SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreSci-Fi & Fantasy

Rings of Power: where did Durin's Bane the Balrog come from?

The fire demon King Durin III died fighting at the end of season 2 is older than the rings, and the show planted its origin in a legend about mithril

Film Paradise (AI-assisted)15 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2023 · more than 58,000 subscribers 1,560 words · 7 min read
Rings of Power: where did Durin's Bane the Balrog come from?

The Balrog at the end of season 2 of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, the one King Durin III gave his life to stop, has everyone talking. Almost nobody is asking the real question: where did it come from? My answer is that it didn't start in that mine at all. It's older than the rings, older than Sauron's whole war, and the show quietly handed us its origin in one scene that's easy to forget.

The series, which premiered in 2022 with Morfydd Clark and Robert Aramayo in lead roles, never stops to explain what the creature is. The answer goes back much further than Moria.

How King Durin III woke the Balrog in Khazad-dûm

Think back to how it went down. King Durin III had his dwarven ring on his finger, and the greed had completely taken him over. He kept driving his miners deeper into Khazad-dûm, tearing out more and more mithril and ignoring every warning his own son gave him.

Then the picks broke through into something that had been sleeping down there since before the dwarves ever existed. King Durin snapped out of it, pulled the ring off, grabbed an axe and threw himself straight at the creature so Prince Durin and the others could live. You felt that moment. But the show never explains what the creature is or where it came from.

The Balrog is a fallen spirit, the same kind as Gandalf

This is the part that messes with people. A Balrog isn't a big animal, and it isn't some devil that clawed its way up out of the ground. It's a spirit, one of the oldest in the entire world, from long before there were mountains or oceans or anything alive walking around. "It's the same kind of spirit as Gandalf. The same exact kind."

Tolkien built his world with powerful spirits called the Ainur. Think of them like angels. They showed up before almost anything else and sang the whole world into existence. The greatest of them are the Valar, who are more or less the gods of this place. The Maiar were one step down, and even they were strong enough to move mountains.

Gandalf is one of the Maiar. Saruman and Sauron are on that same list. And, believe it or not, so is the Balrog. Every one of them started out as the exact same kind of being.

Why the Balrog turned: a spirit of fire that loved power

The Balrog began as a spirit of fire. It was drawn to heat and flame right from the beginning, back when everything was still good and clean. The reason it turned is sad. The spirits who loved fire and power the most were the easiest ones to pull over to the dark side, and the Balrog loved both.

Even the name spells it out: Balrog means demon of might. Sit with that for a second. The thing that kills Gandalf and Gandalf himself both started life as the same type of being. One stayed good. The other was twisted into a monster, on purpose, by someone the show has already introduced in a way.

Morgoth, the dark lord who made the Balrogs

Sauron is the big villain, but people forget he was never the top of the chain. Long before him there was a far worse dark lord named Melkor, and Sauron became his servant and second in command. In season 2, Sauron himself tells us about the god who broke him. That god is Morgoth.

The elves hated Melkor so much that they refused to say his name, so they called him Morgoth, the black enemy of the world. Morgoth had one nasty move he pulled over and over. He couldn't create anything good of his own, so he grabbed things that were already powerful and twisted them until they were his.

That's exactly what he did to the fire spirits. He got hold of them, bent them and burned every good thing out of them until all that was left was hunger and fire. What crawled out the other side were the Balrogs, his own personal monsters. If that sounds familiar, it should: it's the same thing Sauron later does with Celebrimbor and the rings. Sauron learned how to ruin good things by watching Morgoth do it first. The Balrog never started as a weapon. It was turned into one, and Morgoth pointed his Balrogs straight at the elves.

Gothmog and the Balrogs of the First Age

This is where the name's terror comes from, and the movies completely skip it, which is a shame because this is the good stuff. In the First Age, a Balrog was the single scariest thing on any battlefield in the world. The worst of them was Gothmog, the top general of Morgoth's whole army.

These creatures fought wrapped in fire and shadow, swinging a whip of flame that could rip a grown warrior off his feet from across a field. Gothmog did not lose. Balrogs killed elf kings. Gothmog himself cut down the High King Fingon after a second Balrog caught him from behind with a whip of fire. A whole pack of Balrogs took down Fëanor, the most gifted elf who ever lived. When one showed up, entire armies broke and ran. In the main stories most fans know, only three warriors ever managed to kill one, and it cost every one of them their own life.

This is also where the most famous Balrog argument on the internet comes from: do they have wings? Tolkien wrote that the shadow around it reached out like two huge wings. Half the fandom swears it has real wings, while the other half says it's only shadow and smoke shaped like wings. Tolkien never settled it. Either way, the picture is the same: a giant made of living fire and shadow that almost nobody could stand in front of and live.

Why Balrogs aren't still ruling Middle-earth

If these creatures were that terrifying, why isn't the world run by them? Because they lost, and they lost hard. At the end of the First Age, the good side finally came for Morgoth in a war so massive it broke the map, known as the War of Wrath. Whole mountain ranges came down, and the sea rushed in and swallowed entire kingdoms forever.

Morgoth's monsters were hunted down one by one, the Balrogs right along with them, until almost all of them were wiped out. Almost. A few fled straight down and buried themselves deep in the roots of the mountains, far below the light and any army. They weren't dead. They were sleeping. Kingdoms rose and fell while they sat in the dark, waiting for someone foolish enough to come digging.

Here's a detail that blows my mind: Tolkien later decided there were never more than seven Balrogs in the entire world. That made every survivor of that war rarer than a dragon and far harder to kill. One of those survivors buried itself under the Misty Mountains, the exact mountains Khazad-dûm is carved into. In Tolkien's books, it slept there for over 5,000 years. The show wakes it far sooner, in the closing minutes of season 2.

The Rings of Power hid the Balrog inside the mithril legend

The clever part is that the show handed us the whole origin early on, then moved on before most people noticed. In season 1, Gil-galad, the High King of the elves, realizes his people are fading. Their light is going out, and unless they sail west to the Undying Lands, every elf in Middle-earth will fade into nothing. There's one possible cure: mithril. So Gil-galad sends Elrond to his old friend Prince Durin to get it.

To explain why, the show tells an ancient legend, the song of the roots of Hithaeglir. On a peak in the Misty Mountains, a single elf warrior fought a Balrog over one tree, and inside that tree was a lost Silmaril, one of the holiest lights left in the world. While the elf and the Balrog tore each other apart, lightning struck the tree. The show says all that power, the holy light of the Silmaril and the Balrog's hatred together, poured into the mountain and soaked into the rock. That, according to the show, is how mithril was born.

Tolkien never wrote a word of that legend. The show made it up. But look at what it pulled off: it planted a Balrog right at the birth of mithril, the one thing the entire plot is chasing. King Durin III refuses at first, telling his son that it's the elves' time and nothing should live forever, but Prince Durin and Disa push to help the elves anyway. The elves' need for mithril and the dwarves' hunger for it point at the exact same spot in the rock. That's the show pointing at something huge, and most people walked right past it.

Durin's Bane was asleep under Khazad-dûm all along

So here's where the Balrog comes from, and the real answer is better than a basic origin story. "In Rings of Power, the Balrog didn't come from anywhere. It never left." It was already asleep under Khazad-dûm before the show began. The series is set in the Second Age, but this creature, the one Tolkien calls Durin's Bane, isn't supposed to fully rise until the Third Age, thousands of years later.

The best mithril in the world sits deep in the rock of Khazad-dûm, and at the very bottom, under everything, the last survivor of Morgoth's army had been sleeping the whole time. Every time King Durin pushed his miners to dig deeper and faster, a clock was ticking down. They were racing for the one thing that could save the elves, and it sat right on top of the one thing that could wipe them all out. The grim part is that mithril is found in only one place, Khazad-dûm. There was no digging somewhere safer.

That's why King Durin's death hits so hard once you know the lore. The creature he threw himself at is Durin's Bane. The rocks came down and sealed it back in, at least for now, but it's awake and it isn't going back to sleep. Tolkien named it Durin's Bane because this same creature later kills another dwarf king, Durin VI, drives every last dwarf out of Khazad-dûm, and turns the greatest city they ever built into the dead tomb everyone calls Moria.

It's the same monster that one day corners Gandalf on a narrow bridge while the Fellowship runs for their lives. Gandalf plants his staff and faces it alone, buying the others their escape at the cost of his life. It drags him into the dark with a whip of fire, and they fight all the way back up to the peak of the mountain, where Durin's Bane finally dies, thousands of years after it should already have been gone. So when King Durin stares down the creature in the dark at the end of season 2, remember what's really there. "That isn't just a monster in a mine. That's a fallen angel from the dawn of the world waking up right on schedule."

What other creators are saying

More on The Rings of Power →
New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
I think the show nails Tolkien lore aside from one flaw: keeping the eagles silent weakens the coronation, since a talking eagle could have clearly signaled support for Míriel instead of letting Pharazôn hijack the moment. I also think the rushed, confusing Númenor subplot stems from shooting during the writers' strike without rewrites.

Rings of Power S2E3: should the Númenor eagles talk? →

GIQUE · more than 25,000 subscribers
After just two episodes, I felt The Rings of Power season 2 had moved past season 1's exposition-heavy setup into real emotion and human connection, with elves manipulated by Sauron's pride-stroking and dwarves drawn back to ring-making, making it more engaging than shows like House of the Dragon.

Rings of Power season 2 review: more emotion than season 1? →

The Gold Man · more than 170,000 subscribers
I don't think season one was a total failure, though its pacing, a Galadriel arc that never earns sympathy or shows real consequences, and a purposeless Harfoot plot badly hurt it, while Elrond and Durin's friendship, built on genuine consequence and a strong moral dilemma, is the show's emotional heart.

Rings of Power season 1 review: what failed and what worked →

Watch the original

@filmparadise · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Film Paradise's video of 12 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

The Rings of PowerBalrogDurin's BaneKhazad-dûmMorgothTolkienGandalfMithril

More from @filmparadise

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →