SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
ReviewFilm & TV

The Boys season 5 premiere review: is it the best opener yet?

My spoiler free look, with Matt, at the final season's opening pair, from Antony Starr's unleashed performance to a comedic second episode and a cautious hope for the finale

Heavy Spoilers (AI-assisted)17 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2009 · more than 1.6 million subscribers 1,390 words · 6 min read
The Boys season 5 premiere review: is it the best opener yet?

We were lucky enough to see the first two episodes of The Boys season 5 before they arrived, and we came away on the same page: this is a strong, fantastic opening to the final season. The Boys first launched in 2019, starring Karl Urban, Antony Starr and Jack Quaid. This is a spoiler free look at the premiere from me and Matt, one of our writers, researchers and editors.

The verdict in short: I think episode 1 is the best premiere the show has done, episode 2 is a step down but still good, and Antony Starr's Homelander sits at the center of all of it.

The Boys season 5 feels like the older seasons and the comics

Matt absolutely loved it. To him it felt a lot more like the older seasons of The Boys. He wasn't a big fan of season 4, which he felt mirrored real life too closely, the life we're living through at the moment. Season 5, by contrast, felt a bit more like the comics to him.

He acknowledged the comics are controversial, but said he feels they're a bit better in the later part of the story. Above all, the new episodes felt like the show had reached its endgame. There's a goal now, and the story is heading toward it. In his words, "it was a lot of fun."

Antony Starr gives his best Homelander performance in episode 1

Matt thinks Antony Starr does his best work of all the seasons here, calling him fantastic in a multi-layered role, and I think he takes it to the next level. I was surprised to learn that the season was written before the last presidential election, because much of it feels on the nose with what's going on today. My guess is that the plot was already in place and events simply turned out that way.

I think episode 1 hits the ground running. Many season finales, including recent ones like Stranger Things, drag things out and don't push the plot forward. Here, I was surprised at how much happens within the first 15 minutes: something is exposed, and everything starts falling apart because of it.

That gives Starr the chance to show what Homelander is truly like. I feel that in the past, the villain has been held back from doing certain things, even though we know he's bad. This time, about halfway into the episode, he's fully off the leash and doing whatever he wants. I think it's his best performance by far, and the best premiere the show has done.

The action toward the end of episode 1 also stood out. Because Homelander is so powerful, he rarely gets to do his thing, with the triple threat fight at Herogasm in season 3 the comparison raised. Here he gets to unleash his powers and fight properly instead of just lasering his subordinates.

Episode 2 brings a new superhero team and a lighter tone

Episode 1 ends in such a big way that the show could easily have released it on its own. Its final scene is impactful enough that it almost sucks all the air out of the room. Streamers, though, tend to insist on more than one episode for a premiere.

The second episode is a step down, though still good. It isn't quite a monster of the week story, but it centers on a superhero team we haven't met before that the Boys have to deal with. The new team riffs on Marvel and DC, including a play on a member of the Fantastic Four that's very funny. Episode 2 is mainly built around that character, and it lets the team work through a problem together.

This felt closer to the comics, where the Boys fight different teams, such as Teenage Kicks and the G-Men, including Hughie infiltrating one of them. Seeing teams other than the Seven was welcome, since the Seven are presented as godlike, mythical figures based mainly on DC's Justice League. Episode 2 also brings back an older character, already seen in the trailers, who throws a curveball into things. We won't say who.

There was a downside. Because episode 2 is a jokey, traditional Boys episode, it was felt to undercut the ending of episode 1. The tone between the two is very different: one is mostly comedy, the other is about fighting a war. The wish was that episode 1 had been released alone so audiences could sit with that ending for a week, though that was called a very minor thing.

Why The Boys keeps the focus on Homelander and the Seven

In the comics, the focus wasn't so heavily on the Seven, which allowed for an extra arc after Homelander was defeated, centered on Billy Butcher. The view in our discussion was that the show couldn't do that, because Starr, Homelander and the Seven are such strong characters and so much the focus.

The comparison offered was The X-Files. When Mulder and Scully left, John Doggett and Agent Reyes took over. They were loved, but Mulder and Scully were the characters people wanted to see, which is why they came back for the films and later seasons.

Homelander has been built up in a way that removing him would impact the show massively. The show has smartly kept the focus on him, recognizing that he's the strength of the season, while turning the other characters up to 11 as well.

Butcher, Annie and the Boys back together

Butcher's arc appears to set aside the ending of last season. It is acknowledged, but only in a passing line, which felt a bit convenient. With only two episodes seen, how that develops was still unclear.

There was an expectation of two teams going forward, a good resistance and a darker side, in the vein of Magneto and Professor X. Instead, everyone came back together, which doesn't make a lot of sense. Still, seeing them together was enjoyable because of Annie's story this season. Erin Moriarty does good work, and the writers have fleshed Annie out beyond being a typical resistance leader.

Having the band back together works better than keeping them divided. They still have conflicts and aren't all reading from the same hymn sheet. Episode 1 does a lot to reunite them, and it works well. There are some great dark moments, with Billy as a complicated character who does some bad things, and it all feels authentic to who these characters are.

The Deep, Ashley and Sister Sage stand out

The Deep gets strong material. He's clearly terrified of Homelander while trying to act macho, and he has a good standoff with A-Train. These character moments show who the characters are.

There had been a worry from the trailer that the show was skipping over things with Ashley. Instead, there's a good reveal about what's going on with her, which was called hilarious. Her return isn't just a gesture to bring the actress back for the final season. It fits where the story is going, especially given what happened after she took the V.

Sister Sage is strong too, though we don't yet know much about her endgame.

Homelander's conflict and the hope for an award

The supporting cast is given room to breathe, and the new characters feel true to the universe. There's a conflict within every character, even Homelander. He wants to be worshipped as a god and doesn't understand why people are afraid of him instead.

The people around him pretend not to be afraid, but they all seem to assume they could die within seconds if they anger him. He's now the most powerful person on Earth, politically and in terms of his powers, so any moment with him could be life or death. The hope was voiced that Starr wins an award for this season, and it met with immediate agreement.

The way he flips between the old Homelander, his mommy issues and the would-be tyrant is fantastic to watch, and every scene he's in carries tension. There are so many curveballs that, even with deep familiarity with the source material, it was impossible to predict what was coming. Yet it still feels true to the characters, and nothing feels clichéd.

Cautious optimism about The Boys finale

Looking beyond episode 2, the show has brought forward the epilogue story from the comics and is merging it all into one, which makes where it goes next very interesting. The balance of humor, drama, shock moments and gore felt well planned, with no single element overemphasized.

There are plenty of meta jokes about finales. Episode 1 itself acknowledges that a finale has to please so many people and tick boxes to tie up every loose end. Finales are almost impossible to get right, and Stranger Things was raised as a reminder that a final season can have good parts and bad parts. So the mood was cautiously optimistic.

Reviews had come out by then, with the belief that the season scored 100% on Rotten Tomatoes. But critics hadn't been sent the finale, so it remained to be seen whether it would face backlash.

As far as first episodes go, we're on board.

Watch the original

@heavyspoilers · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Heavy Spoilers' video of 7 April 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

The BoysThe Boys season 5HomelanderAntony StarrErin MoriartyTV reviewPrime Videosuperhero TV

Also on The Boys

2 creators, 5 takes →

More from @heavyspoilers

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →