SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreSci-Fi & Fantasy

Dumbest Star Trek characters ranked: is it Gul Dukat?

Rank, intelligence and experience didn't stop these Star Trek characters from walking straight into disaster, and Gul Dukat tops the list.

ChaosTrek (AI-assisted)17 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2024 · more than 15,000 subscribers 1,840 words · 8 min read
Dumbest Star Trek characters ranked: is it Gul Dukat?

I'm counting down the 11 dumbest characters in Star Trek, and Gul Dukat takes the top spot. These are the people who got warned, made a mess of things anyway, and still acted like everybody else was the problem.

Some of the worst offenders had the rank. They had the intelligence. They had the experience to know exactly how badly they were about to blow it. If your favorite character is on this list, I'm sorry, but I have to be real.

11. Tom Paris breaks the warp 10 barrier and lands in the brig on Voyager

I like Tom Paris. If I'm on Voyager and we need somebody to fly us through a situation nobody in their right mind would volunteer for, I want Tom at the helm. And then I want somebody else to make the decisions once we land.

In Threshold, Tom breaks the warp 10 barrier, starts mutating, and eventually kidnaps Captain Janeway. By the time the crew finds them, they've turned into amphibious creatures and had offspring. I'm giving Tom a pass on most of that, because he was undergoing a medical event no doctor could reasonably have seen coming.

Thirty Days is a different matter. Tom goes against Janeway's orders and tries to stop an alien ocean from being destroyed by attacking a refinery. His heart is in the right place, but his first officer still has to fire on him, and he ends up demoted with a month in the brig. Tom has enough good instincts to save your life and enough confidence in those instincts to make you wonder what he'll do the next time you leave him alone with a shuttle.

10. DaiMon Bok lets a grudge against Picard cost him two crews

DaiMon Bok hates Picard because Picard destroyed a Ferengi ship commanded by Bok's son at the Battle of Maxia. Okay, that's a reason to want revenge. I get that.

The first time he comes after Picard, he uses a device to manipulate Picard's mind and gives him back his old ship, the Stargazer. Very cool. But Bok is prepared to throw away a valuable ship and put his own crew at risk for a personal grudge. His crew eventually has enough of him and takes him into custody.

Years later, Bok comes back. You'd think losing command might have made him reconsider the whole thing. Nope. He alters a man's DNA to make it look like Picard had a son, then threatens to kill him. He has to invent a son for Picard to finish his revenge plan, and once his crew learns there's no profit, they turn on him again. I need to know what Bok was telling people during recruitment, because apparently he managed to hire two different groups of Ferengi without realizing either one would eventually ask how they were going to get paid.

9. Captain John Harriman leaves the bridge of the Enterprise B with Kirk aboard

The first thing John Harriman does as captain of the Enterprise B is take it out with a bunch of reporters and three legends of Starfleet aboard. Fair enough. They're supposed to go around the block, wave to the cameras and come home.

Then the distress call comes, and we find out exactly how much of the ship is arriving on Tuesday. Tractor beam, Tuesday. Medical staff, Tuesday. The ship is the only one close enough to respond, so Harriman has to act with what he's got.

The moment that puts him in the hot seat is when he decides to leave the bridge and make the deflector modifications himself, with James T. Kirk standing right there. Kirk has to tell him the captain's place is on the bridge, and then Kirk goes down and does it. Harriman gets some slack because he's new and the situation is brutal. Unfortunately for him, his first day at work ends with a hole in the Enterprise and everybody thinking he just got James T. Kirk killed. Good luck at the next press conference, buddy.

8. Brunt of the Ferengi Commerce Authority never sees Rom coming

Brunt is a Ferengi Commerce Authority liquidator. Let that sink in for a second. I swear his favorite thing about his job is getting to walk into Quark's bar and say, "Brunt, FCA." He enjoys it so much that I'm convinced he starts smiling in the hallway before the doors even open.

He goes after Quark for letting his employees form a union. He takes away Quark's business license when Quark refuses to honor a contract for his own remains. And when Quark and Rom become part of a plan to get Grand Nagus Zek back into power, Brunt gets involved again because he sees a chance to benefit.

I think what he never seems to grasp is that the people he bullies talk to each other. Quark has friends on the station. Rom has people willing to back him. Brunt has a title he announces every time he enters a room. By the end of Deep Space 9, Rom is Grand Nagus. Imagine spending years treating a guy like he's too stupid to function and then finding out he's in charge of all the Ferengi.

7. Admiral Pressman takes the Enterprise back to the Pegasus

In The Pegasus, Admiral Pressman takes the Enterprise looking for his old ship, which was lost while testing an illegal Federation cloaking device. That particular cloak lets a ship pass through solid matter. On the first test, his crew mutinied, the ship was lost, and most of the people aboard died. Pressman's takeaway was apparently, "We should go back and get it."

And who does he bring along to help keep the secret? Riker, one of the few people who survived, and a man who has spent years serving under Jean-Luc Picard. Riker has grown into a completely different officer, yet Pressman's whole plan depends on him acting like the scared young man he was the last time Pressman gave him an order.

Once the Enterprise gets trapped, Riker comes clean. Picard uses the cloak to get them out and then decloaks right in front of the Romulans. Pressman went looking for a way to bury what happened on the Pegasus, and he ended up with Picard personally showing the evidence to the people the Federation signed the treaty with. That's irony.

6. Seska bets on the Kazon instead of Voyager

Seska has a good thing going at the beginning of Voyager. She's a Cardassian operative who successfully infiltrated the Maquis disguised as a Bajoran, and she finds herself on a Federation ship that might be able to get her home. Then she takes a look around the Delta Quadrant and decides to hitch her wagon to the Kazon.

To be fair, she gets results. She helps take Voyager in Basics, which is more than many people who try to steal the ship can say. Then the Kazon leave Janeway and most of the crew alive on a planet and fly off with several people still aboard who can help take the ship back.

Here's the part I love. Even after Seska dies (sorry, spoiler alert), Voyager eventually finds out she booby trapped the old Maquis mutiny holodeck program. She went out of her way to hide a revenge plot inside a training exercise. She was smart enough to get away with a lot, so I can only imagine what her life would have looked like if she could have made it through a week without turning one person into an enemy.

5. Admiral Leyton manufactures the emergency he warned Earth about

Leyton sees what the changelings can do and decides Earth is vulnerable. He's right. Then he uses that very real threat to justify a plan to put Starfleet in control of Earth. He has cadets help sabotage Earth's power grid, which makes it look like the kind of attack he's been warning everybody about. Suddenly, the emergency he needs is the emergency he created.

His mistake is bringing in Benjamin Sisko and assuming that because Sisko once served under him, he'll go along with it. Sisko takes the threat seriously enough to investigate. It just happens that the person he needs to investigate is Leyton.

A changeling even tells Sisko there are only four of them on Earth. Think about it. The Dominion sends a handful of infiltrators, and one of Starfleet's own admirals decides to take down the power grid, compromise officers and push the Federation toward a fight with itself. If I'm the Dominion, I'm reading that report twice to make sure I didn't miss the part where I had to do any work.

4. Lore can't leave a good con alone, from Datalore to Descent

Lore has most of Data's abilities and a head start on understanding human emotions. He also has absolutely no ability to leave a good con alone.

In Datalore, he impersonates Data and gets close enough to fool the crew. Then he has to deal with Wesley Crusher, a teenager who happens to be paying attention, and that's where things unravel. Imagine assembling an entire plan around feeding a starship to the Crystalline Entity, only to have a kid looking at you like that's not Data.

Then in Descent, Lore gets a group of disconnected Borg to follow him and gains influence over Data again by giving him access to emotions. This is probably the most control Lore has ever had over his brother. So what does he do? He keeps pushing Data until he's asking him to kill Picard. Data ultimately turns on him and shuts him down.

That's what gets me about Lore. He had years to study his brother and figure out what makes him tick. He finally gets Data to feel something, and his big idea is to see how far he can push him before those feelings get in the way.

3. Gowron's jealousy of Martok puts Martok in charge

The Klingon Empire was fighting for its life in the Dominion War, and Chancellor Gowron looked at one of his best generals and thought, "How can I make this guy look bad?" So he started sending Martok on missions he had little chance of winning. Imagine being a Klingon soldier, finding out your assignment is probably going to get you killed, and learning the reason is that your boss is jealous of your other boss.

I'll defend early Gowron. He survives the civil war, he knows how to work the Klingon High Council, and those eyes alone probably won him half his arguments. Late Gowron is a different story. Martok's popularity is growing during the Dominion War, and Gowron decides a good way to handle that is to take direct command and order attacks that waste Klingon ships and lives.

Worf sees it happening, and Sisko needs it dealt with. Even then, Gowron gets a chance to read the room. He's got Martok standing there, the war still needs winning, and Worf is openly challenging his decisions. This would have been a great time to remember that Worf has spent his entire adult life taking Klingon honor more seriously than most of the people who lecture him about it. But Gowron takes the challenge and dies. Worf gives the chancellorship to Martok, so Gowron's jealousy does the one thing he was desperate to prevent: it puts Martok in charge.

2. Kai Winn chooses the office over the Prophets

Kai Winn spends years wanting the Prophets to speak to her. Meanwhile, the Prophets are perfectly willing to deal with Benjamin Sisko, a man who probably would have appreciated a few fewer interruptions. You can see how much that bothers her, and it explains a lot of why she does what she does, without making any of it a good idea.

When the Pah-wraiths reach out to her and she realizes who's behind the visions, she goes straight to Kira for help. Kira tells her to step down and devote herself to serving the Prophets. You can almost see Winn do the math. She spent her whole life saying she serves the Prophets, and she's finally presented with a chance to prove it by giving up the office. She keeps the office.

From there, she stays on a path that leads straight to the fire caves with Dukat. By the time she finally tries to help Sisko stop him, it's too late to save herself. She had a moment where she understood exactly what she was doing, and she could still have walked away. I guess the thought of somebody else getting to be Kai was apparently harder to live with than whatever was waiting for her in those caves, but I don't know.

1. Gul Dukat keeps making the deals and blaming everyone else

Gul Dukat wants the Bajorans to thank him for how he ran the occupation. Think about that. He wants a statue. He genuinely believes that if the people who lived under him would just hear him out one more time, they'd understand how lucky they were to have him.

Then the Dominion offers him a way back to power. He brings Cardassia into the alliance and gets Deep Space 9 back for a while, which must have felt like the greatest vindication of his life. But Cardassia winds up taking orders from the Dominion, and the station is lost again. When the Cardassians finally rise up, the Dominion retaliates against the civilian population. The deal Dukat made to restore Cardassian greatness led his own people into a catastrophe.

With all that behind him, what's his final play? He disguises himself as a Bajoran, manipulates Kai Winn and goes into the fire caves to release the Pah-wraiths. Sisko tackles him in the flames, and Dukat ends up trapped with the very powers he thought he could use.

Dukat takes number one for me because you can go back to almost any point in Deep Space 9, ask him who's responsible for what's happening to him, and get a different answer every time. The Bajorans, the Dominion, Sisko, somewhere in the middle of that. You'd think he might take a look around and realize who keeps making the deals.

What other creators are saying

More on Star Trek →
Lore Reloaded · more than 140,000 subscribers
Sisko never sought command of a wartime front, I argue; loss, an unglamorous posting, the wormhole's discovery and his role as Emissary stacked together until the Dominion War simply formed around the ground he'd been placed to protect.

Sisko and the Dominion War: was he placed at Deep Space 9? →

The Gold Man · more than 170,000 subscribers · Snippet
Star Trek (2009) and The Force Awakens share a director, a reboot mission and the start of a trilogy

J.J. Abrams Played an Almost Identical Role in Star Trek and Star Wars →

Galaxy Geeks · more than 680,000 subscribers · Snippet
One card plays artifacts from the top of your library, and the other rewards facing a dilemma with free spells

Zefram Cochrane and the Caretaker among Magic: The Gathering Star Trek preview cards →

Breakdowns & Blockbusters · more than 240,000 subscribers
A Romulan War buildup, a Mirror Universe miniseries, the Borg Queen's origin and a refitted NX-01 were all part of the plans for a season that never got made

Star Trek: Enterprise season 5: what was planned for it? →

Watch the original

@chaostrektv · YouTube

Adapted with AI from ChaosTrek's video of 16 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Star TrekDeep Space 9VoyagerThe Next GenerationGul DukatKai WinnGowronLore

More from @chaostrektv

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →