SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreMarvel

Kevin Feige and Amy Pascal's lunch: how Spider-Man joined the MCU

A book on Marvel Studios recounts the pitch that ended Sony's plans for The Amazing Spider-Man 3 and led to a shared Spider-Man

The Cosmic Wonder (AI-assisted)15 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2018 · more than 990,000 subscribers 1,010 words · 5 min read
Kevin Feige and Amy Pascal's lunch: how Spider-Man joined the MCU

A book called The Story of Marvel Studios: The Making of the Marvel Cinematic Universe drew a lot of attention when it came out, because it tells how Kevin Feige, the president of Marvel Studios, went over to Sony and got Spider-Man into the MCU. That story runs from Captain America: Civil War to Spider-Man: Homecoming, Spider-Man: Far From Home and Spider-Man: No Way Home. As far as I'm concerned, Feige is a legend for it.

Feige didn't only get Spider-Man into the MCU. He made it so Spider-Man would shape the MCU's future. At the time, the hype for No Way Home was off the charts, and I put that down to Kevin Feige. I hoped the possibility of Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield showing up in the film was all thanks to this story, and I hoped, fingers crossed, that it would be the start of the true Spider-Verse.

Sony planned The Amazing Spider-Man 3 before Kevin Feige stepped in

At that point, Marvel Studios couldn't use Spider-Man in the MCU because it had zero rights to him. Sony was also making its own Spider-Man films with Andrew Garfield, and it planned a third Amazing Spider-Man with Garfield still in the role. Depending on your view of The Amazing Spider-Man series, we have Kevin Feige to either thank or blame that we never got that third film.

According to the book, Sony had big plans for The Amazing Spider-Man franchise. Then The Amazing Spider-Man 2 flopped, and the studio didn't know what to do. Sony was in something of a panic, especially since it had many spin-offs in its Spider-Man universe in the works. Meanwhile, Feige and Marvel Studios were dominating the box office with the MCU, and fans loved their movies. After The Amazing Spider-Man 2, Sony decided it wanted to be as big as the MCU, so Amy Pascal, a producer and chairperson at Sony's motion picture group, called Feige in.

Kevin Feige told Amy Pascal "it's not gonna work"

The book sets the scene this way: "with a good sense of how they would like to handle the character feige was ready for his lunch with pascal what he wasn't ready for was pascal's reaction to his proposal." The meeting took place in Pascal's office at Sony. As expected, she wasted no time in saying she wanted Feige to be more directly involved creatively in The Amazing Spider-Man 3. She was excited about the ideas her team had and said she'd send him the latest draft.

About halfway through the sandwich she'd brought in, Feige turned her down. In his words from the book: "I said amy in all fairness it's not gonna work." He added that they had sort of done that before and that he didn't think he was particularly helpful there. What Pascal didn't know was that Feige had plans of his own for Spider-Man, just not in Sony's universe. He wanted him in the MCU.

Feige pitched Marvel Studios to Sony the way DC used Christopher Nolan

Feige wasn't done. He had a counter proposal: "the only way i know how to do anything is to just do it entirely so why don't you let us do it." He told Pascal not to think of it as two studios or as giving another studio back the rights, with no money changing hands. Sony would simply engage Marvel Studios to produce the film.

He compared it to what DC did with Christopher Nolan. In the book Feige says: "i'm not saying we're nolan but i am saying there is a production company that is doing this pretty well." The production company he meant, obviously, was Marvel Studios.

Amy Pascal's first reaction to Feige's Spider-Man proposal

Pascal was taken aback. She was surprised, and then she got upset. She admits in the book: "at first i was super resentful." She goes on: "i think i started crying and threw him out of my office or threw a sandwich at him i'm not sure which."

Then she started to think it through. Looking back on where Sony's films stood, Pascal is candid: "by the 5th spider-man movie we weren't giving them anything new." She says the studio was trying so hard to be different that it went places it shouldn't have, and that "we weren't fresh anymore."

Why Amy Pascal trusted Kevin Feige with Peter Parker

Pascal says the lucky thing is that she and Feige come from the same place in how they love Peter. She'd worked with him on Spider-Man movies since Sam Raimi's. According to Pascal, Feige would come to the meetings, get everybody coffee and never say a word for years. She says that makes you love somebody, because when they do open their mouth, you realize they've been thinking all the big thoughts the whole time.

Pascal called Feige back the day after their lunch. The idea of a collaboration between Sony and Marvel Studios hadn't left her mind. After hearing his specific thoughts for Spider-Man in the MCU, she says putting him up against a world where everybody had everything and he had nothing "was a whole new way of telling his story," and she came away thinking Feige was smart. He is very smart; he's the president of Marvel Studios. I think everybody could probably agree that Spider-Man in the MCU is way better than anything Sony could have produced on its own.

From Captain America: Civil War to Spider-Man: No Way Home

From there, Marvel Studios brought Spider-Man into the MCU gently, introducing him in Captain America: Civil War. It was a brief appearance, but an iconic one. Then came Homecoming, Far From Home and No Way Home, which at the time I thought could have more hype than Avengers: Endgame. I saw Endgame something like ten times in theaters.

Spider-Man helped shape the MCU, being one of the most popular characters of all time, if not the most popular. The whole concept of the multiverse shines when it comes to Spider-Man, because it opens up the Spider-Verse. No Way Home was bringing back old villains from the other universes, and I thought that alone was enough for a ton of people to want to go see it.

That's the story of how Kevin Feige went over to Sony and got Spider-Man into the MCU. What a legend. Thank you, Kevin Feige, and thank you, Sony, for doing what you thought was best for the character.

What other creators are saying

More on Kevin Feige →
Beyond The Trailer · more than 930,000 subscribers
I suspect Feige revealed Wanda's return partly to change the conversation away from DC and to boost lagging Doomsday ticket sales, and the uncorroborated rumor of 60,000 extra tickets sold in 48 hours fits that theory. I'm using Endgame's total sellout as my measuring stick for whether Doomsday matches it.

Wanda's MCU return: did it sell 60,000 Doomsday tickets? →

Everything Always · more than 1 million subscribers
I don't buy the Kang Dynasty bait and switch theory Feige describes. I think Marvel's plan to set up Doom midway through a film still titled The Kang Dynasty, after Kang had already been defeated twice, would have been one of the studio's worst catastrophes, and I'm glad circumstances stopped it.

Avengers: Doomsday: was a Kang to Doom switch ever planned? →

New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
I think the Doomsday trailer shot shows Johnny Storm shielding Franklin Richards, probably near the film's climax during a three way incursion, and that Franklin may later transform Johnny into a living sun to save him. I believe Feige's comments point toward Secret Wars rebuilding the MCU around a long, carefully planned Mutant Saga.

Avengers: Doomsday trailer: is Johnny Storm shielding Franklin? →

Breakdowns & Blockbusters · more than 240,000 subscribers · Snippet
Marvel's notes on the Andrew Garfield sequel covered too many storylines, a cartoonish Rhino and a high school problem

Why Kevin Feige Hated The Amazing Spider-Man 2, and Why Sony Ignored Him →

Watch the original

@thecosmicwonder · YouTube

Adapted with AI from The Cosmic Wonder's video of 23 October 2021 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Kevin FeigeAmy PascalSpider-ManMarvel StudiosSonyMCUThe Amazing Spider-Man 3Spider-Man: No Way Home

More from @thecosmicwonder

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →