Spider-Man: Brand New Day: did it kill superhero fatigue?
Superhero fatigue was real. The record-breaking Spider-Man sequel shows that audiences will still turn up in huge numbers for a superhero movie they actually want to see.
Spider-Man: Brand New Day did not kill superhero fatigue, and I don't think Spider-Man is immune to it either. What the film did prove is that audiences are not done with superhero movies. They are only done showing up simply because something is a superhero movie.
Apparently nobody told Spider-Man about superhero fatigue. In 2008, Iron Man helped kick off one of the biggest gold rushes Hollywood has ever seen. Over the next 15 years, superhero movies went from being just another genre to completely dominating the industry. Then the cracks started to show. Marvel's seemingly unstoppable winning streak ended with box office bombs like Eternals and The Marvels, and DC blew up its entire universe and started over from scratch. Everyone blamed the same thing: superhero fatigue. Then Spider-Man: Brand New Day didn't just succeed. It became one of the highest grossing movies of all time, as audiences who were supposedly suffering from superhero fatigue showed up in massive numbers. So what happened? Did people suddenly stop being tired of superheroes, or is Spider-Man simply immune? And did superhero fatigue ever exist in the first place?
Superhero movies went from two in 2002 to nine in 2018
In 2002, only two superhero films came out: Spider-Man and Blade II. In 2018, nine of them came out. That meant audiences were getting a new one roughly every six weeks, which is kind of insane.
Audiences clearly couldn't get enough, though. Most superhero films easily cleared $500 million at the box office, and several crossed the billion dollar mark. So, naturally, Hollywood kept making more, and the genre completely took over. With that much content, eventually something had to give.
Disney Plus made keeping up with the MCU feel like homework, while DC built a second universe
After Disney Plus launched and gave us five new superhero shows in 2021, "keeping up with the MCU started to feel like homework." You had to see WandaVision to understand what was going on with Wanda and Doctor Strange, Loki to understand the multiverse, and The Falcon and the Winter Soldier to understand the new Captain America. If you missed a show, you'd walk into the next movie with no idea what was going on.
Marvel wasn't the only one doing this. DC was trying to build its own cinematic universe at the same time, basically speed running what Marvel had spent years building in an effort to catch up. So audiences weren't following one giant interconnected superhero universe. They were following two of them at the exact same time. To make things even more confusing, not every DC movie was part of the DC universe, as Joker and The Batman existed in completely separate continuities.
Marvel and DC had similar heroes telling the same basic story
To make things more confusing, or I guess redundant, both DC and Marvel had their own versions of basically the same heroes. Marvel had Quicksilver while DC had The Flash. Marvel had Tony Stark, the billionaire playboy, while DC had Bruce Wayne. Marvel had Thor, while DC had Wonder Woman, both gods from other worlds.
So you don't only have similar heroes. How many times can you tell the same basic story before people start feeling like they've seen it before? There are only so many times you can see somebody discover their powers, learn how to use them and become a superhero before it starts feeling a little repetitive. How many times can a guy in a cave beat up criminals in an alley? How many times can the entire planet be minutes away from destruction before saving it stops feeling particularly special? Eventually it becomes harder to come up with something original that audiences haven't already seen a dozen times.
Sony, Fox and Madame Web showed studios scraping the bottom of the barrel
Besides Marvel and DC, Sony decided to build its own superhero cinematic universe using Spider-Man's leftover villains, while Fox had its own sandbox with X-Men, Fantastic Four and Deadpool. For the average moviegoer, this was all incredibly confusing. Even the actors were confused: Dakota Johnson allegedly thought her Madame Web film was part of the MCU, only to learn after the movie came out and was panned that it wasn't.
Madame Web is also what happens when you start scraping the bottom of the barrel. There are only so many Supermans, Batmans and Spidermans to go around, so studios have to dig deeper and deeper into the comic book libraries for characters to turn into movies. Marvel made its bones turning C list heroes like Iron Man and Thor into A listers, but "there's only so many times you can turn chicken into chicken salad before you get something like The Eternals."
Superhero movies no longer feel like events
With so many superhero films every year, they don't really feel like events anymore. I remember when Spider-Man came out in 2002. The movie was such a hit that I started dreaming about all the other superheroes who might finally get their own movies, like Iron Man and Thor and all these other characters we'd never seen on the big screen before. Back then, a new superhero movie was a pretty big deal because we weren't getting them every other month.
Now that they're everywhere, unless a movie looks amazing, there's really no reason to rush out and see it. You can skip it because another one is probably right around the corner. When audiences no longer feel they have to see every superhero movie, being a superhero movie isn't enough to guarantee a hit.
Superhero fatigue was real, but audiences were tired of movies with nothing to say
So are audiences actually sick of superheroes, or have we reached a point where there are so many of these movies that audiences can afford to pick and choose? I think it's probably a little bit of both, because the problem with making this many superhero movies is that they can't all be great. When you're constantly recycling the same basic formula, some of these movies are going to start to feel a little soulless.
The best superhero movies aren't just about people with superpowers fighting each other. They're actually about something. The Dark Knight explored terrorism, surveillance and how far we're willing to go in the name of security in the post 9/11 world. Black Panther explored isolationism, colonialism and whether a wealthy nation has a responsibility to help those beyond its borders.
Then you have movies that don't really have anything to say at all. They're soulless, hollow, and feature people floating around in front of a green screen shooting CGI lasers out of their hands at each other for two hours. When you're getting half a dozen of these every year, why bother going to see the one that looks exactly like that? So yes, superhero fatigue was real. But perhaps audiences weren't necessarily tired of superhero movies. They were tired of superhero movies that weren't giving them a reason to show up.
A $600 million Superman shouldn't spark talk of a dying genre
There's another problem with the superhero fatigue narrative. Expectations have gotten completely out of control. After Black Panther, Captain Marvel and even Aquaman started making billions of dollars, a superhero movie making 500 or 600 million suddenly didn't seem particularly impressive, which is kind of ridiculous. Most movies would kill to make that kind of money. For Marvel and DC, though, anything short of a billion dollars can feel like a disappointment.
There's a good reason for that: they cost a lot to make. Superman cost $225 million, but another 150 million was spent on top of that marketing it. So the movie didn't cost $225 million. It cost almost 400 million, and that's not even what it needs to break even, because theaters get a piece of the box office too. While Superman made 600 million at the box office, after expenses and the theaters' cut it probably only made Warner Brothers around 100 million.
That creates a pretty ridiculous situation. Hollywood has become so accustomed to astronomical returns that when a film makes what Superman made, we're suddenly having conversations about whether the genre is dying. Not necessarily because audiences rejected the movie, but because the studio spent so much that $600 million might not be enough to justify the investment.
Regardless, there has been a recent downturn. Five of Marvel's last seven films before Brand New Day underperformed. Basically everything DC pumped out after Aquaman as part of its cinematic universe performed dreadfully, leading it to reboot with Superman, which was followed by Supergirl, which bombed.
Marvel cut back, and audiences love Tom Holland's Spider-Man
So why did Spider-Man: Brand New Day make so much money? First, Marvel has seriously cut back its output, which has helped make its movies feel like events again. Perhaps more importantly, audiences absolutely love Tom Holland as Spider-Man. When the Avengers came back through the portals at the end of Endgame, if you were in a theater or have seen the audience reactions online, Holland got the biggest pop. He's essentially the heir to Robert Downey Jr.'s Tony Stark, who was previously Marvel's biggest star, and I guess still is.
That's a big part of what makes these movies successful. Casting matters. Finding actors audiences love matters, and when you don't, audiences won't necessarily rush out. Downey was basically a washed up actor who became a superstar overnight after Iron Man. He was electric in that role, audiences immediately fell in love with him, and it became almost impossible to imagine anybody else playing Tony Stark.
Fantastic Four, Wakanda Forever and Thunderbolts lacked that draw
Compare that to The Fantastic Four: First Steps, which saw a massive second week drop at the box office. I think a big reason is that audiences didn't connect with its actors the way they connected with Downey, Holland or the cast of Guardians. Pedro Pascal is a fine actor, but he's been in so many movies at this point that I don't really associate him with Reed Richards.
Wakanda Forever is another example. It still made $800 million, which is nothing to sneeze at, but without Chadwick Boseman, whom audiences love, it didn't come close to matching the first film, especially domestically. The same goes for Anthony Mackie as Captain America. I like Mackie, but he's not a movie star. He's a supporting actor. And then there's Thunderbolts, which stars a group of supporting players from Disney Plus shows and bombed. What exactly did Marvel think that would do at the box office? It did exactly what you would expect.
Being a superhero film is not enough anymore. These movies need draws. Spider-Man has Holland, Zendaya, Jacob Batalon as Ned and an entire cast audiences love. They love them so much that a film without even a strong villain in its marketing, often the main hook for a superhero sequel, made over $2 billion and became the highest grossing domestic film ever made. Audiences just wanted to see these characters again. They didn't even care who Spider-Man was fighting.
Audiences stopped feeling obligated, not stopped loving superheroes
So is Spider-Man immune to superhero fatigue? No. Superhero fatigue was real, and the box office reflected that. But audiences didn't stop loving superheroes. They stopped feeling obligated to see every single movie Marvel and DC pumped out.
Maybe that's the biggest lesson. In 2002, Spider-Man helped kick off the modern superhero boom by proving how enormous these movies could be. Nearly 25 years later, he's done it again, reminding Hollywood that audiences will still show up in massive numbers for a superhero movie they actually want to see. Spider-Man didn't kill superhero fatigue, but he proved audiences aren't done with superhero movies. "They're just done showing up simply because it's a superhero movie."
Do you think Brand New Day's success came down to Tom Holland and his cast, or to Marvel finally making fewer movies?
What other creators are saying
More on Spider-Man: Brand New Day →I believed Brand New Day was secretly building toward Venom, with the trailer's organic webbing, black eyes, cocoon imagery, sonic clue and Banner's DNA warning all pointing to the symbiote bonding with a broken Peter before fully emerging around Doomsday or Secret Wars.
I think the Spidey tracker scene, the Russos' chess king image, the shared writers and Feige's comments all point to Tom Holland's Spider-Man appearing in Avengers: Doomsday, likely via a cameo or post-credits scene, with Marvel getting multiple Spider-Man variants from Sony for Doomsday and Secret Wars.
Spider-Man in Avengers: Doomsday: will Tom Holland appear? →
After Brand New Day, Spider-Man is drastically stronger, tougher and faster than before, having undergone a biological mutation that gave him organic webbing and heightened abilities. He can now trade blows with Savage Hulk, shatter the Hand's specialized weapons, and easily overpower enemies who previously beat him.
The Robert Downey Jr. feud story, a reported reshoot push, Jackie Chan's stunt work on Spider-Man: Brand New Day, and why rumors may help Marvel's marketing
Watch the original
@breakdownsandblockbusters · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Breakdowns & Blockbusters' video of 30 September 2026 and reviewed by Digital Fox Talent before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @breakdownsandblockbusters
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

