SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreFilm & TV

Tevildo, Prince of Cats: how Tolkien's evil cat became Sauron

Before Sauron, Tolkien's dark lord's chief enforcer was a magical cat with a golden collar and a grudge against a legendary dog. Here is how he was written out, and why his story sits beside a real rescue service for cats.

Alex (AI-assisted)18 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2024 · more than 41,000 subscribers 1,930 words · 9 min read
Tevildo, Prince of Cats: how Tolkien's evil cat became Sauron

Long before Sauron became the Dark Lord of The Lord of the Rings, Tolkien's early drafts gave that same villain role to a cat. Tevildo, Prince of Cats, is a real Tolkien character from the early writings collected in The Book of Lost Tales, and he's exactly as unhinged as he sounds. He was rewritten into Thû the Necromancer, and Thû was eventually refined into Sauron.

I'm pairing his story with something very real: Lifeline, a service run by Cats Protection. A brief warning before I begin: the next section touches on abuse and domestic violence. I'll keep it short, and after that it's cats and lore only.

Cats Protection's Lifeline service keeps cats safe while owners escape abuse

Lifeline helps cats and their humans get away from abusive situations. If someone needs to leave an unsafe home but can't take their cat with them right away, Lifeline steps in. The cat goes to a temporary, loving foster home until the owner is safe and able to be reunited with them. Think of it as a companion rescue quest.

The service is free and confidential. It's run by an experienced team that organizes foster placements through a network of excellent volunteers, people who open their homes so others can get back on their feet. January and February had been some of the busiest months Lifeline had ever seen, with demand higher than usual. That prompted a fundraising appeal aiming to raise £48,928, enough to cover Lifeline's running costs for two months.

Lifeline matters because it's sadly common for abusers to use pets, including cats and kittens, to control, coerce or even threaten someone into staying. Lifeline removes that weapon from the equation. It gives people a way out, knowing they'll be reunited with their cat when it's safe. "Because love should be safe," including the love of a small furry creature who thinks 3 a.m. is an acceptable time to scream.

Who is Tevildo, Prince of Cats, in Tolkien's Book of Lost Tales?

In case you were worried Tolkien was being subtle, Tevildo is helpfully known as Prince of Cats. In the early version of the legendarium, he's the mightiest cat to ever cat, genuinely top of the food chain. He's described as possessed of an evil sprite, as some say, which is Tolkien's extremely polite way of saying this cat is not your friend.

In these early tales, Tolkien seems to be experimenting with the idea that the dark lord phase could be preceded by a more chaotic era of enchanted cats, bad attitudes and what feels suspiciously like a prototype dungeon boss. Imagine Sauron earlier, smaller and furrier, with the moral alignment of a Warhammer chaos familiar who knocks things off tables on purpose.

A big part of his power was his golden collar, which does the same job as every cursed item in Dungeons and Dragons: it looks shiny and it's the source of all the problems. Without it, he probably just knocks cups off tables. With it, straight to evil. He had appointed himself prince of the cat servants of Melko, the first and worst dark lord, and naturally he lived in a castle on a cliff. If you're an evil magical cat, you don't live in a bungalow.

Inside that castle, Tevildo kept mice described as fierce and as large as rats, alive in dark holes, purely for his own amusement. Not to eat, not to hunt. This is less pet owner and more a dungeon master who has lost control of the campaign.

Tevildo's grudge against Huan, captain of the dogs

Tevildo's followers were terrified of the dogs in the nearby woods, which feels fair. Dogs are lawful good paladins with white teeth. Tevildo himself had a personal vendetta against Huan, the captain of dogs, a legendary hound and not just a bloke with a lead.

Huan had once nearly caught Tevildo. That's the kind of near death experience that might encourage reflection or personal growth. Tevildo chose violence instead, escaped by slashing Huan with his claws, took that as a moral victory and held a grudge ever since. If this were a video game, it's the moment the boss flees with 2 percent health and promises revenge in the sequel.

So we have an evil, jewelry powered cat in a cliffside fortress, serving an early dark lord, keeping terrifying mice for fun and holding on to spite like it's his entire character sheet. If Tolkien pitched this today, we'd assume it was a Warhammer short story or a rejected Baldur's Gate companion. And yet he's still recognizably a cat.

Beren and Lúthien, the love story Tolkien wrote about himself and Edith

The story that brings Tevildo into play follows Beren, a human. He's not a wizard, not an elf and not secretly immortal, just a normal man with a sword, a lot of confidence and no sense of self preservation. Beren and Lúthien is an intense love story, and one of my favorites. Beren falls in love with Lúthien, the most beautiful elven princess ever, which is why Aragorn mistakes Arwen for Lúthien the first time he sees her.

Lúthien's father responds by setting Beren an impossible task: steal a Silmaril from the dark lord. A Silmaril isn't just a shiny gem. It's a holy jewel containing the light of ancient magical trees from the beginning of time, and wars were fought over them. Stealing one is like trying to nick the crown jewels from a dragon who invented evil. Beren agrees, and things immediately go wrong. Melko captures him and, rather than imprisoning him dramatically, sends him to work as a thrall, a forced servant, in the kitchens of Tevildo.

This story was deeply personal to Tolkien. Beren is essentially Tolkien writing himself into the legend, and Lúthien represents his wife, Edith. We know this because Tolkien said so, and the names Beren and Lúthien are engraved beneath their real names on their shared gravestone. Under the dark lords, cursed jewels and a malicious cat running a kitchen like a hostile workplace, it's a mythologized version of his own love story, just with more suffering.

How Lúthien tricks Tevildo with a lie about Huan

Tevildo is minding his own business, by which I mean sleeping, when Lúthien is dragged before him by Umuiyan, the cat whose job is guarding the door. Being woken up is already unacceptable, and Tevildo accuses Lúthien of having something to do with dogs, the worst possible insult in his mind. She calmly says she has just escaped from a very mighty dog she knows extremely well, which instantly grabs his attention.

Tevildo orders Umuiyan to take her to the kitchens, but Lúthien's cloak is magical and Umuiyan falls asleep under its spell. Tevildo responds to this mild inconvenience by ordering him thrown off a cliff. Evil cat, strong management style. Tevildo then escorts Lúthien himself, which lets her reveal herself to Beren in the kitchens.

Tevildo briefly considers taking her straight to Melko, the sensible evil overlord move, but chooses to hear her story first. That's a mistake. Lúthien tells him Huan is lying injured in the woods nearby. It's a lie built to hit his biggest weakness, and he wants it to be true so badly that he believes her. He sets off with two of his thanes, trusted lieutenants, one of whom is Oikeroi, his right hand cat and loyal enforcer. Villains really do bring this on themselves.

Huan defeats Tevildo and takes his golden collar

Tevildo and his entourage reach the Withered Dale, where Huan lies on the ground looking badly hurt. It's a classic trap, the kind you'd spot immediately unless blinded by spite. Tevildo decides to attack from all sides, and as the cats creep closer, Huan springs up, because he was never injured. Huan kills Oikeroi and chases off the other thane, leaving Tevildo alone.

The one on one fight goes very badly for the cat. Huan nearly kills him, but Tevildo slashes Huan in the eye and escapes up a tree at the last second, which is humiliating but technically a win. Huan simply sits beneath the tree and refuses to leave until Tevildo gives up information. Under pressure and mild existential dread, Tevildo tells him where Lúthien and Beren are being held.

Then it gets worse. Huan forces Tevildo to throw down his golden collar, the source of most of his evil power, and something very similar to the One Ring. Tevildo also has to reveal the spell that holds his castle together and fills the other cats with unnatural evil power. When Lúthien speaks it aloud at the castle, the cats shrink back into confused house cats. She orders them to release every prisoner, and there are only two: Beren and an elderly gnome named Gimli. Not that Gimli. Tolkien likes to reuse names.

When Melko finds out, he's predictably not impressed. Tevildo is cursed, stripped of favor and banished. He spends the rest of his existence bitter and plotting to recapture Beren and Lúthien, kill Huan and win back Melko's approval, but his fear of Melko is so great that he mostly sits in his hall seething and accomplishing nothing. According to the story, cats as a whole live bitter lives from then on, which explains a lot.

How Tevildo was replaced by Thû the Necromancer and became Sauron

All of this comes from Tolkien's very early version of the world, when he was still working out what his villains were. In those drafts, Tevildo fills the role of the dark lord's lieutenant: not the big bad, but a powerful, cruel enforcer under Melko.

As Tolkien rewrote his mythology, he seems to have realized that an evil magical cat is fun but slightly unhinged, and that he wanted his villain to feel more terrifying and less like they "could be distracted by a laser pointer." So Tevildo is quietly written out and replaced by Thû, also known as the Necromancer. Thû does the same job: he captures Beren, guards the dark fortress and acts as Melko's chief enforcer, but instead of ruling cats he's the lord of werewolves, which is far more intimidating and less fluffy.

Over time Thû is refined and renamed and becomes Sauron. Same role, same function, upgraded like a character going through balance patches. Tolkien also dropped the obvious cat versus dog theme of the Tale of Tinúviel, because the Tevildo and Huan rivalry didn't fit his later, darker tone. A battle between good and evil replaced what was briefly a personal feud between a cat and a dog. Tevildo is what Sauron looked like before Tolkien took off the training wheels.

Tybalt and Cath Palug: where Tolkien's evil cat may come from

Tolkien was borrowing like a professional academic magpie. The name Tevildo almost certainly echoes Tybalt from William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, who is called Prince of Cats in the play because he's aggressive, proud and always looking for a fight. Tolkien read Shakespeare, clocked "prince of cats" and thought: what if I made that literal and evil?

Then there's Cath Palug, a monstrous cat from Welsh legend, less petty aristocrat and more ancient nightmare. In some Arthurian stories it grows into a supernatural beast that terrorizes the land and fights King Arthur himself. In some versions Arthur wins. In others, the cat kills Arthur, no moral lesson attached. Tevildo sits at a crossroads of Shakespeare's smug prince of cats, Welsh folklore's world ending murder cat and Tolkien's own early experimentation, which explains why he feels more unhinged than later villains like Sauron.

Why Beren and Lúthien belongs beside Lifeline

Sarcasm holstered for a moment, there's something fitting about pairing this story with Lifeline. In Beren and Lúthien, Tolkien gave us a tale where love, courage and stubborn hope survive impossible odds. Lifeline does something very similar in the real world, helping people leave situations where fear and control have taken hold without leaving behind someone they love.

For many people, a cat isn't just a pet. It's their comfort, their routine, the one living thing that still feels safe when everything else isn't. No one should have to choose between their own safety and the life of a small screaming creature who treats your feet as a personal enemy. I encourage you to check out Lifeline, share it and support it if you're able. It genuinely makes a difference.

If you take nothing else away, let it be this: even the darkest villain can be defeated, love is worth ridiculous quests, and cats have always been morally ambiguous.

What other creators are saying

More on Sauron →
New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
I believe this evil-forged theme runs through everything here, and I'm convinced Galadriel is wrong that Sauron fled further north, since he's probably hiding in the Southlands. I also think the Southlands may secretly be Mordor's origin, and I'm unsure yet who among Halbrand, Theo, or the Stranger is Sauron.

Rings of Power premiere: what are the hidden Sauron clues? →

Film Paradise · more than 58,000 subscribers
Killing Celebrimbor and burning his records left Sauron without the knowledge needed to finish the One Ring properly. Season 3, set five years after Eregion's fall, reportedly shows him still struggling, with a prototype ring that burns its orc wearer and then disintegrates itself.

Rings of Power season 3: did Sauron kill the wrong smith? →

Watch the original

@ajm_nerdcore · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Alex's video of 9 February 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

TolkienTevildoSauronBeren and LuthienThe Book of Lost TalesHuanMiddle-earth loreCats Protection

More from @ajm_nerdcore

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →