SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
ReviewGaming

Halo TV series: why did Paramount+'s adaptation fail?

From a collapsed movie deal to a showrunner who never looked at the games, the Paramount+ adaptation was built on choices that worked against Halo itself.

The Gold Man (AI-assisted)15 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2014 · more than 170,000 subscribers 1,985 words · 9 min read
Halo TV series: why did Paramount+'s adaptation fail?

Paramount's Halo series ended after its second season, and many consider it one of the worst video game adaptations of all time. That's strange, because the Halo games are some of the most beloved ever made. In the 2000s they were so popular that other studios tried to make what they called Halo Killers. Fans spent decades asking for a live action adaptation, and when they finally got one, they were furious.

The show, Halo (2022) on Paramount+, starred Pablo Schreiber as Master Chief. Many factors fed into the disaster of its first season, and you can't point to one thing and call it the reason. But if I had to pick the biggest one, it's that Halo was made as a big budget TV series at all.

The Halo movie that collapsed and the Spielberg series that stalled

The series premiered in 2022, but its origins go back to 2005, just after Halo 2 smashed sales records and became the best selling game on Xbox at the time. Microsoft wanted to take Halo into another medium. Alex Garland, who wrote 28 Days Later, was brought on to write the script. Peter Jackson, director of The Lord of the Rings films, came on as executive producer, and after initial attempts to get Guillermo del Toro to direct, Jackson settled on Neill Blomkamp.

Then Jackson and the studios butted heads. Universal and Fox were unhappy with how much profit Microsoft and Jackson would take, so the studios backed out. The movie was never made, and Blomkamp declared the project dead in 2007.

In 2013, at an Xbox showcase, a Halo series was announced with Steven Spielberg as executive producer. To me, the best director of all time was going to be involved with Halo, and the excitement was through the roof. Then years passed with no update. Why it took five years to hear anything, in 2018, we'll never know, but all signals pointed to the realization that adapting Halo wouldn't be easy.

Showrunner Steven Kane said he didn't look at the Halo games

In 2018 Showtime gave Halo a 10 episode season. Master Chief would be the main character, and the story would take place in a different timeline from the games. Production got underway in 2020. In 2021 it was announced that the season would shrink from 10 episodes to nine and move from Showtime to Paramount Plus.

Steven Kane came on as showrunner and lead writer. He wasn't a well established writer and had limited credits. What really "excited" fans, though, was his admission that he didn't look at the games when writing. In his words: "we didn't look at the game, we didn't talk about the game, we talked about the characters and the world, so I never felt limited by it being a game." Yeah, that's a "great" way to stay faithful to the source material. When season 1 premiered in March 2022, it became very obvious, because the story was nothing like the games.

Halo's budget problem: the games are too big for a TV show

Halo is a military shooter about humanity's survival in a futuristic galaxy. An alien alliance called the Covenant vows to destroy humanity, and after a losing war and billions of casualties, humanity is on its last legs when it discovers a Halo ring. The game makes you feel proud to fight for humanity. It glorifies war in a way that makes sense, because unlike wars on Earth, Halo is black and white: the Covenant's openly stated goal is to kill every single human in existence.

The games also have wide, epic battles that capture the scale of the conflict, plus spaceships, different aliens, weapons and locations. Halo 2 and 3 in particular are massive in scale. That's why I think it's impossible to capture the Halo story properly in a live action TV show. Streaming shows get blockbuster budgets, and Star Wars shows were given 200 million dollars like the movies. But 200 million dollars on a two hour movie is different from 200 million on an eight hour show. The money is spread thin, and with no box office, streamers rely on subscriptions.

CGI aliens, big battles, spaceships and futuristic sets and outfits are all expensive. So Paramount had no choice but to limit aliens, battles and spaceships, because it can't afford a battle every episode. What you get from a show with three battles in nine episodes is a story where the central conflict is a personal drama between humans. Season 1 is about infighting in the UNSC more than the fight against the Covenant, and that's fundamentally not what Halo is about. People asked why season 1 didn't adapt Halo: Combat Evolved. Adapting all those missions and fights would be way too expensive. When there are battles, they're quite good; the effects are shoddy at times but mostly look good. They just can't happen every episode, or even every other one.

A Halo movie could work, but not a Master Chief character drama

I have serious moral qualms about this. You adapt Halo because you know a huge number of people will show up on day one for the title. You're preying on people's love of a game you didn't create, and if you do that, you owe those fans as faithful an adaptation as possible. A Halo show can't do that. A Halo movie could. You'd probably have to trim the story a bit, but you could adapt each game into two or three hours.

You could counter that Halo can tell smaller stories. There are dozens of Halo books with intimate character stories, and that's absolutely correct; a Halo show could do that. But Paramount wasn't telling a smaller side story to complement the human and Covenant war. It wanted its cake and to eat it too: a character driven story, plus a rebooted timeline with Master Chief as lead, Cortana, other Spartans and other familiar characters. You can't make an interpersonal drama about Master Chief and do the games justice.

Master Chief's helmet and the missing character arcs

The other dilemma is that the original trilogy has close to no character development. One character has an arc, the Arbiter, and 95 percent of it happens in the second game. The games worked because of gameplay and world building. Master Chief barely says anything and is meant as a proxy for the player, so it's easier to feel like you are him. How do you give him nine episodes of development? You fundamentally change the character, which I don't necessarily mind, but some fans won't be happy.

That's the helmet debate. Fans called it an insult to Master Chief, and Pablo Schreiber and the writers defended the decision. I agree with both sides. Having Chief take off his helmet in the first episode, his armor in the second and be naked in the third is a little offensive. But in a character drama where people walk through hallways and talk for four episodes at a time, your lead should probably take his helmet off.

Kiki Wolfkill said staying true to the games wasn't serving the creative team, which needed a creative outlet. She isn't wrong per se, but she shouldn't be making an adaptation if she's going to go against the games. If the answer is to pretend it's a sci fi show unrelated to anything else, then don't title it Halo. And even as a standalone show, I think the story would fail in pretty much every way.

Halo season 1's strong opening and the stalled Spartan backstory

The season opened relatively effectively. Colonists talk about the UNSC and the Spartans as fierce super soldiers, the Covenant attacks and beats them badly, then the Spartans kill all the Elites without a single one getting hurt. It shows how superior and emotionless the Spartans are. Everything after that is a disaster. They find a Forerunner artifact that gives Master Chief visions of his childhood, and he rebels once the UNSC orders him to kill Kwan Ha.

For at least the first five episodes there's no effort to portray humanity's last stand, no camaraderie between soldiers and no existential dread. The Covenant is a minor inconvenience while Halsey tries to advance humanity. The Spartan backstory, kids abducted to become super soldiers, is without question interesting and raises the question of whether the ends justify the means. But we don't care enough about John yet, so five episodes of him uncovering his past bring the pacing to a screeching halt. In the fourth episode he digs holes to find pictures he drew as a child, and something about Master Chief digging holes for an episode is so funny to me.

Miranda Keyes, Kai and the padded runtime

Meanwhile Miranda Keyes is constantly complaining about her mother. I have never seen bigger mommy issues. This is the woman who, in the games, recklessly flew a Pelican through a window to try to kill a Covenant Prophet. Halsey, I don't think, mentions her once in these early episodes, and when Miranda finally interacts with her mother, she's totally cordial. It has nothing to do with the season's theme. The writers are padding a nine episode season that can't have aliens in most episodes.

The most interesting part of the early episodes is probably Kai discovering her humanity. Instead of constant emotional breakdowns, she's exploring herself. When she dyes her hair and Miranda says it looks awful, I chuckled, and later, her lifting Warthogs for fun was awesome because it shows Spartan strength and gives her personality.

Making Master Chief a chosen one breaks the Halo lore

The writing is poor even on its own terms. The Covenant attacks the base and kills humans when excavating the artifact is clearly its mission. In the games, the Covenant is ordered to kill as many humans as possible, but the show never explains why the war exists, even in scenes with Makee and the Prophets. The conveniences pile up: the UNSC's best super soldier is sent to the one planet with an artifact, he's one of two people who can interact with it, and he grew up next to the second piece.

To make that plot work, the show makes Master Chief a chosen one. Only he and Makee can interact with the artifacts. In the games, the Prophets learned all humans are Reclaimers who can activate Forerunner technology and a Halo ring, something no one in the Covenant can do, so they ordered humanity's extermination to keep the secret. If only two humans are Reclaimers, why is the Covenant waging war? The show doesn't explain it because it can't. It's also weird that the artifacts give visions, which feels more fantasy than science fiction. In episode 5 Makee uses one to locate the other, and touching them may or may not trigger an explosion, with no explanation. The script is an unmitigated mess, and this is what happens when Halo is forced into a character drama.

The episode 5 battle shows what the Halo show could do

I'll keep defending the action. At the end of the fifth episode, when the budget goes to the Covenant, it looks good. One Jackal takes out multiple Marines, showing a power gap the games don't convey as well. Spartans in a Warthog are awesome, a Grunt hijacks the Warthog and Chief hijacks it back, and he rams a Phantom with a Banshee. I'll never forget Chief running out of ammo and throwing his pistol at a Grunt. That's the goofy stuff that's sometimes in Halo, and I love it.

Makee, the UNSC and Master Chief's sex scene

I believe the sole reason Makee exists is budget. The writers want a villain but can't afford a prominent alien one, so a human serves as the Covenant's proxy. After the battle she lands in an escape pod and is brought to Reach. The UNSC knows the Covenant wants the artifacts and that only Master Chief and Makee can use them, yet this helpless woman somehow escaped and keeps asking to see the artifact. They still trust her.

The biggest crime is John having sex with Makee. Beyond how weird it is, I'd call it borderline rape, because she's a prisoner of war. It's also funny that a lifetime of Covenant indoctrination is overcome by one sexual encounter. The final episodes then turn into conflict between John, Halsey and the UNSC. Halsey wants the artifact for the next step in human evolution, which makes no sense to me for objects leading to a weapon. I don't want to see Spartans fight each other; I want them fighting aliens.

Halsey's assistant and the themes of Halo season 1

Halsey's assistant drives me insane. He has an obsession with her that's borderline sexual and even tries to kiss her clone, which is never followed up. He's overdramatic, screaming as he's carried out during the battle on Eridanus II. His death was satisfying, and Halsey doesn't care.

Despite all this, the writers were trying to say something. I think the theme is what it means to be human and whether that's worth protecting. Halsey's inhibitor chips remove emotion so Spartans obey without question, and as John and Kai become more human, they question things. I think that was the point of the sex scene. Cortana develops emotions and helps Chief, and I kind of like the poetry of the AI being more human than her creator; it kind of mirrors the themes of Halo 4. John then gives up his humanity to save the day. I don't think it's the worst theme for Halo; the infighting and pettiness are what disappoint.

Kwan Ha is one of the worst side stories I've seen

Kwan Ha's storyline is one of the worst side stories I have ever seen in any movie or show, and I don't say that often. She's introduced as a teenager who does drugs, has no compassion, shows terrible judgment while judging others, and screams and complains throughout. Chief goes rogue to save her in the first two episodes, then never mentions her again. Neither does the UNSC, despite having hunted her. If no one else cares, why should we?

She's saving one planet, Madrigal, while everyone else is saving the human race, and audiences can tell which matters. There's no arc and no link to the themes. The world building in the Rubble is cool but irrelevant. She's also made a chosen one, from a family with a deep connection to the Flood, and her story leads to a portal that's never used once Madrigal is glassed in season 2. The only good thing was Soren, who was entertaining at times. I think this storyline probably exists to pad the runtime.

Season 1 reviews and Steven Kane's exit

Season 2 was greenlit before season 1 came out, and I'm stunned Paramount saw that first season and wanted more. It scored 70 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, with a 52 percent audience score; I think it should be lower. The IMDb episode scores average 7.26 out of 10, with episode 5, Reckoning, highest at 8.2 and episode 7, Inheritance, lowest at 4.8. Steven Kane announced he wouldn't return for season 2 over a year before season 1 released, and why isn't entirely clear. Season 1 is such a mess: the script is weak, nothing feels organic and everything feels contrived.

What other creators are saying

More on Halo →
Chaos · more than 30,000 subscribers · Snippet
After the struggles of Halo Infinite and a move to Unreal Engine 5, the next game carried the series' future

Why Halo 7 Looked Like a Make or Break Moment for the Halo Franchise →

DanCo · more than 590,000 subscribers
Doom Slayer wins. While Master Chief is a superhuman soldier who can defeat large numbers of Covenant forces, the Doom Slayer has killed universal demon lords like the Icon of Sin and Davoth, the Dark Lord, putting him on a far higher power level.

Master Chief vs Doom Slayer: who wins and why it's not close →

Chaos Gaming · more than 2.6 million subscribers
Microsoft has reportedly stripped Halo Studios of control over the next mainline Halo game after cutting 268 positions across Xbox, and word is a new Activision based team is being assembled to build it instead.

Halo's next game: is Activision taking it from Halo Studios? →

Watch the original

@thegoldman25 · YouTube

Adapted with AI from The Gold Man's video of 8 March 2025 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

HaloParamount+Halo TV seriesMaster ChiefPablo SchreiberSteven KaneVideo game adaptationsTV review

More from @thegoldman25

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →