SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
ReviewMarvel

X-Men '97 episode 3: is Madelyne Pryor Jean Grey's clone?

How Madelyne Pryor's story, Mister Sinister's scheme and baby Nathan's journey to the future draw on Marvel Comics

The Cosmic Wonder (AI-assisted)18 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2018 · more than 990,000 subscribers 1,736 words · 8 min read
X-Men '97 episode 3: is Madelyne Pryor Jean Grey's clone?

X-Men '97 (2024) episode 3 delivered something we expected based on what we already knew from the comics. Madelyne Pryor is revealed as Mister Sinister's clone of Jean Grey and becomes the Goblin Queen, and baby Nathan is sent to the future on a path that leads to Cable. Here are the major comic events the episode mirrors.

Madelyne Pryor is Jean Grey's clone in Marvel Comics

In the comics, Madelyne Pryor is a clone of Jean Grey created by Mister Sinister. The story of Jean Grey, Madelyne Pryor and the Phoenix Force is long and complicated. Fortunately, the show simplifies it. At some point, Mister Sinister got his hands on Jean Grey and cloned her. Instead of releasing Jean, he released the clone who goes by the name Madelyne Pryor.

At the very end of this episode, she seemingly gives herself the name Madelyne Pryor. In the comics, it's Mister Sinister who names her, as a pun on her prior existence. In the comics, she's first introduced as a character completely separate from Jean Grey. Later it's revealed that Sinister cloned her from Jean, implanted fake memories in her head and sent her out to seduce Scott Summers, also known as Cyclops, during a period when Jean was believed to be dead.

Madelyne and Scott go on to marry and have a baby they name Nathan. The comic story is very similar to what we saw in episodes 1 and 2. Madelyne wants to leave the X-Men and raise their baby with Cyclops, but he's reluctant. A powerless Storm, which is what we have in the show, challenges Scott to a duel for leadership of the team. Storm wins, and Cyclops starts his life as a father and husband.

Madelyne tries hard to make Scott happy, but Scott keeps thinking about Jean. Then one day Angel calls to tell him Jean Grey is alive. Without telling Madelyne anything, he leaves to find Jean. Cyclops gets back with Jean, Madelyne works with the X-Men for a while, and eventually Mister Sinister reveals that she is his creation and a clone of Jean.

Why Mister Sinister wants Cyclops and Jean Grey's son

Sinister did all this because he believes Cyclops and Jean Grey are the perfect mutants genetically. That holds true for the X-Men animated series too. We learned in season 2 of that show that Sinister had been following them their entire lives. In this episode, Cyclops even says Sinister cloned Jean, creating Madelyne, so he could get his hands on their son Nathan.

This is where Morph explains who Mister Sinister is, without saying his name. His name is Nathaniel Essex. As Morph says, he was a scientist in the 1800s who started experimenting on mutants, cutting them up and stealing their DNA to enhance himself, which essentially made him immortal. Morph adds that Sinister can even take away a person's will.

That's what happened to Morph in the original animated series. Sinister saved Morph's life when everybody believed he was dead, but in return he tortured him and took control of his mind. That's why Morph transforms back into his original self, with the bags under his eyes, and says he should know, because Sinister did everything he just described to him.

Madelyne Pryor becomes the Goblin Queen

Much like in the comics, Sinister appears to Madelyne, who still believes she's Jean Grey, and reveals that he created her. She becomes the Goblin Queen, mostly because Sinister has control over her mind. She tries to fight him at first, but he tells her "every cell in you belongs to me," meaning he created her and he controls her. He says struggling is useless and then says "time to wake up my queen," referring to the Goblin Queen.

She looks at a picture of herself and Scott taken directly from the cover of X-Men number 30, where Jean and Cyclops get married in the comics, and smashes it. She smashes a picture of the X-Men team from the animated series, then one of her with Professor Xavier. Jean was Professor X's first student and one of the original X-Men, called Marvel Girl on that first team. Her first green costume spills out when a box is knocked over.

The scene is meant to show that this clone no longer believes she's Jean. She has embraced being Madelyne Pryor, the Goblin Queen, and declares "they shall know my Inferno." That line comes straight from the Inferno event in the comics. Her pose here is almost a direct reflection of the cover of X-Men Inferno, with the Goblin Queen on the front alongside creatures like the ones she seemingly unleashes in this episode.

Inferno's personal hells for Gambit, Sunspot, Morph, Cyclops and Bishop

From here it gets weird but awesome. When the X-Men wonder what's going on, Morph asks whether it isn't obvious that they're in hell. That's essentially what Madelyne does in the comics: she creates a personal hell for each character, bringing their big fears to life.

For Gambit, it's seeing Rogue with Magneto, his love leaving him for somebody he despises. For Sunspot, a creepy monster comes out of a TV screen and turns into his disapproving mother. He said in previous episodes she didn't know he was a mutant, so here she learns the truth and is disappointed and repulsed by him. Interestingly, Morph's fear is Mister Sinister himself, and he's terrified, saying no, not you, not again, because Sinister previously controlled his mind.

For Scott, it's Professor Xavier handing him demerits, saying he failed to impregnate the right one, meaning he got the clone pregnant and not Jean Grey, and that he failed as the new leader of the X-Men. For Bishop, it's his sister Shard, also a time traveler. The last we saw of her was season four, when she and Bishop went back to the future together. Bishop fears he abandoned her and that she's struggling greatly or has died.

They then seemingly go to an actual hell. Beast asks how Sinister can exude enough power to warp reality like this. Cyclops answers that this isn't Sinister, it's Jean, then corrects himself: it's the clone. Sinister isn't doing this part. Madelyne is, because she has immense power just like Jean Grey, who she was cloned from.

Bishop and Cyclops share the fight's best moment

There are some awesome scenes during this fight. When Beast asks for help, Bishop grabs Wolverine and throws him at Beast. That's epic, but not more epic than Bishop jumping down next to Cyclops and saying "yo Cyclops hit me." Cyclops, with a big smile, hits him with his beams. Bishop absorbs the power and releases a blast even stronger than the one that came from Cyclops.

Once Bishop cleans up, the two look at each other, smile and both say you're welcome at the same time. Bishop means he saved everybody, and Cyclops means he powered Bishop up so he could save everybody. Then a giant devil-like Sentinel shows up, and the real Jean Grey arrives and says enough. She restores everything and seemingly saves everyone for the moment, while Madelyne introduces herself as the Goblin Queen and leaves with Scott's baby, Nathan.

Magneto takes the lead as Cyclops doubts himself

Rogue and Magneto were training in the Danger Room throughout the episode and weren't there for this fight, and Gambit noticed. When they return, Rogue rushes to Gambit's side saying she should have been there, and Gambit says it's okay now that she is.

Cyclops then asks how he can lead the team if he can't protect his own son, echoing what the fake Charles Xavier created by Madelyne told him. Magneto says Sinister has plagued them for too long. Magneto hates Mister Sinister. They interacted a few times in the animated series and even worked together in its final season, but only because they had to save humans and mutants. Other than that, nearly everybody hates Sinister.

Morph says he can show them where Sinister is, because he was captured by him. Magneto says he'll lead the team, and Scott tells him fine, lead, because he's doubting himself. In the fight against Madelyne, Morph turns into Magik, the younger sister of Colossus. Morph tells her he doesn't want to fight her, and she replies that she wants him to fight for her. After Madelyne possesses him, the Magik form turns into Magik's other form, Darkchilde, who has an epic fight with Magneto that he seemingly loses.

Jean Grey and Madelyne Pryor share the same memories

Back at the X-Mansion, Jean is still struggling with her psychic abilities. Wolverine tells her to focus on him and go deeper, and she realizes how much she means to him. But much like throughout the animated series, Wolverine is pushed aside for Cyclops. Jean realizes the team is in trouble and helps with her mind rather than her body. She enters Madelyne's mind and says this ends now. It reminds me of Thor saying this ends here and now in Thor: Love and Thunder, though I don't think there's a connection, just a resemblance.

The two go down memory lane through Jean Grey's life. They both have all of these memories, which makes it impossible to tell when Sinister kidnapped Jean, cloned her and swapped in Madelyne. They don't know, and we don't either. There were two times in the animated series when Sinister had Jean, but we can't confirm the exact point, and given how the episode ends, it's somewhat irrelevant.

This was probably done by Sinister. In the comics he implanted Madelyne with memories, and he most likely did the same here, giving her all of Jean's memories, while Jean seems to have all of Madelyne's too. Eventually they reach the memory of Nathan being born, and he's Madelyne's son, not Jean's. That breaks the spell. Madelyne and Cyclops go after Sinister and defeat him, since Cyclops's blasts are a big weakness for Sinister, as the animated series showed.

Nathan's techno-organic virus and the road to Cable

They seemingly win, but they also lose, because Nathan is now infected with a techno-organic virus that turns living organisms into machines. In the comics, it's Apocalypse who infects him. With Beast's help, they realize they can't save Nathan, at least not in this time, but possibly in the future. Beast has been fixing Bishop's time travel device throughout the episode, and Bishop says it can only take him and Nathan.

Cyclops has a hard time with this. His own father abandoned him, and he didn't want to abandon his son, but he realizes it's the only way Nathan can live. Madelyne says they'll do it because they promised him the best life they could give, and this is best for him. Before Nathan leaves, she implants memories in his head so he'll understand someday that they didn't abandon him.

For those who didn't know, Nathan is Cable in the comics. Cable has the virus, but also psychic abilities that hold it back, which is why he's part human, part machine. Cable got a lot of attention in recent years as one of the main characters in Deadpool 2. When talking about taking Nathan to the future, Bishop says he knows a guy there who could help.

Forge meets Storm for the first time

The guy is Forge, who we met a couple of times in the animated series, and who meets Storm at the end of this episode. Forge met Professor X and other X-Men in the animated series, but Storm wasn't there, so this is their first meeting. What's interesting is that in the comics, Forge creates the weapon that takes Storm's powers away, yet the two fall in love and he finds a way to restore them.

That comic run was called Lifedeath, and at the time of this episode, the fourth episode of X-Men '97 carried the title Lifedeath Part 1, the fifth was titled Remember It, and the sixth was Lifedeath Part 2. Given those titles, I was assuming the same thing would happen in X-Men '97 as well.

What other creators are saying

More on Madelyne Pryor →
Heavy Spoilers · more than 1.6 million subscribers
Episode 3 finally reveals what Sinister has been planning with Madelyne Pryor, and it doubles as a backdoor origin story for Cable.

X-Men '97 episode 3: is Madelyne Pryor Cable's origin? →

DanCo · more than 590,000 subscribers
I think it's a ridiculously close fight, but I give the slightest edge to the Dark Phoenix over Scarlet Witch, and since the Avengers have no real counter to mind control, that edge probably carries the X-Men to victory.

Avengers vs X-Men: why Jean Grey's Phoenix tips the fight →

New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
In the post-credit scene, Ned's Spidey tracker locates a new Spider-Man somewhere out in space, possibly tied to Avengers: Doomsday and Secret Wars. Jean Grey, played by Sadie Sink, is introduced as a mysterious telepath whose powers may involve the Phoenix Force, and she is confirm

Spider-Man: Brand New Day Post-Credit Scene and Jean Grey Explained →

Everything Always · more than 1 million subscribers
The X-Men actress told Entertainment Weekly she was never approached. Here are the reasons Marvel Studios might pass on Jean Grey, and why she could simply be keeping a secret.

Jean Grey in Avengers: Doomsday: why was Famke Janssen not asked? →

Watch the original

@thecosmicwonder · YouTube

Adapted with AI from The Cosmic Wonder's video of 28 March 2024 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

X-Men '97Madelyne PryorGoblin QueenMister SinisterCableJean GreyCyclopsInferno

More from @thecosmicwonder

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →