Rocksteady's next Batman game: should crime scenes be failable?
With a single player Batman game reportedly in the works, I explain why real detective work, one Gotham neighborhood I can learn and maybe Batman Beyond would excite me more than a bigger map
The first thing I want to see from Rocksteady's next Batman game is a crime scene where I can get it wrong. Give me a body, three suspects and a whole block of Gotham to figure out what happened. I want to spend 20 minutes chasing the wrong guy because I missed something in the first five minutes, and then let me go back to that crime scene and see what I missed.
That would excite me more than a trailer telling me the map is four times bigger than Batman: Arkham Knight. Rocksteady is reportedly looking to go back to single player Batman, and I think there's a trap waiting for them. They could give us the safest, prettiest Arkham game they've ever made, and we could all be over it by the second weekend.
What has been reported about Rocksteady's single player Batman game
In February 2025, Bloomberg's Jason Schreier reported that Rocksteady was looking to return to Batman with a single player game, and that the project was years away at that time. Warner Bros. Discovery also told shareholders that 2024 was a very disappointing year for its games business, and it singled out Batman as one of the characters it wanted and needed to focus on.
Look at what's going on in the DC world on the movie and show side, too, where many people have been saying Warner should have focused on Batman. So there is credible reporting on the direction, and there is a clear reason Warner wants to go there. I'd safely say Batman is to DC what Spider-Man is to Marvel. It's a safe bet.
Still, as of now, there's no official Rocksteady reveal. There's no title, no gameplay and no release window. You may have seen 2028 or 2029 thrown around on the internet, but that was rumor territory.
Arkham Knight's Batmobile shows the trap a bigger Gotham could fall into
After Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League, I completely understand why single player Batman is enough to get people excited. Load up Arkham Knight, get on a rooftop, look down at the street, and you remember how quickly that game lets you do the thing you bought it for. You can drop in on a group of guys and disappear around a corner halfway across Gotham before you've decided what mission you want to play.
But I also remember how often Arkham Knight asked me to get back in the Batmobile and fight another wave of tanks. I like the Batmobile. I like driving it. Every time the game made me use it again, though, I liked it a little less and became a little more defiant.
I can already picture a new Arkham game making the same mistake. You get a bigger Gotham, a longer list of gadgets, more AI, twice as many things on the map, and then you spend the next 30 hours doing the same four things.
Give me one Gotham neighborhood I can learn
Instead, give me one neighborhood I can learn. I know there's a diner that's open all night. I know which rooftops are close enough to glide between. I know the guy who runs the pawn shop always leaves through the back, because I've seen him do it from three different angles on three different nights. That's detective work.
Then one night the diner's closed and the pawn shop owner is waiting outside it. If I notice that while I'm on my way to do something else, I'm going to follow that guy before I'd follow any yellow marker you put on the map.
Batman detective work where a wrong deduction matters
This is where I'd put the biggest change. The old games gave you the tools to look like the world's greatest detective, which is what Batman is. I want the next one to let me make a deduction.
Say there's a murder in an apartment and the window's broken. The game lets you look at the glass, pull footage from across the street and talk to the person who heard it happen. If you assume the killer came through the window, you can follow that lead. Maybe it takes you to somebody who's scared out of his mind because Batman just dropped onto his fire escape. Whatever it is doesn't matter.
Some of you may not want that slow, methodical type of gameplay, and would rather take out waves of bad guys. I get it. But I want that mistake to matter. Maybe the real suspect has time to leave town if I spend all night on the wrong lead.
Keep free flow combat and tie predator rooms to the investigation
I do want to keep the free flow combat, please. I still want to clear a room and feel like I knew where everybody was without even thinking about it.
I want the predator rooms too, but tied back to the current investigation. If I cut the power and grab the first guy who walks underneath me, maybe I get through the room faster. If I wait and listen, maybe I hear who he's supposed to call when that shipment comes in. I want all the different angles. I'm being greedy here. I want the whole cake.
Why I'd take a Batman Beyond game with Terry McGinnis
There's one version of Batman I'd take over Bruce Wayne if Rocksteady were willing to take the risk. A specific Batman Beyond leak floated around earlier this year, and Schreier dismissed it. Still, that's what I want to play.
Picture Neo Gotham. The street you're investigating is 50 floors below the people who own it. Terry can fly up the side of a building, cut his engine and slip through the maintenance door before anybody knows he's there. He can use the suit's camouflage to get inside a room, then find out the guy he's following has a camera that can see him anyway. Suddenly you're thinking differently about traversal, stealth, combat and what kind of evidence even exists in a city like that.
You can still get Bruce. Put him in Terry's ear, looking at the same case you're looking at, as a confidant or partner. Let him tell you to go left, and let Terry go right because he grew up in this neighborhood and knows things Bruce doesn't. I want to see what happens the first time Terry makes the better call and Bruce has to sit in it and admit it. You could build a whole game around that relationship, like a good cop, bad cop buddy system.
The safe route: sticking with Bruce Wayne and the Arkham story
The safe angle, of course, is sticking with Bruce, and I'd be there for that too. But I think if they went Batman Beyond style and took a chance in a good way, not a Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League type of chance, people would appreciate it.
If they decide to continue the Arkham story, I feel like that's the absolute safest route in their minds at the board meetings. Arkham has the name recognition, though it also has a little bit of bad taste, but it's the easiest to go back to. In that case, I'd want anything from Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League dropped from canon, and to stay with Bruce. Seeing a Gotham that's learned how to live without Bruce would be something.
What I want to see when Rocksteady reveals its Batman game
Whenever Rocksteady shows this thing, and they are going to show it, I want one uninterrupted stretch of gameplay. I don't know if it's going to be this year, but they are definitely working on it. I don't want a teaser, a cinematic, a fight sequence or some outlandish claim that the map is eight times as big with 4,000 AI characters all doing different things.
I want to see detective work. Batman drops on a roof, sees something happening below and decides what to do about it. Show me what he notices, how he gets in and what happens if he makes a mistake. If I see that and immediately think I would have done it differently, that's it. "Hand me the controller. Take my money." Maybe I'm in the minority.
Look at the latest Spider-Man movie. For the most part, it took him back to friendly neighborhood Spider-Man, at ground and city level, and everybody loved it. It doesn't have to be multiversal, cosmic craziness every single time, and I don't think this next Batman needs to be either. I think they need to focus on the world's greatest detective. I truly think that's the win.
What other creators are saying
More on Rocksteady →A Warner Bros. Discovery executive's comments, fresh rumors, and hidden credits on a recent LEGO Batman game all suggest the studio behind Arkham Asylum is quietly rebuilding its biggest franchise.
Batman Arkham reboot: is Rocksteady's comeback set for 2028-29? →
I think The Batman is phenomenal and builds its characters better than any other Batman story, with Bruce, Selina and the Riddler working perfectly together, and I believe DC needs authorship like Reeves' to earn passionate love rather than mere apathy, so if DC lets Reeves do his thing this universe is destined for greatness.
The Batman: why Matt Reeves' Batman, Catwoman and Riddler work →
I built Clayface's Gotham on old school craft and hidden symbolism, like skin conditions mapped onto a decaying apartment and a courtroom literally split between heaven and hell, even though I know most viewers will never consciously notice these details.
I think Gunn will cast a relatively unknown, non-movie-star actor close in age to the 33-year-old Corenswet, likely someone from TV or indie film, since Gunn values the best actor for the role over star power and may want Batman and Superman to be future best friends.
Watch the original
@morechaosgaming · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Chaos' video of 13 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @morechaosgaming
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

