I Play Rocky Review: Anthony Ippolito Plays Stallone, Not a Rocky Impression
Peter Farrelly's film about how Sylvester Stallone got Rocky made earns a 4.7 out of five as an authentic, uplifting human story.
I Play Rocky, Peter Farrelly's movie about how Sylvester Stallone got Rocky made, is one of my favorite movies of the year, hands down, and I'm giving it 4.7 out of five. The 2026 film stars Anthony Ippolito as Stallone, and he plays the man, not a Rocky impression. AnnaSophia Robb, P.J. Byrne, Matt Dillon, Toby Kebbell and more round out the cast. This review avoids spoilers.
I'm a big Sylvester Stallone and Rocky fan. It's easily one of my favorite franchises of all time. The true story of how Stallone persevered, believed in himself and his dream, and made sure Rocky got made has inspired me, among countless other people. This movie is that story.
Why I didn't scoff when I Play Rocky was announced
When the movie was announced, I didn't scoff at it the way other people did. Plenty of people assumed it was going to be ridiculous and wondered who could possibly pull off Stallone. I wondered that too, but I was more interested in the overall story and in what the trailer would look like.
A clip of Johnny Carson saying this story should be made into a movie had been going around the internet: a movie about where Stallone came from, how he had absolutely nothing, how he built it from the ground up, believed in himself and wrote the script. When the trailer hit, it hit hard.
When Stallone was offered $350,000 to write the script and not star in it, he didn't take it. That's about $1.4 million today. He wrote the thing for himself and wanted to do it.
Peter Farrelly's move from Dumb and Dumber to I Play Rocky
Look back at what Farrelly has directed, starting with Dumb and Dumber, which he made with his brother, then Kingpin, There's Something About Mary and Me, Myself and Irene. After weaker films like Shallow Hal, Stuck on You and Movie 43, I thought maybe that was what he was stuck doing, until he turned himself around with Green Book.
He also directed the TV show Loudermilk and started to maneuver into a different genre. With I Play Rocky, the question was how he would bring this story to life, and whether he would get the feel of it. He does, and a big part of that is Anthony Ippolito.
Anthony Ippolito plays Stallone, not a Rocky impression
I really hope he gets nominated for this. It's going to be tough, but I hope he does.
It's easy to get caught up in an impression, where an actor deepens his voice to sound like Rocky and it doesn't work. Ippolito should sound like Stallone, not Rocky. Stallone is not Rocky. Rocky's a character.
When Ippolito first pops up and introduces himself, I wondered whether that was what we'd get the whole time, or whether he would turn into Stallone. Within seconds, he becomes Stallone and stays there. Stallone is a witty guy, a smart guy and a determined guy, and Ippolito plays all of that.
AnnaSophia Robb, Butkus and how Farrelly shoots the Rocky story
You can see it when Ippolito is with AnnaSophia Robb, who plays Stallone's first wife, Sasha. Their relationship and the belief they had in each other come through. I've read the book, and the movie does take some liberties, for example with how Stallone got Butkus. But the idea of Butkus the dog, and how important that dog was, is all in there.
The way Farrelly shoots this, and the music used to get you motivated and locked in, works. The Rocky story is Stallone's story: the million to one shot who believes in himself, takes his chance and runs with it.
It's uplifting, and I think a story like that is something we need. I love the way that it was executed.
Why I Play Rocky feels authentic where Young Rock and The Iron Claw slipped
As an old-school WWE fan, I found Young Rock's promos didn't feel like that era at all. They felt like a television version that didn't seem like WWE or that time.
Even in The Iron Claw, the majority of the movie nailed everybody. Then there was, I think, one portrayal of Ric Flair that felt like an impression, and it pulled me out of the film.
I Play Rocky seems plucked right from Rocky. There were times when I thought I was watching Stallone for a second. When Ippolito, recreating Stallone's scene as Rocky, has his arms up holding on to the bar while talking to Adrian, it's pulled right from the way that scene was shot in Rocky. The film isn't trying to recreate Rocky frame for frame; it borrows from it to feel authentic. I think that's the word for the movie overall. It was authentic.
Matt Dillon, the supporting cast and my 4.7 rating
One or two of the actors cast to play the original Rocky cast members didn't hit it for me, and it did feel like they were trying to. But they're barely in it, so it didn't affect the overall movie.
It comes down to whether you buy into Ippolito, Robb, who was so much of an anchor in this movie, and Matt Dillon, who plays Stallone's dad. If you know the story of Stallone and his dad, it's sad. How Stallone grew up and the things he went through were sad, but the film incorporates all of it, and that is its strength. I dug it, which is why I'm going big with 4.7 out of five.
Do you need to be a Rocky fan to enjoy I Play Rocky?
The question many people have asked me is whether they'll care about this if they aren't Rocky fans. Initially, I would have said I didn't know. I thought Rocky fans would love it, but I wasn't sure about everyone else.
Then my wife saw it. She had maybe seen bits and pieces of the Rocky movies when I had them on, and she was never interested. She loved this movie. She was locked into it, and like me, she saw it as a feel-good story. She wants to go back and see the Rocky movies, because knowing how they came to be, she wants to see where the character evolves from.
I do think this is a human story in general. It's a matter of whether you can get past thinking, they're doing a movie about Rocky, who cares. This is a great movie, and you don't have to be a Rocky fan to dig it.
What other creators are saying
More on I Play Rocky →I Play Rocky is an incredible feel-good movie and I strongly recommend it, even though I can't decide if it's good on its own or just riding Rocky's coattails. It doesn't have its own great moment, it doesn't exist without Rocky.
I Play Rocky review: A strong crowd pleaser that can't exist without Rocky →
Grace learns Earth's sun returned to normal, meaning the mission succeeded, but he chooses to stay with Rocky and the Eridians rather than return home. The film adds a new dome and beach scene suggesting he has fully accepted his new life, leaving it feeling more definitive than the book's slightly ambiguous ending.
Watching Sylvester Stallone's final outing as John Rambo, we were struck by the age, the gore, and a finale we think should have ended differently.
Rambo: Last Blood reaction: is it the least Rambo film yet? →
Watch the original
@thekristianharloff · YouTube
Adapted with AI from Kristian Harloff's video of 19 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @thekristianharloff
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

