SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreMarvel

Agatha All Along theory: did Tony Stark see Lady Death?

If Death escorts every soul in the MCU, then Thanos, Natasha, Vision and Tony Stark all may have met her, and one look in Avengers: Endgame takes on new meaning

New Rockstars (AI-assisted)16 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2011 · more than 4.4 million subscribers 2,000 words · 9 min read
Agatha All Along theory: did Tony Stark see Lady Death?

Death does come for us all, and Agatha All Along confirmed it. Since Death escorted both the witch Alice Wu-Gulliver and the non-witch Nicholas Scratch, we must assume that every character with a soul in the MCU, witch and non-witch alike, was ferried to the afterlife by some form of this character. Here I'm revisiting the most significant deaths in the MCU and recontextualizing Death's role in them, and I think we can pinpoint the moment Tony Stark saw Death waiting for him.

Agatha All Along (2024) starred Kathryn Hahn, Aubrey Plaza and Joe Locke. Plaza's Rio Vidal was introduced as the Green Witch, a member of Agatha's coven on the Witches' Road. In episode seven, she revealed her true form to Lilia Calderu as the skull faced Lady Death, or Mistress Death, of this Cinematic Universe.

Agatha All Along's Lady Death is life and death in conversation

While it seemed Lady Death could only take that form on the Witches' Road, we also get to see that skull face back up on the surface, in the main world of the MCU.

The show's costume designer has spoken a lot about Death's various costumes. As the Green Witch, the costume embodies an active mycelium fungal network, with a spider on the shoulder. Head writer Jac Schaeffer told The Wrap that it was important to the writers for this version of Death to be in constant conversation with life: "we didn't want death to be destruction." The goal was to embrace the neutrality of nature and how it's "beautiful and Fierce and terrifying and uncaring but also can hold you." Hold on to that connection between Death and nature, because I think it's important to how we see Death in the MCU.

The costume designer also explained the comics origins of the look: "she is actually death itself in every costume that she wears on the show." A little of her ribs shows because the team wanted to call attention to a silhouette introduced in the comics. One comics image of Death comes from 2017's Ben Reilly: Scarlet Spider #7. It's arguably the most feminine Death has ever looked, but one key detail is maintained: the hooded skull face.

Lady Death in Marvel Comics, from Captain Marvel #26 to the Infinity Gauntlet

Death's first appearance in Marvel Comics as an embodied character was in Captain Marvel #26 in June 1973. That story follows Thanos's conquest of the universe, which he undertakes to prove his love for Lady Death by destroying all life. In that storyline he obtains the Cosmic Cube.

Jim Starlin continued the storyline in the early '90s Infinity Gauntlet crossover event, in which Thanos obtains the six Infinity Gems and succeeds in wiping away half of all life. That, of course, inspired the Infinity War film. It's worth remembering that in Marvel lore, Death isn't something specific to Earth. She comes from the cosmos, and when you think about it, that's true in the MCU as well.

Death appeared in Guardians of the Galaxy and Thor: Love and Thunder first

Before Agatha All Along, Death had appeared in the MCU twice. The first was an engraving on the walls of the Morag temple at the beginning of the first Guardians of the Galaxy film. It's better seen during the Collector's monologue on Knowhere later in the film, where depictions of Death, Entropy, Infinity and Eternity surround the Infinity Stones. Marvel released a labeled version of this in The Art of Guardians of the Galaxy book.

The other appearance was as one of the cosmic entities in the chamber in Thor: Love and Thunder. Those entities included Eternity presiding over the front of the room, Uatu the Watcher, the Living Tribunal, the Celestial One Above All, Death, Eon and Infinity. Many of them we've seen in other forms. Beyond the Eternity statue was an ethereal space where Eternity's true form resided, and technically that version of Eternity transformed Gorr's daughter into the entity known as Love. We've seen the Watcher in animated form in What If and in I Am Groot. We saw a severed statue head of the Living Tribunal in the Void in Loki, and multiple Living Tribunals in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. Other Celestials showed up in Eternals and Love and Thunder.

Eon, the entity that represents time, has not been shown. However, Iman Vellani confirmed exclusively to us in an interview about a year earlier that in The Marvels, the moon where Dar-Benn digs up the other Quantum Band was, in an earlier version of the scene, the grave site of Eon. That implies even Eon, one of the cosmic entities, was ferried to some cosmic afterlife by Mistress Death.

Why Lady Death may not look like Aubrey Plaza everywhere in the MCU

Now that Agatha All Along has shown Death's embodied form, I think we can deduce that she might not look like Aubrey Plaza everywhere in the MCU. I think we can also deduce that her natural form is just a feminized body with a skull face, and that Rio Vidal is a form Death takes on Earth and among other humanoid civilizations, a face she wears so as not to upset the soul she is transitioning to the afterlife.

Based on how Death works in the comics, which seems to be generally how Marvel is approaching the character, Death and other cosmic entities of that status supersede all realities of the Multiverse. There isn't a 616 Death and a separate 838 Death. There's one Death. That's why she's so busy, and why, to keep up with all these transitions, she must not be bound by time. I think showing Death physically slicing through the backdrop of the Witches' Road is a hint to that. She can see through and cross the borders of magical pocket realms and realities produced by mortals.

To be clear, Death itself is a different thing from the goddess of death, who is Hela in the MCU. Gods and goddesses in this universe are rooted in mortal spiritual belief networks, representative avatars of concepts important to a society of mortals, but they are not the abstract concepts embodied. Still, I think we can safely assume Death and Hela probably have some kind of relationship. That isn't too hard to imagine.

Lady Death guides souls to many MCU afterlives

One final rule: Lady Death is the embodied concept of the process of death. She isn't the guardian of any single afterlife, or of all the afterlife options souls in the MCU transition into. The MCU has introduced a variety of them. For Wakandans, there's the Ancestral Plane. For Asgardian warriors who die in battle, like Heimdall and Jane Foster, there's Valhalla. For Rocket and Lylla in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3, it took the form of a white limbo space. For believers in Egyptian mythology like Steven Grant, it's the Duat, the Field of Reeds, the Aaru.

In Moon Knight episode 5, Taweret, the Egyptian goddess of women and children, explains how these afterlives intersect, describing how many "intersectional planes of untethered Consciousness" there are, like the Ancestral Plane. The fact that they're all connected suggests one being brings souls to these different options, as if there's a road map someone knows how to follow, taking different exits off the same path.

That phrase, untethered consciousness, helps us understand what Death is doing. I think she's severing the tether between the soul and the body on this plane of existence and carrying those untethered souls to one of these afterlives. It's also why it's so important that Schaeffer and her writers depicted Death as a reflection of both the decay and the growth of life. Death exists as one of these cosmic beings because she's a necessary part of the cycle of nature for new life to grow.

Thanos and Lady Death after Thor's killing blow in Avengers: Endgame

Start with Thanos, who in the comics has an important relationship with Death. We've seen him die multiple times: decapitated in the opening act of Endgame, permanently dusted at the end of Endgame, and, in his alternate 838 version in Multiverse of Madness, impaled by his own sword. In animation, a zombified Thanos appeared in What If episode 5, and he was sliced in half by Ultron in episode 8.

When Thor decapitated him, from his perspective Thanos probably found himself on the floor of his cottage on that garden planet, either while the Avengers were still there or after they left, and looked up to find Lady Death's skull faced form waiting. I think we have to assume that conversation was contentious. Whatever passes between Death and the deceased occurs outside linear time, because she supersedes time.

So the Death who met Thanos there would know what he had tasked her with by using the Stones: ferrying half of all life in the universe. She'd also know that Bruce Banner would bring them all back five years later. I would love to see a scene of Aubrey Plaza screaming in his face, asking why he wasted her time and gave her all that pointless work.

How busy Lady Death was during the blip

From the perspective of the dusted, the blip was a smooth, nearly seamless transition through time. Monica Rambeau woke from what seemed like a nap in the same chair in that hospital. In Hawkeye, Yelena was in the same bathroom while the pictures and wallpaper changed around her. That smoothness was all thanks to Death. She made it so the dusted forgot which afterlife they had been ferried to, and none of them would remember her face.

In Agatha All Along episode 8, Agatha tells Billy that 120 bodies are emptied out every minute. "Emptied out" struck me as something she might have been repeating from Death, complaining about how busy her job is. 120 deaths per minute is apocalyptically higher than the real world, where 105 or 106 people die every minute on Earth. I think the number is higher in the MCU because apocalyptic events are happening on planets across the galaxy beyond Earth, and in the future and past.

From Coulson to Vision: Lady Death at the MCU's biggest deaths

For every soul who has died in the MCU, Death was waiting. That means all the casualties of every conflict across Phases 1 through 5: the Battle of New York and Coulson, and Pietro Maximoff, gunned down by Ultron in Sokovia. For Wakandans like T'Chaka, Killmonger, Queen Ramonda and T'Challa, Death was there to guide them to the Ancestral Plane.

Of the deaths before the snap in Infinity War, Heimdall and Loki, who died on the Asgardian refugee ship, were probably ferried by Death to Valhalla. Gamora, thrown over the cliff by Thanos on Vormir, was probably guided to some Zehoberei based afterlife. Death was there for Vision in the Battle of Wakanda too. I'm including him because I'm assuming the Mind Stone endowed him with a soul, and that the Vision in WandaVision was a piece of Wanda's grief rather than Vision himself. Unless, if you want to get crazy, the afterlife Death took Vision to might have been Wanda's pocket reality, the Hex.

Natasha, Gamora and Lady Death on Vormir

In Endgame, Natasha Romanoff probably sat up from that puddle on Vormir and saw Death waiting for her. With both Natasha and Gamora, there probably was some comment about the visual similarity between this Lady Death and the Soul Stone keeper standing at the top of the mountain they fell from. That's because both the Infinity War team and Schaeffer acknowledged that Red Skull in Infinity War and Endgame was based visually on Lady Death in the comics, and on Agatha they didn't want Rio to look too much like Red Skull from those movies.

Nebula also described Vormir as "a Dominion of death the very center of celestial existence." I think that's a place Death would rule over, that she has a special connection to the Soul Stone, and that Red Skull, like Hela, would be some other being tasked to serve her.

Aunt May, Jane Foster and Lylla

The more recent shocking deaths fit too: Maria Hill in Secret Invasion, Aunt May in Spider-Man: No Way Home, MODOK in Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania, and the Illuminati of the 838 universe in Multiverse of Madness. A form of Death was ready to take each of them to some afterlife beyond. That includes Jane Foster in Thor: Love and Thunder, a transition similar to the Wakandans', except her exit point was Valhalla.

When Lylla died in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3, would Death have taken the form of an otter? It's hard to say. The High Evolutionary experimented on these mammals to give them the intelligence and souls of what he deemed higher, bipedal life forms, so Death may still have looked like Death for her. Again, we don't know.

The moment Tony Stark may have seen Lady Death

Tony Stark's death scene is very interesting in retrospect if you consider that Death was beckoning to him. FRIDAY reports that his life functions are critical, and Pepper Potts says, "Tony okay look at me we're going to be okay you can rest now." When Pepper tells Tony to look at her, where was he looking? Had he been looking off to the side because he was seeing someone calling to him?

Obviously, when Robert Downey Jr. shot the scene, he and the Endgame filmmakers weren't imagining Lady Death or Aubrey Plaza in the character's eyeline. But I do think that when many of these Marvel actors shoot their death scenes, especially Downey here, they include a moment where they untether and look beyond the people around them, focusing their gaze on something we cannot see or comprehend.

It's what Hugh Jackman emoted in his death scene in Logan, replayed in Deadpool & Wolverine: "this is what it feels like." What I loved about Jackman's read is that he was reacting to the screenplay by James Mangold, Scott Frank and Michael Green, which called the moment "a flicker of Wonder." Is that flicker of wonder now Death's green torch? All of these deaths show actors reacting to something wondrous, something natural and beautiful, something abstract. Now we know what that thing was.

What other creators are saying

More on Lady Death →
The Cosmic Wonder · more than 990,000 subscribers
In the comics, Lady Death is a cosmic entity personifying death who shaped Thanos into a killer and shares a complicated romance with Deadpool, who she loves because he cannot die. She was played by Aubrey Plaza in Agatha All Along, and her portrayal there suggested she might take a more active MCU role going forward.

Lady Death in Marvel: why does she love Deadpool over Thanos? →

GIQUE · more than 25,000 subscribers
Mrs. Hart's death, the clues pointing to Rio's true identity, a musical episode that felt too campy, and the Funko spoilers that gave the game away

Agatha All Along ep 4: was Rio Vidal really Lady Death? →

The Movie Couple · more than 80,000 subscribers
Our verdict on Agatha All Along episode one was positive with reservations, a fun start that dragged a little too long in Westview before getting going, buoyed by Aubrey Plaza's fun, spicy performance, though we wished Agatha had finished her off instead of sending the Salem Seven.

Agatha All Along episode 1 review: a fun start that drags →

Kristian Harloff · more than 230,000 subscribers
A first look at the Marvel premiere from one person who knew the WandaVision backstory and one who knew nothing at all

Agatha All Along episode 1 review: is it worth watching blind? →

Watch the original

@newrockstars · YouTube

Adapted with AI from New Rockstars' video of 8 November 2024 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Agatha All AlongLady DeathAubrey PlazaRio VidalTony StarkIron ManAvengers: EndgameThanos

More from @newrockstars

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →