SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Sun, 22 November 2026 36 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
ReactionMarvel

Spider-Man: Brand New Day review: is Jean Grey a problem?

Seen at a press screening before its July 31, 2026 release, the film felt like a glorious return to form, even as Sadie Sink's Jean Grey left an X-Men fan worried

Beyond The Trailer (AI-assisted)20 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2008 · more than 930,000 subscribers 1,985 words · 9 min read
Spider-Man: Brand New Day review: is Jean Grey a problem?

I saw Spider-Man: Brand New Day at a press screening before its July 31, 2026 theatrical release, and I thought it felt very much like a glorious return to form for Marvel. To me, a good comic book movie gives fans a lot to dig into and see multiple times. For a long time Marvel played that game best, then lost its way for a while. Spider-Man fans had plenty to enjoy. Sadie Sink's Jean Grey was another matter.

The post credits scene disappointed me. I'd felt sure there would be an X-Men tease because there is so much of Sadie Sink's Jean Grey in the movie, and my whole audience seemed disappointed. I thought it was a little lame. My summary was this: "I think Spider-Man fans are eating good with this movie, but us X-Men fans, this is scary."

Sadie Sink's Jean Grey never felt like Jean Grey to me

She never seemed like Jean Grey to me, even as we got to know her. She felt like Jean Grey in name only. The only way we know for sure who she is comes from Peter Parker saying so. Maybe he's mistaken. Fingers crossed. At my press screening, people chuckled at the reveal because their guesses were right. I saw a comment online that people in another screening were audibly disappointed, and as an X-Men fan, I get it.

Someone made a good point that the reason we were excited about Fox being sold to Disney was that Kevin Feige would finally give us comics accurate X-Men, which we got in X-Men '97. This, so far, seemed to be the least comics accurate version yet. Jean's sister, Sara, technically comes from the comics, but she never had powers there, and I didn't know why they invented all this new material. It smacked of what other studios do with comic book characters. If there could only be one incursion from another dimension, I'd rather the X-Men had arrived that way than the Fantastic Four, whose origin is easier to explain. I felt bad Sara was killed, but I didn't like her.

A big problem I had was wondering whether Jean was the villain. I think she killed people. You could argue maybe she didn't, but a man she was possessing was hit by a car, and he was not Spider-Man, so I didn't think he could survive that. I wondered if this was her Dark Phoenix storyline, since the Phoenix does kill. Then I noticed she looks like Wanda, acts like Wanda and has powers similar to Wanda. Wanda is already well established and popular, so a Wanda coded Jean, I think, makes Jean lesser, and the Phoenix story has been told many times. I'm an Emma Frost fan and don't like Jean much, so maybe that influenced me. At times Sink's performance, strapped down and experimented on, reminded me of Millie Bobby Brown as Eleven in Stranger Things, with Tramell Tillman getting his Matthew Modine on.

Jean's mind control and powers were wrong, and not pink

Her powers were also wrong. As a big X-Men fan this bothered me, but not so much that I couldn't still very much like the film. Jean, Professor X and Emma Frost are telepaths and technically could make you do things, but we rarely see that in the comics. They usually create a false environment around you instead. Jean puppeting people reminded me more of the Purple Man or the Shadow King. It also reminded me of Mystique, who becomes people and sometimes drops the persona. Here the possessed people had a generic persona, without Jean's voice or speech pattern, though Jon Bernthal was hilarious when he did it. It didn't work as well as Mystique, in my opinion.

I did think her jumping between people was cool, and I liked that she could only jump a certain distance, though I hope she loses that ability. I wished she were a different character. Her powers had a blue, almost rainbow tinge, like oil and water. They're supposed to be pink. I think our demands are pretty reasonable, and they largely come down to making it accurate to the source material, so I didn't know why her powers weren't pink. It's very frustrating.

She also developed telekinesis after the traumatic realization that her sister had died in that very room, in that very chair, in a reveal I found stupid: V-Max, the word her sister had sent her, was just the label on the air conditioning above that chair. I'd been asking where her telekinesis was, so I was glad she got it, but when she made glass shards float around Tillman's character, there was no pink power signature, unlike the iconic comic cover. I didn't know why it became a secondary mutation. In the comics, her powers are jump started when she sees a childhood friend hit by a car, which makes it all the more horrible that she did that to someone here. In the film, she already had powers and the sisters were abandoned by their mom. Why does it have to be redone and changed just for the sake of changing it?

The X-Men were introduced as threats, a change I thought was bad

Walking out of the theater, I thought what Tillman's character did to Jean and her sister was truly awful. But I also thought they might be too dangerous to walk around unsupervised, given the damage done, including MJ crying while frozen in Jean's telepathic bubble.

In the past, the X-Men have stood in for persecuted groups. They were hated for who they were, with some bad apples and some good ones. Here, the MCU X-Men were introduced as legitimate threats to be feared and not trusted. That's a huge change. Because the X-Men are supposed to represent those groups, I thought saying they were reasonably feared was a particularly bad change.

Florence Pugh's Yelena was a wonderful surprise

I didn't know Yelena would be in the movie, and it was a wonderful surprise, even if Florence Pugh appearing at the UK premiere red carpet half spoiled it. My first thought was that I love Yelena. My second was poor Scarlett Johansson, who generously passed the baton to Pugh in a way no other hero has done for a sidekick, yet Natasha didn't get to do these kinds of things earlier.

Yelena's office is a Russian bathhouse where everyone strips down and gets in the water, so she can tell if you're hiding listening devices or weapons. It was unusually sexy for an MCU character. Here Pugh seemed like a partner in those decisions. It's very much the Black Widow persona and weird for a family film, but it works. The water was very opaque, and it was fun. Peter got in buff and mostly naked with his mask still on, which felt right out of the comics.

I liked her small potatoes versus big potatoes line, and when MJ and Ned crashed her call with Spider-Man, she said, "I'm just happy Sad Man has friends." I'd be curious how many of her lines are improvised, since they're remarkably consistent across projects. She's a breath of fresh air. It also showed the loss of SHIELD, since Peter once had Phil Coulson. To some degree the new Avengers were filling in, though they're kind of evil too, so Spider-Man doesn't have many places to turn.

Tom Holland's Peter Parker felt so Spider-Man

The emotional core was Peter working so hard to have no personal life, after what happened to Aunt May, that his human self was fading away. It wasn't just arachnid DNA getting out of control; he was subconsciously erasing himself. I loved when he discovered organic webbing, and I loved the gagging, since I find body horror gross. A nature clip of convulsing spiders, narrated by Keith David in a cameo, was funny and disgusting.

His powers increased, and he kept them. He used an inhibitor to hold back the arachnid DNA, but in the prison fight with the Hand, when Jean told him to give himself over to his powers, he decided to be both Peter Parker and Spider-Man. His eyes turn black when he levels up, which I think he'll get under control. His webbing explosion in the prison was beautiful. With Spider-Man going to tussle with powerful characters, I was glad he leveled up just in time. But the trauma that kickstarted it, seeing Mary Jane making out with her new boyfriend, drew a messy parallel to Jean when he's not a mutant.

On how he afforded his tech, I didn't care. Maybe an insurance policy from Aunt May, or access to one of Tony's warehouses. Tony replaced his Uncle Ben, so I think it makes sense there would always be some Tony Stark in Peter Parker, though it still felt very Peter. His own operating system was perhaps a little cheating, but I think without that he'd seem too antiquated.

Doctor Strange's spell gave him back a secret identity, which is very unusual in Marvel and why Civil War was so big. Keeping his mask on at the bathhouse, at the Punisher's hideout with MJ and in the hospital felt so Spider-Man, as did his talk with Bruce Banner and his self imposed martyrdom. Detective DeWolf, played by an actress from The Bear, became a new Aunt May and a Jim Gordon. It's a little Batman, but I don't mind, because she was cast so well and he needs a mentor. New York felt right too, from the montage of his four years apart from MJ and Ned, with nods to the Tobey Maguire and Sam Raimi films, to stunning wide shots in Dolby. One favorite shot: Spider-Man and the Hulk falling from the Damage Control skyscraper with the park below.

MJ and Ned brought the team back together

I never realized MJ is so much like Aunt May. When Jean first entered Peter's mind, I thought the figure on the bunk beds was MJ, but it was Aunt May. The film also ties into the Brand New Day comics, where Peter rebuilds his life after his marriage to Mary Jane is dissolved through a deal with Mephisto. When Jean possessed MJ, Peter called her a monster, and I agreed. That's something Emma Frost would do. Jean is compassionate, so kind she didn't kill Emma when Emma stole her man.

MJ held her own with the Punisher and stayed a fantastic character and partner. Her relationship with the new boyfriend won't last, because she didn't call him when she was in trouble. She made the important point that an inhibitor is something you put on a monster. When she read Peter's note saying he loved her, she wouldn't lie: she had none of his memories. It was a beautiful scene, and I was glad she invited him upstairs. I think they're going to fall in love again.

