SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreSci-Fi & Fantasy

Star Wars smartest moves: why is Galen Erso's the best?

From a Leia escape pod gamble to a Galen Erso reactor flaw, these are the cleverest decisions across 13 theatrically released canon films, villains included.

Chaos (AI-assisted)19 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2025 · more than 3,000 subscribers 1,270 words · 6 min read
Star Wars smartest moves: why is Galen Erso's the best?

The smartest thing Luke Skywalker ever did was show up to a lightsaber duel without showing up. Han Solo got an Imperial bunker to open its own doors. And in Rogue One, Galen Erso spent years building the most powerful weapon in the galaxy just so somebody could blow it up.

I'm going through 13 theatrically released canon Star Wars movies and picking the smartest move in each one. Villains count, and in one of these the smartest person in the room is a Hutt. If I had to pick one across the whole franchise, I'd probably take Galen, and I'll get to why at number five.

13. A New Hope: Leia Sends the Death Star Plans With R2-D2

Vader's men are already boarding the ship. Leia has maybe a minute to figure out what to do with the most valuable piece of information in the galaxy, and she splits the mission in two. She gives the plans and her message for Obi-Wan to R2, then stays behind and takes the heat herself.

The Empire captures the princess and lets an escape pod go because it has no life signs. That one decision is why the rest of the movie, and the rest of the Skywalker saga, can happen. It's very Star Wars, but "the guy who thought he was saving ammunition ended up costing the Empire a Death Star."

12. The Empire Strikes Back: Lando Calls In Lobot on Cloud City

Lando knows he can't beat Vader, and by the time Vader starts changing the deal, he knows there's no point negotiating with him either. But Lando still runs Cloud City. He quietly signals Lobot, who brings in the city's own security and takes the stormtroopers escorting the prisoners by surprise.

They're too late to get Han back, which is what makes it feel like a real decision with consequences. Lando gets the others out because he remembers he still has something Vader overlooked: the people in the city answer to him.

11. Return of the Jedi: Han Solo Gets the Empire to Open the Shield Bunker

Han has to get back inside the shield bunker while the Rebel fleet is getting hammered in orbit. So he gets on the comm from a captured Imperial walker, poses as its crew and reports that the rebels are retreating. Then he asks for reinforcements to finish them off. The officer inside believes him and opens the door.

I like this one because Han spends half his life bluffing people to get himself out of trouble. Here, that exact skill saves the entire fleet.

10. The Phantom Menace: Padmé Uses Her Decoy Again to Take Back the Palace

Everybody remembers the reveal that the handmaiden was the real queen. The smarter part comes later, when Padmé and Sabé use the switch again in the throne room. The decoy shows up dressed as the queen, the Trade Federation's guards turn their attention to her, and Padmé uses that opening to grab the weapons hidden in the throne room.

The disguise had already gotten Padmé off Naboo. She finds a second use for it when she comes back to take Naboo, and it works again.

9. Attack of the Clones: Obi-Wan Lets Jango Fett Lead Him to Geonosis

On Kamino, Obi-Wan has a dead assassin, a clone army nobody on the Jedi Council remembers ordering, and the man whose face is on every single clone trying to leave the planet. So when Jango gets to his ship, Obi-Wan sticks a tracker on it.

Look at what he gets for letting him go. Jango leads him straight to Geonosis, where the Separatists are meeting and building their droid army. "Imagine how little Obi-Wan would have learned if he'd actually won that fight on the landing platform."

8. Revenge of the Sith: Palpatine Gives the Jedi the Army That Kills Them

Order 66 is the moment we all remember. But think about what Palpatine had to get right before he could make that call. The Jedi had spent years taking clone troopers into battle, trusting them with their lives and spreading out across the galaxy with them. By the time Palpatine gives the order, the troops he needs are already standing next to the people he wants dead.

Look at Cody handing Obi-Wan his lightsaber back right before he gets the call. A few seconds later, he's ordering his men to shoot him off a cliff. That's the whole plan in one scene.

7. The Clone Wars: Anakin Lets Dooku Chase the Wrong Jedi

Dooku thinks the way to stop Jabba from getting his son back is to go through Anakin Skywalker, and Anakin is happy to let him try. He occupies Dooku on Tatooine while Ahsoka takes Rotta to the palace.

Ahsoka runs into trouble getting there. But by the time Dooku realizes Anakin doesn't have the kid, he's wasted his shot at stopping the handoff himself. For a guy who usually wants to be the one finishing the mission, Anakin made a good decoy here.

6. The Force Awakens: Han Solo Comes Out of Hyperspace Inside Starkiller Base's Shield

Starkiller Base has a shield the Resistance cannot get through at normal flight speeds. Han's answer is to take the Falcon through it in hyperspace and pull out close enough to the surface to get the team in.

There's a reason everybody looks at him like he's completely lost his mind. He has to get the timing just right with a planet directly in front of him. But he also understands how the shield works, and for once, the crazy thing Han says he can do is the plan.

5. Rogue One: Galen Erso Hides the Death Star Flaw Where the Empire Can't See It

The exhaust port gets all the credit, but Galen's real sabotage is in the reactor. He makes it so the right hit can start a chain reaction and destroy the whole station. Then he gets a message to the Rebellion explaining what he did and where to find the plans they'll need to figure out how to hit it.

What I love is that the Death Star works. The Empire fires it, sees exactly what it wanted to see, and has every reason to think Galen gave them what they paid for. "He gave them a weapon they'd feel safe standing inside."

4. The Last Jedi: Luke Skywalker Beats Kylo Ren Without Touching Him

Luke knows Kylo will stop everything for a chance to kill him, so he gives him that chance, or at least makes him think he does. Kylo orders every gun to fire on Luke, goes down there himself and spends the whole fight trying to settle something that started years ago. Meanwhile, the Resistance is sneaking out the back door.

Look at the ground during the duel. Kylo's feet scrape up the red salt over and over. Luke's don't. The movie gives you the answer while Kylo is too angry to see it.

3. Solo: Han Builds the Deal Around Beckett Betraying Him

Beckett spends the whole movie teaching Han that everybody will betray you. So when Han goes to meet Dryden Vos, he works out what happens if Beckett tells Dryden the plan. Dryden expects fake coaxium and sends his men after Enfys Nest. The coaxium Han brings is real, and Nest and her crew are ready for Dryden's men.

Han lets Beckett sell him out because he knows Dryden will act on whatever Beckett tells him. You can see the exact moment Beckett realizes Han was listening to all those lessons all those years.

2. The Rise of Skywalker: Rey Hands Ben a Lightsaber From Another Room

Ben walks into a fight with the Knights of Ren empty-handed. Rey has a lightsaber, but she's surrounded by Palpatine and his people. Then she reaches behind her back and passes the saber through their Force connection.

The movie already showed that objects can cross between them when Kylo grabbed Rey's necklace. Now Rey realizes the same thing works in her favor. Ben pulls the saber out from behind his back and gives the knights that little shrug. That's probably my favorite payoff in that movie, to be honest.

1. The Mandalorian and Grogu: Din Djarin Listens to the Hutt He Was Sent to Rescue

Din gets sent to pull Rotta the Hutt out of the gladiator arena. The problem is that Rotta wants to win his freedom. Din could have treated him like cargo and dragged him out. Instead, he takes him seriously, faces him in the arena and spares him.

So when the arena boss turns on them, they fight together, and Rotta ends up giving Din the most valuable piece of information in the movie: the man running the arena is the Imperial warlord Din was looking for in the first place. The Hutts offered to tell him where to find the warlord. Rotta told him who he was.

I know somebody's probably got a different one. But if I get to pick one across the whole franchise, I'd probably take Galen. The Empire gave him the resources to build its ultimate weapon, and he used them to give the Rebellion the win.

Watch the original

@chaoscinemayt · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Chaos' video of 18 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Star WarsGalen ErsoRogue OneThe Last JediHan SoloLeiaThe Mandalorian and GroguLando Calrissian

More from @chaoscinemayt

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →