SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
RankingGaming

Best Battlefield games ranked: why is Battlefield 4 number one?

A redeemed Battlefield V opens the list, and Battlefield 4's turnaround after a broken launch earns it first place.

Chaos Gaming (AI-assisted)15 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2010 · more than 2.6 million subscribers 1,730 words · 8 min read
Best Battlefield games ranked: why is Battlefield 4 number one?

Battlefield is one of my favorite FPS franchises, even if I've fallen off the bandwagon in recent years. It's still where I go for large scale warfare and Battlefield moments you can't get anywhere else, so here are my picks for the 10 best Battlefield games of all time, counting down to Battlefield 4 at number one.

The list runs from DICE's original Battlefield 1942 through the Bad Company games, the futuristic Battlefield 2142 and the World War I setting of Battlefield 1. You're probably going to be a little surprised by my pick at number 10.

10. Battlefield V redeemed itself after a hard beginning

Anyone who has followed my opinions for a while will probably be surprised by this pick. I wasn't happy with Battlefield V when it came out. I didn't like the lack of historical accuracy, I was disappointed by the lack of content, the technical problems were a huge issue, and the Battle Royale mode, which was cool, died off rather quickly.

After all the updates were released, though, Battlefield V ended up being a very fun game. When I put this list together, it was a great experience with plenty of people keeping it populated. The destruction is good and detailed, and it's probably the most visually beautiful Battlefield game to date, which is saying something. Official support has ended, but the final version of the game is solid. It's one of the best Battlefield games of the last decade, and I think it deserves a place in the top 10.

9. Battlefield Hardline was BF4 with its own cops and robbers personality

Hardline is hard to rank because of how different it is from other Battlefield games, especially in multiplayer. Initially, its multiplayer was criticized for being too similar to Battlefield 4. To some extent I agree, because it's very clear the developers had to recycle quite a bit of Battlefield 4's skeleton to get the game done on time.

Once you started playing, though, you noticed the differences. Hardline had some very unique game modes and a distinct style thanks to the cops and robbers theme of its story. It's not the most original Battlefield game ever, but it's fun "if you just lean into the craziness." It was Battlefield 4 but different enough to have its own personality, and with a core as solid as Battlefield 4's, I think it's easy to see why it became a fan favorite over time despite a mixed initial reception.

I think if Hardline had launched a few years later, it probably would have been a fan favorite out of the gate. Since it dropped less than two years after Battlefield 4, comparisons were inevitable.

8. Battlefield: Bad Company laid the foundation and has the most underrated campaign

If I remember correctly, it was the last T rated Battlefield game to be released, and I think that T for Teen rating on the box made people write it off compared to the M for Mature entries. Even though it's less violent than the rest of the franchise, it's still a Battlefield experience through and through.

In fact, I don't think Battlefield would look the same without this game and everything it introduced. Bad Company brought a huge upgrade to the destruction mechanics and a big increase in scope, not just in map size but in how many different ways players could interact with the play area. It was the first Battlefield game built on the Frostbite engine, and it made an incredible first impression.

Some have said its map design and weapon selection are lacking compared to other games in the series, but it's still a solid Battlefield experience that laid the foundation for a ton of later innovation. It also has the most underrated campaign of the entire series. DICE decided to make Bad Company a comedy game for some reason, but I'm okay with it, because the game is hilarious. If you haven't played it, pick it up for the single player campaign.

7. Battlefield 2142 took the formula 100 years into the future without losing it

DICE was doing the futuristic FPS thing before anyone else. Battlefield 2142 is a spinoff of the main franchise that sent players over 100 years into the future to take part in a massive conflict during a new ice age. Mechanically, it was more or less a futuristic reskin of Battlefield 2, but it came with a ton of new gadgets, vehicles, weapons and more.

This game is a perfect example of how to take something that works and build on it to make a brand new experience without losing what made people like it in the first place. You get to play Battlefield, but you've got giant walkers, and that's pretty cool.

It's interesting to look back at how well DICE translated its multiplayer FPS gameplay to a futuristic setting and compare it with how Call of Duty moved into the future. These are two very different mindsets. Call of Duty tried to reinvent itself with jetpacks and verticality, while Battlefield took what people already liked and moved it 100 years forward. I would argue that was a much better way to keep the core player invested.

6. Battlefield 2 and Battlefield 2: Modern Combat share the spot as a double entry

Battlefield 2, released in 2005, was the first time the series was set in the modern day. That meant a whole set of new toys to play with: bigger explosions, faster guns, vehicles and much more.

There were two versions of the game: Battlefield 2 for PC and Battlefield 2: Modern Combat for consoles. Despite sharing a name, they were entirely different games, so you could consider this spot a double entry. Both were good, and both were responsible for making the franchise a lot more popular on PC and console.

In terms of gameplay, it was a perfect update of the original game, adding many new weapons and mechanics and showing how well the formula could work in different settings. I'm willing to bet that many old school Battlefield players got into the series with Battlefield 2, on either PC or console.

5. Battlefield: Bad Company 2 pushed the Frostbite engine and its destruction further

I'm still a little salty that Bad Company 2 ditched the comedic tone of the original, but it's still a top five Battlefield game because of the advancements it made to the engine, along with the formula, the immersion and the gameplay. It launched in 2010 for PC and consoles with the new Frostbite 1.5 engine, and DICE quickly established how detailed and capable that engine was, with incredible destruction mechanics and visuals despite the size and scope of the experience.

The fact that a game this big and detailed could run on an Xbox 360 still amazes me. It still looks good, and the amount of destruction possible in the multiplayer maps is crazy. Bad Company 2 was one of the first games in the series to show how much the experience could change by destroying parts of the map and opening new lanes of action for each team. You had to think about how to approach certain areas before they were destroyed, and how to use the destruction to your advantage.

On top of that, the maps were good. The campaign was a step down from the first Bad Company, but "literally everything else was a step up."

4. Battlefield 3 proved the series was real competition for Call of Duty

Battlefield 3, released in 2011, was one of the biggest games of the PS3 and Xbox 360 era for good reason. It was Bad Company 2, but juiced. A handful of features had to be cut from Bad Company 2 to make its technical advancements work properly, and Battlefield 3 brought them back. The result was one of the most detailed and immersive multiplayer shooters of all time, at least at the time of release.

Battlefield 3 had some of the most incredible moments you could ask for from a video game at that point, and it still has some of the tightest design in the franchise. Every weapon felt distinct, almost all of them had a solid place in the sandbox, and the vehicles at your disposal were awesome. It also still looks amazing on PC despite its age.

The Battlefield series has never been known for its single player campaigns, but the Battlefield 3 campaign is good. This was the game that proved Battlefield was proper competition to Call of Duty.

3. Battlefield 1 made a fast game out of World War I

Battlefield 1, released in 2016, was the first time, and at the time I wrote this the only time, in the franchise that DICE gave Call of Duty a run for its money in sales. It took the series back to the First World War with incredible visuals, plenty of content on day one, a solid single player campaign, an amazing multiplayer and an overhaul of some established mechanics to fit the setting.

The sniping was overhauled to make each rifle feel more distinct. Many weapons had slower fire rates because of the time period, which made for a game pace unlike any other Battlefield. The destruction mechanics were made even more immersive. Overall, the game played very quickly compared to other Battlefield titles, which was generally seen as a positive.

The setting pushed some fans away from the series, which is understandable, but the game itself is extremely polished. I think it's absolutely one of the best Battlefield experiences of all time. It can be hard to make a fun, fast paced game set in the early 1900s, but DICE did it with flying colors.

2. Battlefield 1942 started it all and has aged surprisingly well

Battlefield 1942 is where it all started, and it's still good. Released in 2002 for PC, it was a large scale World War II multiplayer shooter that was totally unique at the time. It laid the foundation for every Battlefield game to come and gave birth to a brand new genre of PVP shooters.

It had different classes that played differently, and you could join huge lobbies, some with over 200 people at a time, assuming the server owner allowed it. Go back and play it today and you'll find clunky controls and relatively simple map design, but you'll also find a truly unique gameplay experience that was way ahead of its time. It holds up thanks to its simplicity and very intentional design decisions.

It might be a little unfair of me to put it this high, but "Legacy means something to me," and I think it's justified. We wouldn't have the franchise without this game, and it has aged surprisingly well.

1. Battlefield 4 went from a broken launch to the best game in the series

Battlefield 4 is one of the biggest comeback stories in gaming history. It launched completely broken, and it was one of the biggest controversies ever for such a high profile game to launch in that state. It was unacceptable, and both EA and DICE had to put a ton of work into apologizing, updating and winning back the community's goodwill.

Now that all the patches are out and almost all the bugs are fixed, Battlefield 4 is not only the best game in the series but also one of the best PVP shooters of all time. The game is overflowing with content, and almost all of it is good. The maps are gigantic and extremely well designed. Each class has many weapons that feel unique and offer different play styles if you're willing to learn their strengths and weaknesses.

The graphics are amazing, especially on PC with the settings turned up. The gunplay is smooth, and the time to kill is perfect for this kind of experience. The destruction physics are good without being so extreme that they become chaotic, and the vehicles are fun and add a lot of dynamics to the experience as a whole.

It's a huge shame the game was rushed out the door. At this point it's common knowledge that EA pushed the deadline forward to compete with Call of Duty and to get early adopters on the Xbox One and PS4, which had just released at the time. That led to many corners being cut and a busted final product. But once DICE was given the space to finish it, Battlefield 4 became the best Battlefield experience of all time.

Watch the original

@chaosgaming · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Chaos Gaming's video of 24 January 2025 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

BattlefieldBattlefield 4Battlefield 1Battlefield 3Battlefield Bad Company 2Battlefield 1942Battlefield VBattlefield Hardline

More from @chaosgaming

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →