SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreSci-Fi & Fantasy

Lickey Hills and Tolkien: did they inspire the Shire?

Stone Age flint, Roman roads, Norman deer parks and a secret teenage romance all sit on one modest patch of Midlands hillside where J.R.R. Tolkien spent a formative summer

Alex (AI-assisted)17 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2024 · more than 41,000 subscribers 1,560 words · 7 min read
Lickey Hills and Tolkien: did they inspire the Shire?

Sometimes fate is cruel and you find yourself on the outskirts of Birmingham. When that happens, instead of embracing the existential void of retail parks and roundabouts, you could do worse than stumbling into the Lickey Hills, a patch of countryside that, it is widely believed, helped shape J.R.R. Tolkien's vision of Middle-earth.

The Lickey Hills are that pleasant plot twist, the unexpected side quest. You expect gray industrial sprawl and instead unlock rolling greenery, woodland trails and views that almost make you forget you're still technically in the West Midlands. It's like discovering a hidden Shire biome just past a fast food restaurant's car park.

Why the Lickey Hills on the edge of Birmingham are worth the trip

I'm not only here because it's surprisingly wholesome. I'm here because of Tolkien, the man who handed half of modern fantasy its homework. He spent time in and around this area, so when you're trudging up a path slightly out of breath, you can tell yourself you're not unfit, you're doing immersive lore research.

Stand at the top, squint a bit, and you can convince yourself you're scouting for Nazgûl, or at least waiting for a quest giver with an unnecessarily tragic backstory. The rolling hills and woodland edges feel very early campaign, before things go catastrophically wrong. The Lickey Hills are a surprisingly solid open world location, worth the visit if you need reminding that even in the Midlands there is still hope. Bring decent shoes, and perhaps lembas, or at least a Tesco meal deal, whichever is easier.

The Lickey Hills' history, from a Stone Age arrowhead to Roman salt roads

I'm the sort of person who wants patch notes for a hill, so let's go right back to the Stone Age. A Neolithic hunter dropped a flint arrowhead on Rednal Hill and left it there. Classic inventory mismanagement. A flint scraping tool was also found in the area, so clearly crafting was enabled.

You can see the arrowhead at Birmingham Museum and Art Gallery. It's quite humbling to look at a 5,000 year old item drop that somebody rage quit on and never came back for.

Next come the Romans. They built a road over the hills, not because they fancied a ramble, but because they were shipping salt between their camps, one of them at Metchley. Metchley sits roughly where the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Birmingham is now, which I find oddly poetic. Two thousand years ago there were legionaries with shields; now there are NHS staff with clipboards. Same energy, different armor. Roman logistics were the original fast travel network: straight roads, no nonsense, and no detours for scenic views.

How the Normans, the Earl of Plymouth and the Victorians shaped the Lickeys

Then in 1066, everything changed. The Norman invasion turned the Lickeys into a royal hunting reserve, which sounds idyllic until you realize it mainly meant posh people chasing deer for cardio. A fun fact: forest didn't originally mean trees, it meant place of deer. If you've ever smugly corrected someone about medieval terminology, this is your moment.

The Normans also introduced rabbits, kept in large warrens and farmed like fluffy loot crates. That's why you get place names with warren in them. Call it a medieval industrial bunny complex.

In 1682 the crown sold the manor, and the family of the Earl of Plymouth, who lived at Hewell Grange in Tardebigge, owned the land for 250 years, an impressively long save file. They managed the land and the locals in a very feudal, this entire landscape is technically mine kind of way.

Fast forward to Queen Victoria and you get steam engines, ambition and mild smog. The railway arrived, schools and churches started to pop up, and it became suburban expansion, Victorian edition. Then in 1888 came the heroic bit. The Birmingham Society for the Preservation of Open Spaces bought Rednal Hill and handed it to the city in trust, and secured further woodland and Bilberry Hill on a peppercorn rent. That sounds adorable, but it means close to free while staying legally tidy. It's why you can still wander around today pretending you're in the Shire. Stone Age hunters, Roman supply chains, Norman deer parks, aristocrats, Victorians and bureaucrats: it's a long running campaign setting with surprisingly good world building.

J.R.R. Tolkien's summer in Rednal at Fern Cottage

In 1904, a 12 year old J.R.R. Tolkien moved to Rednal with his mother, who was recovering from an illness. Up to that point he had been living in what might generously be called gritty urban realism on the edges of Edgbaston and Ladywood. It wasn't exactly Rivendell. It was more like early game industrial Midlands: smoke, brick and probably the faint hum of existential dread.

Enter Francis Xavier Morgan, a priest of the Birmingham Oratory. In what feels suspiciously like a benevolent NPC intervention, he arranged for the family to escape to rural Rednal for the summer. Suddenly there were hills, trees, space and actual horizon lines, and you can practically hear the soundtrack shift from urban melancholy to pastoral strings with a hopeful flute.

They stayed in Fern Cottage, an 18th century building tucked within the Oratory Retreat grounds. This wasn't a grand country manor. It was the local postman's house, and the Tolkiens rented two rooms, with meals included courtesy of the postman's wife. Full board, modest and cozy, very Shire before the Shire was a thing. That summer, Tolkien and his younger brother roamed the Lickey Hills. They wandered, climbed, explored and imagined: two boys in the countryside with nothing but time and imagination, which turns out to be a slightly overpowered combination.

Why the Lickey Hills are believed to have seeded the Shire

It's widely believed that those hills helped seed the idea of the Shire, that gentle green preindustrial ideal where hobbits live in stubbornly comfortable denial of the wider world's chaos. To me, it makes sense. If you'd grown up among bricks, terraces and smokestacks and then found yourself on a sunlit ridge looking over soft countryside, you'd probably think this is what home should feel like.

So the Lickey Hills aren't just a nice walk with decent views and an excuse to wear boots you don't otherwise need. They're part of the deep lore. Before Middle-earth had maps, before hobbits had hairy feet, and before generations of fans learned to say second breakfast without irony, it started with a 12 year old boy wandering hills on the edge of Birmingham, quietly world building in his head. That's either incredibly wholesome or the most overpowered origin story in British literature. Probably both.

Tolkien and Edith Bratt's secret tea and the three year ban

When Tolkien's mother sadly passed away, she appointed Francis Xavier Morgan as guardian to her two sons. For the most part that worked: Father Francis genuinely cared about them. But there's always a but.

Tolkien's later visits to the Lickeys were much happier. In 1909 he returned to the cottage for part of the summer to revise for his Oxford scholarship exams. That same year he went cycling with his girlfriend, Edith Bratt, who lived in the same lodging house in Edgbaston. They rode out to the Lickeys when he was supposed to be studying, and he treated her to tea at the cottage. They kept the relationship secret, setting off separately and arriving separately. The Lickeys became their refuge, a safe place to hide from the world and fall in love. And they fell hard: Edith is the sole inspiration for Beren and Lúthien.

Unfortunately, Edwardian England functioned like a small village group chat powered by tea and gossip. The lady who served them tea mentioned it to the caretaker at the Oratory retreat, the caretaker told the cook at the Birmingham Oratory, and the cook told Father Francis. Stealth mission failed. Father Francis told Tolkien he must not see Edith again and moved the brothers to a different lodging house. Edith left to stay with friends in Cheltenham.

Then in February 1910, after they were seen together again, Father Francis forbade Tolkien from communicating with Edith at all until he came of age. That was three years of no letters and no meetings. If you're 18 and in love, that's the emotional equivalent of being exiled to Mordor with no fast travel. And yet he waited. For me, the most Tolkien thing imaginable isn't the elves, the languages or the maps. It's a teenage boy cycling over the Lickeys to secretly have tea with the girl he loves, then enduring a three year clerical cooldown like a brutally balanced RPG mechanic.

The letter, the engagement and Lúthien and Beren on the gravestone

On the evening of his 21st birthday, when the three years were up to the minute, he wrote to her. He didn't ease in or test the waters. He went straight in and asked her to marry him. Edith replied that she was engaged. Three years of silence, a letter the moment he was allowed to send it, and she was betrothed to someone else.

But he didn't accept defeat. Within a week he was on a train to Cheltenham. He met her in person, and while the details are understandably private, somehow he persuaded her to break off her engagement and choose him. Later he wrote in a poem that the two were like two fair trees, utterly intertwined, which is about the most Tolkien way possible of saying you complete me.

They married in March 1916, as the First World War was unfolding, and stayed married for 55 years, with children and grandchildren, until Edith's death in November 1971. On their shared gravestone their names are engraved not just as Edith and Ronald Tolkien but as Lúthien and Beren, because the great tragic love story at the heart of The Silmarillion was inspired by Edith dancing for him in a woodland glade at Roos in Yorkshire in 1917. It survived Edwardian gossip networks, forbidden contact, a world war and Tolkien's habit of expressing emotion through mythic tree imagery. It's better written than most modern romance plots, and it happened.

Why these quiet hills became part of Middle-earth's story

Stand up there today with your slightly impractical walking boots and your meal deal, and it doesn't feel like the birthplace of modern myth. It feels quiet, almost ordinary, understated. But I guess that's the point. The Lickey Hills aren't dramatic or cinematic. They're not Skyrim on ultra settings. They're gentle, green and unassuming, the kind of place where a boy might look across the countryside and think this is what home feels like.

From that modest patch of Midlands hillside came the Shire, Middle-earth and one of the greatest love stories ever written. That's not bad for the outskirts of Birmingham.

What other creators are saying

More on The Lord of the Rings →
Breakdowns & Blockbusters · more than 240,000 subscribers · Snippet
Shooting in 3D ruled out the camera trick used on The Lord of the Rings, leaving Gandalf's actor alone with a green screen.

Why Ian McKellen Broke Down in Tears on The Hobbit Set →

Film Paradise · more than 58,000 subscribers
The Secret Fire, also called the Flame Imperishable, is Eru Ilúvatar's power of creation, which Tolkien said represents the Holy Spirit. In Rings of Power, it appears to Gandalf in Rhûn and reveals his true mission is mercy: saving the fallen Blue Wizard Pallando rather than destroying him.

Secret Fire explained: what is it in Lord of the Rings? →

DanCo · more than 590,000 subscribers · Snippet
An ancient cosmic entity from Derry meets an immortal Maia who killed a Balrog, and experience decides it

Gandalf vs Pennywise: Why I Think Gandalf Wins →

GIQUE · more than 25,000 subscribers · Snippet
The king whose reign was defined by The Long Winter earned his name with his fists

Who Was Helm Hammerhand? The Lord of the Rings King and His Feud With Freca →

Watch the original

@ajm_nerdcore · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Alex's video of 9 March 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

J.R.R. TolkienLickey HillsThe Lord of the RingsThe ShireMiddle-earthEdith TolkienBeren and LúthienThe Silmarillion

More from @ajm_nerdcore

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →