SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreSci-Fi & Fantasy

Star Trek: is William Riker Starfleet's best strategist?

From a Klingon bird of prey to the Borg cube, Riker wins when he has time to plan, and struggles when he doesn't

Lore Reloaded (AI-assisted)16 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2016 · more than 140,000 subscribers 1,440 words · 7 min read
Star Trek: is William Riker Starfleet's best strategist?

Captain William Riker is one of the biggest fan favorites in Star Trek, and I think he's one of the most brilliant strategists the Federation has. He was a dedicated Starfleet officer, a loving husband (mostly), and quite the womanizer before that marriage. One thing the universe has consistently stated about him is that he's a master tactician.

Riker first appeared in Star Trek: The Next Generation (1987), played by Jonathan Frakes alongside Patrick Stewart. He's been in far too many battles to go through every one of them. The battles below show both his strengths and the one place where I think he falls short: when he has no time to prepare.

Riker wins aboard the Klingon bird of prey Pagh without firing a shot

I believe the first real time we see Riker in combat, and ultimately in command, is aboard the Klingon ship Pagh. I don't know if Riker studied Sun Tzu, but he certainly embraced the wisdom of the man, or whoever wrote it. He embodied the saying that the greatest victory is the one that requires no battle. Ultimate victory comes when battle is thwarted through intelligence or intimidation, with no destruction, no cities seized and no blood shed.

In this instance Riker was serving aboard the Pagh, an aging bird of prey whose crew believes the USS Enterprise has betrayed them. They're outmatched in a fair fight, so the captain's plan is to catch the Enterprise by surprise and destroy it. What's amazing about this fight is that it's twofold. First, Riker isn't trusted on the Klingon ship, because he's a Federation officer. He has to prove his loyalty and also understand the nuances of Klingon culture.

He toes the line, staying loyal to both his former ship and his current crew, and he knows that disloyalty to either will result in his death. He walks that line magnificently. He refuses to reveal the best way to attack the Enterprise, yet tells the captain, "I will obey your orders. I will serve this ship as first officer and in an attack against the Enterprise I will die with this crew."

In the end he does assist the Pagh, but he uses deception to win the day. He tricks the Klingon captain into taking a transponder, and once the captain is gone, Riker takes command of the vessel. He then decloaks and demands the surrender of the Enterprise, which promptly surrenders. He won a battle without firing one disruptor and used his knowledge of both the Klingons and the Federation to stay loyal to each. He also made sure the Klingon captain left with honor, saving his life and the unity of the crew. He knew how to handle people, which is critical for a Starfleet officer.

Riker does more with less on the USS Hathaway

Another battle shows how Riker uses the resources at his command. It's a simulation that pits the USS Enterprise, a top of the line Galaxy class vessel, against the USS Hathaway, a Constellation class ship that is 80 years old and on its last legs. I think this is likely one of the prime examples of why Riker was probably an excellent strategic officer in the Dominion War.

This fight shows that when Number One has time to prepare, he can work magic. He's on the back foot with this vessel and has to do more with less. He picks his crew and lets them play to their individual strengths: Geordi and Wesley work in engineering, Worf is on tactical, and Data is effectively in operations. The ship is restored to where it needs to be for the fight, and they're off to the races.

It's not only that. He listens to his officers and lets them take chances when they come up with ideas. He puts the good ones into practice and modifies the ones that wouldn't work.

Riker cheats the simulation, and it pays off

One of the best strategic moves Riker makes in this whole affair is, frankly, that he cheats. He uses Worf's codes to trick the Enterprise into thinking a Romulan warship is coming upon both ships. That lets him score several hits very early in the game and do significant damage. As I commonly hear in MechWarrior Online, "if you're in a fair fight with someone you've both failed."

He doesn't let this go to his head, though. He still prepares for a fight that's going to be tough. I won't go into the rest of the battle, since the Enterprise is then attacked by another vessel, a Ferengi ship. I won't get into why I think that was a poor call on Picard's side, but it does show that Riker has another trick up his sleeve.

The Hathaway, which was thought to be stuck, has warp capability. Because he trusts his people, Riker warps out and tricks the Ferengi into thinking another vessel is incoming and that they're outmatched. Sun Tzu would be especially proud of this maneuver, and it wins the fight.

Riker outthinks Locutus to rescue Picard from the Borg

I think the most famous battle involving Riker is the one against the Borg during the first Borg war. I'm not talking about the first confrontation, when he attempted to destroy the cube. I'm talking about how they saved Captain Picard himself. Once again, this was a fight Riker was able to prepare for, and he worked diligently to get his people ready.

He didn't let sentiment or personal distaste get in his way. He told Worf he needed his experience at tactical, and told Data he had seriously considered him as first officer but needed everyone where they were. He then gave the first officer slot to Commander Shelby, saying, "I have been reluctantly forced to conclude that Commander Shelby our expert on the Borg is an ideal choice at this time for first officer." He made sure his people and resources were allocated where they needed to be. He also didn't only listen to those under his command; he listened to civilians who had some wise things to say.

After receiving the kick he needed, Riker realized one thing. He was up against an enemy that knew everything there was to know about Starfleet. Locutus knew the technology and even the tactics. So, taking another page from Sun Tzu's book, he realized he needed to know the enemy as well as he knew himself. If he did that, he would need not fear the result of a hundred battles, and he knew success in warfare is gained by carefully accommodating himself to the enemy's purpose.

He knew that Picard knew the playbook, which meant Locutus knew it too, and that was valuable. He could use it against them. During the rescue, Riker delayed to get all his pieces in position, then seemed to attempt an attack Picard was aware of. Ultimately it was a feint. He wanted Locutus, with Picard's memories, to believe he was sticking to the playbook, when in reality he was writing his own. The saucer separated and shielded the Borg cube from seeing what was happening, which let a small away team board the cube and capture Locutus. That gained them the information that resulted in the cube's destruction.

Riker struggles when he has no time to prepare, as at Veridian III

All of this leads to one conclusion: Riker is a strategic genius when given time to plan and prepare for a fight. That isn't the case when he has little time to prepare. Probably the most glaring example is the Battle of Veridian III. Riker has no time to ready himself when an aging bird of prey finds a way to penetrate the shields of the USS Enterprise.

Unfortunately, Riker goes into strategy mode and not tactical mode. A Galaxy class ship against a very old bird of prey is no contest. The Galaxy class should be able to easily overpower a decrepit ship of bygone years. What Riker should have done was position the vessel where it could withstand the most hits and unleash everything it had on the bird of prey.

Instead he relies on a technical trick to win the day. He was successful, but it was ultimately a Pyrrhic victory, because the damage from the prolonged fight resulted in the destruction of the Enterprise. There are many examples of Riker doing very well as a strategist and not so well as a captain when things don't go to plan.

Why I think Riker belonged at Starfleet Tactical in the Dominion War

It's my belief that during the Dominion War, Riker was probably assigned to Starfleet Tactical to plan the battles, leaving the likes of Sisko to carry out his designs.

Riker is probably one of the most brilliant strategists in the Federation. I'm hopeful the Starfleet admiralty realized that, though this is the Federation we're talking about.

What other creators are saying

More on William Riker →
ChaosTrek · more than 15,000 subscribers
I rank William Riker as Star Trek's best first officer, edging out Spock for the top spot because he handles nearly every part of the job, from routine crew management to challenging Picard when necessary. Spock comes close but his struggles leading emotional crews cost him the edge.

Star Trek first officers ranked: Riker or Spock at number one? →

Everything Always · more than 1 million subscribers
The actor behind Jean-Luc Picard and Charles Xavier died at his Los Angeles home following Alzheimer's disease and Lewy body dementia, his longtime spokesperson announced

Patrick Stewart dies at 86: Picard and Professor X star →

The Gold Man · more than 170,000 subscribers · Snippet
Star Trek (2009) and The Force Awakens share a director, a reboot mission and the start of a trilogy

J.J. Abrams Played an Almost Identical Role in Star Trek and Star Wars →

Galaxy Geeks · more than 680,000 subscribers · Snippet
One card plays artifacts from the top of your library, and the other rewards facing a dilemma with free spells

Zefram Cochrane and the Caretaker among Magic: The Gathering Star Trek preview cards →

Watch the original

@lorereloaded · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Lore Reloaded's video of 4 September 2023 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Star TrekWilliam RikerStar Trek: The Next GenerationJonathan FrakesStarfleetBorgLocutusKlingons

More from @lorereloaded

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →