studios wanted those people in everything.

Ryan Reynolds, fresh off Van Wilder, was in the mix of that era too. He might have been on someone's radar for Iron Man, but I think he was still seen as too young, even with a beard as Hannibal King in Blade: Trinity. Matthew McConaughey also came up, and was judged an easy fit in the discussion, though he was busy with other projects.

Jon Favreau leaked that he wanted Robert Downey Jr.

Around 2006, Downey met with Favreau, who knew this was his guy. Downey was on a career comeback after Shane Black's Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, which is so, so good. The industry had wondered whether it could rely on him, but he was transcendent in that role and seemed to be making the right moves. Favreau said: "The best and worst moments of Robert's life have been in the public eye. He had to find an inner balance to overcome obstacles that went far beyond his career. That's Tony Stark." I couldn't have put it better myself.

Marvel executives opposed the choice, so Favreau leaked that he was looking at Downey. Fans and the press were so positive that the studio had to go with it. What a choice to make.

From $500,000 on Iron Man to a tenth of a billion for Doomsday

Downey was paid only $500,000 for Iron Man. That figure drew surprise in our conversation, given the cast around him, and the guess was that Jeff Bridges was probably the most expensive. I think Downey jumped to $10 million for Iron Man 2. For Doomsday and Secret Wars, he was making a tenth of a billion dollars.

The closing thought in the discussion was how secure Downey is going back into the MCU, even as a different character, and that he owns this franchise.

What other creators are saying

More on Nicolas Cage →
Heavy Spoilers · more than 1.6 million subscribers
The author argues that a hidden InGen cabinet logo technically places Face/Off within the Jurassic Park universe, and thinks the studio's objection to Sean adopting Castor's son as un-American was a stupid argument.

Face/Off secrets: is the movie set in the Jurassic Park universe? →

Breakdowns & Blockbusters · more than 240,000 subscribers
From Bob Gale's 1980s script to David Goyer's horror take and a Neil Gaiman pitch, Doctor Strange spent decades in development before reaching the screen

Doctor Strange: why Bob Gale's 1980s script never got made →

The Witching Hour · more than 28,000 subscribers
Ten hidden devil cameos, a count that falls short of the more than 15 Neon's marketing teased, and why I think the man downstairs is staging an opera aimed at American law enforcement

Longlegs hidden devils: why are there only 10, not 15? →

Chaos · more than 3,000 subscribers
A finished script, the original director, and hopes of a returning cast finally make the long-rumored threequel feel real, and one theory about the mystery of page 47 could change what we thought Ben Gates has been doing for the last 20 years.

National Treasure 3: does page 47 show Ben Gates kept hunting? →

Watch the original

@newrockstars · YouTube

Adapted with AI from New Rockstars' video of 18 February 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Iron ManRobert Downey Jr.Marvel Cinematic UniverseJon FavreauAvengers: DoomsdayKevin FeigeTom CruiseNicolas Cage

More from @newrockstars

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →