SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Thu, 19 November 2026 37 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
ReviewMarvel

Agatha All Along finale: was the Witches' Road a lie?

Episodes eight and nine reveal the Road began as a nursery rhyme for Nicholas Scratch, leave Agatha a ghost, and open doors for Billy, Rio and the Young Avengers

GIQUE (AI-assisted)30 September 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2020 · more than 25,000 subscribers 1,870 words · 9 min read
Agatha All Along finale: was the Witches' Road a lie?

The Agatha All Along finale is, as I like to call it, "the Epic manipulation of both Billy and Agatha." Episodes eight and nine revealed that the Witches' Road was never what the witches believed it to be. It began as a song Agatha shared with her son, and Billy's chaos magic conjured the rest.

I loved it. I was at the Arcane premiere while the finale was being released, and I tried my best to sneak a look at a few scenes, but I couldn't. This was something we had to take in and digest in one sitting, and I think that's why Marvel gave us episodes eight and nine right off the bat.

Episodes eight and nine work as one finale

When I talk about the finale here, I mean eight and nine together as one solid episode. I think both were built to be discussed as a single unit, so I am not splitting them apart. I cover Nicholas Scratch, the Road, the coven, Agatha and her powers, Wanda and the future, and the Young Avengers, bouncing between them the way the thoughts came to me.

The Witches' Road was a lie that began with Agatha and Nicholas Scratch

On a scale from 1 to 10, with 10 being that you wrote the comic, I would put my comics knowledge at maybe a six or seven. There are comics I know brilliantly and others I know little about. I came to this show with a love of and excitement for the comics, and I already knew the Witches' Road well from editing other creators' work on it. So I enjoyed all the little nods to the Road, its journey, and its ghosts.

In the comics, the fallen witches still help: you're never really gone when you're a witch, at least as the Witches' Road portrayed it, because the witches of the past can guide you. The Road was a tangible thing in the comics, an important journey where the deity of all witches resides. In the MCU, allegedly, it is a falsehood. Anything is and anything isn't in the Marvel universe because of multiple dimensions, but from what we have gathered so far, the Road is a lie that began as a nursery rhyme, a way for Agatha and Nicholas Scratch to bond and stay together.

Agatha tries to teach him magic, and he struggles to do anything. In the comics, Nicholas Scratch is a brilliant spellcaster and sorcerer in his own right, but here he clearly was not magically gifted, at least from what we saw. He also had a shelf life: some sort of illness was going to take him. So it's not that he was taken by Mephisto.

We still don't know who his father is, and it could still be Mephisto. Agatha did say she made him from scratch, which could mean she used no magic, and that would undercut the Mephisto theory since there would be some element of spellcasting. Unless it was a Zeus situation, where Zeus took someone's form and the mother never knew until Zeus came down and announced himself to Hercules. What we do know is that the song began as a nursery rhyme the two sang while traveling the road together killing witches. Nicholas sang it in a tavern and let a few witches go who should have been killed, and from that came the lore of witchdom, all starting with Agatha's lost son.

Agatha might feel the song was taken from her

Going back to the start of the show, we see all these witches singing the song, and I can't help but wonder how I would feel as a mother. Alice talks about how her mother sang it in full stadiums and made so much money from it. I don't think the witches are degrading the song, but they are definitely taking ownership of it. If I were Agatha, I would feel a little tainted by that, and it would put some resentment in me. It belongs to me and my son, and it was a way for me to trick you all and take your power, so how dare you say it's yours.

Billy, walking the Road, created a whole idea of what he believed it to be, when all it ever was was a way for Agatha to be close to her son. I think that's really beautiful. I think it's really messed up how she ended up manipulating it in her sorrow, but it is beautiful.

If I ever interviewed Agatha, these are the questions I would ask: when you hear the song your son created and see its prestige, do you find joy, or pride that he has somehow lived on? Or do you feel shame that this piece of you and your son has been taken and claimed by witches you deem unworthy and would rather kill? I don't know, but it would be interesting.

Billy conjured the Road, and I think he reached into the witches' minds

Like mother, like son. In the flashbacks to Billy's room, we saw hints of the Road, like the concert photos of the witches on the wall. I didn't think he had spellbound the entire thing, but I did suspect little pieces of it. Now we know Billy was the one who conjured all of it, because he is a chaos witch who can create things out of chaos just from his mind, the same way Agatha does.

That shows how powerful he is. We already know he can read minds. In the beach house trial, which I think was the first challenge, each witch had their own manifestation of terror. So did Billy go deeper into their psyches to find the one thing that would scare each of them, or were they already thinking about those things? It would be weird; I wouldn't think of the guy who took away my powers at a beachfront property. So I do think Billy went into their minds to pull out that negativity because he needed something to fill the space of the Road.

That's dangerous too. Imagine your power being so strong that you don't even understand you're doing it. That is chaos magic, and it is scary.

With Billy around, anyone could come back

I love that we're seeing the correlation between Wanda and Billy, but if Billy can manifest all of this, who's to say he can't just bring Wanda back? At the time, I knew Wanda was about to have her own show, though I didn't know whether it would be a prequel. Either way, "anyone with Billy in the MCU there is no death"; he can bring back anyone he wants, if the MCU can afford it.

With chaos magic, anyone he's talking to could be fabricated in his own mind, and I wonder if the MCU will play with that. It would be an easy writing trick to say that person was never really there. But it would be fun to see people who have left us come back. I would love to see Billy manipulate someone like Star-Lord by bringing back his Gamora using memories from his mind. There are so many ways Billy could turn evil quickly, and I know there are paths in the comics where he does. I'm not mad at it.

Agatha's ghost is pulled straight from the comic panels

Rest in peace to all the women who died on the Road. A fun correlation between Wanda and Billy is that both had Agatha as a guide walking the Road, which I think is the closest the show came to pulling straight from the pages. Agatha finally had her long flowing white hair, ripped straight from the comic panels, where she walks the Road and helps Wanda reach the end and save all of magic. I think that was a wonderful tribute.

It's also a brilliant way to stay in the MCU. As a ghost, she can be anywhere, fade into the distance, or do voiceover work; she is there forever. I'm hoping that, just like in the Witches' Road comic, Agatha will have a moment where she comes back to life. She said she took a calculated risk, and since we see her picking things up, her powers are still there on some level. So there is a possibility, just a possibility, of a second life for her, and I wonder how Rio will feel when that happens.

Rio could take the MCU galactic while the Young Avengers gather

Having Rio in this, I'm excited to see her with Thanos and in the galactic realm. As she said, she is a primordial being, like Eternity; death is a concept bigger than we think. I'm excited for the MCU to travel beyond street level, because that's where my hope is, though I know the Young Avengers are very street level and that's where we're heading.

Now we've got Billy and Agatha off to find Tommy. We have a plan and a path, and we're bringing the Young Avengers together. We still need Hulkling and a few other big characters, but the Avengers are almost here.

Jennifer Kale and the missing Serpent Crown

I appreciate the tributes to the other witches, and I love that Jennifer Kale is still alive with her powers back. I'm wondering how that plays into the larger story. We never saw the Serpent Crown come into play. I think there were hints of it in the trailers, but it never appeared in Agatha All Along, so maybe Jennifer Kale will have some fun with it later. No one has really explained what the Serpent Crown actually is, and that's a big thing for the witches and just about everybody.

A queer forward show with WandaVision's emotional sincerity

I love how this all came together. I loved the twist: the things we thought we knew weren't really what we knew, but what we were given was everything we needed. Like WandaVision, it gave me the same emotional integrity, growth and sincerity that I think most MCU shows have been lacking.

I loved what it did for witches, for lesbians, for bisexuals, and for love. This was a queer show and a queer forward show. In my last piece I said there were times it felt like a lot and like pandering, but this finale flipped that for me and gave me everything I had been hoping for. As a queer woman, I'm proud that it's okay to simply say I love you without it being a big profound thing. Agatha loved Death, and Death is whatever Death wants to be.

I love Rio telling Agatha that this is just the order of things, nothing personal, and that no one has had more advantages than her: "I gave you six years with your son that you weren't supposed to have." She did that out of love. When I wrote this, the lineup still to come included Wonder Man, Marvel Zombies, Eyes of Wakanda and Ironheart.

Which of the Young Avengers are you most excited to see join Billy and Agatha on the road ahead?

What other creators are saying

More on Witches' Road →
The Cosmic Wonder · more than 990,000 subscribers
Billy, who inherited his mother Wanda's reality-shaping powers, created the Witches' Road himself, while Agatha and her son Nicholas Scratch had only invented the song describing it. That's why nothing matched the song, and why Agatha's completed trial did not restore her own powers.

Agatha All Along finale: who built the Witches' Road? →

New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
I believe Lady Death, revealed in Agatha All Along, ferries every soul in the MCU to its afterlife, and I think Tony Stark's offscreen gaze in Endgame was him seeing her waiting to guide him onward, just as she likely did for Thanos, Natasha, Vision and others.

Agatha All Along theory: did Tony Stark see Lady Death? →

The Movie Couple · more than 80,000 subscribers
Our verdict on Agatha All Along episode one was positive with reservations, a fun start that dragged a little too long in Westview before getting going, buoyed by Aubrey Plaza's fun, spicy performance, though we wished Agatha had finished her off instead of sending the Salem Seven.

Agatha All Along episode 1 review: a fun start that drags →

Heavy Spoilers · more than 1.6 million subscribers
I think the episode's visions revealed each witch's deepest fear, heavily foreshadowed Sharon's drowning death, and I believe the Reina wine, 2016 date and Mephisto reveal all point toward Agatha's son and Wanda's lingering influence on the road.

Agatha All Along ep 3: why did Sharon Davis die? →

Watch the original

@gique_ · YouTube

Adapted with AI from GIQUE's video of 31 October 2024 and reviewed by Digital Fox Talent before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Agatha All AlongMarvelMCUAgatha HarknessWiccanBilly MaximoffNicholas ScratchWitches' Road

More from @gique_

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →