SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
NewsMarvel

Avengers: Doomsday Opening Scene Reportedly Pits Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man Against the X-Men

Several insiders claimed the film opens with the X-Men wiping out the Spider-Man universe, and I think a comics-style incursion explains why

The Cosmic Wonder (AI-assisted)15 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2018 · more than 990,000 subscribers 1,390 words · 6 min read
Avengers: Doomsday Opening Scene Reportedly Pits Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man Against the X-Men

Reports about the opening scene of Avengers: Doomsday described it as possibly the greatest superhero opening scene of all time, if Marvel could pull it off. Reportedly, the film opens with Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man against the X-Men, and apparently the X-Men destroy his universe. I thought I knew how that was going to happen, and my theory comes straight from the comics.

The reports came from several insiders at once, and many of them backed each other up. Some people didn't even know how the Russo brothers would pull the sequence off because it sounded so epic. With that many sources lining up, it looked like this could be true.

John Campea says the Avengers: Doomsday action eclipses everything Marvel has done

The first report came from John Campea. He said the Russo brothers were able to eclipse everything else Marvel has ever done in terms of action, so the movie was shaping up to be nonstop and action packed, which I was all for. He described an opening scene that shoots you like a cannon out of the gate, with action that doesn't let up.

Campea framed it as something he hadn't shared before: "What this person indicated to me was the sheer volume of action is going to eclipse everything else Marvel's ever done. People are going to lose their minds." He added: "The movie starts with its foot through the door and shoots you like a cannon out of the gate. There's no slow start."

When you think about all the teams, stories and variants in Avengers: Doomsday, it makes sense that the action wouldn't stop. I also believed we would see a Doom who is more than pure physical, magical and technological force, even though he is all of those things. I expected a cunning, manipulative and persuasive Doom, which I think is something we do need to see.

Insiders report the X-Men destroy Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man universe

Other insiders backed the report up. Murphy's Multiverse and MyTimeToShineHello were among those reporting on it, and the scene was described this way: "Avengers Doomsday opening scene is being described as one of, if not the best opening scenes in a superhero movie ever."

Nerdrotic reported that the X-Men will reportedly destroy Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man universe in the film, and this is said to be the scene Campea was talking about. Another insider said Nerdrotic was saying this too, and a third said it lined up with everything he had heard. Everything seemed to point to this being the opening scene.

We had already heard that Maguire's Spider-Man would be in the opening scene. Previous reports said it showed him watching his universe be destroyed before the TVA picks him up. I fully expected the TVA to collect him, and I expected his universe to die, but I did not expect the X-Men to be the ones destroying it. Reportedly, it is Maguire's Spider-Man and Doc Ock fighting the X-Men, and the TVA shows up and saves him.

My theory: a comics-style incursion forces the X-Men's hand

I don't think the X-Men are out to destroy Maguire's Spider-Man, and I don't think they're going around the multiverse trying to destroy universes. What I think is most likely happening, in a page taken directly from the comics, which I love, is an incursion between their universes. In the comics, the only way to survive an incursion is to destroy the other universe.

I think the X-Men have figured that out. Whoever is in charge or whoever realizes what is happening, whether it's Beast, Professor X or Magneto, I think they realize the only way to survive is to destroy the other universe. That alone could be great to see, because people are going to struggle with it. I can picture Professor X saying they can't destroy an entire other universe to save their own, and someone like Magneto insisting they can and doing what it takes to survive.

That's what I believe goes down, though it was not confirmed at the time. I don't see a scenario where the X-Men are conquering the multiverse and destroying other worlds. But when universes get close, they have to fight, and it makes sense that almost everybody on one world would come together to fight the other. At the time, my guess was that universe was Spider-Man and Doc Ock.

Why Doom could paint the X-Men as the villains

We had heard something like this before. An early report said the X-Men universe destroys another universe and is on a path with our universe as well as the 828 universe. Those are said to be the big three of the incursions, with our universe in jeopardy because both the X-Men universe and the 828 universe are going to have an incursion with us.

This also makes sense of why Doom would take the Avengers to the X-Men universe and tell them the X-Men are the bad guys who have to be stopped. Based on reports, that is what happens: Doom goes to the X-Men universe and we get an Avengers versus X-Men scene. Reportedly, that clash happens because the X-Men are going to be viewed as villains over what happened to Maguire's universe.

If Maguire's Spider-Man is there, he might not be with a group. If he is, he's going to tell everybody the X-Men destroyed his universe, because from his perspective, that's what happened. He might also be with the multiversal Avengers team, with Deadpool, Wolverine and X-23. They might not meet up with everybody else and might be protecting Loki, but by then I think everybody knows Doom is the main villain.

Doom will pretend to be a hero, and I think Loki and Wakanda's vibranium are in his sights

This fits what we know of the plot: Doom is going to pretend to be a hero at first and act like he's trying to save the multiverse. I don't doubt that Doom, at least in the beginning, has tried to save it, but I think he ultimately realizes he can't. He realizes he needs certain things, and he needs certain people out of the way.

I think Loki is one of those people. Doom could get everybody to see Loki as the bad guy, sitting on a throne ruling the multiverse, who has to be taken out. Loki was the villain in the Avengers' past encounters, so I don't think that's a hard sell. And if the X-Men have destroyed another universe, it's not a hard sell for Doom to say they need to be killed, and that they've been able to destroy other universes because they're so powerful.

I also believe Doom is in the Wakanda trailer. He isn't shown, but I think he was either edited out or is on the ship, and I think he's the one Shuri is doing the Wakanda Forever salute to in that scene. I think Doom wants the vibranium as well, which lines up with events that have happened in the comics before.

How Doom could assemble an Avengers versus X-Men war

After that opening scene, I expected to see Doom go to the Fantastic Four first. We had also heard that Steve Rogers and Thor are with him on that ship. That makes more sense if Doom is going around asking for help against a world inhabited by massively powerful individuals, the X-Men, who he says everybody needs to help take down.

So he gets Steve Rogers, Thor, the new Avengers, the Thunderbolts and the Wakandans, and they go to war with the X-Men universe. I think that's how we get Avengers versus X-Men, and it sounds like a big scene. It could be the scene from the X-Men teaser trailer where Doom controls the Sentinels.

Ultimately, I think Doom is using all of this to get rid of everybody. I think everyone realizes that and comes together to stop him, though I think Doom is already gone by that point. I do think there will be some deaths, and the survivors realize they have to stop Doom from getting to Loki. I think Loki and the multiversal Avengers show up and help explain what's going on, because if they fight in a universe, Loki should be able to see them.

Why I think this opening could be the best superhero opening scene

As an opening scene, this has the potential to be the best. Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man against the original X-Men would be absolutely insane. If that is the beginning and the action does not let up, we're in for a real treat. It sounded like the Russo brothers had cooked, since most of the film was already shot at the time.

According to multiple insiders, it seemed this was going to happen. I was stoked for it, and I think it's a great way to start the movie.

What other creators are saying

More on Tobey Maguire →
DanCo · more than 590,000 subscribers
I ranked all 14 Spider-Men by power, putting Spider-Noir at the bottom as the weakest version of the abilities and Tom Holland's MCU Peter Parker at number one thanks to his spider sense, tech, villain experience, and Brand New Day upgrades, with Tobey Maguire a close second.

Strongest Spider-Man ranked: is Tom Holland's MCU Peter No. 1? →

New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
My theory was that Sadie Sink's secret Brand New Day role was Mayday Parker, daughter of Tobey Maguire's Peter Parker, and that this connected Brand New Day to Doomsday, where Maguire's Peter would die, and then to Secret Wars, where Mayday would appear to redeem him.

Mayday Parker theory: Sadie Sink and Tobey Maguire's link →

Colton Ogburn · more than 80,000 subscribers
I'm unsure if this rumored opening (Tobey's Spider-Man and Doc Ock battling the Fox X-Men, ending in Tobey's universe being destroyed) is real, but if true I think it would be brilliant, and I believe Tobey is confirmed to return, though I doubt he dies in the very opening.

Avengers: Doomsday rumor: Tobey's Spider-Man vs. the X-Men? →

The Deep Dive · more than 410,000 subscribers
A crisp, unwatermarked 8K clip, a slow takedown and a sanctioned talk show denial raise the question of whether the studio fed the hype on purpose

Did Sony leak the Andrew Garfield No Way Home shot itself? →

Watch the original

@thecosmicwonder · YouTube

Adapted with AI from The Cosmic Wonder's video of 20 January 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Avengers: DoomsdayTobey MaguireSpider-ManX-MenDoctor DoomMarvelRusso brothersLoki

More from @thecosmicwonder

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →