Avengers vs X-Men: why Jean Grey's Phoenix tips the fight
With both rosters stacked, the fight comes down to Scarlet Witch against Jean Grey's Phoenix, and to whether the Avengers have any answer for mind control.
The Avengers and the X-Men are Marvel's two premier superhero teams. They've fought before, and with the way the MCU is progressing, they'll probably fight again. I think it's a ridiculously close fight, but I have to give the slightest edge to the X-Men.
To get there, I'm giving both teams stacked rosters, then narrowing the battle down to the heroes who would decide it. In the end, it all comes down to Scarlet Witch, the Phoenix, and mind control.
Captain America, Iron Man, Thor and Hulk lead a stacked Avengers roster
Captain America leads the team, and he gets a serious power upgrade if you give him Mjolnir. Even without it, he's the pinnacle of human potential. He's incredibly strong, his shield is nearly indestructible, and he's one of the best fighters on the planet. He's so impressive that he had Deadpool gushing and even Thanos shocked.
Iron Man is the face of the Avengers, and with all his different suits of high tech armor, he's seriously powerful. This is a guy who went toe to toe with Thanos while Thanos had four Infinity Stones. Even if the fight didn't end too great for Tony, that's still impressive. He can fight gods and genocidal robots, and he's smart enough to come up with an answer to any problem he faces.
For years, Thor held the title of strongest Avenger and most powerful hero in the MCU. The MCU has kept expanding since then and a few people have passed him, but he's still a god. He's one of the only heroes who has shown planetary level strength on screen, and he's battled some of the toughest villains out there.
I don't think it's any surprise that the Hulk is something of a disappointment in the MCU. He started out strong in The Incredible Hulk and The Avengers and had some nice showings in Thor: Ragnarok. Then he lost to Thanos in Avengers: Infinity War, became Professor Hulk, and never managed to recover. Still, it's the Hulk. He's incredibly strong and has had great feats, from fighting Thor to snapping with the Infinity Gauntlet.
Black Widow, Hawkeye, Spider-Man and Winter Soldier bring skill and agility
Black Widow is the ultimate spy and assassin, one of the most agile and skilled fighters on Earth, and she has some seriously powerful weapons. Her Widow's Bite can send Ant-Man flying and can even stun Black Panther through his vibranium suit.
Hawkeye is another ultimate spy and assassin, on top of being the world's best marksman. There isn't a shot he can't make. As the years have gone on, his arrow arsenal has only gotten more impressive. He might not look it, but he can take down many enemies with one well placed arrow.
Spider-Man is low key one of the most powerful heroes on Earth. He's strong enough to fight Hulk level villains, and he's fast and agile enough to dodge lightning, energy blasts and everything else that comes his way thanks to his spider sense. With that sense, he's close to omniscient to a certain degree.
Winter Soldier is one of the best fighters and killers on the planet, except he doesn't like the killing part anymore. He's a super soldier like Captain America and close to Cap's equal in a fight. With Bucky's skill and experience, he's a threat to anyone who crosses his path.
Captain Marvel, Vision, Black Panther and Doctor Strange round out the heavy hitters
Captain Marvel is in a class all her own compared to most MCU heroes. Only a few can even remotely compare to her now that she's had massive upgrades from The Marvels (2023). At her best, she's at least hundreds of thousands of times faster than the speed of light. She can fight Thanos and overpower him even when he's wearing the Infinity Gauntlet, which is better than anything anyone else has done. She was even able to reignite a star with her own raw power.
Vision is one of the forgotten heroes of the MCU, but at his best he's very powerful. His phasing lets him cut through characters and attack them from the inside out, and he has super strength and durability. You can't forget that he has an Infinity Stone in his forehead that he can shoot at you.
Black Panther is a lot like Captain America and Winter Soldier, a superhuman fighter. What sets him apart is his access to vibranium tech, which makes him close to indestructible in a fight. It takes a villain like Thanos to knock him out, and if he stores enough energy in his suit, he can floor Hulk level characters.
Doctor Strange is the Sorcerer Supreme, the most powerful sorcerer on Earth and the greatest defense against magical threats. He's dealt with multiversal threats and fought Scarlet Witch and Thanos with four Infinity Stones. However, he's struggled to seal the deal against many enemies. His greatest victory was over Dormammu, and he only did that with the Time Stone, which he no longer has.
Ant-Man, Wasp and Scarlet Witch complete the Avengers
Ant-Man might not be too impressive, but once he becomes Giant Man, it's a whole different story. He has strength nearly on par with the Hulk, can grow hundreds of feet tall, and is a threat to even Kang the Conqueror. Wasp, his partner in crime, can't grow big, but she can shrink, fly and fire laser blasts at will, and she's a surprisingly skilled fighter with her size altering powers.
It took a while for Wanda Maximoff to officially become the Scarlet Witch, but when she did, she cemented her place as a powerhouse. She's one of the most powerful magic users we've ever seen, to the point where she's more powerful than the Sorcerer Supreme. Doctor Strange said he had no way to defeat her and that she could take on all the sorcerers of Earth at once.
She's just as dangerous against regular heroes. She easily took down the Illuminati alone, and that group included an alternate version of Captain Marvel. Scarlet Witch was suggested to be a multiversal threat, and she lived up to the hype.
Professor X, Magneto, Wolverine, Cyclops and Beast anchor the X-Men
If the Avengers get a stacked roster, so do the X-Men. Professor X founded the team and drives the push for peace between humanity and mutantkind. He's one of the most powerful telepaths on the planet. He can read minds with ease, even tapping into almost every mind on the planet at once. Once he's inside your mind, he can shut it down with a thought, knock you out, take control, or plant memories and suggestions. It's scary when you think about it.
Magneto is Professor X's best friend, but the two couldn't be more different on how mutants should relate to humanity. He's the master of magnetism and can control everything on the electromagnetic spectrum, though he usually sticks to manipulating metal. He knows exactly how to use that power, from pulling the metal out of a person's blood to shifting the Earth's magnetic poles and causing destruction around the world.
Wolverine is easily the most famous X-Man, with his adamantium claws and healing factor. He's incredibly strong and can survive any attack that comes his way, even nuclear bombs. You don't want to get caught between those claws. He's a skilled fighter and a lethal killer. "He's the best at what he does. And what he does isn't pretty."
Cyclops leads the X-Men and fires powerful optic blasts from his eyes. Scott has incredible aim and has even mastered the ricochet like he's Captain America. Beast is the brains of the team and one of the smartest men on Earth. In a fight he's a beast: incredibly strong, surprisingly fast and agile, but lacking the versatility many other X-Men have.
Storm, Mystique, Nightcrawler, Kitty Pryde and Rogue add versatility
Storm can control the weather at will and is easily one of the most powerful mutants out there. She can shoot lightning bolts and control thunderstorms, hurricanes and tornadoes. She's a force to be reckoned with and, no doubt about it, one of the top members of the X-Men.
Mystique can shapeshift into anyone she wants, which comes in handy when your real form is a blue skinned, scaly lady. She's fast, agile and a skilled fighter who can casually take down most opponents, and she can even hold her own against Wolverine. Nightcrawler is the original teleporter of the X-Men. He's an expert with his powers, nearly impossible to tag, and he can grab enemies and teleport away with them, taking them out of the fight.
Kitty Pryde can phase through objects by shifting herself on the atomic level. What's especially devastating is when she takes someone along and leaves them stuck halfway inside an object. Rogue absorbs a person's memories and powers by touching them, and if she holds that touch long enough, she'll eventually absorb their life. She can also use another mutant's powers herself, meaning she can potentially have any mutant power out there for a short time.
Deadpool, Colossus, Iceman and Quicksilver bring the muscle and speed
Deadpool is technically a mutant. He was injected with a drug meant to activate any hidden mutant gene, and while it technically worked, giving him a healing factor on par with Wolverine's, it also ruined his life. He took it in stride and became an elite mercenary, one of the best fighters and killers on the planet.
Colossus is the big muscle, but he's also a teddy bear with a heart of gold. He turns his body into living steel, making himself strong and tough enough to beat Angel Dust and even hold his own against Juggernaut, although he got pushed to fighting dirty in that one. Iceman can turn himself to ice and shoot ice all around him, freezing people, trapping them or hitting them with blasts. It looks like he can even control cold and heat itself.
Quicksilver, Magneto's son, is easily the fastest mutant out there. He can reach supersonic speeds with no problem, and he moves so fast that bullets, explosions and even lightning look frozen in place. That speed helps him in a fight: he's able to rock Apocalypse with a punch. Considering only a handful of other mutants are fast enough to catch him, I'd say Quicksilver is definitely powerful.
Jean Grey and the Phoenix make her the most powerful mutant
Rounding out the team is Jean Grey, the person who beat Apocalypse, and she did that before she had officially tapped into the Phoenix Force. She's the most powerful telepath on Earth and essentially unlimited at telekinesis. She can do whatever she wants with a thought, and I do mean whatever she wants.
After merging with the Phoenix, she became even more powerful, easily dwarfing both Professor X and Magneto, because she was essentially given the powers of a cosmic god. No doubt about it, Jean Grey is the most powerful mutant we've ever seen.
Why this fight comes down to the top tier Avengers and X-Men
As much as we want to imagine both teams smashing into each other with every hero fighting at their best, that's not how this goes. Both teams have members we love who are powerful in the right context but won't do much here. "Hulk could kill Beast with just one punch just like Quicksilver could knock out Hawkeye in an instant."
So this is really the top tier Avengers against the top tier X-Men. For the Avengers, that's Thor, Hulk, Doctor Strange, Scarlet Witch and Captain Marvel. For the X-Men, it's Quicksilver, Professor X, Magneto and Jean Grey. You can argue others belong here, but Storm isn't going to out lightning Thor, Colossus isn't landing a punch on Hulk, and Iron Man and Vision aren't making it past Magneto.
Even in this tier, several heroes can take out others in one shot. Professor X can potentially control the Hulk with a thought, but it's just as likely Hulk accidentally steps on Professor X and ends it right there, since this is a guy in a wheelchair. Magneto could potentially control Stormbreaker and send it back at Thor, yet we've never seen Magneto show the durability to survive a full onslaught from Captain Marvel or Thor. Doctor Strange can potentially send them all to another dimension, but Quicksilver could knock him out instantly with a punch.
Scarlet Witch versus the Phoenix decides who wins
This is where the fight is decided. Scarlet Witch can wipe out most of the X-Men by herself. She's already killed Professor X and already caught Quicksilver. With the way she instantly wiped out Black Bolt and killed Captain Marvel, I'm going to say she can kill Magneto too.
The Phoenix is the ultimate telepath and the ultimate telekinetic, a cosmic god. She can easily take out Professor X and Magneto, and she can easily kill Apocalypse. She can wipe out anyone around her with a thought and a gesture. She's terrifying. It's possible either of them could defeat the other team alone, so whoever is stronger will carry their team to victory.
It's a ridiculously close fight. Both seem to operate on a universal level. It's said the Phoenix brought life and created the universe in the first place, and the Darkhold prophesied that Scarlet Witch was destined to rule or destroy the cosmos, meaning the universe and potentially the multiverse. Neither Jean nor Wanda has shown they can live up to that potential, but that's the scale we're talking about.
Still, I think I have to give the slightest of edges to the Dark Phoenix. It's like Wanda fighting Thanos with all the Infinity Stones: she can hold her own and make it a good fight, but she's up against a fundamental force of the universe. "It's an uphill battle from the very beginning." It doesn't help that as ruthless as Scarlet Witch is, Jean is even more so. She will disintegrate everyone in her path with no problem, and she'll definitely get the first shot because she's that ruthless.
Mind control gives the X-Men the win
This is a very close fight, and Scarlet Witch could potentially lead her team to victory, helped by Thor and Captain Marvel as physical juggernauts. But if she can't take down both Jean Grey and Professor X, the X-Men win. She can probably defeat Professor X, but it's much harder to say she can beat the Phoenix.
From what we've seen, the Avengers have no counter to mind control, probably including Captain Marvel and maybe even Doctor Strange. It all depends on Wanda, and that's asking a lot of even someone as powerful as the Scarlet Witch. So I have to give the slightest edge to the X-Men. The X-Men win.
What other creators are saying
More on Avengers →I think the reported Phase 7 Avengers roster, including Sam Wilson's Captain America, a new Iron Man, Vision, She-Hulk, Thor, Captain Marvel, Shang-Chi, Black Panther and Robbie Reyes as a second Ghost Rider, is a pretty cool lineup mirroring Immortal Hulk #7's team.
Phase 7 Avengers roster: is Robbie Reyes joining the team? →
Mayor Fisk's team went after New York's heroes, until the Rhino turned on him over the Purple Children
How Wilson Fisk's Thunderbolts Fell to the Avengers and the Champions →
Reed Richards gets welcomed to the mound, and a Captain America joke landed hard with us
Reed Richards throws a ceremonial first pitch in an Avengers baseball promo →
A trusted insider says Marvel will focus on other team films after Secret Wars. Here is why that is less final than the headlines suggest, and why the Avengers brand is too big to shelve.
Marvel Phase Seven: will there really be no Avengers movie? →
Watch the original
@danco · YouTube
Adapted with AI from DanCo's video of 12 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @danco
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

