SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreMarvel

Fantastic Four 2005 Doom statue: why does it look like RDJ?

A Victor von Doom statue from Tim Story's film resembles Robert Downey Jr., and I think the long running plan for him to play Doom could explain it, though it may be coincidence

Colton Ogburn (AI-assisted)15 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2014 · more than 80,000 subscribers 1,290 words · 6 min read
Fantastic Four 2005 Doom statue: why does it look like RDJ?

A picture of the Victor von Doom statue from Tim Story's Fantastic Four has been sent to me again and again, including a few mentions on Twitter, along with the claim that it looks a lot like Robert Downey Jr. Looking at it, yes, it does look like Robert Downey Jr. I think it's possible the statue was made that way because Downey was once in the running to play Doom in that film, but I'm not saying that's definitely why.

That film is Fantastic Four, which I believe came out in 2005, starring Ioan Gruffudd, Jessica Alba and Chris Evans. Before anyone gets carried away, here's how I see it.

Julian McMahon played Doctor Doom in Tim Story's Fantastic Four

We know Julian McMahon played Doctor Doom in that movie. He passed away recently, so rest in peace to him. He was a very talented actor, and I thought he was a good Victor von Doom.

Here's a fun fact that doesn't get talked about enough: Robert Downey Jr. was going to play Victor von Doom in that Tim Story Fantastic Four movie. That ultimately didn't happen. I don't know that he was ever officially cast and then removed so they could cast McMahon. But it has been heavily reported that he was in talks for the role. He was never officially cast, but it got close.

Robert Downey Jr. as Doom was not a last minute Hail Mary for Marvel

I've argued for a while that the plan for Robert Downey Jr. to play Doctor Doom has been in the works for a long time. Many people think it was a last minute Hail Mary: the Kang character wasn't working out, so Marvel decided to do Doctor Doom and have Downey play him. I don't think that's how it went down. From a production standpoint, and from how the movie industry works, they did not randomly decide on Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom overnight.

We've heard interviews with Kevin Feige and the Russos talking about how the idea of Downey playing Doom was something they'd been kicking around for a while. I think it's possible they were even kicking around the idea of bringing him back as Doom before they made Avengers: Endgame, or in the midst of making it.

I also think Avengers: Secret Wars always had the plan of bringing Doctor Doom in, because "how do you do Secret Wars without Dr. Doom"? So I think they've had the plan to bring Doom in for Secret Wars for a while, and perhaps, even back around the Endgame era, the plan that Downey would be the one to play him.

How Avengers: Doomsday could swap Kang for Doctor Doom

What I think was the last minute change was the pivot. Marvel changed Kang Dynasty, took the Kang character out, brought Robert in earlier and announced to everyone that he would play Doctor Doom. In Avengers: Doomsday, yes, the villain is Doom, but the way I see it, the true villain is the event itself: the end of the multiverse, the doomsday for the multiverse. That was the same case for what Kang Dynasty would have been.

So all they really had to swap out was Kang for Doom. The many Kang variants we were probably going to see fighting our heroes in different places at once would probably be swapped out for Doombots. We've also heard rumors that Doom has a team of masked individuals, and it isn't clear whether they're variants, Doombots or something else.

Why the Fantastic Four Doom statue might look like Robert Downey Jr.

I bring all this up because if Downey playing Doom has been in the works for a while, that could be the potential answer to why the Doom statue in Tim Story's Fantastic Four looks like him. Let me be clear, though: I'm not saying that's why. If you look at it, it looks like Robert Downey Jr., but "it doesn't not look like Julian McMahon" either.

It could be that we're seeing what we want to see. Before this comparison went around, did we really question whether it looked like McMahon? This might be a false memory of mine, and it totally could be, but I feel like the last time I watched that movie, I wasn't thinking it looked like Downey. I was thinking it doesn't look like the guy.

Set pieces and toys are often made before casting is final

Much prep work goes into making things for a set, and a statue like that was probably made well in advance of filming. They likely started making it when the script was completed and they had script lock. The same is true for many toys. They go into early production, and sometimes certain toys look different, with different costumes, and sometimes even the faces won't look right, because they were based on the script, not the actual movie.

So I'm wondering if they made this statue at a point when it looked like Downey was going to play Doctor Doom. Perhaps it got close enough that everyone thought they still had details to sort out, but Downey was who they wanted. If so, the statue may have been made to look like him before they realized he wasn't who they were casting.

Or perhaps they had a certain look in mind, a general look that both McMahon and Downey share. When you get down to a certain point in casting, you'll notice the actors in contention maybe tend to resemble one another because the filmmakers have something specific in mind for the character. Maybe they made the statue vague, close to Downey but also close to the general idea of who they wanted, or maybe they were still looking at McMahon and had to get the props made before final casting. I'm not going to act like I'm an expert in how all of that goes down, but I do think it's certainly possible the statue looks that way because Downey was supposed to play Doom and then they changed it.

Robert Downey Jr.'s long interest in Doctor Doom

There's not a lot about Downey's involvement in that casting process for Fantastic Four that I can find. What I do know is that Robert Downey Jr. has had a deep interest in the character of Doctor Doom for a while.

So I'm wondering if he really wanted to play that role, and because of his own personal things going on at the time, it wasn't the right fit and maybe the part got pulled out from under him, even though it may have looked like he was going to get it. Again, I'm not saying that's the case. It could be us seeing Downey in a vague statue because we want to.

But it would be cool if we find out later that Feige says they wanted Downey to play Doom going all the way back to that Tim Story Fantastic Four movie, and that the statue looks like him for a reason.

What other creators are saying

More on Fantastic Four →
New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
I believe the real reason the rival Avengers teams are at odds probably comes down to Bob, since Bucky would never turn in a misunderstood super soldier while Sam's team would likely demand it. I think Nick Fury would back Sam's Avengers and feed intel only to them.

Thunderbolts* Post-Credits Scene Explained: A Fantastic Four Ship Arrives →

The Cosmic Wonder · more than 990,000 subscribers
I think Avengers: Doomsday is building toward a fight where Doctor Doom's attack on the X-Mansion pushes the X-Men into our universe, where they clash with the Avengers and Fantastic Four before uniting against Doom, resolving much like Avengers' Iron Man/Thor/Cap brawl.

Avengers: Doomsday: is Nightcrawler fighting Mister Fantastic? →

Sorta Stupid · more than 810,000 subscribers · Snippet
A shield, a deflected shot and our guess about the surfboard

Our loud reactions to Fantastic Four's Silver Surfer fight scene →

GIQUE · more than 25,000 subscribers
The Fantastic Four appeared because their comic-book counterparts, particularly The Thing, have historical ties to the New Avengers, having served on the team from 2010 to 2013. It's unclear exactly how Marvel will use this going forward, but The Thing could join the MCU's New Avengers if a full Fantastic Four team doesn't form.

Thunderbolts* ending: why did the Fantastic Four appear? →

Watch the original

@coltonogburnchannel · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Colton Ogburn's video of 19 January 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Robert Downey Jr.Doctor DoomFantastic FourJulian McMahonTim StoryAvengers: DoomsdayAvengers: Secret WarsMarvel

More from @coltonogburnchannel

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →