Star Wars needs new characters, not a fourth trip through the Skywalker saga
With Jon Watts reportedly attached to Simon Kinberg's trilogy and Rey's role still unconfirmed, I'm worried Lucasfilm will undo the ending again instead of giving us someone new to care about
I don't usually lean into the negative, but that's where I am with Star Wars. Picture the next Star Wars movie. You're in the theater with those tingles. The crawl comes up. There's a new empire, the Jedi are in trouble again, and somewhere on a planet nobody cares about, a kid with a mysterious past is about to find out they're special. How many minutes would you give that movie before you walked out?
I used to wonder what was out beyond the movies. Now I wonder how long it'll take the next movie to get back to the movies I've already seen. If the next trilogy is a fourth trip through the Skywalker saga, and all the arrows are pointing that way, I think Lucasfilm is about to find out how many people have stopped caring. I'm calling it: Star Wars is dead. I think it started dying the moment they decided the only way to get us excited about the future was to undo the ending we already loved.
Jon Watts is reportedly attached to direct the first movie in Simon Kinberg's new Star Wars trilogy
First, the news. Jon Watts, who directed No Way Home and co-created Skeleton Crew, is reportedly attached to direct the first movie in Simon Kinberg's new trilogy. The reporting is split on whether it continues the Skywalker saga or starts a new one.
Rey's role in those three movies is unconfirmed, but the word is she'll have a role, maybe as a mentor. If that ends up happening, that alone tells you it's connected to the Skywalker saga. Separately, Lucasfilm announced a movie about Rey building a new Jedi Order. So we have a trilogy in development and an announced direction for Rey, and how those pieces fit together, who knows? My fear is that Lucasfilm sees the Skywalker name and thinks, "Well, at least we know we can sell a million toys that way."
How The Force Awakens undid the ending of Return of the Jedi
Go back to the end of Return of the Jedi (1983). Vader makes a choice that costs him his life. Luke gets his father back for about 30 seconds. The Emperor goes down the shaft, and when everyone is celebrating, you feel like this family paid a price to give the galaxy a future.
Then we come zooming back in with The Force Awakens. Luke's Jedi are gone. Han and Leia are split up and not doing well. The bad guys have built an even bigger Death Star inside a planet. I had fun with the movie, and many of us did. I gave it room because I figured the first one gets everybody back in the door. After that, I wanted to see what happened in the 30 years I missed: what Leia built, who Luke taught, and what those people believed. Instead, by the end of that trilogy, we're fighting Palpatine again.
Palpatine's return happened offscreen, and that's what scares me about the next trilogy
I remember hearing that opening crawl and thinking, "Did I miss a movie? Did I miss a trilogy?" If the Emperor's return is the biggest thing to happen in this galaxy in 30 years, I wanted to be there when it happened. I wanted to see who found out first. I wanted to see what it did to Leia: Luke's sister, Vader's daughter, the woman who spent her entire adult life fighting this man's empire. Instead, the movie starts with the headline and floors it to the next scene.
That's what scares me about this new trilogy. What happens when a new writer needs a huge cinematic opening? Do we find out Rey's school got wiped out between the movies? Do we get another order of Stormtroopers with a new helmet, a new colorway and a different name? How many times can you ask me to care about somebody rebuilding the Jedi if the first thing you do the next time I see them is tear it all down?
Daisy Ridley as a Jedi teacher could work with the right story
I'd watch Daisy Ridley play a Jedi teacher. I would give her a student who's good with the Force and wants nothing to do with the Jedi. Let Rey go to that kid's hometown and hear straight from somebody who lived through it why they'd rather the Jedi stay away. Maybe the people there remember the Clone Wars as the time Jedi generals showed up and their sons never came home.
Rey grew up hearing stories about Jedi heroes. What does she say when somebody tells her a different story? I'd give Ridley that scene and let her sit with it. I've always said I think Daisy Ridley is a good actor, and I think she suffered from bad writing and storytelling. But that idea would require the first movie to be about something they're willing to carry into the second.
If you want my money for three movies, you're going to get it anyway, because it's Star Wars, I'm a glutton for it and I'm a fan. That's not the point. I'd like to know they've at least had a conversation about how the third one ends.
Finn was a character worth following
Look at Finn. In the first movie, you get a Stormtrooper who decides he can't do this anymore and walks away. That's a character to follow, because he knows the people under the helmets. What happens when he runs into somebody who trained alongside him, somebody who thinks Finn abandoned them? What happens when one of them wants out and Finn is the only person willing to go back for him?
You could build a great movie on that setup alone. Years later, we're still sitting here pitching what we wish they'd done with the guy.
Star Wars keeps turning scenes into a pop quiz, and Andor shows why it doesn't need to
Then there's this thing Star Wars does when it turns a scene into a pop quiz. Who does that lightsaber belong to? Did you see who walked into the room? Do you remember this guy from an animated show? I love catching that stuff. I do. But if my buddy sitting next to me sees the same scene and feels nothing because he didn't see six seasons of something else, what does that scene give him? How did that lightsaber end up in that ancient treasure box? I don't know. It's a story for another day.
That's why Andor gets to me. You can follow the prison escape without knowing the name of a single Star Destroyer. You know exactly what Kino Loy wants. You know what it took for him to finally say it out loud, and then you get to the edge with him and realize he can't swim. I remember that line more clearly than half the big reveals Star Wars has put in trailers. There was an actor, a character I cared about and one awful thing he couldn't change. That's what stuck.
Star Wars: Starfighter and Ryan Gosling's new character
I'm curious about Starfighter. Lucasfilm announced it as a standalone adventure with Ryan Gosling playing a new character, set about five years after The Rise of Skywalker. We think he's going to be an uncle. Maybe that's been confirmed. I don't even know anymore.
There's a real chance here to show us how people live in the galaxy after those movies. I want to see what an ordinary pilot does when the war is over and the people who used to tell him what to do are gone. But then again, if he has a nephew who's Force sensitive, we're still doing that. So we'll see. If they could pull it off, I'd want to walk away talking about somebody I met two hours earlier.
What I would do with the next Star Wars trilogy
Here's what I'd do, not that anybody's going to pay me for my opinion. Go far enough into the future that Rey's students have students of their own. Let the order she built survive long enough to change. Then put me on a planet where two Jedi show up to help and disagree about what helping means. One stays and defends the people who asked for them. The other leaves because she thinks the people who asked are lying.
Maybe follow her when she leaves, and give me a reason to worry that she's wrong. By the end of that movie, I want to know her name because of something she chose to do, not because it was shoehorned and forced into my brain. That's the bar. I could buy a ticket to the next Star Wars movie out of curiosity, and I will. To get me back for the second one, give me somebody I'd miss if they never made it out.
Calling Star Wars dead was too brash, and I apologize for it. It's always going to live on. But that's how it feels to me: "Star Wars isn't dead. It just feels really dead right now."
Watch the original
@chaoscinemayt · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Chaos' video of 15 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @chaoscinemayt
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

