Pixar movies ranked: why Wall-E is number one of 29
Why The Incredibles is overrated, Luca and Elemental are underrated, Monsters Inc. outranks Toy Story 3, and Wall-E tops everything
Pixar had made 29 movies when I ranked them, starting with Toy Story in 1995 and running all the way to Elio, which was in theaters at the time I ranked them. I've ranked all 29 from worst to best, and my number one is Wall-E. I consider it not only the best Pixar movie and the best animated movie, but the best movie ever made.
At the very bottom sits Cars 2 at number 29. I think there are only two bad Pixar movies, and this is one of them, mainly because Mater, not Lightning McQueen, is the main character. He's a fine supporting character, but seeing him in the lead is maddening. Here is how the rest of the list runs, from number 19 to the top.
19. The Incredibles is the most overrated Pixar movie
I know this is the hottest take on the list: I don't love The Incredibles. My issues with it are the same ones I have with the sequel. I do love how it explores the realistic parts of life. Seeing Bob work a miserable office job isn't something you often see in superhero movies, and there's something powerful about a man with such aspirations being relegated to that. His sneaking behind his wife's back to feel the pride of his youth again is something I empathize with, and the family dynamic is well done.
The plot and the villain are weak, though. Syndrome is better than the Screenslaver, but he's just someone without powers who hates people with powers. He's defeated by Jack-Jack and no one in the family seems to question it, which was anticlimactic. Bob wanting his family to stay back near the end isn't a movie long arc either, since he only thought they died at the start of the third act. "I will never see what other people see in this movie." Maybe it's nostalgia, or maybe I'm missing something, but to me it's a middle of the road Pixar movie.
18. Cars is all right, and better than its sequels
The Cars trilogy deserves a lot of criticism, but I think the first one is all right. Lightning McQueen learns where happiness comes from: at first he only cares about winning the Piston Cup, then he realizes it's about the journey as well as the destination. The characters are more fun than in the sequels. I don't hate Mater here, though I don't love him either. I like the Porsche, and her dynamic with McQueen was sweet. Doc was probably my favorite, and his journey from grumpy old car to mentor put things into perspective for McQueen.
The world building is solid. It's modern Earth, but seeing how it works with cars as its main characters fascinated me. This may be a hot take, but throwing away the race for a larger message feels cliche, even if it shows growth. I like Cars' ideas more than its execution, which may be why it sits above the other two Cars movies. The sequels did it dirty, which is unfortunate since Cars is one of Pixar's two trilogies.
17. Brave got much better once Merida's mother became a bear
Brave was a first watch for me, and I liked it more than I expected. I didn't love the beginning. I don't care for movies set in medieval times where the girl at the center wants to fight with all the men; it's an overplayed trope. As the first Pixar movie with a female protagonist, I thought it would lean into that, but it only lasts maybe a third or a quarter of the movie. It gets much better once it's about Merida healing her relationship with her mother after Queen Elinor becomes a bear.
Both are strong characters. Merida is stubborn but compassionate, and the bonding scenes are sweet, especially when Elinor starts acting less like a proper queen. Her first moments as a bear were funny, and the brothers' bear scenes were hilarious. I like that the curse breaks when Merida takes accountability and apologizes. The ending was a bit rushed. Nothing stands out, so Brave isn't great, but besides how it was marketed, I don't have many issues. It's a solid movie.
16. A Bug's Life works because Flick is smart
This is where the list reaches the movies I really like. I love the premise of bugs protecting themselves from other bugs. Maybe because I feel like a bit of an outcast sometimes, Flick deeply resonates with me. He's clumsy like Mater, but unlike Mater he's smart: he thought of a fake bird to scare off the grasshoppers, and it only failed because of someone else. The arc works far better than in Cars 2.
I like Princess Atta and the circus troupe, who had great chemistry. The film has strong themes about community and adversity, and the uprising says something about oppression and exploitation. What holds it back is that I don't love much beyond Flick; nothing in the story jumped out as excellent. It's a fun movie I'd happily rewatch.
15. Up should have focused only on Carl and Russell
I have the same takes as everyone else. The opening is so strong, and Carl and Ellie's love story balances wholesomeness and heartbreak in a short time. There's something great about a kids movie making children empathize with an old man instead of the reverse. Carl and Russell's dynamic is great too. I get sad quickly when a kid misses their parents, and Up plays on that. Carl becoming a father figure to Russell is something I loved, and I was surprised the talking dogs were funny rather than annoying.
What I don't love is the villain. I don't think Up needed one at all. There's a powerful story here without a cartoonishly evil villain and a MacGuffin, and they turned what could have been a great movie into a good one. Up is rightly remembered for its beginning, but it's a shame it isn't remembered for all of its screen time.
14. Luca is a surprisingly good movie nobody talks about
Luca was maybe my biggest surprise, since I hadn't seen it before and had barely heard anyone discuss it. A boy who feels lost and unwanted underwater goes to land with another boy, Alberto, where they make friends and enemies while concealing their identities. Watching Luca learn to walk and live on land is funny, and his friendship with Julia is the most wholesome part. I got invested in their quest to win the competition and the Vespa, and Luca is so cute it's hard not to root for him.
The ending was a little quick, but I love the message: the boys reveal themselves and, after some backlash, the community embraces them. It works because they're kids, and excluding kids for being different is wrong. It came out during COVID and I believe it went straight to Disney Plus. It's not a great Pixar movie, but it's a really good one that deserves to be talked about.
13. Monsters University has one of Pixar's best messages
I've previously listed Monsters University as a disappointing sequel, and I take that back. As a prequel, I thought Mike going to scare school would make it predictable, but I was invested even knowing where the characters end up. Its message is one of my favorites from Pixar: just because you can't be great at one thing doesn't mean you can't be great in general. Mike tries his best to be a scarer and learns his creativity and work ethic can make him excel elsewhere. To me that's more real and relatable than Ratatouille's message that anyone can be great.
Having graduated college within the past five years, I felt nostalgia for the setting. One criticism: its portrayal of college, all frats and weird people, was cliche. It may not be as good as Monsters Inc., but it's a really good movie that deserves to be its prequel.
12. Toy Story is brilliant, I just love 11 movies more
Toy Story is arguably the best Pixar movie, and at this point nearly every film on the list is great. It says a lot that about 40% of Pixar's films are great, and Toy Story is one. I love Woody's arc of overcoming his jealousy and embracing Buzz, and the humor of Buzz thinking he's a real space ranger. The premise of toys that secretly come to life is so cool that as a kid it made me love my own toys more.
I don't love the ending. There's suspension of disbelief, as with Finding Dory, but a toy racer keeping up with a truck is funny to me. I also wondered how Buzz could think he's not a toy when he freezes every time Andy walks in. Those are nitpicks.
11. Toy Story 2 edges out the original
Woody's dynamic with the other cowboy toys is more powerful and thought provoking than anything in the first movie. It sets the franchise's precedent that kids grow up and stop playing with toys, seen through Jessie's story, and gives toys deep, depressing backstories. Woody being convinced to join them, then won back, shows he isn't infallible and makes him richer. The wider cast joining the adventure is how this sequel escalates. The only part I didn't love was the other Buzz, since we've seen that story before. It's an excellent movie and an even better sequel.
10. Coco does the new world adventure best
I have a soft spot for movies where characters discover a new world, and Coco does it best. Its emphasis on family matters to me. Its sad idea, that people are forgotten over time, makes me think of ancestors I know nothing about and makes me feel for Hector, the movie's emotional anchor. Miguel trying to save Hector is one of Pixar's most emotional moments. Like Miguel, who wants music while his family wants him in the shoe shop, I grew up thinking about movies all the time. I also laughed at details like security guards in the world of the dead. At the time, I didn't love that we were getting a Coco 2 in four years.
9. Inside Out is Pixar's most creative franchise
Diving into a girl's mind makes for interesting storytelling, and the message, that you can't be happy all the time and great moments need the bad ones, is A+ level. Riley's world feels like it's falling apart, and her breaking down to her parents was powerful. I love that Pixar devoted a movie to processing negative emotions. Each emotion has a defining trait, making great foils, and the Joy and Sadness dynamic can drive the film. Touches like literal thought trains make it funnier too.
8. Elemental is the most underrated Pixar movie
I take back what I said about Luca: Elemental is the most underrated. Besides Wall-E, it's the only Pixar movie driven by a love story, and that story was done excellently. Ember is hotheaded and impatient yet compassionate, and Wade's kindness and naivety make him her perfect foil. I'm a sucker for love montages, and it has one. The world building of Element City was a bit unoriginal but worked. Its message, shared with Coco, is that some people aren't designed to be like their parents. When Ember confesses and her father says he'll always love her anyway, that's the kind of scene I love. I'm glad it picked up in 2023 and became a box office win.
7. Finding Nemo is nearly perfect
I'm no parent, but it's easy to empathize with Marlin, who lost his entire family except one egg. Talk about an underrated beginning. The whole movie is about him finding Nemo only to learn he needs to let go, which I imagine I'll struggle with as a parent. I think it connected with adults the most, which is why it became a phenomenon. The jellyfish field, the shark attack and the turtles in the current are iconic. I still don't love Dory, but she's more tolerable here, and the tank fish are rich characters. I can always rewatch it.
6. Inside Out 2 is a little better than the first
Places in Riley's mind like the belief system, sarcasm and the vault of dark secrets are so creative and funny that I live for it. I wish the new emotions besides Anxiety had more screen time, but they're well developed, and their designs are underrated. Its handling of anxiety, through Riley's hockey camp and the pressure to fit in, is relatable. The scenes between Joy and Anxiety make it work, and Anxiety's anxiety attack is powerful. I hope they make a third one eventually.
5. Toy Story 3 has the most emotional ending in Pixar
The toys are symbolic of parents, and like Finding Nemo, this is about Woody learning to let go now that Andy is an adult. The ending is the most emotional I get from any Pixar movie. Unlike Toy Story 4, which sidelines the supporting characters for Woody and Bo Peep, they get moments to shine. The daycare of toys oppressing each other is surprisingly dark, and I love that the villain, Lotso, is a pink teddy bear who is power hungry. The handholding scene is one of Pixar's darkest. No Toy Story 4 or 5 could undo my love for it.
4. Monsters Inc. is the funniest Pixar movie
It lacks rich themes and emotional scenes, but it's borderline perfect. Sully and Mike's back and forth is so funny, and I audibly laughed when Sully thinks Boo is being killed in the trash compactor. The premise of monsters harvesting children's screams as fuel is so creative. "I could be locked in a room for years and never think of something as creative as that." Sully and Boo's connection gives it heart, maybe Pixar's most defining trait.
3. Ratatouille is a perfect Pixar movie
I love the characters, humor and themes, and Remy is maybe my favorite Pixar character outside my number one. I may not entirely agree that anyone can do anything, but it's a great message, and a rat aspiring to be a top chef is a great idea. Its expectations theme covers both Remy and Linguini, who lacks the talent he wants. Call me a hypocrite after my Toy Story nitpicks, but I love the rats in the kitchen. It has everything.
2. Soul reached into my soul
Movies about finding your passion resonate most with me. Joe's death stuck with me: you never know what could happen. I rewatched Soul right before leaving my corporate job, and I'd be lying if I said I didn't think about it when making that decision. I also relate to its idea that the journey matters more than the destination; reaching an arbitrary number won't bring me joy, but talking about movies every day will. It feels like it was made for me.
1. Wall-E is the best Pixar movie and the best movie ever made
Wall-E represents everything I love about film: a powerful message, great looks and multidimensional characters with deep arcs. It develops two characters who fall in love saying maybe three or four words, through actions, mannerisms and sounds. "The fact that the best romance I've ever seen comes from two robots speaks volumes about how great this movie is." Its real message is about the human condition: being perfectly sedated won't make you happy, but splashing water in a park or holding someone's hand will. The more technologically advanced the world gets, the more relevant it stays. It's my favorite movie ever, so it is the best Pixar movie.
Watch the original
@thegoldman25 · YouTube
Adapted with AI from The Gold Man's video of 28 June 2025 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
Also on Wall-E
2 creators, 2 takes →More from @thegoldman25
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →


