Rings of Power: who rules Númenor after Pharazôn?
Pharazôn, Míriel, Elendil, Isildur and Kemen all have a stake in the crown, but the books point to a kingdom that ends with its last king
Everybody in Númenor seems to be fighting over who deserves the throne. Tolkien's history points to a bigger problem: there may be no throne left to inherit, because Ar-Pharazôn is the last king of Númenor and the crown goes down with the island.
In season 3 of Prime Video's The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, which premiered in 2022, Pharazôn has taken the throne and Míriel has lost it. Elendil is gathering an army, and Isildur has already tried to end Pharazôn's reign. It looks like a succession battle is coming, with one of these characters eventually claiming the crown. I know that's a dramatic way to settle a succession dispute: imagine fighting over the crown only for the entire kingdom to disappear before anyone can inherit it. Still, after the first four episodes of season 3, the question is worth exploring. Several people could have a claim to power, and the show has given each of them a reason to matter.
Where Númenor stands after episode 4: Pharazôn wounded, Isildur on the run
By the end of episode 4, Númenor is in a very different position from where we left it. Pharazôn is still king, although Isildur's assassination attempt has left him wounded. Isildur failed to kill him and had to flee, while Haleth was taken prisoner.
The attempt also exposed how deeply the Faithful have managed to penetrate the king's court. Eärien was working as their spy. She leaked Pharazôn's carriage route, helping create the opportunity for Isildur's attack. When Haleth was brought in, she was the one sent to interrogate him. He asked her for a quick death, and she gave the order, claiming she had got a name out of him.
She also helped Isildur use the palantír to warn Elendil, though Pharazôn's side let that message through on purpose so it could bait a trap for him. Once her involvement was exposed, she leapt from the tower and died. That loss is particularly painful for Elendil. He is already trying to hold the Faithful together, and now he has lost his daughter while his family is caught in a political conflict that keeps getting more dangerous.
Míriel wants unity while Elendil becomes the man with the white flame
Míriel is alive, but she is no longer ruling. The Faithful freed her from the dungeon between seasons, and she has been speaking to refugees heading towards the Havens in the West. It's worth remembering that Míriel did not approve of Isildur's assassination attempt. Her message has been about bringing people together, not creating another division between the king's men and the Faithful. She wants unity, even when the people around her are becoming increasingly desperate.
Then there is Elendil. He has been building an army among the Faithful, and he is now being spoken of as the man with the white flame. That name connects him to Narsil, the sword Míriel gave him at the end of season 2. If you know where this story eventually leads, you already understand why that sword matters. Elendil's army is growing and his influence is increasing, making his family appear central to the future of Middle-earth. For a moment, it is easy to think we are watching the beginning of a new royal dynasty in Númenor.
Kemen, Pharazôn's son, is illegitimate and now a prisoner of the Faithful
Episodes 3 and 4 throw in another development that makes the succession question even more complicated. Elendil and Anárion walk into Pharazôn's trap at the stargazing tower. Kemen is waiting for them, and Elendil is captured again. Anárion and the Faithful later intercept the prison transport, rescue Elendil and take Kemen prisoner.
That last detail matters very much. Kemen is Pharazôn's son, and that should make him the heir. Episode 4 takes that away. Sitting across from Elendil in the carriage, Kemen admits he is illegitimate and that Pharazôn killed his mother after learning of the child, then raised the boy and called it an act of mercy. So the one person with Pharazôn's blood has no clean claim to the crown, and the episode closes with him sitting in a Faithful prison.
Pharazôn's rule is being challenged, his son has been captured, and the people who could threaten his power are becoming more organized. The show has given us a king, a rightful queen who has been removed from power, a rising rebel leader and an illegitimate son who is no longer free. It looks like a succession crisis is coming. The books say otherwise. The whole argument is heading towards a much bigger disaster.
In Tolkien's books, Ar-Pharazôn is the last king and Tar-Míriel the rightful heir
In Tolkien's history, Ar-Pharazôn is the 25th and final king of Númenor. That final part is important. Pharazôn did not inherit the throne the way a rightful king should. His cousin, Tar-Míriel, was the lawful heir, but he took the crown by marrying her against her will. In other words, the man sitting on the throne took it from the woman who was supposed to rule.
This is why Míriel's position is so important to the succession question. In the books, she is not just another person with a royal connection. She is the rightful ruler by inheritance, while Pharazôn's claim comes through the power he seized. The show has kept Míriel alive and given her a role among the Faithful, even though she has lost her sight and her crown. Her presence means the question of rightful rule has not disappeared, and she remains a reminder that Pharazôn's authority rests on a betrayal.
Yet even if Míriel were restored to the throne, she would not become the ruler of a kingdom that survives the events Tolkien wrote. The problem is not only who has the strongest claim. The problem is what happens to Númenor itself.
How Sauron's capture and the great armament end Númenor
Pharazôn eventually sails to Middle-earth with an enormous army in the year 3261 of the Second Age. His forces are so powerful that Sauron's armies abandon him. Rather than fight, Sauron surrenders and allows himself to be taken to Númenor as a prisoner. You would think bringing Sauron home as a captive would be a great victory, but Pharazôn has no idea what he is bringing into his kingdom.
Sauron gradually gains influence over the king. He manipulates Pharazôn's fears, encourages the worship of Morgoth and turns the people of Númenor away from the Valar. The king who once appeared powerful enough to frighten Sauron becomes one of the instruments through which Sauron's corruption spreads. This is where the story becomes especially tragic. Númenor's people had been given gifts and long life, and their island was a place of extraordinary beauty and power. Yet their fear of death and their desire for immortality become part of their downfall.
Pharazôn becomes obsessed with the idea that the Valar are keeping immortality from him, and Sauron feeds that obsession. In the year 3319 of the Second Age, Pharazôn gathers the great armament and sails west towards Aman, intending to take the Undying Lands by force. When he sets foot on Aman, the Valar lay down their guardianship and call upon Eru Ilúvatar. The seas are bent, Númenor is swallowed beneath the water, and Pharazôn and his army are buried under falling hills.
There is no palace left to inherit, no throne room waiting for a new ruler and no kingdom for a successor to govern. The throne does not pass to another person. The kingdom itself comes to an end, rotted from within by Sauron's corruption and then drowned by the hand of Eru.
Míriel's fate in the books and what the show could change
This part of the story could become especially emotional if the series follows Tolkien's account. Míriel is the last rightful ruler of Númenor, but she never gets the chance to rule as queen the way she should have. In the books, when the downfall comes, she tries to climb the Meneltarma, the sacred mountain of Númenor. She is caught by the great wave and dies as the island is destroyed. It is a heartbreaking end for a character whose claim to the throne was stolen from her.
The series has already made changes to her story. She is alive, she has survived her imprisonment and she is preaching unity among the Faithful. Her survival gives the writers room to take her character in a different direction before the downfall arrives. Could they restore her to the throne before the island is destroyed? Absolutely. It would give her a moment of justice after everything Pharazôn has taken from her. Could they change her fate altogether? That is also possible, although it would be a major departure from the books.
What we should not do is treat her survival in the show as proof that she will eventually become queen again. That has not been settled yet, and her role is one of the biggest things to keep an eye on as the season continues.
Elendil becomes a king, just never king of Númenor
This is where a lot of people may be getting the succession question wrong. Elendil does become a king in Tolkien's history. He just never becomes king of Númenor. When the downfall happens, Elendil escapes with the Faithful. Nine ships survive the destruction: Elendil takes four, Isildur takes three and Anárion takes two. They carry precious things with them, including a seedling of the White Tree and the seven palantíri. These represent the survival of Númenórean heritage beyond the destruction of the island.
The survivors reach Middle-earth, where Elendil establishes the northern kingdom of Arnor, while Isildur and Anárion establish Gondor in the south. Gondor's early centers include Osgiliath, Minas Ithil and Minas Anor. In the year 3320 of the Second Age, Elendil becomes High King of Arnor and Gondor. The kingship does continue, but in exile across the sea in new kingdoms.
That is what makes Elendil's future so fascinating. He does not inherit the throne Pharazôn leaves behind. He becomes the founder of something that survives after Númenor is gone, and his line eventually leads to the kings of Arnor and Gondor and, much later, to Aragorn. Narsil is the clearest sign of where this is heading. The sword Míriel gave him will one day be broken and reforged as Andúril, the blade Aragorn carries thousands of years later. That is a future far bigger than whoever ends up in Pharazôn's chair.
Five ways The Rings of Power could handle the succession
We have to leave room for the series to surprise us. The show has already made changes to Tolkien's established history, introduced its own character developments and rearranged parts of the timeline, so we cannot assume every event will happen exactly as it does in the books. The first possibility is that Míriel is restored. This would be the cleanest answer if the show wants to resolve the immediate question of rightful succession. She is the lawful heir, she is still alive, and her message of unity gives her a different approach from Pharazôn's increasingly oppressive reign.
The second is Elendil becoming king in the show. This would be a significant departure from the books, but the series has been building his leadership among the Faithful, and his growing army and the sword at his side already make him look like a future ruler. The question is whether the writers make him king of Númenor or save that royal destiny for the realms he establishes in Middle-earth. Then there is Isildur, the elder son, whose failed assassination attempt has placed him directly against Pharazôn. In the books, he becomes one of the founders of Gondor and later plays a major role in the defeat of Sauron at the end of the Second Age. If something happens to Elendil, the show could explore Isildur stepping into leadership earlier than expected.
We should not forget Kemen either. Episode 4 confirmed he is illegitimate, which may be exactly why he is not already the heir, and being captured leaves him further from the crown than ever. If Pharazôn loses power but Kemen survives, he could still become a rival claimant. Finally, Pharazôn could hold the throne for longer than expected. The series could end this season with him still ruling, leaving the great armament and the destruction of Númenor for a later chapter. These are all possible directions for the adaptation, not the book ending, and we should keep those two things separate.
Three signs the show is steering towards Tolkien's ending
First, look for Sauron's arrival in Númenor. In Tolkien's account, he is brought to the island as Pharazôn's captive, and his influence over the king becomes one of the most important steps towards the downfall. If the series begins moving towards that part of the story, we may be getting closer to the events that destroy the kingdom.
The great armament is another major clue. Pharazôn's decision to sail west is not just another military campaign; it is the action that brings the story to its terrible conclusion. We should also pay attention to Elendil's ships and the White Tree. If the series begins emphasizing the survival of these things, it may be preparing the ground for the escape of the Faithful. The next episodes will give us more clues, but we should not pretend we already know what the show has not revealed.
The real succession: Númenor ends, but its legacy survives
When people ask who will be king after Pharazôn, I understand why Elendil is usually the first name that comes to mind. He is gathering the Faithful, he has Narsil, his sons are becoming important leaders and his family is connected to the future of Middle-earth. Everything about his story points towards a royal legacy.
But Tolkien's answer is more complicated than a straightforward transfer of power. Pharazôn is the last king of Númenor. Míriel is the last rightful ruler by inheritance, but she never gets to establish a lasting reign. Elendil escapes the destruction without inheriting Númenor's throne; he establishes Arnor and becomes High King of Arnor and Gondor. That is the real succession. The kingdom ends, but its people, its bloodline and its legacy survive.
In a way, that makes the struggle over Númenor's throne even more tragic. Pharazôn is fighting to preserve his power, Míriel has lost the crown she should have inherited, and Elendil is risking everything to protect the Faithful. Yet the future belongs to none of them in the way they might imagine. The crown does not pass to another ruler. It goes down with Númenor, and the next kingdom rises across the sea.
What other creators are saying
More on The Rings of Power →I think the show nails Tolkien lore aside from one flaw: keeping the eagles silent weakens the coronation, since a talking eagle could have clearly signaled support for Míriel instead of letting Pharazôn hijack the moment. I also think the rushed, confusing Númenor subplot stems from shooting during the writers' strike without rewrites.
After just two episodes, I felt The Rings of Power season 2 had moved past season 1's exposition-heavy setup into real emotion and human connection, with elves manipulated by Sauron's pride-stroking and dwarves drawn back to ring-making, making it more engaging than shows like House of the Dragon.
Rings of Power season 2 review: more emotion than season 1? →
I don't think season one was a total failure, though its pacing, a Galadriel arc that never earns sympathy or shows real consequences, and a purposeless Harfoot plot badly hurt it, while Elrond and Durin's friendship, built on genuine consequence and a strong moral dilemma, is the show's emotional heart.
Rings of Power season 1 review: what failed and what worked →
Watch the original
@filmparadise · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Film Paradise's video of 17 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @filmparadise
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

