SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreGaming

Worst Call of Duty pistols ranked: why the ASP comes last

From the Modern Warfare 3 starting pistol to a revolver that played like a standard handgun, these sidearms struggled even as a last resort.

WesNemo (AI-assisted)17 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2012 · more than 190,000 subscribers 1,560 words · 7 min read
Worst Call of Duty pistols ranked: why the ASP comes last

Pistols are supposed to be a last resort option in Call of Duty, and in most FPS games. That's not always how it works: there have been some good ones over the years. But some pistols couldn't even manage to be good as a last resort. This is my ranking of the worst pistols in Call of Duty history, and I have no problem naming the ASP from the original Black Ops as the worst of them all.

The list runs from two guns I consider among the worst ever, through a numbered countdown from eight to one.

The USP .45 in Modern Warfare 3 was a starting pistol for a reason

The USP .45 was your starting pistol in Modern Warfare 3, and it was widely ignored because it was bad. It had horrible damage, a very low fire rate cap, and high visual kick that made it awkward to use.

You weren't going to kill anyone with it, and it wasn't any fun to use. There was no broken attachment combo or anything else that made it worthwhile. I guess there was a bug where akimbo USPs gave you very fast melee animations, but other than that the gun had nothing going for it. You put it on your class because there was nothing else available, then dropped it once you got something better, which was everything in the game. It's easily one of the worst pistols in Call of Duty history.

The Executioner in Black Ops 2 was a gimmick with awful damage

You knew the Executioner was going to be here. Some of you probably didn't want it here; you just didn't know where I was going to rank it. A shotgun and pistol hybrid felt cool and looked cool, but it was a gimmick weapon, and to this day I'm not sure what the reason for it was.

A shotgun revolver was a cool idea, but the damage was awful and the reload took forever, which made it a liability more than anything else. The recoil was heavy, making it hard to hit consistent shots, which you had to do because the damage wasn't there. If you weren't within knifing range, you probably weren't getting a one shot kill. I know this gun had a little fan club, but I don't get it. It was fun to goof around with, but in terms of stats it's one of the worst pistols in Call of Duty history.

8. The M1911 in Call of Duty 4 was iconic but outclassed

The M1911 is an iconic weapon that has appeared in more Call of Duty games than any other pistol in franchise history. The Call of Duty 4 version wasn't very good, though. There were four handguns in Call of Duty 4, and three of them, the M9, the USP .45 and the M1911, shared nearly identical stats. They handled differently and had different magazine sizes, but their time to kill was nearly identical, so it didn't matter which one you took. Take the one that handles best, I guess.

The M1911 had the worst handling of the three. It was bouncy, had a lot of recoil, and only carried an eight round magazine. Why would you take a bouncy pistol with no ammo if you weren't even getting better damage output than the other two? And why take it at all when the Desert Eagle existed? Despite being such an iconic weapon, it was poor in Call of Duty 4. You didn't see it online; most people ran the Desert Eagle or the USP.

7. The X16 in Modern Warfare 2019 was a Warzone starting gun people used as a club

The X16 is perhaps the most hated gun in Modern Warfare's Warzone, though I don't know. It's not good. It had more ammo than the 1911, yes, but the visual kick was annoying and the fire rate felt low. Most people are well acquainted with it because it was your starting gun in Warzone for the longest time.

There's a reason most people ran around using it as a club instead of pulling the trigger. The damage was inconsistent, and the fire rate and visual kick made it feel awkward. Even if you timed your shots perfectly and stayed on target, there was a good chance your enemy would just run up and punch you. On top of that, the X16 could be outdamaged by practically every other gun in the game. It was bad, and I know I'm not the only one who's very glad Warzone left it behind.

6. The RK 7 Garrison in Black Ops 4 was a burst pistol that couldn't burst kill

The RK 7 Garrison was a three round burst pistol with many similarities to the legendary M93 Raffica, but in terms of damage it was a far cry from its older brother. It had a decent fire rate and low recoil, but the damage was abysmal, and using it as a primary wasn't viable.

Some of you may argue that the gun wasn't designed to be a primary. There is some truth to that, but the damage on the RK 7 was bad, especially for a burst weapon. Burst guns are usually supposed to have a lot of potential in the damage department, because you're giving up constant fire rate for more consistent damage. The RK 7 "felt like a peashooter," and getting one burst kills was nearly impossible outside of hardcore modes. One burst kills are the whole point of using a burst weapon. It felt good and handled well, but the damage took it down a notch.

5. The Reichsrevolver in Call of Duty: WWII didn't function like a revolver

I've criticized this gun quite a bit over the years, and I'm going to continue. I don't know why it was added to the game at all, and it confuses me why Sledgehammer thought people would get a kick out of it. Call of Duty: WWII launched without any revolvers, but a few months into the game's life cycle we got two: the Enfield No. 2 and this one. The Enfield was about what you'd want from a revolver and dropped enemies with two bullets.

The Reichsrevolver didn't function like a revolver at all. Yes, it had six rounds and you had to reload each one individually, but the fire rate was high, the recoil was low, and the damage was very low. It killed in three to four shots, yet it only carried six rounds and had no speed loader attachment. Its damage was on par with the other handguns, but those weapons had faster reloads and better ammo capacity. It's a revolver that functions like a standard handgun, so what was the point of the gun?

4. The .357 in Modern Warfare 2019 was powerful but awkward up close

The .357 was extremely powerful and could drop enemies with a single bullet. It was also very awkward to use, with a long fire delay that made it one of the worst weapons in the game for close range combat, which is what you're supposed to use a pistol for. When you pulled the trigger, there was a short delay before the shot came out.

In a game like Call of Duty, a lot can happen during that time. Your target can move, your teammate can get in the way, you can get shot, or you can walk into a claymore. Aside from the shot delay, it had awkward handling. The sway while aiming down the sights was very noticeable, and I still think the iron sights were slightly misaligned, because it never seemed to shoot where you were pointing. With the snakeshot ammo conversion it was decent, but by itself it was bad. People finished their camo challenges and never touched it again.

3. The USP .45 in Modern Warfare 2 was buried by better secondaries

Did you ever see a single person running the USP .45 back in 2009? Modern Warfare 2 was loaded with top tier secondaries: the SPAS 12, the Raffica, the G18, the Desert Eagle, the .44 Magnum, the AA12, the Model 1887, and I could go on. So who was taking the USP .45 as their secondary?

It was a small handgun with 12 rounds that dealt very little damage and had a weird low fire rate cap for a semi automatic weapon. The only good thing about it was a bug where akimbo USPs gave you a faster knife animation than normal, so if you were running a knife only class, I guess they were good. Other than that, nobody used it. It was terrible in Modern Warfare 2, especially next to all the other secondaries you had at your disposal.

2. The Makarov in Black Ops was the definition of a starting weapon

Not to be confused with the Modern Warfare villain of the same name, this pistol unlocked at level four in the original Black Ops, and it's one of the weapons you put down as soon as you unlocked something else. It had eight rounds in the magazine, a very low fire rate cap, and took three to five shots to kill.

Its handling was average for a pistol in the original Black Ops, but that wasn't saying much, because only a couple of pistols in the game were worth using. The Makarov was the definition of a starting weapon: you unlocked it early, didn't do anything with it, then put it down once you unlocked something better. Believe it or not, I do think there was one pistol that was even worse, and it's also in the original Black Ops.

1. The ASP in Black Ops is the worst pistol in Call of Duty history

If you know your Call of Duty history, you've probably already guessed it: the ASP in the original Black Ops. This is as bad as it gets. I've held a grudge against this thing for years, and that's going to continue. I don't even know what ASP stands for, but if I had to guess, I would say it stands for "really bad pistol." I'm fully aware that wasn't funny, but neither is the gun.

The ASP had seven rounds in the magazine and could take up to five shots to kill. It had no front sight at all, so aiming was awkward, and it wasn't accurate. Despite good handling speeds and a high fire rate cap, it was easily the worst pistol in the game. Some people think the Makarov was worse, but I think the mere fact that the Makarov had a bigger magazine gives it the slight edge in the ranking. The ASP was terrible, and "I have no problems calling it the worst pistol in cod history."

What other creators are saying

More on Black Ops →
Chaos Gaming · more than 2.6 million subscribers
From Black Ops classics to a research base on Europa, these are the frozen battlegrounds I rank highest, ending on the obvious number one.

Best Call of Duty snow maps ranked: why is Summit number one? →

GIQUE · more than 25,000 subscribers
From iron sights in 2003 to Warzone and crossplay, a game by game look at how the main series rose, stumbled and recovered

Call of Duty's 18 Year History: The Games That Saved the Franchise and the Ones That Dragged It Down →

Heavy Spoilers · more than 1.6 million subscribers
Woods worked with Savannah and used Black Ops brainwashing to control Mason, and the final cutscene hints that both men became Blackout archetypes

Black Ops 4 ending: did Woods brainwash Mason for Savannah? →

Watch the original

@wesnemotv · YouTube

Adapted with AI from WesNemo's video of 5 February 2022 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Call of DutyPistolsBlack OpsModern WarfareWarzoneCall of Duty WWIIBlack Ops 4Rankings

More from @wesnemotv

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →