Avengers: Doomsday cameo fest? Screen time math says no
Lewis Pullman said every character gets a moment, and screen time estimates from recent Marvel crossovers suggest the Russo brothers aren't to blame for the cameo fest trend.
Was Avengers: Doomsday shaping up to be a cameo fest or a large ensemble story? A statement from Lewis Pullman, who plays Bob Reynolds, the Sentry, reassured me about how the Russo brothers were balancing the film. After running the screen time numbers on recent Marvel crossovers, my conclusion is that the Russos, whatever you want to say about them as filmmakers, aren't really to blame for the cameo fest trend.
That raises a bigger question about superhero crossovers. Where's the line between a film that leans on nostalgia and familiar faces to excite fans while adding no narrative weight, and one that gets accused of it without deserving the label?
Lewis Pullman says Avengers: Doomsday gives every character a moment
Pullman was profiled by Esquire and asked about returning as Bob Reynolds in Avengers: Doomsday. His Thunderbolts team, also known as the New Avengers, will definitely be in the film. Esquire described him as part of the film's sprawling cast and wrote that, despite that vast cast, Doomsday is not just a cameo fest.
"Every character has their moment that builds the dimensions of them," Pullman told the magazine. He added that the Russo brothers "do not want anyone just sitting in the background" and took seriously the responsibility of having some of the best actors in the world together. "There's a lot of really exciting pair-ups that happen," he said, describing how fans would get to see what happens when characters they dreamed of pairing finally work together.
The term cameo fest came from the writer of the article, not from Pullman himself. It seems to be a paraphrase based on the question they asked him. Either way, it's the sentiment Pullman was addressing.
Doomsday teasers and set photos pointed to mixed teams
While Avengers: Doomsday will likely have some cameos, structurally the Russos are building it to mix and match the bigger names to produce different character combinations, chemistries and alignments. We could already see some of that in the marketing and production photos.
In the fourth teaser, Shuri and M'Baku meet Ben Grimm of the Fantastic Four. The Thunderbolts post-credit scene, which the Russos shot to be part of Doomsday, shows the Thunderbolts witnessing someone piloting a new version of the Fantastic Four ship. Production photos from Bahrain suggest Ebon Moss-Bachrach's Ben Grimm shares the set with the Wakandans, characters from Talokan, and Wyatt Russell's John Walker.
On the X-Men side, Alan Cumming and Kelsey Grammer talked in interviews about sharing the set with Pedro Pascal. Thor also seems to be headed to the TVA, based on a social media post from his stunt double on a set with the TVA logo on the floor. And when Collider interviewed the cast of Fantastic Four: First Steps, they said the Baxter Building set was spruced up for Doomsday, with a seating area big enough for other Marvel actors, and that familiar 616 universe characters would be sitting there with them.
What a cameo fest is, and the Marvel films accused of being one
I still think there's skepticism in the film commentary community over whether Doomsday, by recasting Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom, could come close to righting the wrongs of the era that community dubbed Marvel fatigue. There's concern Marvel Studios might still try to cash in with the same cheap tricks critics blame for that malaise.
So I think it's important to define the term. A cameo fest is a franchise film that heavily markets itself as a crossover event in which several surprise characters appear for a short time with limited narrative impact. It may still have a grounded emotional through line, but the central marketing appeal is: who's going to show up?
Non MCU franchises have done this too, from the 2023 Flash film to Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse. But the MCU films since Avengers: Endgame most accused of being cameo fests are 2024's Deadpool & Wolverine, 2022's Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness and 2021's Spider-Man: No Way Home.
How the Oscars and Emmys separate a cameo from a supporting role
A cameo is an appearance limited to one scene or less, by a well known person or someone playing a well known character. A supporting role is a more expanded part that serves the narrative, just less important to the plot than the lead.
Somewhat surprisingly, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has no clear distinction between lead and supporting roles. Films will often use that vagueness to strategically submit leading actors from ensembles as supporting to try for an extra win. Over the years, actors like Judi Dench in Shakespeare in Love and Viola Davis in Doubt were awarded or nominated for performances that, while incredible, had very limited screen time.
The Emmys do separate supporting actors from featured or guest actors, who have very limited roles over a couple of episodes, often Saturday Night Live guest hosts. In 2024 and 2025, the rules were updated so guest or featured actors must appear in less than 50% of a season's eligible episodes and have at least 5% standalone, contiguous screen time. That came up with Sam Rockwell, whose White Lotus season 3 episodes fell on the wrong side of the submission deadline, leaving him ineligible. I think these numbers give a good range: a cameo is someone in less than 5% of the overall narrative, especially when that time is spread across scenes that don't serve the story.
Deadpool & Wolverine and Multiverse of Madness qualify by the numbers
These figures measure how much of a film's edit features a character on screen, using estimates assembled by fans on Reddit and Tumblr. Deadpool & Wolverine runs 127 minutes. Deadpool was on screen for 72 of them, or 56.7%. Wolverine got 48 minutes, or 37.8%, though that number seems to lump in some Wolverine variants. Mr. Paradox had 13.5 minutes, or 10.6%, and Cassandra Nova had 13 minutes, or 10.2%.
Every other character was on screen for 5 minutes or less, under 5% of the film. That includes memorable cameos like Chris Evans as Johnny Storm and Wesley Snipes as Blade, even though they appeared in multiple scenes. I think it's safe to say a film with that many X-Men B players hanging out in the background, or Deadpool variants crowding a street, qualifies as a cameo fest. The percentages never add up to 100 because characters share the screen; each is measured against total runtime.
Multiverse of Madness runs 126 minutes. Rintrah and Sara may have seemed bigger than Bruce Campbell's Pizza Poppa, but their scenes were very short, and Rintrah was a visual effect, so many shots lasted 5 to 10 seconds. Campbell's comedic bits, especially in the post-credit scene, used up more time. And when the 838 universe Illuminati got wiped out before any of them reached more than 2.4% of the runtime, that's a cameo fest too.
Screen time matters less than whether a character has an arc
I think more important than screen time is how the script uses it. The rule that matters more: does the character have their own arc? Are they there to get a cheer and then be killed off, or do they change, learn and grow?
Under that test, an argument can certainly be made for Laura, X-23, in Deadpool & Wolverine, as a catalyst for Wolverine's growth. An argument could be made for Professor X in Multiverse of Madness too, though I'm sure many critics would argue the contrary for both.
Why I don't think it's fair to call Spider-Man: No Way Home a cameo fest
Many called No Way Home a cameo fest, but I'm not sure it is. Of its 148 minutes, Tom Holland's Peter Parker was on screen for 72 minutes and 26 seconds, or 48.9%. MJ and Ned came next. Andrew Garfield's Peter Parker was in the film about a minute longer than Doctor Strange, who was only 30 seconds ahead of Tobey Maguire's Peter. The scenes with the three Peters on the rooftop, in the science lab and on the scaffolding added up to a lot of time together.
Doc Ock and Electro had more screen time than Willem Dafoe's Norman Osborn because both had scenes when Peter captured them and longer scenes with their own Peters at the Statue of Liberty in the final act. The takeaway is that Dafoe got that much mileage out of about 4 minutes and 45 seconds. In retrospect, I think he deserved Oscar consideration.
I don't think it's fair at all to put No Way Home in the same sentence as the other two. Andrew's and Tobey's characters have arcs and huge sections of screen time, and the returning heroes and villains appear throughout, many with arcs of their own. The only true cameos are Matt Murdock and, in the post-credit scene, Eddie Brock.
Civil War, Infinity War and Endgame spread screen time across the ensemble
The Russos' big crossovers are Captain America: Civil War at 147 minutes, Avengers: Infinity War at 149 and Avengers: Endgame at 181. All three show a far more even distribution of screen time. Over half the cast has a share of 5% or more, and in Civil War and Infinity War it's the top two thirds. Endgame drops off more only because half its big names were dusted for most of the film.
When it comes to cameo fests, the numbers don't lie: the Russo brothers aren't to blame. If anything, they've proven the most effective at balancing dozens of characters whose roles amount to somewhat distinct arcs. This isn't a knock on Sam Raimi or Shawn Levy. It's that those particular films, in how the studio constructed and marketed them, are the worst offenders.
What this meant for Avengers: Doomsday
Steve Rogers appeared in the first teaser, and I expected him to be in a lot of the film, not just a cameo. Anthony Russo said as much in Empire, talking about Chris Evans "retaining his role moving forward." Given what Pullman said, I didn't expect one team versus another. The teams would mix, new pairings would happen, and that's where the magic would be: Ben Grimm with John Walker or Red Guardian, Reed Richards with Hank McCoy, Susan Storm with Shuri, and a very creepy alignment of Doctor Strange and Doctor Doom.
I also didn't think there would be many surprise cameos. The Russos and their effects team loved putting Howard the Duck in the background of Endgame and an Arrested Development blue man in the background of Infinity War, but those are the kind of cameos they like. Rather, I think the surprises are going to come in what these characters do with each other, and what they do to each other.
What other creators are saying
More on Russo Brothers →I believe Avengers: Doomsday and Secret Wars cannot fail because the Russos only returned once their story idea clicked, putting storytelling above fan service, and Feige let them rebuild from scratch. I hope I'm right.
Russo Brothers: why they only returned for Avengers: Doomsday →
The Russos marked one year until release with a countdown clock that briefly spells out doomsday, and I don't think it pointed to a surprise drop.
Avengers: Doomsday Countdown Teaser Hides the Film's Title in Its Clock →
I'm not fully sold on this leak, but I find it fun and it matches my longtime theory that Doom isn't trying to win the final battle, just stall across three locations while the multiverse collapses so he can build Battleworld and reset everyone.
Avengers: Doomsday leak: where does Doom's final battle happen? →
I think these Encore scenes, especially the TVA one, set up Doomsday heavily: Doom is gathering Avengers like Thanos gathered stones but bigger than the Gauntlet, he's somehow colliding universes, and with the multiverse collapsing I think we're in for a lot of loss before Secret Wars.
Doomsday setup: why is Doctor Doom collecting Bruce Banner? →
Watch the original
@newrockstars · YouTube
Adapted with AI from New Rockstars' video of 12 March 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @newrockstars
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

