The Odyssey review: is it Christopher Nolan's best film?
A first time experience of the 2026 epic brings praise for Matt Damon, Anne Hathaway and the Cyclops, plus Oscar predictions
Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey (2026), starring Matt Damon, Tom Holland and Anne Hathaway, is now Sam's favorite Christopher Nolan movie. She said it has to be one of the best movies she's ever seen. My own verdict when I first saw it: I think this is a masterpiece.
Sam had never seen a Christopher Nolan movie until I showed her one about six or seven months ago. She went into this one blind, with no idea what we were about to see. She never paid attention to the Odyssey in high school and has never seen the movie Troy. When the horse appeared, I thought she would figure it out, but we paused once she saw the title. She had wanted to see it when it came out, but we kept it from her.
Sam feared Odysseus would not survive
I knew she would have loved it if Odysseus lived. Sam said she spent the whole film thinking she would be so angry if it ended with him dead.
Matt Damon is incredible in this, and Good Will Hunting also came up as one of the best movies he's done. The discussion covered how haunted Odysseus is, his loyalty as a soldier and everything he goes through with his men: the Cyclops, the witch, the giants, the dead, and the cattle they are not supposed to eat. He spends seven years with a woman who holds on to him, even though she knows he will start remembering his family.
Robert Pattinson, Jon Bernthal and John Leguizamo stand out
Robert Pattinson was great. His casting as James Bond came up, and there was some doubt in the discussion about whether that was a good thing. I think he'll pull it off.
The music was another talking point. It doesn't let up, and it brought real anxiety, especially during the Troy sequence with Jon Bernthal. John Leguizamo was awesome too. The guess in our discussion was that Anne Hathaway and Matt Damon will definitely be nominated for the Oscar for this, and that a best supporting actor nomination for Leguizamo wouldn't be a surprise. Tom Holland was good, but with performances like Pattinson, Damon, Hathaway and Leguizamo around him, it isn't a fair contest.
Penelope, the Cyclops and the pig scene
The love between Penelope and Odysseus across 20 years drives the build to the final scene, with Penelope unraveling her work to buy time. The film blends historical material with mythology. The Cyclops could have looked like bad CGI, but it didn't. The pig scene felt like something from a horror movie, looked real and was disgusting, which is exactly the range of emotions it is meant to take you through.
Asked if this was her favorite movie of the year, Sam said she has seen a lot, but for this one she doesn't even have words. She loved Interstellar, but this is her favorite Nolan.
What other creators are saying
More on Matt Damon →Despite its flaws, I think The Odyssey is the best movie of the year so far, built around Matt Damon's third act monologue, its message that civility underpins civilization, and its unflinching, probably Oscar-worthy portrait of how men bury their feelings and leave the women in their lives waiting.
The Odyssey ending explained: why Nolan's film is the year's best →
On a technical level this might just be one of the best movies ever made, bringing Nolan's 20-year-old Troy ideas to screen. I don't agree with Emily Wilson's claim that it has nothing to say, and I'm glad Nol
The Odyssey: how Nolan's scrapped Troy movie shaped his Homer →
A first reaction to the epic: stunning visuals, deep characters and a 3 hour runtime that never dragged
A schedule clash with Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey, secret fan research and a scene shut down with Zendaya all trace back to choices Holland made along the way
Watch the original
@thekristianharloff · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Kristian Harloff's video of 19 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @thekristianharloff
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

