SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreGaming

Horus Heresy vs 40k: why lapsed players are switching

Vehicle armor, blast templates and a grounded war story are pulling returning Warhammer fans 10,000 years into the past, but there are catches worth knowing first

Alex (AI-assisted)17 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2024 · more than 41,000 subscribers 1,507 words · 7 min read
Horus Heresy vs 40k: why lapsed players are switching

Many of you have been telling me the same thing lately: you're getting back into Warhammer, but you're skipping 40k and heading straight for the Horus Heresy. Same universe, 10,000 years earlier. So what's dragging everyone over there: nostalgia, the rules or the setting, and to figure out who Heresy is worth a look for. Games Workshop has also announced two Heresy Christmas boxes, and I know which one I'd pick.

It started with someone telling me one of their favorite memories from the 90s was when tanks had different armor on the front, the side and the back. They'd spend 20 minutes crouched at table height arguing over whether a shot hit side armor. If you played 40k years ago, you probably remember all that. If you've come back recently, you'll have noticed it's gone. So what if the Warhammer you remember never went anywhere?

What the Horus Heresy is, and why lapsed players are turning to it

One comment stuck with me: "I dropped 40k years ago, but Horus Heresy completely reignited my passion for Warhammer."

For anyone who has never had it explained, here's the quick version. The Emperor is busy conquering the galaxy with his Space Marine Legions, led by his sons, the Primarchs. There were 20 of them. Then Horus, his favorite, decides to betray him. Half the Legions go with him, and the whole galaxy descends into probably the worst family argument in human history. It makes your in-laws look quite civilized.

I've read the Horus Heresy books, and I've collected Blood Angels. I only got round to the Siege of Terra last Christmas, which tells you how long the rest took. That series is a bookshelf. I'm curious how many of you came in through the books, and how many found it through the tabletop or lore content instead.

Horus Heresy rules feel like older editions of 40k

I think the tabletop game is different to modern 40k. In 40k you've got Orks, Necrons, Tyranids and everything else trying to kill each other, whereas Heresy is Space Marine Legions trying to kill other Space Marine Legions, which to be fair is the entire plot. You get classic tanks, huge armies and rules that have a lot in common with older editions of 40k.

That brings me to something I kept hearing from returning players. Quite a few of you said Heresy feels like the Warhammer you remember. Then I found one from someone who started with 10th edition 40k and had never seen a template in their life. When Heresy 3rd edition came out, they moved over completely. What they loved was vehicle armor, blast templates, flamers and character duels. So newer players are finding the older stuff and preferring it, which is a bit like being born in 2005 and getting really into fax machines.

Loads of you also mentioned Dawn of War, Tactical Squads, Rhinos and those classic firstborn Marines. One of you said you can't imagine a tank without tracks, which I think is a reasonable position to hold on tanks.

Vehicle armor facings, reactions and points for every upgrade

The models are only half of it. In Heresy, weapon skill and initiative still matter. Vehicles have different armor depending on where you shoot them. You can also react during your opponent's turn, so you're no longer sat there for 20 minutes watching your army get taken off the table and eating crisps.

You also get a lot more freedom building units. Every weapon and upgrade has its own points cost, and one of you said weighing those up is half the fun. That does sound great if you like converting your own models. If you're me, it's more opportunities to glue something on the wrong way, upside down or even backwards.

Horus Heresy feels like Band of Brothers, not space opera

Then there's the atmosphere. Someone described 40k as space opera and Heresy as Band of Brothers, and I love that, because I love Band of Brothers. Heresy does have a grounded military feel to it, with armored columns and campaigns that go on for months. You're playing through a war documentary, with a bit more genocide than they normally show on a Sunday evening.

A few of you said Heresy feels more about the story side of the hobby. One of you got in through the plastic Mechanicum range and then stayed for the more relaxed atmosphere. Came for the models, stayed for the game, which I think is the healthiest relationship anyone has ever had with Games Workshop.

This comment really caught my attention: "Modern 40k feels increasingly like a competitive game that happens to take place in the Warhammer universe. Horus Heresy feels like the Warhammer universe brought to life through a war game."

I haven't played Horus Heresy yet, but the setting is pulling me in

I can't agree or disagree with that, because I haven't played Heresy yet. It's a slightly awkward thing to admit in a piece about Heresy. I do like modern 40k. I can't remember what half my Blood Angels do, but that's less a rules problem and more a me problem, I suppose.

Still, the more I hear from you, the more Heresy pulls me in. For me, I think it's mostly the setting. I love the books and the whole tragedy of it, and getting to play through that story instead of only reading about it sounds brilliant.

I do wonder whether Heresy is really more relaxed, or whether Heresy players have been at it so long they've given up arguing. I reckon you can probably have a lovely story driven game of 40k with the right people, and a miserable game of anything with the wrong ones.

Which Horus Heresy Christmas box I'd pick: Vanguard Assault

If I had to pick one of the two Christmas boxes, and I did think about this, I'd probably go with Vanguard Assault. The Heavy Assault box has brilliant models, especially the Terminators and the Land Raider. But Vanguard has Assault Marines, a Predator, a Rhino and a Contemptor Dreadnought.

Being a Blood Angels player, jump packs and Dreadnoughts are already doing a lot of the selling for me. That's concerning, because I haven't played Heresy yet and I'm already thinking about it. But this is how it starts, isn't it? One box. I'll just have a look. Maybe I'll pop it on my Christmas list.

The catches: 3,000 point games, cost and Marines versus Marines

Before anyone rushes off to buy one, there are a few catches. One of you mentioned that the first games feel quite slow, and then in the same breath recommended starting at 3,000 points. I've barely got time to finish a game of 40k as it is. At 3,000 points I'd need to book annual leave.

Then there's the cost. Lots of you pointed out that, like 40k, the models and the books are expensive, and you don't fancy buying new rulebooks every few years. I think as Warhammer fans we've all accepted that, like the weather. There's also the Marines versus Marines question. Somebody asked whether that gets a bit boring.

What surprised me was how differently people feel about third edition. One person said it killed their local Heresy community. Somebody else said it's doing brilliantly round their way and nobody bothered sticking with second edition. So that's cleared things up. It seems to depend on where you live and which clubs and gaming shops you go to. If you're thinking about Heresy, I'd start by finding out what your local club plays, because an army with nobody to play against is a very expensive shelf.

Who should give the Horus Heresy a go

I'd love to get a demo game in. The biggest thing stopping me is probably time. I've already got a Blood Angels army that barely sees the tabletop, and there are only 24 hours in a day, which feels like an oversight.

If you played years ago and miss the old rules, building your own units and those classic Marine models, I can see the appeal. If you're like me and love the Heresy books and that whole period of the lore, there's loads here for you too. If you've got a mate or a club already playing, even better.

But if you love the variety in 40k, with your Orks, Necrons and Tyranids, Heresy might not scratch that itch, because there are no Orks. Nobody's driving a Battlewagon into a Land Raider. And if you're enjoying 40k already, there's nothing wrong with sticking with it. You don't have to hate one game to enjoy another, which on the internet makes me some sort of radical.

For me, hearing all that has made me want to try Heresy. I just want the story, templates and all. Maybe some of you never fell out of love with Warhammer. Maybe you just fell out of love with one version of it.

Watch the original

@ajm_nerdcore · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Alex's video of 13 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Warhammer 40kHorus HeresyGames WorkshopBlood AngelsTabletop GamingSpace MarinesWarhammer Christmas Boxes

Also on Games Workshop

2 creators, 12 takes →

More from @ajm_nerdcore

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →