SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreGaming

Baldur's Gate 3 HBO series: can one canon ending work?

A Craig Mazin series set after the game, made without Larian Studios, has to pick one canon ending for a story built on player choice

Alex (AI-assisted)17 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2024 · more than 41,000 subscribers 1,985 words · 9 min read
Baldur's Gate 3 HBO series: can one canon ending work?

A Baldur's Gate TV series should have been a dream for me, because Baldur's Gate 3 went straight into my top five games after my first playthrough. Instead, when I heard about the HBO show, my first thought wasn't excitement. It was a long, unconvinced why, because I think a series that has to lock one version of events into place risks missing the whole point of a game built on player choice.

Baldur's Gate 3 (2023), developed by Larian Studios, is a 200 hour RPG. Trying to adapt it into eight episodes and saying it will definitely end well gets the same response from me that a friend gets when he insists his new Warhammer list is totally viable: a skeptical "Hm."

HBO's Baldur's Gate show has Craig Mazin in charge but no Larian Studios involvement

At the time of writing, a Baldur's Gate TV show was apparently happening at HBO with The Last of Us co-creator Craig Mazin in charge. Crucially, Larian Studios has zero involvement. The show is set after the events of Baldur's Gate 3 and is meant to carry on from where the game leaves off. That sounds reassuring until you remember the game can end in many different ways depending on your choices, your dice rolls, and whether you trusted someone who was very obviously evil. We technically have information, but it tells us nothing.

It's important to be clear about the Larian point. Larian doesn't control the IP anymore. Baldur's Gate 3 lives in the world of Dungeons & Dragons, which makes it Wizards of the Coast's intellectual property, and the partnership with Larian is over. Wizards can do whatever it likes with Shadowheart, Astarion, Gale and the rest of the party: spinoffs, sequels, TV shows, lunchboxes, probably a Funko Pop of Withers. Legally, no rules are being broken. Hasbro is effectively holding the dice, and this gives me real Halo TV series energy.

Creatively, though, I think it would be madness. Leaving Larian out is like running a D&D campaign without the DM who wrote it. You can do it, but don't be surprised when it turns into chaos, the tone is all wrong, and everyone quietly agrees the original would have been ten times better. Larian lived and breathed this game. It understands the characters, the themes and the strange little moments that made people fall in love with it. Ignoring that is like throwing away a plus five legendary weapon for a rusty old dagger.

Larian's Michael Douse asked that the Baldur's Gate 3 writers get credit

After the announcement, Larian's director of publishing, Michael Douse, posted on X about spending the last eight to ten years working alongside the writers and creators of Baldur's Gate 3, calling them some of the best storytellers in the industry. His main hope was that they get the credit they deserve and that the characters are treated with the same care they had in the game. To me, that reads as PR speak for please don't mess this up.

Fans then started questioning Larian staff on social media. When someone asked whether any of the game's writers would be involved in the show, Larian's CEO, who directed Baldur's Gate 3, said not to his knowledge. He did add that Mazin had reached out and asked to visit the studio for a chat, and that Mazin seems like a genuine fan. To be fair, that's more reassuring, I guess, than the alternative. We've all seen what happens when someone adapts a franchise after skipping the wiki, and I'm looking at The Witcher.

So while it looks like no one from Larian is in the production trenches, it's mildly encouraging that Mazin is at least consulting them. But is that enough? This studio revived a long dormant CRPG series, turned it into a cultural juggernaut, and made millions of people care about dice rolls and approval ratings. I can't help feeling a couple of studio visits and a chat over coffee won't cut it.

Deadline's original report also said Mazin wants to reach out to the game's cast for their thoughts on the characters and whether they want to be involved. I think that's a smart move, because the cast is the soul of the game. Still, I'll be curious how those actors feel about delivering someone else's dialogue, or about the real possibility their roles go to a more recognizable Hollywood face. Someone on Larian's side later added that they didn't genuinely think anyone could trump the writers, which I guess is fair. I don't think the game's writers have to be locked into the TV writers' room, since writing for games and TV are completely different things. But having someone present when those stories were forged feels less like a bonus and more like a wisdom save the show probably shouldn't skip.

Why The Last of Us had Neil Druckmann and Baldur's Gate does not

This isn't me saying I have no faith in Craig Mazin. I'm cautious, not unhinged. Chernobyl is probably one of the best pieces of TV in a very long time, and The Last of Us season one was top tier. Season two, I don't have words. I've had better naps.

The key difference, I think, is that The Last of Us had Neil Druckmann, the co-creator of the games, at the top of the initiative order. His involvement kept the show broadly tethered to the game's tone, themes and sense of what the story is about. Even when people disagreed with decisions, you could see the thought process. Druckmann has since stepped back to focus on future games at Naughty Dog, but his early involvement did a lot of the heavy lifting. Season one worked, I think, because it had one foot planted in the games at all times. Baldur's Gate looks like it's being adapted without anyone from Larian holding the map.

Baldur's Gate 3's five endings, and which one HBO might make canon

The next big barrier is the endings, and there are spoilers here. Baldur's Gate 3 has roughly five, and which you see depends on how you behaved, whether you played a Dark Urge run, and what you did with each companion, such as whether you let Astarion ascend or talked him down.

