SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
ReactionMarvel

Spider-Man: No Way Home: was Tom Holland ready to go solo?

A spoiler look back at the three Spider-Men, Aunt May's death, Doc Ock's bridge fight and Peter and MJ, as attention turns again to Tom Holland's Spider-Man

Beyond The Trailer (AI-assisted)18 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2008 · more than 930,000 subscribers 2,000 words · 9 min read
Spider-Man: No Way Home: was Tom Holland ready to go solo?

Spider-Man: No Way Home, starring Tom Holland and Zendaya, opened in theaters on December 17, 2021. I had a great time with it even though I think it has problems. The parts that worked best for me weren't the multiverse parts. They were the beginning and the end, which truly feel like a Spider-Man story as much as the first two Sam Raimi movies.

The multiverse and MCU parts of No Way Home were my least favorite parts of the movie. I came away thinking Tom Holland's Peter Parker was ready to fly solo without any MCU training wheels. Here is what I loved, what frustrated me, and the questions I was left with at the time.

How No Way Home used two classic comic stories to free Tom Holland's Spider-Man

Where I wanted to start is the heart of the film. It's a Spider-Man movie not just because it has three Spider-Men in it. Marvel and Sony took two classic Spider-Man incidents from the comics, his identity reveal and having his relationship with MJ erased, and used them in the most abstract sense. In my opinion those aren't even particularly good stories, so there's no reason to go read them, but they are famous points in Spider-Man comic history.

The basic elements of those stories let the film do a soft reboot on Tom Holland's Spidey, which I found exciting. More than that, they finally got him out from under Iron Man's shadow and out from under the shadow of the entire MCU. Director Jon Watts was moving on to Fantastic Four, and after seeing this movie I understood why he got that gig. Still, I would have liked him to stick with Spider-Man, though maybe he doesn't want to make Spider-Man movies for the rest of his life. Tom Holland, after all, wants to star in them.

Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire's return was a thrill

It was thrilling to see Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire run into the film as if called in from off stage. Both still look great in their Spidey suits. Seeing the three Spideys together made for some great shots. A favorite of mine was the two Peter Parkers silhouetted at the top of the school, Batman style. I also enjoyed the moment Zendaya's MJ tells a tearful Peter there are some other people for him, and it turns out they're stuck under the wall.

The three of them working together in the lab and in the field was cool to see. I'll never forget Andrew Garfield cracking Tobey Maguire's back, which was silly and fun, and of course there was that hug goodbye. If you're a hardcore Spider-Man fan, I think they played many of the right notes. If you side more with the villains, or with Batman, it won't work as well. What that hug was trying to show, I think, is that throughout the multiverse one constant is that "it ain't easy being peter parker," and that's what makes the character so relatable to many fans.

Why I felt Maguire and Garfield weren't playing their own Peter Parkers

To me, neither Andrew Garfield nor Tobey Maguire acted like they did in their respective films. I rewatched Spider-Man 1 and 2 to get ready, and Spider-Man 2 twice. Alfred Molina understood the assignment: his Doctor Octopus walked right into this movie from the last one. In those movies Tobey Maguire had a very specific take on Peter Parker, including an extremely unique speech pattern that I missed. I get that his Peter matured, but people don't change that much. It seemed more like Tobey Maguire than Tobey Maguire's Peter Parker, and his Peter is who I wanted to see.

Andrew Garfield, to me, seemed like he hadn't yet turned off his musical theater vibe. He came across more like a musical theater guy than a scientist, with a theatrical, dramatic tone and excitement about everything. That was funny, and fans of musical theater may like him even better, but to me he wasn't the same character, which frustrated me. I have to give him major credit, though, for the moment he caught MJ and was reminded of Gwen. The look on his face when he asked if she was okay was incredible. That's more of what I was looking for.

The missed chances, from Mayday Parker to Kirsten Dunst

Part of the fun of the Spider-Verse is seeing how each Spidey is different through different circumstances, so I thought there was a real missed opportunity to flesh out these Spider-Men. I feel like the attitude was that this was it, they weren't coming back, so nobody wanted to tease a bigger life that fans would never get to see. I would have taken the tease. At least we would know it existed out there somewhere.

There was a rumor going around that Tobey Maguire's character would have a daughter, Mayday Parker, who in the comics is the Spider-Girl from an alternate universe and a cult popular character. That didn't come to fruition, but I thought it was a very good idea. It would have been touching to tell Tom Holland's grieving Peter that May lived on, in a way, through Tobey Maguire's daughter. Andrew Garfield even gave the perfect opening when he asked how his life was. Tobey Maguire's Peter played it close to the vest, and given how bad Tom Holland's identity reveal was, you can see why. But among other Peter Parkers, I wanted details. We waited almost 20 years. It's too bad Kirsten Dunst couldn't show up, and Emma Stone was also supposed to come back. I think COVID had a bit of an effect on this film.

Experience, the Green Goblin stab and the SNL sketch feeling

Andrew Garfield's Peter said he stopped pulling his punches after Gwen Stacy was killed, but he didn't seem like that person at all. If anything he seemed to land even softer punches, because he was such a nice guy feeling lame next to the others. All the jokes between the three Spideys were good, but it seemed more like a great SNL sketch than these three movie characters getting together. That isn't a knock, since there have been some great SNL sketches.

It also surprised me that, while both are older than Tom Holland and further along in their Spidey lives, they seemed to have the same level of experience. Tobey Maguire was the first Spider-Man and has been around the longest. He should have been Spider-Man 1 and calling the shots more. And when Green Goblin stabbed him, I rolled my eyes. He was totally fine, he'd been stabbed before, yet the sound effect made it sound like a serious stab. Green Goblin must be losing his touch, but he did get Aunt May.

Aunt May's death and whether Marisa Tomei was fridged

I have mixed feelings about that scene. I didn't dislike anything here; I just thought it could have been better. I appreciated the depiction of what I'd call walking dead syndrome, which is very sad and very much how it happens in real life. Aunt May had no idea she was dying, and at first neither did Peter. I don't think May ever knew. She was just getting more and more tired and wanted to rest. Marisa Tomei, an Oscar winner, did a great job.

But I didn't see the need to kill her, and part of me feels she might have been fridged. All it seemed to do was underline for Tom Holland's Peter that doing the right thing matters more than anything, even your own life and the lives of your loved ones. I don't agree with that at all, but I think that message will speak to Spidey fans. I'm a Batman fan, so imagine me seeing this movie as if Batman bought a ticket, and how he would take everything. I was also surprised this Peter hadn't yet heard the line with great power comes great responsibility.

Why curing the villains made No Way Home feel like Scooby-Doo

I'm not into curing villains. Rehabilitating them, maybe, but from a story perspective I think curing them is a horrible idea. Taking away Jamie Foxx's Electro powers felt mean, though I can see why he'd remove the thing on his chest that was slowly draining him. I felt bad for him. I also think it takes away from the power of these villains to boil them all down to scientists who just had an accident. If the Spideys really want to help the world, maybe they should advocate for lab safety and tell everyone to wear their goggles.

It all seemed very Scooby-Doo, which is of course a line from the actual movie. Are all the other superheroes jerks for not curing their villains? Thank goodness the Avengers don't remember who Peter Parker is, or they'd ask what he's doing to their images. It's a slippery slope: next time a hero punches a villain, are we going to expect them to save them instead?

Electro's Miles Morales shout-out

I loved it, and my theater loved it, when Miles got a semi shout-out. Electro sees Andrew Garfield's face and says he figured Spider-Man would be Black, given he comes from Queens and helps the disadvantaged. My audience erupted in applause, and I'm sure Jamie Foxx loved getting to do that. As a Miles Morales fan from day one, who saw the character have difficulties when he started out, it made me so happy that he's now beloved.

I couldn't wait for him to eventually come to live action. It could be soon, maybe in the next chapter for Tom Holland's Spider-Man, or it might be after his animated movies end, but I believed he was coming. Tom Holland broke into tears at the end of the premiere because he was the star of such an incredible movie, and it's going to be that way for a Black Hispanic actor too. They'd better cast it right or the internet will be furious.

The plot holes and why No Way Home felt talky

If Electro didn't know his Spider-Man was Peter Parker, how did he get pulled into this universe? Why would all the Peter Parkers get pulled through because they knew they were Spider-Man, when Venom had no idea who Spider-Man was? And why were Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire just wandering around this new universe? They're experienced superheroes who should have quickly found fellow heroes and familiar foes. The movie is very sloppy in many regards.

Those are my main problems, along with it being a bit too jokey and talky. I think that's partly due to COVID, which resulted in many small groups having conversations in small rooms. Succession season three, which is so good, has the same issue, especially early on, where scenes aren't as dynamic as you'd want because of restrictions on who could be in a scene and where they could film. You have to allow for that a little with this movie.

The Doc Ock bridge fight and the battle at Happy's apartment

There isn't much action. I thought the Statue of Liberty material was a dud action wise. But the quality of the two action scenes it does have is incredible. Alfred Molina didn't miss a step as Doc Ock, and the bridge scene was a perfect Doc Ock versus Spider-Man fight: funny, suspenseful, and full of New Yorkers in danger. When the car went over the side and Spider-Man realized a family was in it, that was incredible. The actress playing the MIT college advisor was phenomenal with her screen time. My favorite line came when the Iron Spider suit deployed its legs and Otto said it looked like they had some competition.

I also loved when Otto assimilated the Iron Spider tech and Peter regained control of the arms, like syncing a new Apple device. Tony Stark doesn't get enough credit for how advanced and easy to use his tech is; they ran a whole portable lab in Happy's apartment and you believed it. The fight at Happy's apartment building was very well done, and for maybe the first hour the movie clicked. The Sinister Five was lame, but it worked for a moment. Jamie Foxx telling Otto "i liked you better before" was great, and Green Goblin and Peter punching each other through floors from apartment to apartment was excellent. Otto jinxed it by asking Norman if he was excited to be normal, and with J. Jonah Jameson downstairs with his camera, everything was clicking.

Tom Holland's Peter and Zendaya's MJ are a great team, and Ned is a third wheel

The other thing I loved was Tom Holland's Peter and Zendaya's MJ, whose name was confirmed to include Watson, which I thought was wonderful. I don't feel they're over as a couple. Peter is still making selfish decisions about MJ; he didn't learn that she'd like to be consulted on major life choices, including whether to tell her who he is. I thought they might spend a movie apart, with MJ probably still in it because she's too great a character. Maybe she'd have her own science accident at MIT. But their love is too strong, and I could imagine her seeing something on the news and thinking she knows that guy. MJ and Peter never recovered in the comics after One More Day, but I hoped they would here.

I loved how the movie showed what a great team they are, and that MJ is an asset instead of a liability. Zendaya was great throughout, and she sold how hurt MJ was that Peter erased her and everyone else's knowledge of him without consulting her, while still being nice about it. Anyone in a relationship can relate. Ned, meanwhile, continues to be a third wheel, something the movie even jokes about. I think he's a bad friend who keeps making mistakes and going back on his word, as when the police tricked him into confirming Peter is Spider-Man. Now that he can do magic, he's never going away. Still, there were great lines throughout, like Happy overhearing their late night call and saying "no new ground is being broken here," which read almost like a screenwriting note, the kind of meta I appreciate. Taping a phone to Peter's chest so MJ and Ned could help him on FaceTime was clever, too.

The identity reveal and Charlie Cox's Matt Murdock

The revealed identity material was extremely interesting and showed a darker side of celebrity that isn't discussed much: how valuable anonymity really is. The opening is absolutely incredible, with great energy, very high stakes and almost a commentary on society today. It did make me wonder why everyone went crazy over Spider-Man's identity when the Avengers' identities are known and they walk around in other movies. Maybe it's the Mysterio murder angle, or that it was a secret. You'd think New York City would be a superhero industry town.

It was wonderful to see Charlie Cox's Matt Murdock again, even if it was incredibly brief. He caught the brick, which was cool, but cooler was his amazing legal advice. He didn't miss a beat, and I was excited to see more of him as he entered the MCU. What made that cameo so perfect was that he was exactly as we all remembered him. I wish someone had applied that note to Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield. They aren't totally responsible for their choices; everyone involved signed off on them. Maybe the filmmakers were so happy the actors agreed to come back that they didn't want to bother them, but I wish they had pushed them a little more.

What other creators are saying

More on Zendaya →
New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
I think Dune Part Three will expand Chani's role and finally show the galactic wars Herbert skipped, and I believe it will hold better at the box office than Avengers: Doomsday while joining Lord of the Rings as this generation's defining trilogy.

Dune Part Three trailer: how big is Zendaya's Chani role? →

Breakdowns & Blockbusters · more than 240,000 subscribers · Snippet
Three companies approved it, the internet mocked it, and Zendaya saw the genius in it

Why the Dune: Part Two popcorn bucket was a marketing breakthrough →

The Cosmic Wonder · more than 990,000 subscribers
A spoiler free verdict on Tom Holland's latest outing, Sadie Sink's standout turn, a packed opening crowd and the one thing I wish the film had more of.

Spider-Man: Brand New Day review: is it the best Spider-Man film? →

CinePals · more than 880,000 subscribers
Reacting to the Sony Pictures Entertainment casting reel for Spider-Man: No Way Home, I broke down why Tom Holland, Zendaya and Jacob Batalon each booked the job in very different ways.

Spider-Man audition tapes: how did Tom Holland book it? →

Watch the original

@beyondthetrailer · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Beyond The Trailer's video of 16 December 2021 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Spider-Man: No Way HomeTom HollandZendayaAndrew GarfieldTobey MaguireAlfred MolinaMarvelSony

More from @beyondthetrailer

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →