X-Men '97 episode 2: who is the second Jean Grey?
Rogue's past with Magneto runs from the Savage Land to a marriage in the Age of Apocalypse, and Cable's comic origins point to who the second Jean may be.
Episode 2 of X-Men '97, the 2024 animated series, revealed that Magneto and Rogue share a past, and it ended with a second Jean Grey walking through the door. The romance between Magneto and Rogue has a long history in Marvel Comics. The comics also suggest that the baby born to Scott Summers, also known as Cyclops, and Jean may not be what it seems.
Many people said they were confused by the Magneto and Rogue relationship, and many said they found it weird. But this is not new. When most people think of X-Men couples, they go straight to Jean Grey and Cyclops, and of course Gambit and Rogue. It looks like the show set up a love triangle in each of those relationships.
X-Men '97 set up love triangles for Rogue and Cyclops
Rogue is supposed to be with Gambit, but now Magneto is in the equation. Scott was supposed to be with Jean, but another Jean arrived right after the couple had their child, Nathan Summers.
Many of you have probably caught on by now: Nathan Summers is the mutant Cable, the telepathic and telekinetic soldier who time travels. If you know Cable, you know his father is Cyclops. His mother, however, is not Jean Grey. That detail matters for the episode's final scene, and I'll come back to it.
Episode 2 revealed Magneto and Rogue's secret past
In episode 2, it was revealed that Magneto and Rogue have a past with each other, and it's heavily implied that this was a romantic relationship. Rogue seemed resistant toward Magneto, and she told him that no one can know about their past.
If you're wondering whether any of this history appeared in the original X-Men animated series, it didn't. Luckily, we know a lot about Magneto and Rogue through Marvel Comics history. Keep in mind that Marvel has many alternate timelines, alternate realities and alternate versions of characters. It's cool that the MCU is jumping into that now in live action with the Multiverse Saga.
How Rogue got Carol Danvers' powers
If you've only seen Rogue in the original X-Men movies, you're probably wondering how she can fly and how she has all of her powers in X-Men '97. That's because in 1991's Uncanny X-Men #274, she permanently absorbs the powers of an incredibly powerful superhero.
Rogue's mutant powers are energy and life force absorption. When she touches a mutant with her bare skin, she can absorb their powers. When she was very young, she touched Carol Danvers, Captain Marvel, for too long. That put Carol into a coma, and Rogue permanently absorbed her superhuman strength, her powers of flight and her memories.
Later, Rogue went through a mystical portal called the Siege Perilous, which split her into two people. One was the original Rogue. The other was a version of Carol, who realized she could not survive if Rogue was alive. Rogue went to the Savage Land and Carol followed her, but there Magneto killed Carol.
Rogue and Magneto found out she could touch him
This was not the real Carol Danvers. It was the split version of Rogue that carried the Carol personality, so Carol Danvers did not die. Rogue was left with all of Carol's powers.
This is where the relationship between Magneto and Rogue comes into play, because they both found out that Rogue could touch Magneto. That's the story X-Men '97 drew on when Magneto tried to take Rogue's glove off so he could touch her and she pulled away.
The story doesn't end there. In the main universe, after they realize she can touch him, Magneto kills the enemy Zaladane in cold blood. Rogue is horrified and terrified of Magneto, so she leaves him before anything official can start.
In the Age of Apocalypse, Magneto and Rogue married and had a son
Here's the cool part. In the Age of Apocalypse reality, Rogue and Magneto get married and have a kid. In that reality, a young Charles Xavier dies, leaving Magneto to form the X-Men himself. That's close to what we're dealing with in X-Men '97. A young Charles didn't die, but Charles is gone and he leaves the X-Men to Magneto.
It gets even closer. In the Age of Apocalypse, Magneto forms the X-Men and Rogue is one of his top members, but she's in a relationship with Gambit at the time, which is what we see in X-Men '97. Then Wolverine, an enemy of the X-Men in that reality, attacks Magneto, Rogue and Gambit. Rogue can only save one teammate, and she chooses Magneto.
Gambit doesn't die, but Rogue's choice makes clear where her heart is. A heartbroken Gambit leaves the X-Men, and Magneto and Rogue become a couple. Since Rogue's powers contain a form of magnetism, the two magnets cancel each other out, and that's what allows them to touch. They marry and have a son named Charles, who has psychic abilities.
Unfortunately for Magneto, the Age of Apocalypse timeline is eventually wiped out of existence and the true X-Men reality is restored. It's as if their romance and marriage never happened.
Joseph, Magneto's clone, and why touch matters to Rogue
Something interesting happens afterward. Joseph, a clone of Magneto, enters the main 616 timeline. Rogue and Gambit had broken up at the time, and Rogue and Joseph ended up dating. Eventually Joseph dies and Magneto returns, and that's essentially the end of it. There's no more relationship between Rogue and Magneto, or Rogue and Joseph.
So there's a big history here. Magneto and Rogue were at some point both essentially villains, but now Rogue is good, and that's what she's telling Magneto she wants to keep in the past. She has a great family with the X-Men and she doesn't want anyone to know about her past with Magneto.
The connection to Magneto stems from the fact that their powers essentially cancel each other out, so Rogue can touch him, something she can't do with anyone else. I'll try to keep this PG, but you need to touch your partner when you're in a relationship. Being able to physically touch somebody without essentially killing them is extremely important to Rogue, and the original live action X-Men movies explored that too.
Why I think the Jean at the end of episode 2 is probably the real Jean Grey
The person who appeared at the end of episode 2 claiming to be Jean may confuse many people, but the comics have this story. As I mentioned, Cable isn't the son of Cyclops and Jean Grey. He's the son of Cyclops and Madelyne Pryor, a clone of Jean Grey.
Since the woman we think is Jean and Cyclops named their son Nathan Summers, who is Cable, we can assume the person who had the baby with Cyclops is Madelyne Pryor. The Jean who came in at the very end of episode 2 is probably the real Jean.
It makes even more sense when you remember that in the comics, Madelyne is a clone of Jean created by Mister Sinister. Marvel Studios had already told us that Mister Sinister would be the main villain of X-Men '97, and he popped up several times in the original animated series. In season two of that series, Mister Sinister kidnaps Jean.
That's probably where he clones her. He most likely created Madelyne Pryor, let her go and kept Jean. Jean most likely broke out of Mister Sinister's clutches and fled back to the X-Men.
Madelyne Pryor, the Goblin Queen, could go either way
Madelyne is the Goblin Queen, so she's not exactly a hero. In fact, she's a villain a lot of the time. Her story is very complicated, and it could go either way in the animated series. She could end up working for Mister Sinister, or she could stick around with the X-Men.
It was unclear at that point whether she knows she is a clone of Jean Grey and is pretending, or whether she believes she is Jean Grey, which is something that happens in the comics. Either way, episode 2 ended with the relationship between Magneto and Rogue being teased, Gambit seeing what happened between them, and Madelyne Pryor coming into the equation.
What other creators are saying
More on Rogue →A return to New Orleans, an unexpected survivor and a secret Rogue absorbed through her powers pushed the couple to a breakup
How Gambit's Past Strained His Relationship With Rogue in the Comics →
Apocalypse's endgame for the X-Men, Gambit's return to New Orleans, and the poker legend behind the episode's title
The voice of Rogue on returning after 25 years, the grief and survivor's guilt driving her in season 2, how she found the voice, and the setback that taught her to let go of the outcome
From Rogue's foreshadowing postcards to Magneto's stringless Newton's cradle, here is what the first X-Men film hides in plain sight, and how it was made
Watch the original
@thecosmicwonder · YouTube
Adapted with AI from The Cosmic Wonder's video of 21 March 2024 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @thecosmicwonder
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