  • The bad ending: you beat the Netherbrain but take its power, sitting on the throne of the Absolute. You must kill whichever Mind Flayer helped you, whether the Emperor, Prince Orpheus or a volunteering companion like Karlach. Then you mind control the party, the city descends into chaos, and your character delivers the line "in my name."
  • The good ending: you convince the Netherbrain to remove itself along with the tadpoles. The survivors look at the sunrise over Baldur's Gate, each companion gets an epilogue shaped by their personal quest, and the city slowly recovers.
  • The good Dark Urge ending: you resist the Urge all game, deal with Orin, refuse Bhaal's offer of godhood and destroy the Netherbrain. Your character is freed from Bhaal's influence. It's one of the most satisfying redemption arcs in modern RPGs.
  • The bad Dark Urge ending: you seize the Netherbrain's power in Bhaal's name, kill a companion with a dagger after a final kiss, make the rest hurl themselves off the Netherbrain, and murder everything in the city. Bhaal shows you a future where you're the last living thing left. It's bleak, brutal and incredibly well done.
  • Gale's sacrifice: if you followed Gale's quest, including Sorcerous Sundries and his talk with Mystra, you can send him alone to the Netherbrain's brainstem to detonate himself. The city survives, and the party stands at the docks at sunrise, minus one.

Which ending HBO canonizes is anyone's guess, but the bad Dark Urge ending is probably not making the cut, mainly because it leaves most of the cast dead. HBO has confirmed we'll see new and recognizable characters, which relies on those recognizable ones being alive. Interestingly, Larian's CEO said the endings were designed with future stories in mind, and reflected on how a story born in a small hotel conference room became an HBO series after the studio worked hard to make Baldur's Gate 3 worthy of its legacy.

The obvious choice is the good ending: the city survives and the world is left in a marketable state. It's safe, sensible and deeply uninteresting. The good Dark Urge ending is more compelling, a protagonist outrunning their past, which I think is proper HBO material. That's exactly why I don't fully trust it will be done justice without Larian to stop it turning into edgy nonsense. Gale's sacrifice is tragic, messy and interesting, but easy to mishandle if you care more about spectacle than consequences. Whichever they chose would say a lot about whether this was a careful continuation or a convenient reset, and based on everything we knew at the time, I wasn't convinced they were rolling with advantage.

Why canon is a strange idea in Dungeons & Dragons

Canon in D&D is already a slightly unhinged concept. The hobby is built on players being handed a world and asking how they can ruin it. The Forgotten Realms has big immovable lore pillars, like the Time of Troubles, when the gods were kicked out of the heavens and became mortal. But inside those events are millions of stories, all canon and none compatible. D&D canon is a spaghetti diagram held together by house rules and head canon.

That's why locking it into one TV timeline is risky. The moment you do, you're telling millions of players their version is no longer real. I've done three full playthroughs and keep poking at a fourth, but my canon run is still my first. Yours will be unrecognizable to me. Maybe your Gale is just a severed hand you carry around, or your hero helped massacre the tiefling refugees instead of rescuing them. Baldur's Gate isn't one story; it's thousands, and for a game built on letting players write their own legends, picking one is a risky move.

The Baldur's Gate 3 companions risk becoming cameos

This whole thing feels to me like it was conceived in a windowless room where someone asked how to monetize it. From what we've been told, the show follows a completely new adventuring party, while the Baldur's Gate 3 characters are apparently going to pop up occasionally, like retired fellowship members dragged out for a cameo. They aren't the leads; they're legendary NPCs now. So why wake them up at all? They've earned the right to brood on a balcony somewhere.

Someone asked me why I care so much. Baldur's Gate 3 matters to me, and judging by how heated companion discourse still gets, it matters to many of us. These characters aren't IP tokens to drop into a scene for applause. They're people we spent hundreds of hours adventuring with, romancing and traumatizing. My problem isn't that a show exists; it's that it feels like it exists for reasons unrelated to why the game worked.

The freedom that makes Baldur's Gate 3 work

I love Baldur's Gate 3 because it gives you an unhinged amount of freedom. Character creation is unrestricted chaos, and you can talk your way out of situations you shouldn't survive. Every character I make feels genuinely different, and the game remembers what you do and reacts to it. You get real agency without the story collapsing into incoherent soup.

The opening helps. You start inside a nautiloid and within minutes you're infected by a parasite turning you into a tentacled abomination. That gives a party with wildly different beliefs one shared motivation: don't become squid. It's a group project where everyone hates each other, and it feels like a real D&D table. The combat refuses to tell you no, rewards creativity, and doesn't care how you win as long as you commit to the bit.

The Fallout approach is what I think could work

At no point in any playthrough did I think this desperately needs a TV show. If anything, the only version that might work is the Fallout approach: same universe, new story, no obligation to declare player choices canon. My worry is what gets injected creatively, given Mazin's record of Chernobyl on one hand and The Last of Us season two on the other. And if the show isn't the Baldur's Gate 3 story, it's just a D&D show, which risks exposition dumps explaining magic to people who've never rolled a die.

The safest, smartest option is to set it in the Forgotten Realms, reference the games as distant history and move on. If characters must return, use secondary ones like Zevlor or Barcus, who add flavor without rewriting anyone's playthrough. The setting is high fantasy and needs to be embraced as such, not sanded down into something gritty. Canonizing outcomes opens a can of worms: does Raphael survive, when I kill him every single time for the loot?

Could it be good? Sure, the same way it's theoretically possible for a stormtrooper to hit a target. But with no Larian involvement, a setup that explains nothing, an inevitable canon ending decision and the smell of brand synergy, I'm not brimming with confidence. I'm cautiously pessimistic, emotionally attached, and fully prepared to be proven wrong or horrifically right. Keep Shadowheart and Astarion at arm's length, like a cursed artifact, and let them rest like heroes at the end of a long campaign.

Watch the original

@ajm_nerdcore · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Alex's video of 14 February 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Baldur's Gate 3HBOCraig MazinLarian StudiosWizards of the CoastTV adaptationDungeons & DragonsThe Last of Us

More from @ajm_nerdcore

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →