Ebenezer review: is Johnny Depp's darker Scrooge worth seeing?
Ti West's take on Dickens is bleak, moving and nothing like its silly trailers, though it could have been scarier and cozier
Ebenezer, the new A Christmas Carol starring Johnny Depp and directed by Ti West, is the darkest version of the story I've ever seen. I cried several times. I'd wager it's also the truest to what Charles Dickens intended when he wrote the original. Would I watch it every year? Probably not. It's too sad. But it certainly made a strong impression on me, and it's grown on me the more I think about it.
The 2026 film from Paramount casts Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge, alongside Sir Ian McKellen as Jacob Marley, Tramell Tillman as the Ghost of Christmas Present, Sam Claflin as Scrooge's nephew Fred and Rupert Grint as Cratchit.
Why I came to Ebenezer as a lifelong A Christmas Carol fan
I'm a massive fan of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol. I could act it out for you. When I was in London in 2024, I visited Dickens' home and even got a coaster. They had one of his writing desks on display, though unfortunately it's not the one where he wrote A Christmas Carol.
I've seen the Mickey Mouse version, the Muppet version, Scrooged and Spirited, which has a great song. There was also the version that played at Madison Square Garden for years, and I've done a few comedy sketches on the story myself back in my improv days in New York City. I even once played a ghost; I think it was the Ghost of Christmas Past.
My absolute favorite version is the 1951 film starring Alastair Sim. I watch it every single Christmas. That's important, because I've seen this story so many times that it takes something different to surprise me. Ebenezer did.
The Ebenezer trailers don't reflect the movie
When I saw the trailers, I thought: what is there possibly to add at this point? They looked silly and over the top. I wondered what kind of creative choices Johnny Depp was making. It turns out that ad campaign is a blatant lie. If you think the trailers look good, I feel sorry for you, because the movie is not like that at all.
The trailers are almost entirely made up of scenes from the end of the film, when Ebenezer is giddy like a schoolboy. Take the way he says "Merry Christmas." I hated it in the trailer, because it seemed like he was making fun of saying it. In the film, it turns out that's simply the way he says it, and now that I know he isn't mocking Christmas, I like it.
Because the marketing only focuses on those giddy scenes, I'd assumed Depp was mimicking his Jack Sparrow performance, mugging for the camera and betraying that he had no idea why Jack Sparrow worked. The trailers made him look like a fool. I even thought maybe he should consider retiring. I was wrong.
Debtor's prison and Dickens' own history
Some backstory matters here. Charles Dickens' father went to debtor's prison. In 1800s England, if you couldn't pay your debts, you went to prison and worked them off through forced labor. It had a traumatic effect on Dickens financially and emotionally, and it must have, at least to some degree, inspired him to write A Christmas Carol.
Other versions tend to sometimes leave out the debtor's prisons, apart from Scrooge's line about there being no prisons, which is really what he's referring to. Ebenezer leans into them, and it isn't a cozy place, as you'll see.
Greed, the Gilded Age and Scrooge's selfish motive
For most of history there has been enormous financial inequity. After the Gilded Age, which is also a great show on HBO, there was so much excess wealth not being spread around that restrictions had to be imposed on capitalism. Then after World War II, particularly in the United States, the middle class developed. That's starting to go away.
Even the Gilded Age had one thing going for it. Tycoons back then felt some responsibility to society. They donated to charity and contributed. So far, it seems only Mark Cuban and Jeff Bezos's ex wife feel that way today. "Perhaps many of the billionaires today should be visited by three spirits."
For the first time, even after all these viewings, it struck me that Ebenezer was, I think to a large degree, driven by selfish reasons. He did not want to share the same fate in the afterlife as his late partner Jacob Marley. There was some compassion for sure, but that was a big part of it. That made me think that perhaps religion losing its grip on the world, partially organized religion's own fault, maybe contributed to how out of control greed has become, and maybe to why Gilded Age tycoons gave back while today's see no such need.
Johnny Depp's Ebenezer is a complicated, damaged man
Johnny Depp has still got it. I didn't think he did. His performance here reminded me more of his Mad Hatter in the first film, where the character was surprisingly emotional and tragic. (The second movie was awful.) From the opening scene, where we get to see Scrooge and Marley together and catch Ebenezer glancing at his friend with a look of true love and admiration, I thought this movie might be different than the trailers.
His performance is not caricature at all. He still does his trademark transformation through hair and makeup, but I think it hearkens back to his more nuanced earlier serious roles, maybe a little Edward Scissorhands. Edward was a blank slate of a character, though, while Ebenezer is very rich, not just financially but in the complicated life he's lived.
Depp presents Ebenezer as a complicated, damaged man whose change isn't like flipping a light switch, but a gradual shift through the night thanks to the spirits' lessons. He's been treated poorly almost his entire life, so he's put his guard up and made the worst assumptions about people he's never met, and tragically about his own nephew Fred. I think he connects most with Tillman's spirit, and I was very moved by their scenes. There's a great line where the Ghost of Christmas Present, seeing Ebenezer feel some empathy, says "perhaps there is a flicker of humanity in you after all still." I've never read the original, so I can't say whether that comes from Dickens. It's a beautiful performance.
Ti West makes Ebenezer faithful and bleak, but I think not scary enough
In some ways, Ebenezer is more faithful to Dickens than any adaptation I've seen. I love the title cards throughout. But it also makes additions, like that opening scene with Marley, and some changes, particularly in the second act, just when the film started to lose me a bit. Some will ask who dares rewrite Dickens. Because the story has been told so many times and so long has passed, I think the changes work, freshening it up and making it a little better for modern audiences.
Still, I wondered if Paramount was happy with West's directing. Almost every version I've seen has tremendous warmth even though it's a dark story, and perhaps that's why none has struck me the way this does. This has a bleakness I've maybe only seen in Scrooged, and even that gets much warmer at the end with its Christmas TV special. That never really happens here. Paramount hired an indie horror director most famous for the X trilogy. Pearl was a little warmer, so maybe they thought he'd lean that way. He did not.
Perhaps West is a little too accurate about life in Dickensian London instead of delivering the Hollywood version everyone likes. It's a cold, bleak, sparse and often dirty world. It really is a ghost story, which may be why they hired a horror director, and West leans into that. But I think he doesn't make it scary enough. If you're going to do it, do it. He does make some cool choices and visuals I liked a lot, including an opening shot that's a take on the mountain becoming the Paramount logo, which I thought was cute in the best way.
Part of me felt he was inspired by Nosferatu, but he didn't go full Robert Eggers. At the very end, when the camera pans up on the Scrooge and Marley shop front, I wondered if they reused the Nosferatu sets. I don't know if they did, but it looked like it. That Dickensian quality was one of the coolest things about Nosferatu.
Emma Watts should have pushed for more scary and cozy
I think Johnny Depp and Ti West are an inspired combination, but their producer, former Fox executive Emma Watts, let them down. Good creative collaboration sometimes means being brutally honest with someone and moving forward from there. She should have told them to "turn the dial up to an 11 in terms of scary and cozy." Scarier and cozier, and maybe they would have had a hit on their hands. We'll see how this turns out.
Paramount has tried to market this as a holiday film for families. Good luck with that. It's more of a cautionary tale for adults, who will relate, especially these days, to what it explores, and maybe for mature teenagers getting into horror. Horror fans who look for holiday horror films might like it too.
Arthur Conti, Sam Claflin and the rest of the Ebenezer cast
There's nothing to critique about the acting for the most part. Arthur Conti, who was in Beetlejuice Beetlejuice, plays the younger Ebenezer. Move over, Timmy C, we have another good young Johnny Depp. I think he lacks Depp's warmth, but I believed him as a younger Depp, which sold those very important scenes.
Sam Claflin is fantastic as Fred. The character is supposed to remind Ebenezer of his late sister, which is one reason Ebenezer can't talk to him; it's too painful. But as we spend more time with Fred, you see glimmers of Ebenezer in him, which made them seem more like family. I thought that was a brilliant choice.
Ian McKellen is, of course, fantastic, and Tramell Tillman is amazing. West fleshes out the Ghost of Christmas Present role and Tillman steps up to the challenge. Andrea Riseborough is mostly wearing an amazing costume. I'm sorry to say Rupert Grint is not a very good actor. In a movie where everyone makes interesting choices, he does not. His Cratchit is boring and one note, though he looks very Dickensian. Tiny Tim not only has the leg problem but looked a little cross eyed, which felt like laying it on thick. He's in it less than in other versions, which I thought was okay, because this is a Christmas Carol for adults.
Should you see Ebenezer in theaters?
Now I have a real problem. I always watch the Alastair Sim version every year, but this makes me feel that one might be a little light. It doesn't go where it needs to. I don't feel like I'm experiencing the story Dickens intended. But do I want to cry every Christmas? I cry with Elf too, but those are happy tears. This was a sad cry.
I guess Ebenezer came out at just the right time, right after Halloween as Christmas is getting started. You can be a little sad and a little scary, take some medicine for the soul, and still have good cheer closer to December 25.
If you're a fan of A Christmas Carol, Johnny Depp or holiday horror, you should see this in theaters. Otherwise, you can take a pass and catch it down the line; I'm sure it's going to be on digital very close to Christmas. I liked Ebenezer more than I thought I would. It challenged me, it stuck with me, and I like it more and more the more I think about it.
What other creators are saying
More on Ti West →Ebenezer pleasantly surprised me: Depp is comfortable and believable as Scrooge, the cast including McKellen, Tillman and Riseborough is solid, and West's horror-tinged, Burton-esque style keeps a faithful retelling from being boring, though I think it's too scary for young kids. I'm giving it a 3.7.
Our first impressions of Ebenezer, starring Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge, straight out of the theater
We found Johnny Depp's Ebenezer takes A Christmas Carol in a darker, horror direction →
Some actors on the set of Ebenezer did not recognize him when he wasn't in costume
Johnny Depp Spent Over Three Hours a Day in Makeup to Play Scrooge in Ebenezer →
Watch the original
@beyondthetrailer · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Beyond The Trailer's video of 13 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @beyondthetrailer
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →
