Annabelle Comes Home: how much of the Warren story is real?
The 2019 Conjuring spinoff traps Judy Warren and her babysitters with the doll for one night. Here's what's real, what's hidden in the museum, and why I want a break from Annabelle.
Annabelle Comes Home isn't my favorite of the Conjuring series, but it does have some fun to it. I like the babysitter horror vibe and the focus on the kids rather than the Warrens. Even so, I'm getting some Annabelle fatigue, and it was fun getting a bit more information on some of the other artifacts in the Warrens' museum.
Annabelle Comes Home (2019), starring Mckenna Grace, Madison Iseman and Katie Sarife, is the third solo outing for the doll. Annabelle took a break while Valak carried 2018's The Nun. After Annabelle showed how the doll came to the Warrens and Annabelle: Creation showed where it came from, this one gives us a night in the life of the doll as she terrorizes the Warrens' daughter and her friends.
Annabelle Comes Home opens with the Warrens taking the doll, again
The film opens with a scene we've now seen about three times: the Warrens meeting Annabelle. It's the same scene that opens the first Conjuring and 2014's Annabelle, where the Warrens are called in by a nursing student and her roommates who claim the doll is possessed. This time we get an extra 30 seconds of Ed and Lorraine offering to take the doll to contain the evil. Thank goodness they fixed that plot hole. I thought they just shut her out of the house.
Driving home with Annabelle in the back seat, the Warrens are stopped by police at an accident. Ed asks if he can help and is asked if he's a doctor. "Or something," he says, which is funny to me, because what is he going to do? Lorraine then sees a bloody girl in front of the car, so whoever was in the accident is already dead. The car dies outside a cemetery, Lorraine spreads a map across the window, and the silence is preparing us for a classic James Wan loud noise.
The girl appears behind Lorraine and says "I like your doll," a callback to Annabelle Higgins in the first Annabelle. I love the camera trick where the girl disappears as Lorraine turns without a cut. At this point the jump scares have gotten a bit stale, but the camera work in these films is always top notch. More spirits gather at the cemetery gate, and Lorraine explains the doll is a beacon for the others.
Judy Warren, the sealed case and the real family story
Back home, Judy is up past her bedtime and Father Gordon is waiting. He's the paranormal Commissioner Gordon of these films, sending the Warrens on cases. In a one shot, Judy sees her parents through the window and runs to meet them, and her bedroom door shadow shifts, showing Annabelle is already causing trouble. I swear you can see Annabelle's head turn slightly toward Judy, synced to Lorraine's walking pace. I think the stories can be hit and miss, but the filmmaking is always excellent.
Father Gordon's blessing isn't enough, so Annabelle goes behind church glass. The score fades in and out of white noise until the cage closes and it goes dead silent. EVP apparently captures spirit voices on tape, often laced through white noise, so this ties the rumbling to Annabelle. A year later, Judy reads a newspaper calling her parents frauds after an exorcism, with a byline that's a nod to the film's prop master. The kids' show playing is Captain Kangaroo, which aired from 1955 to 1984 on a commercial network.
On fact versus fiction, the whole story is made up. The Warrens had a few claims about Annabelle after she went into the museum, but nothing like this. Leaving Judy to hunt demons is real, though. She spent most of her childhood with her grandparents, refused to sleep in the house on the few times she visited, and never lived with the collection, which was in a separate building attached to the house, not a basement. She says she still gets upset reading negative articles about her parents.
Easter eggs at school and Palmeri's Market
At school Judy is an outcast who eats alone and sees a creepy priest on the playground until she hides under her hood holding her cross. His bust names him Father Michael Morrissey, a nod to one of the film's producers. A bully, Anthony, later revealed as Daniela's brother, says nobody is coming to her party. Another girl who joins in is played by the daughter of DC Studios co-chairman Peter Safran, and she also appeared in Annabelle: Creation.
At the grocery store, Mary Ellen meets her friend Daniela, who's obsessed with the Warrens and clearly a troublemaker. The comic rack holds Action Comics, The Demon, Mister Miracle, Swamp Thing, Detective Comics and The Phantom Stranger, all from fall 1972, when the film is set. Each has a supernatural angle, and these issues involve heroes battling villains using artificial or resurrected bodies. They're all DC titles, owned by Warner Bros. Annabelle has popped up in Aquaman and Shazam, and the silver key from Aquaman sits on a museum shelf.
The store is Palmeri's Market, owned by the family of Bob, Mary Ellen's crush across the street. Palmeri has come up before, as Palmeri Apartments in 2014's Annabelle and the funeral home in The Devil Made Me Do It. They seem to control the whole economy of the Conjuring universe, and I wonder if one day they'll be revealed to be running the entire world.
Daniela opens the Warrens' museum and the real artifacts inside
Daniela blackmails her way into the house and calls for the spirits. The museum door carries the Magician tarot card, representing the union of the physical and spiritual worlds, as above, so below. That contrasts the Devil card on Annabelle's case, which represents fear and being trapped. Daniela turns a picture of Jesus face down and finds the keys behind it, which feels like punishment.
Inside are a samurai, what I'm pretty sure is the Book of the Dead from the Mummy films, and a picture of what looks like the real-life inspiration for the nun. There's a book on the Black Shuck, Feeley Meeley, a real Milton Bradley game from 1967, and a bride's dress. The Warrens had a dress representing the White Lady of Union Cemetery in Connecticut, whom they allegedly photographed. Many of the masks were Halloween junk Ed collected. The piano is real too, from a haunted house in Stratford, Connecticut.
Just the presence of Annabelle in the museum makes the spirits act up, and the accordion monkey starts to come alive. In 2021's The Conjuring: The Lover issue 3, the monkey, Jocko, holds the spirit of a nurse warning people that a child was the Antichrist. I'm not sure it's canon, but it gives him a reason to be here: he's trying to warn everyone to get Annabelle out.
Annabelle gets out and each girl's fear takes shape
Daniela calls out to her dead father. He died in a car accident in which he was driving, and she blames herself for his death. That's why she's so determined to get into the Warrens' house, and if that's what happened, I can forgive her for how she's behaved this whole time. When Annabelle slams against the glass, Daniela ignores the warning sign and opens the case, and the white noise returns. A smoke alarm pulls her away, she forgets to lock it, and Annabelle is free.
Judy senses Daniela's grief, beyond seeing the paranormal for the first time. The real Judy claims abilities, but that's a little contested. She stayed away from her parents' work until this film and a 2020 documentary, and later married Tony Spera, with whom she runs the New England Society for Psychic Research. Her son from her first marriage, Chris McKinnell, says otherwise: "My mom has never had anything to do with the paranormal." Then again, these films aren't trying to be based in reality anymore.
Bee from Annabelle: Creation appears at the door, with Samara Lee reprising the role. Judy finds Annabelle's note, Miss me, and a knife-wielding bride charges her in a shot that seems to be an homage to the nun's shadow in The Conjuring 2. I think many of the best scares come from slow, deliberate camera work. The bride is played by Peter Safran's wife. Ed's painting looks like the Snedeker house, which inspired The Haunting in Connecticut and happened in 1986, another sign of his psychic abilities.
The Ferryman, the Bride and the Black Shuck files
Daniela's case files reveal the Ferryman, whose victims look like Mary Ellen. A deleted scene has her recall nearly dying as a child and being read her last rites, which explains why he targets her. I wish they'd kept it, because it highlights how the demon uses each girl's worst fear: Daniela's guilt over her father, Judy's fear of ghosts and of never measuring up to her parents. Annabelle 2014 did the same to Mia.
The Black Shuck is an English legend of a demonic black dog. The Warrens investigated a 1989 case where UK man Bill Ramsey claimed to be a werewolf. The Ferryman draws on the Greek boatman of the River Styx, paid with coins over the eyes. The bride killed her husband and others and possesses anyone who wears the dress. Judy won't discuss Annabelle, who traumatized her in the first Conjuring a year earlier and is the source of her greatest fear.
Fake outs, Bob and the Circle of Fear door trick
Three fake outs in a row, from a scare at the door that turns out to be Bob to the lights going out for the birthday cake, strip the movie of tension. We learn the nickname Bob's Got Balls comes from him being the basketball team's ball boy. The Black Shuck chases him into the chicken coop, where he apologizes to a chicken it tears apart. Even terrified, he won't leave Mary Ellen.
Daniela finds the mourner's bracelet, made for the film but probably inspired by the Warrens' pearls of death. Her father plays Twinkle Twinkle Little Star with her, then screams that his death was her fault. The rocking chair references Ed's double rocking chair, which Zak Bagans bought the day Lorraine died.
Upstairs, Judy's door closing is synced to a door closing on a TV episode of Circle of Fear, Doorway to Death, about a closet holding a murderer's spirit. It foreshadows the Ferryman putting Mary Ellen in a closet. But that episode aired in 1973, a year after the film takes place.
The future TV, the Ferryman's coins and Valak
Daniela sees a TV showing her immediate future. Her reflection reacts a couple of seconds before she hears the snake, and Jocko acts up again. Mary Ellen follows the Ferryman's trail of coins to the kitchen. I love how the coins in his eyes glow before they fall to the ground, and the sound of the coins hitting the floor is really effective. The Ferryman is probably my favorite demon design in these movies, like the Crooked Man in The Conjuring 2: the coolest character we never see again.
Judy is yanked out of bed, and the projector reveals Annabelle's shadow as Bee, then Annabelle Higgins, then Valak, the demon controlling the doll as a conduit. The TV shows Daniela answering a phone and ending up covered in blood. I've criticized the future TV, but that was quite good. Judy stops her in time, and Daniela admits she touched everything.
The final battle and the ending of Annabelle Comes Home
Bob saves Judy from the Black Shuck, played by stunt actor Douglas Tait, who played Jason Voorhees in Freddy vs. Jason's final scene and Michael Myers in Halloween Kills, in a practical suit by Fractured FX. Bring back actors in monster suits. The samurai armor echoes in Japanese and may be inspired by the Oni. I like how the demons come from Japanese, Greek and English traditions, showing evil is universal.
Mary Ellen enters the Ferryman's hallway and finds her own corpse holding Annabelle. Daniela, possessed by the dress, is freed when Judy projects the exorcism over her face. The demon tries to take Judy's soul, which breaks the rule from 2014's Annabelle that a soul must be offered, but I guess they needed a boss battle. Judy slams a cross on it, and the girls lock Annabelle away. "The evil is contained."
At the party, Anthony apologizes, a nod to Judy's husband Tony Spera, though they met much later. Lorraine helps Daniela speak to her father, and the credits pay tribute to Lorraine Warren, who died shortly before release.
My verdict on Annabelle Comes Home
Letting the kids save themselves gives them agency, but the final battle is almost comically easy. It feels like a side quest, and none of the artifacts reach the heights of The Conjuring, The Nun or even Annabelle. Still, I'd like to see more of the Ferryman or even the future TV. Just give me a break from Annabelle. She's been carrying the whole franchise for ages.
What other creators are saying
More on The Conjuring →Composer Joseph Bishara has scored the Insidious and Conjuring films and played demons in both franchises
The Insidious Lipstick Demon actor also played Bathsheba in The Conjuring →
A Kickstarter promise led two self-declared horror haters to sit through the 2013 film, and it won some respect
Watch the original
@heavyspoilers · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Heavy Spoilers' video of 14 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @heavyspoilers
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

