SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Sun, 22 November 2026 36 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
LoreFilm & TV

Wake Up Dead Man Ending Explained: Who Really Killed Wicks and Why

The third Knives Out mystery hides its killer behind a wolf's head, a sealed crypt and a diamond, and its reveal is probably the most clever and satisfying in the series so far

Heavy Spoilers (AI-assisted)22 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2009 · more than 1.6 million subscribers 1,930 words · 9 min read
Wake Up Dead Man Ending Explained: Who Really Killed Wicks and Why

Wake Up Dead Man (2025), Rian Johnson's third Knives Out mystery starring Daniel Craig, Josh O'Connor and Glenn Close, arrived on Netflix with another Benoit Blanc case. It's packed with twists, but the real answer to who killed Wicks belongs to Martha, who runs the books and keeps everything filed at the church. I think it delivers probably the most clever and satisfying reveal in the franchise so far.

You know the formula by now: a group of ridiculous individuals become suspects in a classic whodunit. Like Glass Onion, this film takes its title from a song, this time from a U2 album. Here's how the mystery fits together, the Easter eggs I spotted, and how it holds up against the rest of the series.

Father Jud, the boxing priest who narrates Wake Up Dead Man

The film opens with Blanc by a fire, reading a letter. That leads into narration from Father Jud, who tells us the story of the Good Friday murder and more or less becomes our main character. He's not a typical priest. Early on he smashes a fellow priest in the face, and much of the film is framed like a fight, with characters exchanging blows and coming out swinging when their backs are against the ropes.

Jud answers to a senior priest, played by another Bond alumnus, and we learn Jud was a boxer who lived on the streets and accidentally killed someone in the ring before turning to the priesthood. Jud argues the church needs fighters, because the priest is a shepherd and the world is a wolf. The senior priest believes that once you start fighting wolves, everyone you don't understand becomes a wolf too. To him, the world needs forgiveness, not violence. He still sees Jud's potential and sends him to a failing church run by Wicks.

Father Wicks and the dark history of his church

Jud quickly discovers Wicks is a terrible priest and a complete psychopath who controls his parish through fear. Martha runs the books, manages the little money the church gets, and files everything meticulously. Glenn Close wears a crucifix throughout, and according to IMDb trivia it was given to her by her father, who apparently got it at St. Peter's Basilica, and it's the same one she wears in The House of the Spirits. The only other worker is Sam, Martha's partner and the caretaker, who says Wicks is the only reason he's sober and Martha is his angel.

Martha tells Jud the church was founded by Wicks's grandfather, whose daughter Grace was branded a harlot. Grace became pregnant with Wicks and waited for her father to die so she could take her inheritance. Martha, a little girl then, saw him take his last communion and drop dead. But he had cleaned out his accounts, leaving only a snow globe with Jesus inside and a French inscription. It points to Eve's apple, though the French translates as the awakening call, which fits the film.

Grace went into a blind rage and wrecked the church, including the crucifix, which stayed off the wall as a reminder of her sins. When Martha told Grace God would forgive her, Grace beat her, then died of a brain hemorrhage after slamming herself against her father's crypt. That crypt, covered in rocket ships drawn by local kids, has a Lazarus door that opens from inside but needs construction equipment to open from outside.

The suspects in Wicks's flock

The regulars are our suspects. The town attorney's father was Wicks's attorney and drinking buddy, and he made her raise a child as her adopted son. That son, Cy, is an influencer who moved home after a failed political career, chasing every culture war talking point. I see him as a very on the nose metaphor for aspiring politicians who'll try anything for popularity, including weaponizing the church. The local doctor, played by Jeremy Renner, a meta callback to his mention in Glass Onion, fell into an alcoholic spiral after his wife left him for a man she met on a fish messaging board.

Another regular is a once bestselling author hoping to save his career with a book on Wicks, whom he sees as a modern prophet. A former world class musician was left in constant pain by an unknown illness, and Wicks promised to heal her through prayer. Wicks exposes their confessions from the pulpit, which the mainstays secretly love. When Jud challenges Martha about confessing her deepest sin to Wicks, she leaves the confession booth out of breath, followed by a gasping Wicks. Maybe my mind is in the gutter, but I guessed straight away the two were up to something, which I don't think Sam would be happy about.

When Jud finally confronts Wicks, Wicks punches and kicks him, insisting the world needs to get angry and fight back. Jud doesn't take the bait and vows to cut Wicks out of the church like a cancer, which Cy films. After Wicks throws a Bible at him, Jud gets drunk at a bar, breaks a lamp with a wolf's head on it, and later throws the head through a church window.

The Good Friday murder in the storage closet

On the day of the murder, Wicks's sermon is more unhinged than usual. He ducks into a side storage closet to recharge, which we later learn means drinking from a flask. He collapses, and Jud finds the wolf's head, now painted red, lodged in his back. Dr. Nat inspects him, Martha screams and knocks over a crucifix at the altar, and Nat pulls out the head to reveal a blade as blood pools. Outside, Martha promises Wicks will rise again.

Chief Scott, played by Mila Kunis, questions Jud but lets him go because the murder seems impossible. She warns him everyone thinks he's guilty, especially after Cy posts the cancer threat. Jud admits his heart was glad Wicks was dead, and while praying he meets Blanc, who says his mother was religious but he sees it as a scam, though he likes the architecture. Jud tells him you can always be honest by not saying the unhonest part. I love Daniel Craig.

Benoit Blanc, The Hollow Man and the Easter eggs

Blanc enlists Jud with a plan: view the body, trace the weapon, inspect the scene. At El Diablo, the bar where Jud got the wolf's head, Blanc keeps moving a photo of the lamp back and forth. The photo also shows Dr. Nat at the bar with his briefcase. Nat is Hawkeye's nickname for Black Widow, and Josh Brolin and Jeremy Renner both appeared in Endgame. Rian Johnson regular Noah Segan returns after Looper, The Last Jedi, Knives Out and Glass Onion. There's a shout out to Lieutenant Elliott, played by LaKeith Stanfield, who gave Scott Blanc's number, and Blanc uses the iPad he won from Bron in the previous film.

Calling it a textbook impossible crime, Blanc pulls out The Hollow Man by John Dickson Carr, a real 1935 book considered the best locked room mystery of all time. Jud realizes it was on the church book club list, which every suspect belongs to. Blanc's scenarios come from chapter 17, where Dr. Fell explains how impossible murders can be committed. At Sam's garage, a taped Cubs game shows interference suggesting a remote device, but it happened after Wicks was already dead.

Jud's letter and the hidden flask

Stumped, Blanc has Jud write the whole story from his perspective, bringing us back to the opening letter. Jud says he's been writing for an hour, and you might notice this is exactly one hour into the movie. Blanc realizes Jud had unobserved access to the body before police searched it. Blanc isn't asking why Jud killed Wicks, but why he hid the flask. Jud did it for Sam, fearing that learning Wicks had been drinking would send Sam back to the bottle. In the original murder scene, you can hear the flask clank against the door as Jud kicks it aside. This is such a good detail.

When they go to retrieve it, the flask is gone. Jud is being set up.

Cy's tape, the crypt order and the resurrection

At Wicks's funeral, the crypt is opened and sealed. Cy reveals he taped a secret meeting where Vera exposes Cy as Wicks's son. Wicks declares Easter Sunday his final sermon, after which he'll close the church and destroy each of them: Nat for treating patients drunk, Lee for his book, Vera for disappointing her father, and Simone, whom he won't heal because she's a faithless woman. All of this ties into Easter, the resurrection and the sealed crypt. Cy says Wicks claimed he'd found his grandfather's fortune but died before telling him where it was. Cy believes it's hidden in a Swiss bank account, and Wicks left a clue about Eve's apple being restored to the tree. Blanc and Jud realize it refers to the snow globe, which is framed right behind them, a great shot.

The globe holds nothing, but Jud learns the order to open the crypt was placed a week before Wicks died. Scott then points out Blanc skipped a fourth Hollow Man option: the victim presumed dead before he is. Cy's clip shows nine seconds where Jud was alone with Wicks. If you were obsessed with Jonathan Creek like I was as a kid, you might remember an episode where an electric alarm clock knocked a judge out and a policewoman secretly stabbed him.

In a storm, Jud sees the Lazarus door open and Wicks walk out with Sam. Jud is punched, wakes holding a knife, then finds Sam dead with the same knife Sam carried at the start. Martha appears to praise the resurrection, and her popping up like the butler from Mr. Deeds is by far my favorite gag. The receptionist confirms Wicks placed the crypt order. At Nat's trashed house, Blanc and Jud find Wicks's body in an acid tub, his hand around the neck of Nat's skeleton, plus a bottle of pentobarbital. Jud still insists on confessing to Sam's death. Catholicism is all about guilt, and I love how he carries that throughout.

How the wolf's head trick worked

Blanc explains Wicks was knocked out by a tranquilizer in his flask. The bar photo shows two identical lamps, both missing their heads. One head, painted the red of the thread found near the body and of Wicks's vestments, was hollowed out, filled with blood, sewn to his robes and triggered by remote. You can see it on Wicks's robe as he enters the closet, such a good touch. Nat triggered it, got Jud out of the room, then stabbed Wicks when Martha's outburst distracted everyone and pocketed the fake. He just couldn't find the flask Jud had hidden.

As Blanc readies his checkmate, sun streams through the windows. Remembering Jud's road to Damascus moment, he says he can't solve the case, giving Cy material to spin. Then Martha arrives, and Blanc says he played the fool to let her confess of her own accord.

Martha is the killer behind Eve's Apple

Martha reveals Prentice put his fortune into a diamond he called Eve's Apple, swore it would never fall into evil hands, swallowed it and choked to death in front of her. Grace recognized the globe as the jewel's box. Young Martha called her a harlot, said she'd never find it and laughed during the beating, showing she's a little bit of a psychopath. This confirms Martha brought that beating on herself and branded Grace a harlot, the lie at the church's foundation. She kept it secret 60 years, until Jud challenged her.

When Wicks embraced Cy, Martha knew he'd go for the jewel. Inspired by The Hollow Man, she enlisted the weak and desperate Nat, spiked the flask and sewed on the head. With Sam along for the ride, she moved Wicks into the crypt to get the jewel and stage a resurrection. Jud's arrival ruined it, and Nat killed Sam for the jewel, framing Jud. Nat planned to poison Martha, but she switched their cups. I feel like Martha might be an Agent 47 level assassin. She has taken a lethal dose of pentobarbital, and after Jud urges her to seek Grace's forgiveness, she dies in his arms. A diamond falls from her fist, and Blanc raises his hands and walks away.

The ending: the inheritance is in Christ

A year later, Jud says the jewel was never found. Lee's book is a success, with fans he loathes; Vera moves for a fresh start; Simone plays again. Cy, with lawyers, vows to keep an eye on Jud, who tells him the real inheritance is in Christ. Jud rebuilds the cross, the church becomes Our Lady of Perpetual Grace instead of Perpetual Fortitude, and the jewel sits in Jesus's chest.

Jud resisted Eve's apple through compassion and forgiveness, not violence, refusing to see people as wolves, which also led Blanc to his Damascus moment. The cross offers Grace a forgiveness she never got from her father or Martha, and the jewel closes a circle of greed, showing true wealth comes from God's love.

My verdict on Wake Up Dead Man

It still has comedy and an all star cast, but it leans more into thriller territory, and playing on the impossible murder and personal themes of religion makes the absurd crime feel grounded. Craig is so good that Blanc may be the role he was born to play, and I'll take as many of these as he and Johnson can make. But Josh O'Connor's Father Jud does much of the heavy lifting and completely stole the show among a cast of heavy hitters.

Watch the original

@heavyspoilers · YouTube

Adapted with AI from Heavy Spoilers' video of 12 December 2025 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Wake Up Dead ManKnives OutBenoit BlancDaniel CraigJosh O'ConnorGlenn CloseRian JohnsonNetflix

More from @heavyspoilers

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →