Could McAvoy and Fassbender Return to Marvel, and Why Fox Never Made a Deal
I revisit X-Men: First Class and the two questions it raised: whether the rebooted Fox mutants could still turn up, and why Fox and Marvel Studios never partnered
At the time of this discussion, the MCU seemed to be bringing mutants like Jean Grey into movies like Spider-Man: Brand New Day, with terms like mutate and evolution entering the language around enhanced persons. I think it's a better time than ever to revisit how mutation was explored in Marvel films, starting with X-Men: First Class (2011), starring James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender and Jennifer Lawrence. My revisit also raised two bigger questions: could McAvoy and Fassbender ever come back, and why did Fox never make a deal with Marvel Studios?
X-Men: First Class introduced the children of the atom
X-Men: First Class is the film that introduced the phrase children of the atom in a way that I think is going to be very important to how Marvel Studios adapts the X-Men. That isn't only because Bruce Banner is lecturing at Empire State University about the subatomic particles that hold the nuclei of atoms together. Well, maybe because of that, too.
X-Men: First Class wasn't only a good X-Men movie. It provided so many critical lessons for future filmmakers: how to introduce iconic mutants on screen, how to blend them with history, and how to make the emergence of their powers a natural adaptation to their environment.
Evan Peters' Quicksilver and the hope for McAvoy and Fassbender
Evan Peters only shows up in the 1973 storyline of X-Men: Days of Future Past, the same era as Charles Xavier played by McAvoy, along with Fassbender, Lawrence and Nicholas Hoult. When Peters appeared in WandaVision, the reaction from many people was that it raised the odds of seeing McAvoy and Fassbender again. The way WandaVision ultimately made him Ralph Bohner, though, made that feel less likely.
So I asked Jessica Clemens whether Avengers: Doomsday or Secret Wars could bring back McAvoy or Fassbender. Jessica thinks it could. She admitted it might just be her deep down heart talking, but to her Ralph Bohner is a variant of Quicksilver in a different reality, so Evan Peters is still Quicksilver, just one who happens to be a failed actor in that universe. From that angle, she'd like to think there could be a reality where young McAvoy and young Fassbender play these two again.
The obstacle Jessica raised was time and money, and whether the actors would commit to such a small cameo. She thinks McAvoy might be done and Fassbender might be uninterested in returning. She called it crazy that Hugh Jackman would come back as Wolverine while those two seem to say no. She didn't mean it as a mean thing, more that they are doing other things and this was a career they had around 15 years ago.
Did X-Men: Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix hurt the First Class cast's chances?
I pitched Jessica a film theory. If the only two movies from this era were X-Men: First Class and X-Men: Days of Future Past, pretending X-Men: Apocalypse in 2016, Dark Phoenix in 2019 and New Mutants never happened, then 2014's Days of Future Past would be the last time we saw Fassbender, McAvoy, Lawrence and Hoult. In that case, there would be a better chance of those characters coming back in the MCU.
The argument is that Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix damaged the franchise so badly, and so recently, that people don't want to see these versions again, whereas ending on a high would have helped. A counterpoint followed: by the logic of the timeline reset in Days of Future Past, audiences would want to see these characters in the 1980s anyway.
The response was that Marvel could still pick and choose if it wanted to. There'd be no problem saying, "We just want this character. We're going to ignore Dark Phoenix completely." The view offered was that they don't want audiences to remember Dark Phoenix exists, and sometimes not Apocalypse either.
Could Fox have joined the MCU the way Sony did with Spider-Man?
Days of Future Past was so successful that another X-Men film was inevitable, but I think Fox rushed the next one out, and the franchise went off the wheels at that point. I can understand Fox feeling it had to make an X-Men movie every two years, but I think it could have made Deadpool the future of the franchise and worked toward a Deadpool and Wolverine team up instead.
Fox needed an executive willing to part ways with McAvoy and the others for a while, then bring them back through a partnership with Marvel Studios, like the Spider-Man partnership Sony struck. Fox could have seen how fortuitous that deal became in Captain America: Civil War, taken time off, and done a multiverse Secret Wars style event earlier.
I see no reason the X-Men couldn't have shown up in Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame. Days of Future Past had already reset the timeline, so the Scott Summers, Jean Grey, Logan and Professor X at the end of that movie could have been placed in the MCU. "If you squint through that window, there's Avengers Tower in the background." There was a guess that maybe one person at the studio said they could do it, and 50 others said let's not.
Why Fox and Marvel Studios never made a deal
Then there's the business history. I think Ike Perlmutter, still Kevin Feige's boss before Civil War, refused to make a deal with Fox and Rupert Murdoch and wanted to crush them instead, and that it was really Feige who stepped out of line and made the deal with Amy Pascal, seeing Sony's weakness. 2014 was the key year.
It's interesting that The Amazing Spider-Man 2 grossed about 709 million dollars worldwide and was seen as enough of a failure that Pascal felt she had to make a deal with Feige. Days of Future Past, by contrast, did slightly better, yet the franchise was viewed as untouchable and not something to make a deal over. The point came up that Sony has other things, but Spider-Man was the property it would not lose.
There were various reasons a Fox deal didn't happen. One was the Sony hack, which came from North Korea, and which weakened Sony's reputation and left its executives vulnerable in ways they otherwise would not have been. On the Fox side, any movie with X-Men in the title, for at least a certain number of years, had to credit Bryan Singer as a legacy producer, something Feige would never want to do.
Finally, Murdoch was looking ahead at the streaming wars, as Netflix challenged other studios to license their content through it. So Murdoch decided to sell Fox's film studio to Disney, and Bob Iger said, "Great. We'll do that."
What other creators are saying
More on X-Men: First Class →After Logan, Deadpool and the MCU, Sam finally steps into the X-Men films, and the plan is to finish them all before Doomsday
X-Men: First Class reaction: does Sam love her first X-Men movie? →
My favorite option is for James McAvoy to step in and finish Patrick Stewart's Fox era Professor X arc in Secret Wars, possibly as a younger Xavier inside Doom's Battleworld. I think that would be a beautiful, meta tribute to Stewart.
Can James McAvoy finish Professor X's story in Secret Wars? →
An early cut alarmed the studio, sidelined Josh Trank and led to reshoots without key actors
Watch the original
@newrockstars · YouTube
Adapted with AI from New Rockstars' video of 21 March 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @newrockstars
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

