Avengers: Doomsday theory: is Doctor Doom on a rescue mission?
A mid-credits scene in the VisionQuest finale, a tapestry from the D23 special look and decades of comics may point to Doom trying to get somebody back
In the mid-credits scene of the VisionQuest finale, Doctor Doom digs the Scarlet Witch out from under a mountain, and most breakdowns will tell you he wants her power. I don't think power is what Doom wants in Avengers: Doomsday. I think he's trying to get somebody out, and I think Marvel has been showing us that since the first poster.
Spoilers follow. Wanda has been buried at Wundagore since Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. Doom lifts the rubble off her and says, "Scarlet Witch, awaken. Your power will be mine." Then her eyes open green. This is the third round of my Doomsday board. The board holds the picture I think this movie is going to be, every new piece either sharpens it or breaks it, and every card carries a date so I can be held to it. Nothing gets graded until December 18. Round one was the ending. Round two was the way in. This round is the simplest question on the board: what does the man in the metal mask want?
The Doom tapestry may show his mother and a boy, not a wife and son
My correction goes on the record first. In rounds one and two, I said the D23 special look shown in August has Doom losing a wife and a child. I said it like it was a fact. Marvel never said that. In that special look, Doom stands in his throne room looking up at a tapestry: old cloth, a woman in a veil bent over a boy, their foreheads almost touching, angels up in the corner. Over that shot, Sue Storm tells a room full of heroes that Victor used to be kind and that everything he loved was taken from him. The words wife and son are never said.
Some fans point out that everyone talking about the tapestry has called it a wife and child, but considering a potential Mephisto angle, it's Doom and his mother, and there's something on that side. In June, the Russos' own company ran a cafe pop-up in London with Robert Downey Jr.'s coffee brand, and one blend on the menu was called Cynthia's Blend. That's the name of Doom's mother. Nothing on the menu mentioned a wife. It could be a wink for comic book fans and nothing more, but it's still the filmmakers' own shop, so it's evidence, small as it is, and I think it counts.
I'm not at 100% on that. It could still be a wife and a son, with Doom absent from the picture because he's the one standing there looking at it. That's fair. But I can't prove wife and son, and neither can anybody else, me included. So that card comes down and a better one goes up. Fans have also asked the question that's been bugging me: isn't Doom from the same universe as the Fantastic Four, so how could an incursion have killed his family? Sue talks about Victor like somebody she's known half her life, so whatever happened to his family happened in her world. I don't have an answer yet. It goes on the board with a name on it.
Why the word "taken" matters for Cynthia von Doom and Mephisto
That one word, taken, matters to anybody who has read the books. Doom's mother is Cynthia von Doom. In the comics, her soul is claimed by Mephisto, Marvel's devil, and held in hell. That's the wound under the whole character. She was taken by somebody to somewhere, and if you can be taken somewhere, you can be gotten back.
The special look says everything Doom loved was taken. Marvel hasn't told us who. But that's a picture on a wall. Doom also says something out loud in that same special look.
"Hell answers to me": what Captain America's current run says about Doom
Near the end of the special look, Thor swings at Doom and tells him he'll beg for hell before Thor's done. Doom answers, "Hell answers to me, for I am Doom." Then he puts his hand on the ground and a field of dead Sentinels stands up. It plays like a flex, the biggest man in the room telling the god of thunder to sit down. Fans have asked whether I'd read what's happening with Doom in the comics now, since he just took over hell after using Steve's soul to defeat him. Another reader said that line sounds like a Doom who has already made the bargain.
So I got the books. The current Captain America run is written by Chip Zdarsky and drawn by Valerio Schiti, and the story in issues 12 through 16 is called Hell's. Issue 12 came out in June and issue 16 came out October 28. Doom is dead, Steve Rogers is in a coma, and Steve wakes up in hell because before he died, Doom tied his own soul to Steve's on purpose. In issue 12, Doom tells him he is to be Doom's protector and deliverer. Doom needs the one soul clean enough to stand beside him while he goes after Mephisto.
In issue 15, the Red Skull asks whether ruling hell means owning everything in it, and whether Victor von Doom can own people. Issue 16 answers it. Doom wins, takes the throne of hell, and one of the first things he does is say he's no jailer. He calls owning a soul a horrific practice, tears up every contract Mephisto ever held, tells every soul they're free to walk, and hell empties out. So the comics have left Doom running hell, and he took the job to let people out. Hell answers to Doom because that's where his people are.
Triumph and Torment and Unthinkable show Doom's oldest move
One comic is one comic, so it took two older books before I believed what I was seeing. In Triumph and Torment from 1989, by Roger Stern and Mike Mignola, Doom and Doctor Strange go into hell to get his mother. Mephisto offers a trade, his mother for the sorcerer, and Doom takes it. His mother watches her son sell out the man who came to help him, tells him he's no son of hers, and refuses to go. That refusal frees her, because a soul that turns down a deal like that can't be held. Then Strange finds a little device of Doom's tucked inside his own cloak and works it out: the betrayal was a sham.
Fantastic Four number 67, cover date May 2003, by Mark Waid and Mike Wieringo, is the story called Unthinkable, and this one is the debt. Doom tracks down Valeria, the girl he loved when he was young, and tells her he's done with armor and science and wants a second chance. Once she believes him, he tells her about a deal he made with demons for power and what the price was. He trades her for magic. That's Doom putting somebody he loves in hell with his own hands.
The current Captain America story pays that off. Valeria is down there, and Mephisto offers Doom his life back if he'll hand her over to be tortured forever. Doom takes that deal too, and it's a setup again. In issue 16, once he has Mephisto where he wants him, one of the first things he does is let Valeria go, tell her he's sorry, and send her on. That's 37 years and three different writers, and it's the same move every time. The moment Doom looks like he's sold everybody out, that's the play. He's getting somebody out.
My read on Doom's motive in Avengers: Doomsday
Every breakdown has Doom either conquering the multiverse or saving it, the tyrant or the guy who might be right. I don't think he's doing either. I think Marvel took the oldest story this character has and gave it to Robert Downey Jr. Somebody he loved was taken, he knows where they are, and everything he grabs in this movie, the Hulk, the Sentinels, all of it, is him paying for the trip. So when the movie shows Doom turning on every hero in the building, and Reed asks, "Victor, did you do this?", the question I'll be asking is who he's getting out.
That's my read. Marvel takes the name and goes somewhere else, and that's still the rule on this board, so the motive is all I'm claiming. When Doom looks like he's selling everyone out, that's the rescue. And in the VisionQuest finale, Marvel showed us the first person he went and got.
Why Doom chose the Scarlet Witch
Elizabeth Olsen has played Wanda Maximoff for over a decade, and what the character is known for is what she does when she loses somebody. In WandaVision, she lost Vision and rewrote an entire town so she could have him back, with two little boys to go on that. In Multiverse of Madness, she lost those boys and tore through one universe after another trying to reach them. Nobody in the MCU has gone further to get their family back. So when Doom says "Your power will be mine," ask what that power has ever been used for. And Marvel placed that scene right after her son asks if he's ever going to see his mother again.
The books go further. In Avengers West Coast number 52, cover date December 1989, by John Byrne, Wanda learns her twins, Thomas and William, are missing pieces of Mephisto's soul, and he takes them back. Her children get taken by the devil. Doom's mother, Wanda's boys, same guy.
I'll say this before anyone else does: "Your power will be mine" is the best evidence that I'm wrong and this is a power grab and nothing else. It lines up with the card I pinned in round one, Doom collects, so it goes under that card with its date. Her green eyes go there too. Wanda's magic has been red since Age of Ultron, and green has been Doom's color since 1962. But if power was all he wanted, there's a multiverse full of it. He went to one grave, one mountain, for one woman who has already done what I think he's trying to do. Doom took the Scarlet Witch because she's done this before.
"Stolen lives" and why Avengers: Doomsday may come down to Doom and Steve Rogers
A rescue costs something, and Doom has already said who he thinks owes him. Fans have quoted the line I'd walked past for two rounds and said it explains everything. They were right. In the special look, Doom says, "All of you have lived stolen lives," and tells them they have to give them back. Look at who in this movie is living a life he wasn't supposed to get. In the first teaser, Steve Rogers is holding a child. He went back, he got the dance, and he got a woman and a child. Go look at that tapestry again.
The Writers Guild credit for the movie recently came out, and it lists two names: Stephen McFeely and Michael Waldron. McFeely co-wrote all three Captain America movies, The First Avenger, The Winter Soldier and Civil War, then Infinity War and Endgame, and he's one of the two writers behind the dance. Waldron created the Loki series and wrote Multiverse of Madness, the movie that put the word incursion on screen. Round two opened on Loki standing in Steve's house. I don't think those two ended up on the title page together by accident. The Russos told Empire that Steve is central to this one, and they've said they meant Endgame to be his ending.
Back to issue 15. Mephisto makes two offers. Doom's deal is to give up somebody else. Steve's deal is to give up himself so the whole world goes free, and Steve says yes. Doom pays with other people; Steve pays with himself. In round one, I pinned that this comes down to Doom and Reed. I'm moving that card, with both dates kept on it. This movie comes down to Doom and Steve.
Tony Stark's look in 1970 stays on the board
One card took fire and I'm leaving it up. In round two, I pointed to Tony Stark's face in 1970 when Howard tells him his wife is expecting, and said it reads to me like a man doing math. Some fans never thought that look meant anything, and others asked what happens to my read if the writers never meant it that way. They may be right. But in Age of Ultron, when Tony picks Friday for his suit, another chip on the desk is labeled Jocasta. That was a wink, and nobody meant more by it. Eleven years later, Terry Matalas built a whole series on it, and in the first mid-credits scene of the VisionQuest finale, Ultron holds a drive that says Jocasta.
What a writer intended and what a performance leaves on the table for the next writer are two different things. Downey put that look on film, and McFeely is the one who said he found a way in. I don't know what that is, or whether that look is it, but that face is clearly something. It stays, marked as my read.
What would break the Doomsday board
The new cards: everything Doom loved was taken and Marvel hasn't said who; hell answers to Doom because that's where his people are; when Doom looks like he's selling everyone out, that's the rescue; Doom took the Scarlet Witch because she's done this before; and this movie comes down to Doom and Steve. Doom collects stays, now with Wanda's name under it, and I'm adding a line: he's collecting what it costs to get them back.
I'm watching what Doom does with Wanda's power, whether her eyes stay green, whether he offers anybody terms or spares somebody he could have killed, and whether that woman and boy appear somewhere he can reach. What breaks it: Doom kills somebody with no offer on the table, never tries to get anyone back, uses her power only to rule what's left, or Marvel says flat out that it's his wife and son, they're dead, and that's all. From what I hear, the final trailer is supposed to break the internet.
At the end of Triumph and Torment, Doom's mother is free, and it costs him her love; she leaves believing her son was a traitor. Strange, who figured out the betrayal was never real, asks Doom's old servant Boris, "Could he have planned all this?" Boris says, "Perhaps." I think Marvel's about to ask that same question again.
What other creators are saying
More on Robert Downey Jr. →I think Iron Man 2 is an A minus to Iron Man's A, a chaotic but miraculous launchpad for the MCU, and its line "It's me. I'm here. Deal with it" might hint at how Avengers: Doomsday handles Robert Downey Jr. playing Victor von Doom.
Iron Man 2 revisited: could it hint at Doctor Doom's origin? →
I believe Tony Stark is a variant of Victor von Doom, not the other way around, likely created when He Who Remains manipulated events so the Starks adopted the baby who should have become Doom. I think Secret Wars will reveal Tony learning he was never supposed to be Tony Stark at all.
I agree Doom is not a Tony Stark variant, though I still suspect some connection exists, maybe tied to Downey's old Fantastic Four audition. I believe Doom has lost his wife and a son, has used the Darkhold, and this film will be darker and bigger than expected, making me very excited.
I am on the fence about Downey playing Doom, liking how Marvel handled the reveal while worrying the sunglasses moment undercut it. I think it is probably the right business choice, though whether it works creatively depends on a movie nobody has seen yet.
Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom: can he escape Tony Stark? →
Watch the original
@arealknowitall · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Mr. Know-It-All's video of 15 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @arealknowitall
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

