Doctor Strange 2 original plan: was Shuma-Gorath the villain?
Pieced together from leaks, interviews and insiders, the early version had Wanda seeking redemption, Clea as a love interest and Shuma-Gorath as the real villain
Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness (2022), starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Elizabeth Olsen, definitely divided the fan base. I fall on the side that thinks it was a roller coaster ride with some of the best horror scenes in the MCU. Wanda was a great villain to me, and that chase across several universes felt like one of the most fun rides I'd had in the Marvel universe in a long time. But the film was originally going to be different from what we got, and the earlier plan had a different villain, a different Wanda and Clea appearing much earlier in the movie as a love interest.
What follows is pieced together from leaks, interviews and what insiders close to the movie have said: elements of what the original plan for the film was supposed to be.
Why Scott Derrickson left Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
If you cast your mind back to the Phase 4 announcement, you'll remember Scott Derrickson was initially behind the project. He had come off the back of the original Doctor Strange film, and at the event he said they were gearing up to create the first horror movie in the MCU.
Derrickson and the studio ended up parting ways over what was said to be creative differences. Rumors flew around at the time that Marvel were afraid of how far he was going to go with it. That was sort of debunked when Kevin Feige told Empire that the studio still loved Scott and that it was genuinely down to creative differences, though no one really believes them. Since then, Derrickson has gone on to direct the phenomenal The Black Phone, which might make you wonder what his original plan was going to be.
Three versions of the film and the No Way Home swap
There were three versions of this film: Derrickson's, and then Sam Raimi's plans both before and during the pandemic. Multiverse of Madness was originally slated to release before Spider-Man: No Way Home, but Sony refused to budge on their December release date, which led to the two films swapping places.
America Chavez was originally going to be introduced in Multiverse of Madness, and then in No Way Home she would be the person who pulled Andrew and Tobey across. This was shown in a lot of concept art for the film, and to me it makes way more sense than having Ned discover he's a wizard.
America Chavez and a Wanda seeking redemption
The original version of the film was meant to center heavily on America Chavez being trained by Strange and Wong. On top of this, they would also be helping Wanda to harness her abilities after the events of WandaVision.
Unlike what we got in the final release, Wanda was trying to redeem herself after Westview. She would start the movie as a fallen idol seeking redemption. She did eventually turn into a villain, much like in the final film, but this happened over time, and only after she learned about the multiverse by seeing what America could do.
She was also more of a puppet for the film's true villain. The plan was to spread madness throughout the multiverse, and this would be accomplished through her being a nexus being, someone who is the same in every reality. That would let the bad guys create branches through every reality by using her. Even so, she would turn bad at the end and face off against the heroes because she wanted her kids back.
Michael Waldron on making Wanda a villain from the start
Michael Waldron, the film's writer, has talked about how this evolved over time. He said that originally there was a version where Wanda was going to turn at the end of the film, but he decided to set things in place from the start instead.
In his words: "I think originally it was a version where wanda was maybe gonna turn bad at the end that was a big change that i made and i had a strong perspective on making her a villain from the get-go." He added that the thinking had always been that it would happen in an Avengers movie or something, but "my perspective was why are we letting some other movie get the best villain ever."
Clea as a love interest and Brother Voodoo as an ally
Alongside America's introduction, we would also have got Clea appearing much earlier in the movie. She would have been a love interest from the start, rather than Strange going back and forth with multiple versions of Christine. In the comics, the pair got married at one point, and this movie had elements that would show the foundations of their relationship being put in place.
They were also going to be joined by Brother Voodoo, who would act as an ally. I'm not sure whether this was changed to Rintrah for the final draft, but either way, Voodoo was in the early plans for the movie.
Shuma-Gorath and Nightmare as the original villains
The villains were going to be both Shuma-Gorath and Nightmare, building off the back of What If. Shuma-Gorath was going to be a multiversal entity who wanted to use his enforcer Nightmare to manipulate Wanda into wreaking havoc across the multiverse by using her as a vessel. He wanted to spread madness throughout the entire multiverse, and this would enable him to consume all of reality.
Shuma-Gorath sent out Nightmare, who captured America and took her hostage. The wizards then start to learn about Shuma-Gorath and discover that he had been defeated in the past by the wizard Cagliostro, who also appeared in episode 4 of What If. Once more, we were going to watch Strange encounter him and find a way to take out the villain.
This involved a mystical ritual with a heavy basis in the occult, and it would have added to the horror side of the movie. In the final version, we got Strange dreamwalking into his own corpse, which stirred the spirits of the damned, and I imagine this might have been along the same lines.
Mordo's plan to kill America Chavez
On the other side of this, we also had the Mordo from Earth 616, who returned after the scene after the credits of the first Doctor Strange movie. He was still hunting wizards.
After he also learned of Shuma-Gorath's plans, he attempted to kill America before Nightmare could take her to him.
The reported final battle in the realm of dead universes
A user on Twitter put together what was going to happen in the final battle. It would reportedly take place in Shuma-Gorath's realm, known as the realm of dead universes. This contained all of the realities the villain had consumed, and here Nightmare would unleash his full powers, bringing forth physical manifestations of the characters' worst fears.
It is also at this point that Wanda would fully change. She would realize there was a way to get her kids back and turn against the heroes. Though she would help them defeat Nightmare and Shuma-Gorath, it set a lot of things in place for the future.
Rather than "killing her off" the way the final release did, the plan used her more to set up future showdowns, and this could possibly even have tied into a House of M style movie. There has been stuff that is clearly based on it, but you have never had her truly change the entirety of reality the way she did in that book, and it would definitely be an interesting direction to take things.
Would the original Multiverse of Madness have been better?
Many of the complaints I see about Multiverse of Madness are that Wanda's change was too sudden. Having this movie make that change and then set things up for the future would probably have been the smarter way to go about it.
This would have massively changed the movie we were eventually given. I probably prefer the focus being on Wanda as the villain from the start. However, this version seems to handle some pieces better, such as Mordo coming back around. There was actually a scene in the original Raimi version that had him dying after being killed by Wanda. At the time I looked at this, though, he was still out there in the MCU, and it was going to be interesting to see whether villains like Nightmare would be brought across in the future.
We did get something similar to Shuma-Gorath in Gargantos, who appeared in the Raimi version as one of Wanda's minions. Having the creature as the main villain would have completely flipped things on their head, though, and I think it would have tied more into What If.
Whether this would have been better or not is difficult to tell, because these ideas don't paint the full picture. You also don't get elements like the Illuminati or the cameos we had throughout the film.
What other creators are saying
More on Scott Derrickson →The sequel's frozen afterlife, the truth about Finn and Gwen's mother, and the rules behind the phone, broken down after an early festival screening
I found Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness sloppy: the visuals, gore and action work, but the arcs for Doctor Strange, Wanda and America Chavez don't hold together or stay consistent with their previous stories, making the character work incredibly uneven.
Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness review: sloppy arcs →
In Multiverse of Madness, the watch Christine gave him stays broken until he talks with the Earth 838 Christine Palmer.
Doctor Strange's Broken Watch Mirrors His Relationship With Christine Palmer →
Why I found the Sam Raimi sequel maddening for the wrong reasons, from the music fight and the Illuminati to what it did to Wanda and America Chavez
Doctor Strange 2 review: why Multiverse of Madness maddens →
Watch the original
@heavyspoilers · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Heavy Spoilers' video of 30 July 2022 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @heavyspoilers
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

