Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness review: sloppy arcs
The look, gore and action work, but the arcs for Doctor Strange, Wanda and America Chavez don't hold together
I saw Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness (2022), starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Elizabeth Olsen, and I found it pretty sloppy. The visuals, the gore and the action work. The character work does not. Spoilers follow.
Many people are going to praise this movie for being different from the standard MCU, because it's a Sam Raimi movie first, more than a Marvel movie. Some of that praise is fair. My problem is with what the film does to its three main characters, and with how it treats the stories that came before it.
What Sam Raimi's Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness gets right
The movie looks far better than most MCU movies. It's also far gorier than what we're used to, which I like. It didn't seem to rely too much on the typical Marvel humor, which I also appreciate. The action overall is pretty great.
Since a good portion of the MCU movies have rather poor CGI, it was a refresher to see this one with fairly good CGI. That's about all the praise I can give, though. The character work I found to be incredibly sloppy. In my words, "it's not awful by any means but it's by no means good." Three characters have arcs here: Doctor Strange, Wanda, also known as the Scarlet Witch, and America Chavez.
America Chavez is more MacGuffin than character
America Chavez probably has the most rushed arc. She begins the movie and we have to accept that there's a girl out there who can travel through universes whenever she's scared. It's a Marvel movie, so I try not to think too much about that kind of thing. I enjoyed this character, and I thought the actress did a good job with what she was given.
But America Chavez isn't a character in this movie so much as a MacGuffin. It's her power Wanda is after, and she needs to be protected throughout the whole film. She talks about how she can't control her power and only activates it under duress. Then in the climax, Doctor Strange tells her she could control it the whole time, that it's in her head and she needs to trust herself. She does, and she learns to control it.
Nothing in the movie suggests how she overcame this other than trusting herself. I find that trope overdone, where a character only needs to believe in themselves to accomplish their goals. Still, I like the character and I hope I see her in the future.
The wedding scene raises blip questions the film drops
Doctor Strange begins the movie at the wedding of his former love, Christine, a character who hasn't been seen or mentioned since the first Doctor Strange movie. I haven't seen that one since it came out in theaters, around six years earlier. I got excited at first, because a guest starts asking Strange questions I found fascinating.
This man tells Strange he was blipped too, and in that time he lost both his cats and his brother. He asks whether giving Thanos the Time Stone in Infinity War was the only way Strange could have won the fight. So I guess what happened in Infinity War is now common knowledge to the entire world. I'm fine with that. Strange says he had no choice.
I wish the MCU dove deeper into the effects the blip had on people outside of Endgame. There's a moment in Spider-Man: Far From Home where someone says that in the five years he was gone, his wife married someone else. The movie plays it as a joke, but I thought it was an excellent idea to explore. Strange made a decision that did ruin many people's lives, but that thread is dropped, and the film treats his Infinity War decision as something negative, which I disagree with.
Doctor Strange's flaw doesn't fit what he did in Infinity War
We learn Strange is unhappy because he can't be with Christine, the woman he loves. She tells him the reason is that he always feels he needs to be in charge, and he's uncomfortable when other people save the day instead of him. That's the basis of his arc: he needs to learn to trust others to save the day.
This makes no sense to me. In Infinity War he made a decision where he would die and the other Avengers would have to save the day in Endgame. And in Endgame, Tony is the one who saves the day with his sacrifice, an action Strange encouraged. So this flaw didn't make sense to me from the start, but I can accept it.
The Multiverse is used poorly next to Loki and No Way Home
America Chavez shows up and tells Strange that every version of him she's seen across all these universes has the same problem: he needs to be the one who saves the day. I feel this was a poor way to bring the Multiverse into the movie.
Loki and Spider-Man: No Way Home both did an excellent job using the Multiverse to their advantage. Granted, I know Loki dealt with different timelines, but the concept of meeting alternate versions of yourself still stands. Both Loki and Peter Parker meet other versions of themselves, and those versions help the main Loki and Peter grow. It's also established that the same person looks different in every universe, yet here Doctor Strange and every Christine look the same. That's a minor nitpick.
Throughout the movie, Strange is told how dangerous his alternate versions are, to the point where the Illuminati needed to execute one because they couldn't trust him. That whole middle portion is cluttered. We're shown John Krasinski as Mr. Fantastic, Patrick Stewart as Charles Xavier and Captain Carter, and they didn't do anything other than serve as obstacles for Wanda to kill.
Doctor Strange's arc is not earned
Strange tries to prove himself to everyone, and he does, by allowing America Chavez to be the one who saves the day at the end. That mirrors the opening, where a different Strange tried to kill her to take her power. So yes, he goes on an arc. My biggest problem is that it isn't earned.
The flaw is shown in the alternate Doctor Stranges, but it's never shown in ours. As I see it, "not once does his need to save the day hurt our characters or the plot in any way." His arc concludes in the complete opposite way of Peter's in No Way Home. Peter had a flaw that caused problems, and the other Peter Parkers helped him overcome it. Here, Strange sees how his flaw caused problems for other Doctor Stranges and decides to change, even though he never caused any problems with it himself. That's not a compelling arc to me.
I also found the subplot about his happiness disappointing. Maybe this is only me, but I hate it when a character is in love, the message is to learn to let go, and they don't end up together. I'm not saying it's a bad message. People should learn to let go when a relationship doesn't work out. I don't like seeing it in a film, because it's depressing. That's my biggest problem with the movie: Strange's arc is uncompelling and doesn't make much sense to me, and the Multiverse is used in a rather poor way.
Wanda's motivation ignores Vision
I think Wanda does have a compelling arc, though there are things I find pretty problematic. Her motivation is that if she can travel to alternate universes, she can be with her kids again. Even though those kids were created through her imagination in WandaVision, apparently every other Wanda in every other dimension is a single mother with these kids. Fine.
What I find annoying is her complete disregard for Vision. The whole reason she did what she did in WandaVision was to be with Vision. The kids were a happy byproduct of that. In this movie she only cares about her kids, and I find that an inconsistency in her character. Vision is mentioned once or twice in the whole movie, which was annoying to me.
Setting that aside, I like that Wanda is motivated by something relatable. She wants to be with her family, and that's a powerful motivation. I wish the film had explored that with Strange too. At some point he could have had the chance to live in an alternate universe with Christine and chosen not to, because he knows it's wrong. That's what would separate him from Wanda, the villain of this movie. It isn't explored.
Wanda's best moment and the ending I object to
The climactic moment where Wanda's kids see her as a monster is the single best moment in the movie. Wanda realizes her quest to be with her two sons is turning her into a monster, someone her kids don't want to be with. Elizabeth Olsen's acting is fantastic, and she delivers on the heavier moments. She realizes what she was doing was wrong and lets her kids and the other Wanda live peacefully.
The way they wrap up her story is where I have a major problem. She basically kills herself because she can't be with her kids. Technically she sacrificed herself to destroy the evil spell book, but nothing suggested she had to die. I'm assuming she's dead because the movie gave no indication she could still be alive.
If she had real kids and could no longer be with them, I'd be somewhat okay with this, but not really. The major problem is that her kids never existed. Wanda died believing there was no purpose in living in a world without her made-up kids. I question what message that sends to women who can't be or aren't mothers. To me this is far worse than what Black Widow said in Age of Ultron about being a monster because she can't have kids.
What bugs me most is that, had Wanda stayed alive, nothing suggests she couldn't have kids if she wanted. She could go to a sperm donor and have real children, not figments of her imagination. If she couldn't have kids biologically, she could adopt two boys and raise them herself. I find it so weird that she ran a whole plan to kidnap a girl and manipulate the Multiverse for made-up kids, when she could have used that time to have her own.
Didn't Wanda already learn this lesson in WandaVision?
Didn't Wanda overcome this in WandaVision? At the end of that series she realized it's not right to hurt other people to get what you want. In this movie, the whole plot is about her wanting to hurt someone to get what she wants.
I feel that's the core problem with this movie. Looked at as its own story, it's not as bad as I've suggested. But this is a movie that relies on previously told stories, and it's a problem when those stories portray these characters in a different way. That is why I found Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness to be sloppy.
What other creators are saying
More on Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness →I loved the final film's horror and Wanda as villain, but I think the scrapped version, with Wanda turning gradually and setting up future showdowns, would probably have handled her change better, even though it's hard to say for certain which was truly superior.
Doctor Strange 2 original plan: was Shuma-Gorath the villain? →
In Multiverse of Madness, the watch Christine gave him stays broken until he talks with the Earth 838 Christine Palmer.
Doctor Strange's Broken Watch Mirrors His Relationship With Christine Palmer →
Why I found the Sam Raimi sequel maddening for the wrong reasons, from the music fight and the Illuminati to what it did to Wanda and America Chavez
Doctor Strange 2 review: why Multiverse of Madness maddens →
A surprise cameo and a display of power leave the room in disbelief
The 'What Mouth?' Scene in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness Draws Stunned Reactions →
Watch the original
@thegoldman25 · YouTube
Adapted with AI from The Gold Man's video of 8 May 2022 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @thegoldman25
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