Ned had no selfish moment this time, so he seemed like a nicer guy. I liked the Lego scene and him saying Spider-Man would get fed at his house. In the bodega, when Peter introduced himself as Peter, you saw it dawn on Ned, and it was so satisfying. He also remembered their handshake. Peter said he wouldn't go it alone, and I liked the idea of him staying a free agent across the groups.

The inhibitor, the Hulk, the Punisher and Damage Control

Peter handing his power inhibitor to the Department of Damage Control is a huge moment for the MCU. He's more like Tony than he realizes, since Tony invented Ultron. Jean also broke something in Bruce's mind, so he can't hold back the Hulk, which means Angry Hulk is back. I liked that, though Jean would never leave something broken.

This was the best I've seen the Punisher. I loved the hair, the weapons and the humor, like "I should have had a bigger gun." I think he overshadowed Peter in the humor department, and I'd love to see him team up with Yelena. When he apologized for shooting Peter, who took the bullet meant for Jean, it was a beautiful moment, though perhaps more complex than an MCU movie can handle. Both men had cut off human connection, but Peter can get his family back and Frank cannot. Frank wearing Peter's mask in the hospital window so Peter could see how loved he was felt like a wonderful gift.

Damage Control, unlike SHIELD, is worried about humans rather than heroes. That reminded me of Lex Luthor in James Gunn's latest film and the latest Avatar movie, with Tillman's character floating giving powers to people they pick. I see a lot of potential there.

Ranking the Spider-Man: Brand New Day action scenes

Spider-Man versus Hulk versus Punisher was by far the best, I think an instantly iconic sequence. It kept escalating: Spider-Man arrives, the Hulk is involved, the Punisher shows up, then Jean takes him over. It bookended the Hulk's fight with Thor in the first Avengers, clap included. My favorite shot in the entire movie was the slow motion frame of the Hulk, Spider-Man dragging the Punisher by a web, and the Punisher firing, as good as a standout shot in Deadpool and Wolverine. When the Hulk turned back, all Bruce needed to know was whether he hurt anybody.

Spider-Man versus the Hand came very close second. I think the Ten Rings was a missed opportunity given Destin Daniel Cretton directed Shang-Chi, but he made the Hand look cool, launching each other through the prison tower. In the Ultimate comics, Peter dated Kitty Pryde, so I didn't know where the Jean material was coming from. Third was Jean jumping to MJ, done with very little VFX, though I wanted it explained how she reached MJ after Peter's helicopter plan. Fourth, the third act at Damage Control, where I didn't think V-Max was a good payoff and the Aunt May conversation felt familiar after Welcome to Derry. Fifth, the tank chase, mostly shown in trailers, with less coverage than I expected. Last, the Scorpion fight, important because Peter almost kills a police officer.

For all my problems with Jean, none of it stopped me from very much liking the film. For Spider-Man, this felt like Marvel back at its best.

What other creators are saying

More on Sadie Sink →
New Rockstars · more than 4.4 million subscribers
My theory was that Sadie Sink's secret Brand New Day role was Mayday Parker, daughter of Tobey Maguire's Peter Parker, and that this connected Brand New Day to Doomsday, where Maguire's Peter would die, and then to Secret Wars, where Mayday would appear to redeem him.

Mayday Parker theory: Sadie Sink and Tobey Maguire's link →

The Cosmic Wonder · more than 990,000 subscribers
Ahead of SDCC in July 2026, conflicting reports about Adam Driver, Sadie Sink and the Brand New Day post-credit scene looked very intentional, as if Marvel had big news to hide

Marvel X-Men leaks: is Sadie Sink really playing Jean Grey? →

Everything Always · more than 1 million subscribers
From Vision's return with James Spader's Ultron to a full X-Men cast reveal and a May 5, 2028 release date, here is everything that dropped during Marvel Studios' D23 panel.

Marvel X-Men cast revealed: Sadie Sink is Jean Grey at D23 →

Kristian Harloff · more than 230,000 subscribers
Plus what I'm hearing about Dave Bautista's possible God of War casting and the next James Bond announcement.

Spider-Man 5: what Kevin Feige said after Brand New Day's record →

Watch the original

@beyondthetrailer · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Beyond The Trailer's video of 30 July 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Spider-Man: Brand New DayTom HollandSadie SinkJean GreyFlorence PughYelenaPunisherJon Bernthal

More from @beyondthetrailer

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →