SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreMarvel

Will Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man return in Avengers: Doomsday?

I assume his Peter Parker will reach Battleworld, but a look back at The Amazing Spider-Man films argued Marvel may be done with him and many of his villains

New Rockstars (AI-assisted)15 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2011 · more than 4.4 million subscribers 1,030 words · 5 min read
Will Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man return in Avengers: Doomsday?

I don't think it takes much to assume Andrew Garfield's Peter Parker will show up in Battleworld. Garfield played the hero in The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) and The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014), and thankfully we got to revisit his version in 2021's Spider-Man: No Way Home. At the time, I was hoping we would get him again in Avengers: Doomsday or Avengers: Secret Wars.

Revisiting those 2012 and 2014 films is a critical step on the road to Doomsday. Jessica Clemons and Alex Berg went back to both movies and talked through what they represent to the overall Marvel legacy. On the question of whether Garfield returns, their conversation leaned toward doubt.

Canon events and the Spider-Man quip Avengers: Doomsday could include

The discussion turned to how these films could tie into Avengers: Doomsday. Because so much was already featured in the Spider-Man movie, which brought them back, the view was that not too much would carry over. Still, there was a through line worth noting. Sony calls them canon events, while the MCU talks about Nexus points.

The argument was that those canon events will always be attached to a Spider-Man, no matter where he is. If Doomsday brings in Spider-Man, there will be a mention of a Spider-Man. The suggestion was a quip along the lines of "oh, this boy whose uncle just died," which would clearly point to Spider-Man. No Way Home had already done something similar, with Electro saying there has to be one Black kid in some universe who is a Spider-Man.

Why Jess and Berg doubted Garfield's Peter Parker would return

No Way Home brought these Spider-Men together, and both Peter and Doctor Strange know there are other universes with other Spider-Men who can be called on in times of great need. The counterpoint raised was that because the films had only just done this, it couldn't be done again here.

There was also a practical issue. It was suggested that Garfield had two British films shooting that year, and that they may have overlapped with Doomsday, which would have kept him away.

The conversation then moved to what was called the Andrew Garfield Spider-Man effect, which also happens to Benedict Cumberbatch. When either actor does press for a film that isn't Marvel, they get asked one Marvel question, and that's what blows up from the interview, not the movie. Garfield will always be asked, "When are you coming back as Spider-Man?" The view offered was that he's in his forties and doesn't really want to, and one impression of his life was that he can't go to the corner store.

The response was that he's great, but there's a wish, for his sake, that the fan base would move on. "Just let him go. We got Tom Holland now," was one reaction, along with the reminder that fans already got him back in No Way Home.

Gwen Stacy, the Sinister Six and Sony's grip on Spider-Man characters

Gwen Stacy came up next. Right now Gwen appears only in animation, while MJ is the one in live action. The expectation in the discussion was that we won't get much of Gwen in live action Marvel for the near future.

Part of the problem is that Spider-Man is still Sony's. There's already a deal that lets Marvel use Tom Holland, but asking Sony for the Sinister Six as well would probably get a no. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 came up here, as a film that clearly thought it was getting its sequel.

There's so much legal wrangling behind the scenes over individual characters and who they belong to. The example given was Kingpin, said to be kept out of the Spider-Man movies because he's only allowed on Marvel TV, tied to a Netflix deal from a decade ago.

Why Tom Holland could come to Doomsday but not Daredevil: Born Again

The point was made that it's easier to get Marvel characters into Sony's films than to get Sony characters into Marvel's. Marvel could put the Punisher in Brand New Day and Daredevil in No Way Home. But it can't borrow MJ for Thunderbolts, or get Tom Holland to cameo in Daredevil: Born Again.

That led to the agreement that Holland isn't coming to Daredevil, while Daredevil can show up in a Spider-Man film and say he's a very good lawyer. Holland only comes for the Avengers movies, and Doomsday is one. That led to the thought that maybe Holland's Peter Parker could show up in Doomsday, while Garfield's Peter Parker was harder to see.

The reply was "No, I don't think so," followed by the view: "I think we're done with him." That speaker really likes Garfield and was happy to see him in No Way Home, but was okay with it ending there.

Lizard, Tombstone and the Spider-Man villains who may not return

The villains from these films were the last big question, whether for Doomsday or anything beyond. The Lizard looked like a hard case. Rhys Ifans played Curt Connors and was then in the newest Venom movie as a separate character, all within the Sony Spider-Man universe. That makes it hard to bring him back, so the Lizard was considered done for now unless he returns played by someone else.

Sandman has already been done a number of times. The prediction in the discussion was that Scorpion wouldn't show up a fourth time, or Tombstone a third. Tombstone already appears in the animated Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man for Marvel's streaming animation. That might feel like a kids' show, but the argument was that Marvel still recognizes it and wouldn't want to bring Tombstone directly into the films.

The way through, according to the discussion, is a character who hasn't appeared yet, like Black Cat, or someone who could have turned up in the Insomniac Spider-Man games but never on TV or in a movie.

What other creators are saying

More on Andrew Garfield →
Colton Ogburn · more than 80,000 subscribers
I believe Garfield and Maguire are guaranteed returns in Secret Wars (with Maguire likely also in Doomsday), since their No Way Home comebacks were a welcome back, not a goodbye, setting up a three-Spider-Man multiversal crossover split across teams alongside the Avengers and X-Men.

Andrew Garfield in Secret Wars: will he return as Spider-Man? →

Breakdowns & Blockbusters · more than 240,000 subscribers · Snippet
Marvel's notes on the Andrew Garfield sequel covered too many storylines, a cartoonish Rhino and a high school problem

Why Kevin Feige Hated The Amazing Spider-Man 2, and Why Sony Ignored Him →

Sorta Stupid · more than 810,000 subscribers · Snippet
A police standoff in the Andrew Garfield sequel draws quick reactions and a closing line: that's real bad

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 police standoff: oh, that's real bad →

Movie Facts Pro · more than 220,000 subscribers · Snippet
Dozens of takes meant a fresh prop for every attempt, and the actor's real exhaustion ended up on screen

Andrew Garfield Smashed Over 30 Laptops for One Scene in The Social Network →

Watch the original

@newrockstars · YouTube

Adapted with AI from New Rockstars' video of 4 April 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Andrew GarfieldSpider-ManAvengers: DoomsdayThe Amazing Spider-ManTom HollandMarvelSonySpider-Man: No Way Home

More from @newrockstars

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →