SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
TheoryFilm & TV

MobLand theory: is Paul secretly working with the police?

From the explosives Eddie demands to the drive past a police operation at the Cotswolds estate, Paul's moves this season look very different if he's undercover.

Film Paradise (AI-assisted)19 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2023 · more than 58,000 subscribers 1,990 words · 9 min read
MobLand theory: is Paul secretly working with the police?

At first, I thought Paul was simply loyal to Harry. There's a theory out there that flips everything he's done this season on its head: what if Paul isn't only protecting Harry, but is working with the police, sitting right under their noses while the Harrigans carry on believing he's one of their own? I have a feeling we may have been underestimating Paul in MobLand (2025), the crime drama starring Tom Hardy, Pierce Brosnan and Helen Mirren.

The show hasn't confirmed that Paul is a police officer, so this is a theory, not an established fact. For most of the season, he has looked like a man who's happy to follow orders, keep his mouth shut and stay out of trouble. Somehow, though, he keeps finding himself in positions where he can help Harry, even when that puts his own neck on the line. I'm not saying we should start calling Paul detective inspector just yet. Still, when you consider how easily people underestimate him, you begin to wonder whether that harmless image is exactly what makes him so useful inside the family. If the theory is right, the Harrigans may have been keeping their biggest enemy much closer than they realized.

Why Paul refused Eddie's request for explosives

Paul's reaction to Eddie asking for explosives is more revealing than it first appears. Paul refuses until Eddie brings out the blackmail card, and that first refusal caught my attention. Paul is supposed to be the dependable man who gets things done, works for the Harrigans, follows their instructions and tries not to make himself a problem for anybody. Yet getting explosives for Eddie is where he suddenly draws the line.

One explanation is that Paul doesn't want to be involved in a plan against Harry. He may be personally loyal to him, and helping Eddie could mean crossing a line he isn't prepared to cross. There's another possibility, though. Paul may know that getting involved with the explosives could compromise whatever he's been doing behind the scenes. Maybe he's been trying to keep his hands clean for a reason. If he's working with the police, he'd be supplying the tools for an attack while potentially letting the authorities trace his involvement. An undercover officer has to be careful about the jobs he accepts, particularly when they could lead to murder. "You can't exactly explain to your police handler that you accidentally helped organize an assassination because your boss's son asked nicely."

Eddie's blackmail makes it messier. Eddie knows Paul gave Harry information about the Ireland trip, and he squeezes him with it until Paul folds. What I find important is that Paul has already taken risks by helping Harry. This wasn't harmless information; it was serious enough to give Eddie real leverage. The undercover theory could explain why. Paul may have been gathering information, protecting certain people, or quietly interfering with the Harrigans' plans while trying not to expose himself.

There's one detail I wouldn't overlook: we never see Paul deliver the explosives. He appears to agree after Eddie threatens him, but agreeing and doing are two different things. Could Paul be pretending to cooperate while buying time, working out how to protect Harry without revealing what he's up to? I wouldn't be surprised if those explosives become one of the biggest tests of Paul's loyalty. The Harrigans should consider opening a loyalty testing department, since everybody in that family seems to be testing everybody else.

The drive past the police operation at the Cotswolds estate

This is where the theory really starts to heat up. Did Paul stumble across the police, or did he know exactly what he was doing? If he was unaware of the operation, contacting Harry makes perfect sense. He sees something is wrong and alerts someone he trusts. If he already knew the police were there, the scene means something else entirely.

Imagine being an undercover officer inside a criminal organization. You can't walk into the office and announce that you're working with the police. You have to maintain your cover, keep people comfortable and wait for the right opportunity, because one mistake could land a bullet in your head. Paul could have been doing exactly that. Driving Eddie past the police might have put Eddie close to an operation without making Paul's involvement obvious, while contacting Harry gives him a reason to be there. He can always claim he was warning Harry. Paul could be serving two masters at once, feeding the authorities while still looking like the most dependable name on the Harrigan payroll.

There's another way to look at it. Maybe Paul isn't trying to expose Eddie at all. He genuinely wants Harry to know what's happening because he believes Harry is the only person who can deal with it. That fits the idea that Paul trusts Harry more than anyone else, and makes the call about personal loyalty rather than an undercover operation. The question is whether Paul helps Harry because he cares about him or because protecting Harry is part of a much bigger arrangement. We don't have the answer yet, but that drive gives us a very good reason to keep watching Paul.

Is Paul deliberately playing the fool?

Here's a possibility I find particularly entertaining: what if Paul is much smarter than he lets people believe? The Harrigans don't see him as the mastermind behind anything, just the dependable enforcer who gets handed the ugly jobs, does what he's told and goes home. That image could be working in his favor. People rarely pay attention to someone they've decided is harmless, because they're busy watching the powerful and the ambitious, while the quiet man in the corner hears almost everything.

If Paul is deliberately playing the fool, he has a very convenient cover. Nobody expects him to be several steps ahead, so nobody looks for a hidden agenda. One fan interpretation suggests his apparent foolishness could be hiding a much more dangerous character. He could know exactly what's happening but have learned that pretending otherwise is the safest way to survive. I like this possibility because it changes how we see his position. Paul may not be pushed around because he can't make decisions; he could understand that appearing obedient keeps him close to the people he needs to observe.

I'd pay attention to two things. First, does Paul ever show knowledge he shouldn't have, such as details about police movements, family plans or conversations he was never part of? That would be a much stronger clue than looking suspicious. Second, what does he do when he has a choice? Does he always follow the Harrigans' instructions, or quietly make decisions that benefit someone else? Of course, being underestimated isn't the same as pretending to be a pushover, and Paul may be an ordinary enforcer who has become more important than anyone expected. Still, I'd love the show to reveal that the man treated like the office errand boy has been watching them all along.

Colin's informant, Paul's nephew, Donny's head and Frankie

The theory isn't based on the explosives and the Cotswolds drive alone. One claim connected to it is that Colin mentioned an informant with inside knowledge of the Cotswolds estate, someone who knew the family's secrets. If Paul is that person, it would explain how he's stayed so close to the Harrigans. He doesn't need to force his way into conversations or win their trust. He's already part of the operation, right there in their faces.

The theory also points to Paul's behavior after the death of his nephew, suggesting the loss may have given him a personal reason to turn against the criminal world. I think that's worth considering, because an undercover character needs more than opportunity; there has to be a reason for taking such a dangerous risk. If Paul suffered a loss because of the world the Harrigans operate in, his loyalty may have been damaged for a long time, and he could want to see the organization brought down.

Another claim involves Donny's severed head being left in a marked bag. The theory suggests Paul could have deliberately left something behind to help investigators follow the trail. That's a much bigger assumption and we shouldn't treat it as confirmed, but if the bag was a deliberate clue, it would suggest Paul has been helping the police without openly betraying the Harrigans.

Then there's Frankie. When Frankie captures Paul, the way he treats him has been interpreted as unusually sympathetic. One reading is that Frankie may know Paul isn't just another Harrigan enforcer, and that there could be a connection between them going back further than we know. That would be a major reveal. Then again, this is the same Frankie who had Paul tortured, so the sympathy could mean something simpler: respect, or a sense that the Harrigans have treated him badly. We can't turn every moment of kindness into evidence of a secret police arrangement. Put together, though, these suggestions describe a man who may have been gathering information, leaving clues and maintaining connections that could help bring the family down.

Who Paul contacts first when something goes wrong

One early interpretation suggested Paul would surprise everyone. Another line of thinking focused on three things: whether Paul drops his act when he's alone, whether he knows things he's never been shown learning, and who he contacts first when something goes wrong. That last point is especially useful. If he acts independently or reaches out to someone connected to the police, the theory gets stronger. If he consistently turns to Harry, we have to ask why. Is it genuine care, or is there a reason Harry needs to stay alive? Harry has enemies coming from every direction, yet Paul keeps finding ways to help him.

There's also a theory that Paul may eventually warn Harry about Eddie's intentions and let him deal with the problem himself. I think that's a believable possibility. Paul may not want to get his hands dirty, but he can still make sure Harry knows what's coming. The problem is that these clues don't all point to the police. Some suggest personal loyalty to Harry; others suggest Paul is hiding his intelligence. They may all connect, or we may be forcing separate pieces of behavior into one explanation.

Could Paul be Maeve's man, Harry's man, or loyal to nobody?

I don't think we can discuss Paul without looking at Maeve, because his loyalty may still be with her. Back in season 1, Maeve put a call into Paul the morning before a car blew up. It's a small detail, but what if Paul has been feeding information to Maeve rather than the police? His warnings to Harry could then be part of her strategy. She's cunning, and she may want Harry to know certain things so he makes particular moves. Maeve is capable of making people believe they're acting independently when they're dancing to her tune, and she could be using Paul to keep an eye on Harry without him realizing.

The second possibility, probably the most straightforward, is that Paul is simply Harry's man. He trusts Harry, and that loyalty is stronger than whatever the rest of the Harrigans expect of him. His refusal to help Eddie fits perfectly: he doesn't want to contribute to a plan that could get Harry killed, and Eddie's threat forces him into a corner. Then there's the possibility that Paul isn't loyal to anybody and is just trying to survive. Maeve can make his life miserable, Eddie has leverage, and Harry expects him to do his job. I wouldn't blame him. "Nobody on that payroll is guaranteed to see Monday." I wouldn't dismiss that explanation just because the undercover theory is more exciting.

Seraphina, Maeve and Frankie are also informant suspects

There's another reason I'd be cautious about declaring Paul the police's man: he isn't the only possible source inside the family. Seraphina has also been considered a possible informant, and Maeve herself has been raised as a candidate. Maeve leaking information would be quite something, using the police as another weapon in her struggle for control while everyone assumes she's protecting the family.

The lake raid doesn't settle it either. Information reaching the police doesn't mean Paul supplied it. Frankie could have spoken directly to Colin, and Colin's explanation about receiving information from a narc may not tell the full story. That leaves at least four names: Seraphina, Maeve, Paul and Frankie. For the lake tip itself, Frankie is still my main suspect, because he had the motive to plant a body and a line to Colin to deliver it. What Paul has is access. He's a strong possibility, but the police operation alone can't pin it on him, and I'd rather see a proper reveal than decide every suspicious character works for the authorities.

What the MobLand finale needs to answer

First, what happens with Eddie and the explosives? Does Paul follow through or sabotage the plan? If he warns Harry first, that could be another sign his loyalty isn't where Eddie expects. Second, will we learn who Colin's informant with inside knowledge of the Cotswolds estate is? If that person is identified, Paul could suddenly become the center of the investigation. I also want to see whether Maeve, Eddie or Harry starts putting the pieces together, because the moment someone looks closely at Paul could be dangerous. And does Frankie know more than he's letting on?

For the theory to stand, Paul must either be identified as the informant or his actions must become so clearly tied to police work that other explanations stop making sense. If he's exposed as Maeve's man or dies loyal to the Harrigans, it loses its strongest foundation. I'm particularly interested in what happens when Paul can no longer keep everybody happy. He can't warn Harry, satisfy Maeve, obey Eddie and protect himself forever. Knowing this family, I doubt they'll ask politely.

I'm not ready to call Paul a police officer yet. There are too many possible explanations, and some clues are interpretations rather than confirmed facts. But there's more to Paul than the harmless, dependable enforcer we've been shown. I'm sure of that much. If he is the police's man, the Harrigans have spent all season watching the enemies at the gate, and "Nobody thought to watch the man standing at it." If he isn't undercover, then nobody in that organization has been more loyal to Harry, and in their world that kind of loyalty gets people killed. Either way, I wouldn't take my eyes off Paul, because he is acting like a man with something to hide.

Watch the original

@filmparadise · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Film Paradise's video of 18 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

MobLandPaulHarry Da SouzaHarrigan familyMaeve HarriganEddie HarriganFrankieTV theory

More from @filmparadise

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →