Avengers: Doomsday: will Avengers vs. X-Men really happen?
A shadow in a cast photo, a rumored incursion and Joe Russo's talk of a new beginning sparked a debate over whether Marvel would pit its heroes against the X-Men
After the Avengers: Doomsday cast reveal, the question we kept coming back to was whether the Russo brothers' next Avengers film would turn into Avengers vs. X-Men. A rumor pointed in that direction, and so did a theory built on a shadow in one of the reveal photos. Coy thinks the clash is an inevitability in some ways, but he doesn't expect a whole movie built around the fight the way Civil War was. Winston is excited about it, but a little worried.
Marvel's five-and-a-half-hour cast reveal livestream set off a wave of speculation about what Marvel was doing with the movie. Overall it was a smart marketing move, because of how much time people spent on it. Was it the best plan? Probably not. Then came the next round of speculation: is this X-Men versus Avengers?
The Avengers: Doomsday cast photo fans read as an Avengers vs. X-Men tease
An article we discussed laid out the theory. The cast reveal showed that several actors from the X-Men franchise would appear in Avengers: Doomsday. The piece listed Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellen, Alan Cumming, Rebecca Romijn, James Marsden and Kelsey Grammer, alongside Channing Tatum from Deadpool and Wolverine, with more expected to follow.
The article noted that this had been suspected for a while, partly because Kevin Feige got his start as an associate producer on 2000's X-Men. It also cited a rumor that an incursion would force Earth-616's mightiest heroes to battle the X-Men, essentially an Avengers vs. X-Men movie.
Many fans were convinced they had spotted a shadow in a photo that followed the cast reveal, forming an A and an X sitting on top of each other. If that sounds like a stretch, the article pointed back to Avengers: Endgame. Before that title was revealed, the Russo brothers shared a behind-the-scenes image and told fans to look hard. Eventually people worked out that items on set spelled out Endgame.
Joe Russo on why the Russos came back: a new beginning
The same article quoted a recent interview in which Joe Russo explained what brought him and Anthony back to the MCU. "It's a new beginning," he said. "We told an ending story, now we're going to tell a beginning story."
The article said that lined up with what had been heard about Avengers: Secret Wars softly rebooting the MCU and creating a new sacred timeline that the Avengers, the Fantastic Four and the X-Men call home. On what comes after, Joe said, "who knows where we'll go from there, maybe it'll be another five years." He added that "the only thing that brought us back was the right story." The article also noted that rumors persisted that the Russos would direct the eventual X-Men reboot.
Coy expects a comic book style misunderstanding, not a Civil War
When I asked Coy whether he bought any of it, he said a clash felt like an inevitability in some ways. He pictured it playing out like the comics, where the X-Men fight the Avengers after a miscommunication and then team up. As he put it, if comics teach us anything, it's that heroes have to fight first and then realize they're on the same side.
Coy didn't think it would be a full-on Civil War style movie where the fight changes everything. He expected these X-Men to appear in both Doomsday and Secret Wars, with Secret Wars escalating and adding even more actors, so he didn't see the fight lasting across both films. He did expect fights, and said they'd be exciting. He also pointed to a James McAvoy clip and said, "I think the X-Men take out the Avengers pretty well," especially since the Avengers didn't have a strong, settled team at that point.
Winston worries the Phoenix story could be stripped for parts
Winston said he was excited, but Avengers vs. X-Men is such an epic storyline, built around the Phoenix, that it gave him pause. If Marvel brought in the Fox universe, he wondered whether the Phoenix would be the cosmic bird fans expect or just an alter ego of Jean who can't control her powers. That worried him a little. He noted Marvel did a good job adapting Civil War, but said this story is so good on its own.
The discussion also raised the fear of the story being stripped for parts just to say Marvel did Avengers vs. X-Men. One example given was the Iron Man versus Magneto fight from the comic, where Tony uses an alloy that can't be magnetized and summons power to try to punch Magneto. With Robert Downey Jr. brought in for Doctor Doom, the thinking was that fight probably wasn't coming.
The case for Doom as the trigger for an Avengers vs. X-Men clash
One point made in the discussion was that a clash has to be earned. It has to be something you believe in, not just a hook to get people into the theater, and the view expressed on the show was that it's going to be earned. The X-Men we know from the earlier films clearly aren't part of the MCU, but the thinking was that they're going to be, because of Doom. As discussed on the show, Doom brings one group into it, the two sides rival each other, one believing it's doing the right thing, and then they fight.
It's the same pattern as Batman v Superman or Godzilla vs. Kong. You're against each other first, then you're together, and then you battle everybody else in Secret Wars.
The reply in the discussion was agreement, along with the view that the Russos would handle the ensemble well. Infinity War juggled three storylines with Thanos largely the lead, and Endgame added even more arcs through time travel. But this film also had to assemble an Avengers team, establish Doom as a viable threat and set up Secret Wars. Whatever seed Fantastic Four planted had to pay off in Doomsday's first act, the way Thanos led Infinity War.
My prediction: Doom kills Loki to show his power
I think Doom will be devastating, and as Winston and I discussed, a lot of people are going to die. I think Loki dies. I think Kang originally had to die to show how powerful Doom was: Kang Dynasty was going to be a Kang movie, and Doom would kill him at the end, leading to Secret Wars. With Kang no longer a factor, or not as big a one, I think having Doom take out the god of stories is the only way to show the power scale.
The discussion noted that Infinity War opened the same way, with Thanos killing Asgardians and Loki, and that killing Loki has become a running gag to start things off. That led into a back and forth over how many times Charles Xavier has died: Multiverse of Madness, Logan and X-Men: The Last Stand. There was a debate over whether Logan counted, since he was already dying, and a reminder that he was brought back without explanation after The Last Stand. If anyone rivals Loki, it's Xavier.
How the Russos can build without an Infinity Saga runway
The other part of the article I wanted to dig into was the Russos carrying things over. What people worried about was that, unlike Infinity War, there wasn't a run of films locking audiences in. But that's like any other movie series. If you're the Russos, give me a little setup in Fantastic Four, then make Doomsday a great movie. Part two is essentially Spider-Man 4, because whatever happens leads into it.
That explains why Marvel wanted a grand scale multiverse version of Spider-Man rather than a grounded one, because a grounded Spider-Man after all those huge events wouldn't work. The discussion also noted that Destin Daniel Cretton, first attached to Avengers: The Kang Dynasty, then got moved to Spider-Man 4, with the view on the show being, "I think they're planning a big thing for him in particular." Then Secret Wars follows as part three, with a soft reboot where Avengers still pop up but the focus shifts to the Fantastic Four and the X-Men. The closing view: simplify, but keep enough that you know what you're doing, because that is the direction Marvel needs to go.
What other creators are saying
More on Avengers: Doomsday →I think Avengers: Doomsday will finally resolve Clea's mid credits scene, and the current theory is that she and Strange are secretly working for Doctor Doom, with Strange possibly becoming Doom's sheriff in Battleworld. I also now lean toward Wanda, not Strange, being Earth-616's anchor being.
Doctor Strange: does Avengers: Doomsday resolve Clea's scene? →
I predict the final trailer lands November 25, with the November 30 Holiday Spectacular footage likely being a movie scene rather than trailer content, similar to Endgame's approach. I hope both show more Loki, Doom, Magneto and the witches without spoiling too much.
Avengers: Doomsday final trailer: will it land November 25? →
My favorite poster is Cyclops and Sam Wilson, while Mystique's hideous costume bothers me most. I don't buy Marvel's claim that Doom was always planned, but I don't care, since all I want is to have a good time with Marvel again.
Avengers: Doomsday posters: why is Mystique's costume so bad? →
The cloud latte and both donuts were good, but the Doomsday Donut, with its brownie batter and Doctor Doom inspired sprinkles, is my favorite and addictive. If you're in LA, I think it's worth stopping by for a donut and some coffee.
Avengers: Doomsday Dunkin' menu: is the Doomsday Donut worth it? →
Watch the original
@thekristianharloff · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Kristian Harloff's video and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @thekristianharloff
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

