Halo series: why Master Chief's helmet scene fell flat
Two scenes from the Halo TV series, Master Chief's helmet coming off and his night with Makee, show where the series swung too far one way and skipped the buildup
As a lifelong Halo fan, I find the Halo TV series fascinating, but not in the way you'd think. The series premiered in 2022, starring Pablo Schreiber as Master Chief. Two scenes in particular, Master Chief removing his helmet and his intimate scene with Makee, are where the pendulum swung too far one way.
I've been running an experiment of sorts with the show. One group is made up of fans of the games, and the other is made up of people who have never played them.
Halo fans and newcomers reacted differently to Master Chief's face and romance
Those who have played the games have been frustrated at certain moments: seeing Master Chief's face, seeing him with no clothes on, and seeing him have sex with Makee, a woman serving the Covenant. That should come as no surprise. Throughout the games, we never see Master Chief's face apart from the Legendary ending of Halo 4, and we never see him enter a romantic relationship. Cortana is a separate case, which I'll come to.
So it isn't surprising that these moments angered fans of the games. But none of the people who haven't played the games have complained. They don't mind seeing his face, they don't mind seeing him without his armor, and they don't seem to care about him having sex.
My takeaway is that there has to exist a healthy medium between these two groups: a story that newcomers can enjoy while still pleasing the original fans.
The appeasement scale: Halo the series leans toward newcomers
To explain this, I created what I call the appeasement scale. On one side is appealing to the new audience, meaning someone who has never played the games. On the other side is appealing to the existing audience, meaning the people who love the games.
On this scale, the show sits closer to the newcomer side. There are moments that cater to the fans, but for the most part the show is directed toward people new to Halo. That said, if the show went all the way to the other side, it would be a complete disaster. The main reason is that the Master Chief of the original Halo games would make an awful protagonist in a medium outside video games.
The two scenes I'm focusing on are places where the pendulum swung too far one way, and I'll explain how I feel they could have been handled so they land closer to the middle of the scale.
Master Chief's helmet removal felt hollow to newcomers and angered fans
The first scene is Master Chief removing his helmet for the first time. As I noted above, this scene doesn't bother or emotionally move newcomers, but it angers existing fans. Master Chief has never removed his helmet in any of the games, and the writers were aware of this. They tried to add emotional weight to the moment.
The way the scene is filmed puts the emphasis on the fact that we are seeing his face. He takes his helmet off slowly, and the music swells up until the reveal. The marketing for the series never showed Master Chief's face, and even his main poster doesn't show it.
For newcomers, though, the scene isn't emotional, because up to that point the series has never made a big deal about Chief wearing his helmet. They aren't aware of the legacy of Master Chief, so the moment has no emotional weight. For existing fans, it was a problem because in the very first episode we see his face, "something that has been sacred in the games", and there wasn't much buildup to it. To existing fans, this is a slap in the face.
Two ways Halo could have shown Master Chief's face
I could simply say the show shouldn't have shown his face, but I want to be more creative than that, because I do think the series benefits from showing Master Chief's face. The first approach would be to open the series with his face already visible. If the series began with the Spartans in the Pelican and he wasn't wearing his helmet, there would be no false payoff of him removing it for newcomers.
That would also set the tone right away for existing fans. We wouldn't be pretending for 40 minutes that Master Chief's face is some big mystery leading to a big reveal. Chief would simply be a super soldier who wears his armor in battle. I still feel fans wouldn't be thrilled with this, but I also feel it wouldn't anger them either.
The other approach would be to show his face for the first time later in the season. It doesn't have to be in the finale, as The Mandalorian did, but it should come at an important moment. The first season is about Master Chief finding his humanity in a war where humanity is on the brink of extinction, and I think that's a compelling idea to explore in a Halo series. The face is the most human part of the body, so the first time we see it should matter to John, whether that's the first time he meets Cortana, when he takes out the chip, or when he decides to be intimate with Makee.
John and Makee's sex scene has no buildup
In a way, John's intimate scene with Makee is the climactic moment of his arc in the season. He goes from an emotionless robot at the start of the season to taking part in the most human and intimate act possible.
The biggest problem is that there is no buildup to it throughout the first seven episodes. John is definitely finding his humanity and doing more human things, but intimate human connection is never something he's curious about. He shows no signs of longing for romance or of wanting to get to know other people better.
The same applies to Makee. She has been reading a book and has shown hints of interest in her life as a human, but throughout the first seven episodes she has only shown interest in serving the Covenant. Even though the show does spend time on John and Makee's connection and on how similar the two of them are, this step feels so off and happens way too quickly.
Why Halo 4's ending works where the series doesn't
I want to contrast this with a similar moment in the Halo franchise: the ending of Halo 4. In Halo 1 through 3, we never really see Master Chief show emotion. He's always focused on the mission at hand and occasionally makes a funny comment. The ending of Halo 4 portrays him in a completely different light from the Chief we're used to.
It works because Master Chief and Cortana have spent four games together, and we've seen their relationship grow. Across those games, there are only two people Master Chief has conversations with that aren't plot related: Johnson and Cortana. It doesn't happen often with Johnson, but there are numerous occasions where Chief lets his guard down around Cortana. Even in Halo 3, when they spend most of the game apart, he consistently shows how much he cares for her. One of the last missions has him going alone into a city infested by the Flood to save her.
Halo 4 takes that established relationship further. In the first mission, Chief is his typical self. He talks a bit more than before, but his number one focus is still saving humanity whatever the cost. The second Cortana hints that she's dying because of rampancy, he shifts his focus to saving her, and the first word out of his mouth is Halsey, the woman he thinks can save her. So when Cortana dies at the end, his completely different behavior is earned, because the buildup is there.
"You can't have a powerful payoff without setup." The sex scene between Makee and John has none. They've known each other for one whole episode, and they have sex halfway through their second episode together. "That is payoff with no setup."
My verdict on Halo the series
Even with these critiques, and even though I still think the show could have been significantly better, I enjoy it for the most part. That might be because I'm a Halo shill who loves the franchise, but I think the series is doing a lot right.
I hoped a second season would make some changes to feel more like Halo. Still, I've enjoyed this journey and seeing how newcomers feel about the show.
What other creators are saying
More on Master Chief →After the struggles of Halo Infinite and a move to Unreal Engine 5, the next game carried the series' future
Why Halo 7 Looked Like a Make or Break Moment for the Halo Franchise →
Doom Slayer wins. While Master Chief is a superhuman soldier who can defeat large numbers of Covenant forces, the Doom Slayer has killed universal demon lords like the Icon of Sin and Davoth, the Dark Lord, putting him on a far higher power level.
Master Chief vs Doom Slayer: who wins and why it's not close →
Microsoft has reportedly stripped Halo Studios of control over the next mainline Halo game after cutting 268 positions across Xbox, and word is a new Activision based team is being assembled to build it instead.
Halo's next game: is Activision taking it from Halo Studios? →
Watch the original
@thegoldman25 · YouTube
Adapted with AI from The Gold Man's video of 20 May 2022 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @thegoldman25
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

