WandaVision: did an alternate Scarlet Witch guide the Mind Stone?
Before the finale aired, my theory was that an alternate Scarlet Witch reached across realities to make sure the stone found Wanda, a question worth revisiting as VisionQuest brings this corner of Marvel back into view.
The penultimate episode of WandaVision (2021), starring Elizabeth Olsen and Paul Bettany, showed us the origin of the Scarlet Witch, and my theory at the time was that the Mind Stone didn't pick Wanda by accident. I believed an alternate reality version of Wanda, the Scarlet Witch herself, reached back into this reality to make sure the stone connected with her. That piece was written before the series finale aired on March 5, 2021.
Episode 8 traced Wanda Maximoff from a Sokovian orphan born with power to a Nexus being, after an Infinity Stone amplified what she already had. The most mysterious part was her meeting with the Mind Stone. Wanda briefly saw a silhouette shaped like her future self as the Scarlet Witch. The questions then were who exactly she saw, what that vision meant, and whether this was the "Wanda vision" of the show's title.
WandaVision episode 8 revealed Wanda had magic before the Mind Stone
Episode 8 confirmed that Wanda didn't get her power solely from the Mind Stone. She already had low level magic from a young age. The Stark bomb that traumatized Wanda and Pietro didn't fail to detonate because it was defective. This is Stark Industries we're talking about, not Hammer Tech.
Instead, the bomb failed because Wanda cast what Agatha later identified as a probability hex. That was among Wanda's powers in the early comics, where her magic let her alter the causal probability of events. So this implied that Wanda could have been a witch from birth, or at least from a very young age.
Was Wanda Maximoff born a mutant? The genetic theory
In the Marvel comics, Wanda was originally a mutant, the daughter of Magneto. Later comics altered that history, but classically Wanda and Pietro have been understood as mutants associated with the X-Men and other mutant groups. House of M, the most famous Scarlet Witch comic event, is very much an X-Men mutant story.
Before WandaVision came out, Marvel began dropping hints in companion literature that Hydra might have chosen Wanda and Pietro's Sokovian homeland for its Mind Stone experiments because those test subjects were naturally more likely to survive the radiation exposure. Between the Winter Soldier post credits scene and this episode, we saw that most of those test subjects died, but Wanda and Pietro survived. That suggested both could have been born with a genetic predisposition.
I thought that was the best explanation, because Pietro isn't a witch. So we were probably looking at something genetic, a mutant gene or an X gene. That gives us a formula: mutant gene plus cosmic radiation yields powers.
Monica Rambeau follows the same formula
We saw a similar equation with Monica Rambeau. She was exposed to cosmic radiation with her passes through the Hex wall, but the show gave us clues that her DNA was unusual before those exposures.
After only two of the three exposures, her scans showed up blank, and she was able to rip the rover's hatch door fully off its hinges. Before any of those exposures, she knocked down a man in the hospital who looked like he had at least 40 pounds on her. So it's the same equation: some natural, pre-existing, maybe genetic starting mutation, plus radiation, gives us new powers.
Infinity Stone visions and why Wanda's Scarlet Witch silhouette was different
When Monica was irradiated, she heard voices from her past: her mother Maria, Carol Danvers and Nick Fury. That's similar to other times MCU characters have encountered Infinity Stone derived radiation. Peter Quill, while wielding the Power Stone, saw a vision of his mother on her deathbed. Thanos saw young Gamora in the Soul Stone. And in a deleted scene, Tony Stark saw a future version of Morgan Stark in the soul realm after he snapped.
With Wanda seeing the Scarlet Witch in the Mind Stone's glow, it was the first time we'd seen a character see a future version of themselves. But because Wanda Maximoff is a unique Nexus being with the power to rewrite reality and branch out into the multiverse, I believed that what we and Wanda were seeing wasn't a future version of herself. In the same way Monica split into alternate selves, I believed Wanda saw an alternate reality version of herself.
When you adjust the levels on the silhouette, you can see that it's clearly Elizabeth Olsen's face, but with darker hair than the red hair she had at the time. So we were looking at an alternate Wanda look.
Why I didn't think the silhouette was Wanda's mother
Some wondered if the silhouette could have been Wanda's mother, since in some comics Wanda's mother was a Scarlet Witch before her. That theory also suggested that her mother's strange reaction to the danger in the streets of Sokovia was because she might have wanted herself and her husband to die so their children could fulfill their destinies.
I didn't think so. What a crummy thing to do to your kids, especially when it would essentially doom your son to death. For the Maximoffs, civil unrest in Sokovia was sadly a routine occurrence. They probably didn't expect it to escalate to an air raid. They were just trying to distract their kids from all that violence and chaos, like the heartbreaking Irish mom telling her kids bedtime stories as the Titanic went down.
The Scarlet Witch crown and Agatha's mythology
The weirdest thing about Wanda's Mind Stone baptism wasn't only the silhouette of the Scarlet Witch. It was that the stone wriggled free from Loki's scepter and floated out toward her. It chose her. When the Mind Stone amplified the low level sorcery Wanda had as a child, it charged her up in a way that made her a kind of mythological goddess, at least as Agatha described it. Agatha told Wanda she was supposed to be a myth, "a being capable of spontaneous creation," and named it chaos magic. In that sense, the Scarlet Witch isn't just a superhero nickname but a title, a rank.
Agatha's mother Evanora had blue magic that manifested as a crown around her head, a crown Agatha didn't inherit after draining Evanora's life force. Yet that crown was distinctly visible in the silhouette, even in the reflection of Wanda's eyes. That's how important the show wanted that pointed tiara shape to be.
I thought this meant the Scarlet Witch was a rare distinction Agatha had sought after. It's the witch of all witches, the myth of all myths, a sorceress so powerful she can tap into the multiverse as a Nexus being and spawn realities where the dead can walk once more.
Why Hayward could track Vision inside the Hex
Some were confused about why Hayward was able to track Vision inside the Hex when that Vision wasn't built from the parts at SWORD headquarters. My answer was that the Vision Wanda made in the Hex isn't an illusion or a fantasy. It's a real reality. She created vibranium out of nothing.
Wanda only has that power because her low level sorcery was amplified by cosmic radiation, the magic of the Infinity Stones. That's science so advanced that Asgardians equate it with magic, and Asgardians had witches too. Thor's mother Frigga was a witch, so they know what they're talking about there.
Why the Mind Stone chose Wanda: my trans-dimensional loop theory
That brings it back to the central question. My theory was that the stone chose Wanda because the Nexus being, the Scarlet Witch in a separate reality, a time and space far beyond this one, tapped back into this reality at that moment to make sure the stone connected with Wanda.
That closes the loop, but not in a time travel way. It's trans-dimensional. I see it as side to side instead of forward and backward: the Scarlet Witch didn't reach back from Wanda's future, she reached across from another reality to make sure the stone found her.
What other creators are saying
More on Wanda Maximoff →I think Wanda's return proves she's still the MCU's most popular female character, and I suspect she may secretly be the engine Doom uses to create Secret Wars, with Doomsday setting up a WandaVision-scale finale and The Children's Crusade possibly becoming its own later project.
Scarlet Witch returns: what Wanda's reveal means for Doomsday →
I loved the final film's horror and Wanda as villain, but I think the scrapped version, with Wanda turning gradually and setting up future showdowns, would probably have handled her change better, even though it's hard to say for certain which was truly superior.
Doctor Strange 2 original plan: was Shuma-Gorath the villain? →
I believe this confirms Wanda will appear in Avengers: Doomsday, taken captive so Doom can steal her power rather than recruit her, and I suspect Doom reached the MCU long ago given her unfrozen body. I don't expect her role to be huge in Doomsday, but I hope I'm wrong.
VisionQuest post-credits scene: why does Doom take Scarlet Witch? →
I think the Ancient One has a genuine shot using her mastery of the Mirror Dimension to trick and trap Wanda, but she isn't more powerful than Wanda. Since Wanda has already beaten two Sorcerer Supremes, my verdict is the Scarlet Witch wins this one too.
Watch the original
@newrockstars · YouTube
Adapted with AI from New Rockstars' video of 1 March 2021 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @newrockstars
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

