SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
NewsMarvel

Ebenezer box office: is Johnny Depp's comeback real?

Ebenezer's opening, Avengers: Doomsday and Dune: Part Three splitting screens, VisionQuest's finale numbers and the Thanksgiving box office lineup.

Beyond The Trailer (AI-assisted)16 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2008 · more than 930,000 subscribers 1,990 words · 9 min read
Ebenezer box office: is Johnny Depp's comeback real?

I wouldn't say Johnny Depp is back, but I wouldn't say he's not back either. Ebenezer opened at number one with fantastic audience scores. Some people will say Depp is dead to them, but he's not dead to Hollywood. He has a pulse.

Can a movie star be uncancelled? Many celebrities are wondering that, and Skydance sure hopes so, because it seems to be a major part of its business strategy. Mel Gibson and Arnold Schwarzenegger have managed to come back, sort of, but never to the levels they once were, or even close. That's what makes Ebenezer interesting. Depp is closer than they've ever gotten.

Ebenezer opened at number one with audiences across the country

This is far from the openings of the mainstream blockbusters that made Depp a superstar. Still, Ebenezer found audiences evenly across the country. This wasn't a middle America play with the coasts refusing to show up. It's a smaller audience overall, but no part of the country totally ignored him.

Its best location was AMC Disney Springs. That's a fantastic sign for the potential return of Jack Sparrow, which I think is the linchpin of Johnny Depp's comeback. Disney has been wondering whether it can make a Pirates movie without Depp, and whether it can make one with him.

The release date helped. Depp's potential comeback had the weekend all to itself after the previous weekend's big movies fizzled, so all eyes were on him and it gave him an easy number one. He could have missed, but the bar wasn't set that high. It would have been nice if the opening had a two in front of it. Projections were 20 to 25 million, and it came in a scooch under 20. Maybe the final numbers will push it over. It's weak, but it's still number one, and Violent Night 2, another holiday release this season, is tracking to open with around half of that.

Depp's pay cut gave Ebenezer a low break even

I think Depp's team was very clever here, and so was Skydance. Depp was willing to take a massive pay cut, going from 20 million upfront to 5 million. That was crucial. It allowed Ebenezer to be made for 38 million dollars after rebates in the UK, giving the movie a break even of 95 million. After one weekend worldwide, it's already about halfway there.

The audience also skewed female. Depp has always done well with female audiences, and he still does, which I'm sure will surprise some people. It skewed a little older, but Depp can work with that, especially if he keeps his rate down. He's also getting backend, although there won't be much of it here. Backend can sometimes extend into digital, but it's usually thought of as theatrical. This was about getting Depp back on the board in any capacity, and it succeeded.

Depp has also proved he's willing to work hard for a smaller paycheck. He did two events at Comic-Con in full costume, one on the streets of San Diego and one in Hall H, although apparently his appearance wasn't cleared with everybody on that panel. I wouldn't want headlines like that to keep coming if I were his team. He also appeared at the Bryant Park holiday market in New York City to promote the film.

I don't think they gave him anything to do at these events, and I think they didn't totally land as a result. They should have hired a writer to give him something to say. I think Depp is very talented as an actor, but I don't know how good his improvisational skills are. I'm sure they're serviceable, but they're clearly not A+. Still, I think the appearances made the film feel like more of an event. Now his team can say Johnny can still open a movie at number one with broad appeal. Based on these results, I think he will return as Jack Sparrow in some capacity, and he'll get another lead role as long as he keeps his rate under 10 million. I think he could ask for a little more.

Skydance's 45 day theatrical window keeps Ebenezer off digital until December 28

Skydance gets a nice new holiday movie out of this, a little one, but a nice one. The catch is that David Ellison committed to a 45 day exclusive theatrical window. Toward the end, he would have committed to anything to get his deal through, and to his credit he did. That means Ebenezer can't hit digital until Monday, December 28.

Maybe people will watch it between Christmas and New Year's, but the fact that it can't hit digital right before Christmas is nuts. I don't think the success of Ebenezer was at the front of Ellison's mind. With a 30 day window, it could have dropped around December 13. With the oncoming wave of holiday movies, I wonder whether there will even be screens left for it. Not all of these releases can hope to survive. Some will debut on very small screens, and some aren't going to make it.

Skydance has also shown that maybe it can rehabilitate careers. It wants to go after cancelled actors because it sees them as cheap and as having something to prove. I think that's playing with fire. I think Depp is a unique case, and I can't think of any other cancelled actor who I think could come back. Probably not even Depp, but I think he might be the one. Maybe Schwarzenegger is the closest comparison, but it's complicated.

Johnny Depp's future: a Pirates of the Caribbean cameo and big IP

I don't think Depp's career will ever go back to what it once was, and that's coming from someone who enjoyed Ebenezer. But I do think it would be wrong to make a Pirates of the Caribbean movie without him, at least in a cameo. After this performance, I think you could give him two or three scenes. I wouldn't make him full supporting, because I think it might be too risky. I'd want a sprinkling of Depp throughout the film, perhaps once in each act.

Outside of Pirates, I think movies like Ebenezer are his future: big IP with lots of flourish to sweeten the deal. I think the days of anyone paying to see Depp in a drama are over. He could probably rely on small parts and cameos, like in Tim Burton movies, although Burton seemed to step away from him. Someone said Ebenezer felt like a Tim Burton version of A Christmas Carol, and when I saw it again, I thought that's maybe what the director was going for, and to his credit he sort of succeeded. It was a more muted, dialed back version of that style. Maybe the movie would have done better somewhere in the middle.

Depp also has many friends in Hollywood. Besides Burton, he could team up with longtime pal Nicolas Cage, whose career is in a similar spot.

Nicholas Hoult's How to Rob a Bank flopped

I predicted How to Rob a Bank, starring Nicholas Hoult, would bomb, and I was correct. It debuted at number seven with a little over five million across three days, and it doesn't have strong audience scores. Maybe someday he can pull a Ryan Gosling, who has given hope to great actors who can't sell a movie ticket. Right now, Hoult is still in that category. Nobody really feels he's in the running for James Bond, but if he had any hope, this killed it.

I enjoy his Lex Luthor quite a bit, but maybe he's holding the Superman box office back. I've always thought they could have had a bigger star there, and casting Hoult aged the character down. Bryan Cranston or Denzel Washington would have been interesting choices. I think Hoult belongs on streaming, and there's nothing wrong with that. The Great is one of the best things he's done, and he's signed on for Mosquito, a new Hulu show from The Great writer Tony McNamara. I will watch it.

As for director David Leitch, I think he's already stuck in mediocre. He started out with Chad Stahelski on the John Wick movies before heading off to Hollywood. At this point, I'd be a little nervous to hire him, because I'd wonder whether he can deliver a strong movie.

Ghost Soldier, Victorian Psycho, Paper Tiger and the rest of the top 10

Even Ghost Soldier did better, with Jim Caviezel doing a pretty good Jason Statham impression for Sony. It's doing pretty well in theaters, but it will likely make most of its money on digital, like a Statham movie. Victorian Psycho did poorly. It should have been on digital for Halloween; I would have watched it. I thought the trailer was pretty good, but now I've forgotten about it. Maika Monroe is very talented, but she's going to have to think about why her career isn't working out. Marvel came calling for Samara Weaving, who had the same problem of being stuck in Margot Robbie's shadow. What franchise is left for Monroe?

Paper Tiger debuted with a soft per theater average and only an okay critic score. I turned my screener off after 20 minutes. Like Margot Robbie, Adam Driver has the worst taste in small movies for himself, which is maybe why he finally answered Marvel's call, on top of being, as he's admitted, a massive X-Men fan. He recently said the ship has sailed on returning as Kylo Ren, and he's still shocked that Disney said no to a Steven Soderbergh Kylo Ren movie that was ready to go after two years of development. It is shocking. But I wouldn't close the door on that, especially with new leadership coming in.

Godzilla tumbled 73% in its second weekend despite a massive online ad push from GKIDS. It's at around 100 million worldwide, and the last one ended at 100 million, so it will get a little past that. That's fine, because the new Toho Godzilla movies are inexpensive to make. Ramayana fell only 38% and is now at 150 million worldwide, already one of the top 10 grossing Indian films worldwide of all time. Amanda Seyfried will host SNL for the first time on Saturday, December 5, as she campaigns for a best supporting actress nomination. I'll be amazed if she gets it, but good for her for trying. Warner Bros. kept the number two spot with Cat in the Hat, while Clayface is almost out of the top 10.

Avengers: Doomsday vs. Dune: Part Three at one New Jersey multiplex

My case study is the AMC Garden State 16 in New Jersey, a huge 16 screen multiplex. Dune gets the IMAX screen. This AMC has two Dolby theaters, one for each movie, and Doomsday will also have ScreenX and XL. It looks like both films have about five screens each. Dune will have two premium and three regular screens, while Doomsday's marketing says all its screens are special, even the 3D one.

Quite a lot of tickets were still available for Friday afternoon, which means there could be a lot of walk up business. In New York City, forget it. Both movies run around three hours with trailers and are playing around the clock. It's going to be a historic weekend at the box office.

VisionQuest's finale numbers trail Loki season 2

VisionQuest still isn't doing well enough to make Nielsen's overall chart, but it has passed what Lanterns did week to week. Lanterns was always in the low 500s, and VisionQuest has climbed to the high 500s. Disney released a headline calling the VisionQuest finale the most watched Marvel finale on Disney+ in three years, since Loki season 2. I think that's a touch misleading. When I looked it up, the Loki season 2 finale had three times the audience, and Lanterns came closer to that than VisionQuest did.

I would argue Disney+ Marvel shows aren't doing better because they're on Disney+ and have to be too safe for that service. Put them on Hulu, where they could compete with HBO. People are harder on Disney, Star Wars and Marvel, and I think Disney+ is the wrong service for Marvel content.

Nobody Wants This, K-pop Demon Hunters and Netflix's charts

Nobody Wants This keeps chugging along and has been renewed for a fourth season. They have to fix the Sasha and Morgan mess. It made me so angry it made me hate the season, but I will definitely tune in to see what happens. Come to think of it, they're like Ross and Rachel on fast forward: Sasha is very Ross coded and Morgan is very Rachel coded.

K-pop Demon Hunters is back at the bottom of the top 10 after sitting at number three the week before. Netflix has announced a global arena tour that will use new technology to bring the animated movie to life on stage. I'm not a super fan, but I like the movie and enjoy a good night out, so I was tempted. Netflix's first holiday movie of the season also came out swinging, a nice feather in Dennis Quaid's cap. I don't think Quaid was ever cancelled, but he did get political, and I think that hurt him.

Brad Pitt tops digital and Robert Pattinson's awards push

Is Brad Pitt cancelled? That's hard to tell. Maybe he's a good Depp equivalent, although he never fell as far career wise. He's at number one on digital with Heart of the Beast, with Jason Statham's Mutiny right below. There's also a Robert Pattinson double feature with Primetime and The Odyssey. His awards campaign for The Odyssey is going extremely well. You never know for sure, but I think it's extremely likely he gets a best supporting actor nomination. Whether he can also land best actor for Primetime at the Oscars, I don't know, but maybe at the Golden Globes, whose nominations come Monday, December 7.

The Hunger Games could open to 80 to 100 million before Thanksgiving

The weekend before Thanksgiving has become a major release date because Disney Animation won't budge from Thanksgiving weekend itself. The new Hunger Games is taking that slot, and it looks like it might recapture the franchise's former glory, with maybe an 80 to 100 million opening. That would be incredible, around double what the last one opened at.

Expect I Play Rocky to maybe carve out a little space too, because it's a real crowd pleaser. I really enjoyed it, particularly if you like behind the scenes Hollywood stories. Club Kid also goes wide, and Andrew Scott is gaining momentum as the new front runner to win best actor. I think I Play Rocky has the potential to be a hit as well: "A smaller hit but a hit. It's a great movie."

What other creators are saying

More on Johnny Depp →
Kristian Harloff · more than 230,000 subscribers
Ebenezer pleasantly surprised me: Depp is comfortable and believable as Scrooge, the cast including McKellen, Tillman and Riseborough is solid, and West's horror-tinged, Burton-esque style keeps a faithful retelling from being boring, though I think it's too scary for young kids. I'm giving it a 3.7.

Ebenezer review: is Johnny Depp's Scrooge worth watching? →

The Movie Couple · more than 80,000 subscribers · Snippet
Our first impressions of Ebenezer, starring Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge, straight out of the theater

We found Johnny Depp's Ebenezer takes A Christmas Carol in a darker, horror direction →

Movie Facts Pro · more than 220,000 subscribers · Snippet
Some actors on the set of Ebenezer did not recognize him when he wasn't in costume

Johnny Depp Spent Over Three Hours a Day in Makeup to Play Scrooge in Ebenezer →

Breakdowns & Blockbusters · more than 240,000 subscribers
From a 65-pound weight gain for Chapter 27 to bombs like Morbius, Tron: Ares and Masters of the Universe, the Oscar winner has never proven himself a box office draw.

Jared Leto box office: why he is no draw despite an Oscar →

Watch the original

@beyondthetrailer · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Beyond The Trailer's video of 16 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Johnny DeppEbenezerBox OfficeSkydancePirates of the CaribbeanAvengers: DoomsdayDune: Part ThreeVisionQuest

More from @beyondthetrailer

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →