SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
TheoryMarvel

Avengers: Doomsday theory: why Doctor Doom has Tony Stark's face

New Empire photos and quotes from Kevin Feige, the Russos, Robert Downey Jr., Pedro Pascal and Simu Liu reveal more about Avengers: Doomsday's Victor von Doom

New Rockstars (AI-assisted)15 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2011 · more than 4.4 million subscribers 1,990 words · 9 min read
Avengers: Doomsday theory: why Doctor Doom has Tony Stark's face

Kevin Feige says Robert Downey Jr.'s Doctor Doom in Avengers: Doomsday isn't a variant of Tony Stark or connected to him in any way. At first that made no sense to me, but I think I've figured out what he means: in this multiverse, Downey's face belongs to Victor von Doom, and Tony Stark is the exception.

That comes out of a batch of new information from Empire Magazine, which released new photos ahead of its November 19th issue along with quotes from the Avengers: Doomsday filmmakers and cast. Here's everything in it, connected to the biggest question heading into the movie: why does Victor von Doom look like Tony Stark?

Empire's new photo puts Doctor Doom on top of the X-Mansion

The fresh look at Doctor Doom shows a cloak that doesn't look green. It looks more like the darker color it appeared to be in the scene added to the end of Vision Quest involving Wanda Maximoff. In the image, you can see what appear to be the organized parapets of a castle, which means Doom is standing on the battlements.

My first assumption was that this is Castle Doom, part of which we see in the background of the Jeep ad that gave us our first look at Latveria. The other option was that Doom is on the roof of this movie's X-Mansion. That same Jeep commercial showed the mansion's exterior for the first time, with one of Doctor Doom's enslaved TVA agents driving Sentinel parts into the battle.

Empire also released a new image of James Marsden's Cyclops and Channing Tatum's Gambit outside the X-Mansion, before it seems to get attacked by the Sentinels. At the very top of the mansion in the background, you can see those same parapets. To me, that confirms Doctor Doom is standing on top of the X-Mansion in that photo, meaning he has already conquered it.

Kevin Feige and James Marsden on the X-Men joining the Avengers

Empire describes the X-Men's return as the fulfillment of a longtime dream for Feige, who was an associate producer on 2000's X-Men. Feige pointed to old interviews in which Hugh Jackman said people called it impossible, but maybe someday the X-Men and the Avengers could all get together. "It just felt like the fun way to culminate a quarter century of storytelling," Feige said.

For Marsden, Empire writes, it means a chance for Scott Summers to become the X-Men's leader on screen, after his death in X-Men: The Last Stand was undone by the timeline altering events of 2014's X-Men: Days of Future Past. "I like to think of Scott as a noble and good man who, at the end of the day, will do the right thing," Marsden told Empire.

The multiverse collapsing stakes mean there are no easy decisions, though. Marsden teased that it "probably reveals quite a lot about your character, what you're willing to do," adding that it isn't black and white and carries potentially catastrophic implications. It sounds more and more like the X-Men are going to do some very bad things at the beginning of this movie, which lines up with what's been rumored about how it opens.

Joe and Anthony Russo describe Doctor Doom as gothic, grieving and driven by ego

Empire's early previews include quotes with context from writer Ben Travis, and the aim, according to the magazine, is to deliver on what makes Victor von Doom tick. "Doom is a gothic character," director Joe Russo told Empire. Russo added that Doom says hell answers to him and isn't kidding, calling him a powerful character with dark magic who isn't above selling his soul to get what he wants.

Empire writes that the fear factor will be compounded and underpinned by tragedy. "He's a father who's a victim of trauma. He has lost a child," Russo teased, adding that people who see the film call it a very scary movie because Doom is so profoundly damaged. Co-director Anthony Russo set Doom apart from the last big Avengers villain: "Doom is much more ego-driven than Thanos." Thanos believed he was serving a greater good.

That gives us a lot more context. It confirms this Victor lost a child, which fits what Sue Storm says in the D23 trailer when she says he lost everything. Russo teasing that hell answers to Doom and that he made a deal with the devil has my mind racing about Doom's comic book connections to Mephisto. In the comics, the soul of Doom's mother Cynthia was claimed by Mephisto until Doctor Doom and Doctor Strange worked together to exploit a loophole that freed her soul to the good afterlife.

Robert Downey Jr. on realizing he's the bad guy

Downey's Tony Stark launched the franchise and closed the Infinity Saga with his sacrificial snap, so returning as Doom required some recalibration. Downey told Empire he thought of Michael Douglas at the end of Falling Down saying he's the bad guy. He said he had that realization a couple of days into shooting, "because all the heroes are over there and I'm the problem," and that once he leaned in, it was a glorious time.

Empire frames it this way: if Iron Man built the MCU, Doom is ready to remake it in his image. "I like a bit of scorched earth," Downey teased, adding that whatever people think he may be entertaining, if they multiply it by 10, they'll probably be closer to the ballpark.

Downey's reference to Michael Douglas's character in Joel Schumacher's 1993 film Falling Down is a frightening comparison, since that's a seemingly mild mannered man who snaps into a violent rage. And yes, I caught the scorched earth and remaking it in his image references. Obviously, Doom is going to scorch these earths and build something new out of them.

Kevin Feige says Doctor Doom is not a Tony Stark variant

Then there's the big question: does Downey's casting mean Victor von Doom is somehow a variant of Tony Stark? Feige maintains that he isn't. "Is Steve Rogers a Johnny Storm variant?" he asked, pointing to Chris Evans playing both characters across different eras of Marvel. Feige said people wondered whether Doom was a variant of another character, or a shortcut to bringing back another character. "The answer is no. He's Victor von Doom."

I don't think Feige is shutting the question down completely. I think he's using a very particular set of words that will make sense once we see the movie. Back in July, Joe Russo was asked the same question in an interview whose wording was hard to follow (I think it might have been another language), and he answered: "No better actor in the world than Robert Downey. I'm not going to give away anything. It will all make sense when you watch the movies."

My theory: Victor von Doom is the rule and Tony Stark is the anomaly

Victor von Doom may not be a variant of Tony Stark, but I think what Feige is getting at is that this movie will reveal Downey is only Tony Stark in the 616 universe. In the 828 universe and every other universe, he's Victor von Doom. Ninety nine times out of a hundred, a person with this face is named Victor von Doom, which would make Tony Stark the accident, the anomaly, the violation of that rule.

So it's not that Victor is a variant of Tony. Victor having this face is the rule of the multiverse, and Victor is the standard. The visual similarity isn't meant to be read as him being a TVA coded variant. It's meant to reframe Victor von Doom as the character Downey was always meant to play, with Tony Stark as a weird coincidental accident that makes Victor very frightening to the 616 heroes who knew him as someone else.

The Russos have also told Empire that when we see Downey's face in this movie, it's going to be so heavily scarred that they had to augment it with CGI, and we did see motion tracker dots on his face in a behind the scenes photo. They want us to know he's going to be completely transformed. I think Feige is doing some expectation management, telling audiences not to expect an in universe explanation. But Downey's casting was obviously intentional, and I think they want to redefine this face as Doctor Doom in a way that unnerves these heroes.

Why Feige points to Chris Evans as Johnny Storm and Steve Rogers

When Feige was first building the Marvel Cinematic Universe and cast Chris Evans as Captain America, he didn't see the MCU as firmly bound by Disney, Sony, Fox or Universal studio lines, because this was all before Disney. Marvel Studios was partnering with Paramount for Iron Man, Captain America: The First Avenger and Thor, and with Universal for 2008's The Incredible Hulk.

So Feige didn't yet see the 2005 and 2007 Fantastic Four movies or the X-Men movies at Fox as a completely separate universe. He hoped they might all connect someday. Initially, he wanted the post credits scene of 2008's Iron Man to have Nick Fury reference radioactive bug bites and assorted mutants.

To Feige back then, Evans playing two Marvel characters who could have existed in the same universe wasn't a big deal. That's why he uses the example now, and why he thinks Downey playing two characters isn't a big deal either. Still, I think Feige and the Russos underestimate how confused fans are going to be by this casting.

Shang-Chi faces Gambit inside the X-Mansion

Empire also released a new image of Shang-Chi in his fight with Gambit in the X-Mansion. I'm guessing Shang-Chi is using his rings to create something that can catch him or cushion his fall. According to Empire, Shang-Chi is now part of the new Avengers team that Sam Wilson's Captain America has assembled, which was teed up at the end of Captain America: Brave New World, and the trailers tease Gambit's kinetic purple powers clashing with Shang-Chi's rings.

Simu Liu told Empire the showdown reminded him of the bus fight from his first film, not in structure but in how the filmmakers approached it. "I have two comfort zones. One is comedy and one is action. This movie gave me an opportunity to do both," Liu said. He added that he was so stunned by the fan response to the first film that it set off an expectation in his mind that the character's journey would be paid off, and when Doomsday came around, it felt right.

Pedro Pascal says Reed Richards and Doctor Doom are bonded as scientists

Another Empire image is a new angle on the trailer shot of Reed Richards, Yelena Belova and Sam Wilson in the X-Mansion, with Shang-Chi there too. I love the practical look of Reed's stretched out arm and how his jacket is made from a fabric that stretches and bends with his limbs. Empire notes the Fantastic Four's history with Downey's Doctor Doom should come in handy.

"They're bonded as scientists," Pedro Pascal told Empire. He said they think together through science and math in ways most people don't, and that you can't help but feel a bond of friendship and kinship, and feel less alone, when there's a mind equal if not superior to your own.

In recent weeks, I've discussed how it seems like this movie will establish the comic backstory of Reed and Victor as former college roommates, at MIT in the 828 universe, and Pascal is echoing that here. I think Reed is going to be the first and smartest to understand exactly how Victor betrayed them. I think this is even more evidence that Feige considers Downey's Victor von Doom his own guy with his own established history, so that Downey's Tony Stark ends up feeling like an oopsie next to who this character is.

What the Avengers: Doomsday writing credits reveal

The Writers Guild of America has published the official writing credits for Avengers: Doomsday. Stephen McFeely and Michael Waldron are listed as the screenplay's primary writers. Under an additional category, additional literary material not on screen, the WGA credits McFeely, Waldron, Eric Pearson, Chris McKenna, Erik Sommers, Jeff Loveness, Andrew Lanham, Destin Daniel Cretton, Ryan Reynolds and Hugh Jackman.

That means the screenplay incorporates character and world details from other films. Pearson worked on Thunderbolts and Fantastic Four: First Steps, though he said he didn't write the Thunderbolts post credits scene the Russos shot that seems to be part of Doomsday. McKenna and Sommers would be there for Spider-Man: No Way Home and Spider-Man: Brand New Day. Loveness is there for Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania, I assume probably for the Scott and Cassie material, but maybe more. Lanham and Cretton co-wrote Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings. Reynolds co-wrote Deadpool and Wolverine, and Jackman improvised many of his lines and much of his character development in that movie.

Interestingly, Ryan Coogler and Joe Robert Cole weren't listed for characters like Shuri, M'Baku, Namor and the Talokan, who return from Black Panther: Wakanda Forever. Maybe the WGA ruled that no actual written material from that film was used. Loveness's name makes me wonder if Doomsday will reference the Kang lore he wrote for Quantumania and the material he drafted with Cretton for the original fifth Avengers movie. Will we get a line about how Doom ousted a previous multiversal dynasty of some kind?

Despite the limited amount we've seen of Avengers: Doomsday in its marketing, all of this tells me it's also going to be partly a Wolverine and Deadpool movie, partly a Spider-Man movie, partly an Ant-Man movie, and somewhat a Shang-Chi movie.

What other creators are saying

More on Robert Downey Jr. →
Mr. Know-It-All · more than 80,000 subscribers
I don't think Doom wants power in Avengers: Doomsday, I think he's trying to get someone back, and I believe the movie will ultimately come down to Doom and Steve Rogers, with Doom collecting whatever it costs to rescue them.

Avengers: Doomsday theory: is Doctor Doom on a rescue mission? →

Colton Ogburn · more than 80,000 subscribers
I believe Tony Stark is a variant of Victor von Doom, not the other way around, likely created when He Who Remains manipulated events so the Starks adopted the baby who should have become Doom. I think Secret Wars will reveal Tony learning he was never supposed to be Tony Stark at all.

Avengers: Doomsday theory: is Tony Stark a Doom variant? →

The Cosmic Wonder · more than 990,000 subscribers
I agree Doom is not a Tony Stark variant, though I still suspect some connection exists, maybe tied to Downey's old Fantastic Four audition. I believe Doom has lost his wife and a son, has used the Darkhold, and this film will be darker and bigger than expected, making me very excited.

Avengers: Doomsday: is RDJ's Doom a Tony Stark variant? →

Kristian Harloff · more than 230,000 subscribers
I am on the fence about Downey playing Doom, liking how Marvel handled the reveal while worrying the sunglasses moment undercut it. I think it is probably the right business choice, though whether it works creatively depends on a movie nobody has seen yet.

Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom: can he escape Tony Stark? →

Watch the original

@newrockstars · YouTube

Adapted with AI from New Rockstars' video of 13 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Avengers: DoomsdayDoctor DoomRobert Downey Jr.Kevin FeigeRusso BrothersX-MenShang-ChiPedro Pascal

More from @newrockstars

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →