The Penguin premiere review: is episode 1 worth watching?
The first episode picks up right after The Batman, keeps its grim tone and sets up Oz's climb through Gotham's underworld
The first episode of The Penguin doesn't disappoint. I'm extraordinarily impressed by it, and I gave the premiere a solid 8.5 out of 10. Is it the greatest thing ever? Probably not. But it's good, and I'm down.
The Penguin (2024) stars Colin Farrell, Cristin Milioti and Rhenzy Feliz, and it follows Oswald Cobb, the Penguin, in the aftermath of The Batman. I went back to The Batman to get in the mood before diving in. You don't need to, but it definitely helps. Spoilers follow, because I'm going to get into all of it.
Why I'm curious about the fascination with the Penguin
I'm curious about the fascination everyone seems to have with the Penguin. The new animated Batman: Caped Crusader series has the Penguin as the first villain Batman faces. It's a genderbent Penguin, but the Penguin nonetheless. My big complaint isn't the genderbent part. It's that there didn't seem to be any Penguin affectations. No webbed feet, nothing, just a person in an outfit with an umbrella.
If you remember back in the day, the Gotham series also had the Penguin as a benchmark character, a big character. Don't get me wrong, the Penguin has always been something special. This show does a good job with him.
Colin Farrell's Oz Cobb has range and star power
Colin Farrell is next level. His version of Oswald Cobblepot is Oz, the Penguin. The show doesn't go with Cobblepot here. They call him Oswald Cobb. Whatever the name, Farrell is doing amazing work.
This comes right on the heels of another series he starred in, which is an amazing series if you haven't seen it. For him to go from that to this, the man's got range. Undeniable range, and star power.
The Penguin picks up right after The Batman, in the same tone
The episode picks up on the heels of the events of The Batman, almost the next day or so. There's no sign of Batman, other than a brief montage at the very beginning showing a bit of what happened, with it playing on TV screens.
The entire show is filmed in the exact same tone as The Batman, which helped a lot. I can see The Batman in this. I don't know if they used the exact same city or shot in some of the same areas, but it feels very much like the same place. The Iceberg Lounge looks exactly the same.
A Falcone insult sets Oz's night in motion
Oz gets a visit from a member of the Falcone family. If you remember The Batman, the Falcones were the ones in charge, and Oz works for them. He runs the drug trade and has the Iceberg Lounge. The visit is about the drug business Oz runs.
During the conversation, Oz shares a history of the organized crime figures in his area. If you know anything about organized crime, it's a familiar story: a made man everybody knows takes care of the little people, and when he dies the town throws him a parade. In the show, Oz recalls that the man had a heart attack and died "still holding a cigar," and "in my neighborhood they throw a parade in his honor." It's not a new story, but I don't mind. It worked for what they wanted to do. I think it's wonderful when a show takes an established mythology and passes it into the storytelling as a shorthand.
Then the Falcone insults Oz, saying something along the lines of "what a guy, what a little" before trailing off. What Oz does next is immediate. At first I thought that moment was happening in Oz's head, because we've seen that kind of thing before. I thought he was going to be smarter than that, but he turned out to be smarter than you'd even think. From there it becomes a whirlwind of events, with Oz trying to keep everything under wraps.
Victor's stutter and Oz's shoe hit home for me
When Oz goes outside, some kids are trying to boost his car. He catches one of them, a kid who stutters, and threatens him. That kid is Victor, played by Rhenzy Feliz, and he's a very interesting character. At first Oz insults him and drags him along to help through the night. When the moment comes that Oz is clearly going to have to do away with him, Victor tells him he's got ambition. Oz sees potential in him, and Victor ends up becoming his partner in crime.
The stutter really hit home for me. I grew up that way. When I was younger, I stuttered just like Victor. When something was difficult or emotions were high, it was very hard to get my words out, and it took me a long time and hard work to get past it.
When I was a kid, I also wore a correcting shoe, though that has long since been corrected. Oz wears a shoe too, and it gives him that gait he walks with. That's the Penguin affectation I'm talking about, put together very realistically here. Both characters are sympathetic to me because of their affectations. They both have things that make me go, I feel you guys.
Sofia Falcone and Oz's mother push him toward a plan
We meet Oz's mother, played by Deirdre O'Connell. She's an interesting character. Oz also has the misfortune of dealing with Sofia Falcone, played by Cristin Milioti, and Sofia is off her rocker. She tells Oz that people underestimate him, "but not me." Apparently she was in Arkham. The show hasn't fully revealed why, but at the end of the day she was.
Oz believes Sofia is on to him. He goes to his mom's place, finds a stash of money and plans to run away with her. She stops him. She tells him this isn't the kind of man he is, that he's a brave man, "my big strong boy." In her telling, what he did wasn't impulsive. It happened because this is his moment. That conversation gets serious, and Oz hatches a plan.
Salvatore Maroni, Sofia and the payback ending
The dead Falcone had a ring, and Oz takes it to Salvatore Maroni. Maroni is played by Batman alum Clancy Brown, who is an amazing actor, and I thought having him in the role was cool. Oz gives Maroni back his ring, and when Maroni asks how Oz came to have it, Oz suggests he might be more than Maroni thinks.
Sofia catches up with Oz, and things turn violent at a house. She's out of her mind in this scene, telling Oz to say she's too emotional and that she shouldn't take things so personally. It's insane, and she's doing amazing work.
Then a car runs into the building. They rush outside, find a brick and open the trunk. Inside is the dead Falcone's body, missing a pinky. It's framed as payback. Oz has put the Maronis against the Falcones again.
It ends great, with Victor and Oz enjoying slushies. They both mix a suicide, which is when you mix all the flavors together, and in a slushie it's better. Then the episode closes with the song 9 to 5.
A classic singer scene hints at Oz's future club
There are things throughout the episode I enjoyed. In one moment, Victor and Oz are sitting at Oz's mom's house, and Oz puts on an old movie. It features a classic singer of the kind you might see in the 40s or 50s: the single microphone, the dress, the long gloves. It's very Oswald Cobblepot, very Penguin.
From where we are, I can see him eventually getting a place like he has in the comic books and other media. A bigger, fancier place, a nightclub, not the club where he sells drugs. I believe firmly we're going to eventually get Oz in the top hat and suit, the whole nine yards. They're going to have to give us an umbrella and the trappings eventually, because he has to have something to aspire to. From what it looks like, this series is setting up Oz's rise to becoming the Penguin we know from Batman's rogues gallery.
My predictions: a turf war and a new drug
Oz has an I come from the streets, very grounded mentality and personality that I like. He's looking for whatever he can get, loyalty, whatever. I'm interested in seeing where it goes.
I firmly believe that before it's all said and done, he's going to get the club, a real fancy one. I believe we're watching a turf war, and he's going to play both sides as much as he can. There's a special new kind of drug that allegedly is coming out, and apparently he's going to try to take control of it and maybe take over. He's a firm believer that if he takes over the drug trade in Gotham, he's going to become a big player. Maybe. We'll see how it goes.
My verdict on The Penguin episode 1: 8.5 out of 10
The show wants to be Goodfellas meets The Sopranos, meets any other mob story you want, but it's got personality. At the time of the premiere, it was set to move to Sunday nights at 9 Eastern after its debut slot.
I'm impressed. I really am. They do some very interesting things, and I'm thrilled about the entire thing and where it's going. I'm giving this episode a solid 8.5 out of 10.
What other creators are saying
More on The Penguin →I think The Penguin is one of the best shows of 2024, building the most well-realized live-action Gotham by exploring inequality through Oz, Victor and Sofia. Oz has no redemptive arc and is revealed as a true monster, a victim turned perpetuator of the system, making him one of the best comic book villains ever put to screen.
Actor discusses whether Matt Reeves' Batman universe could coexist with James Gunn's new Superman film
The Penguin's Rhenzy Feliz on Robert Pattinson's Batman in the DCU: 'I Don't Think So' →
Watch the original
@arealknowitall · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Mr. Know-It-All's video of 20 September 2024 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @arealknowitall
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

