Order of the Phoenix movie: does it beat the book?
David Yates's 2007 film trims a slow, overstuffed novel, sharpens Harry's arc and lands at number four in my ranking of the Harry Potter movies.
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is one of the more peculiar entries in the Harry Potter franchise for me. The book is by far my least favorite of the series, but on a rewatch I couldn't help liking the movie more than the book, and I somewhat enjoy it as a standalone film. I still don't think it's a great movie, and it lands at number four in my ranking of the Harry Potter films.
The movie, starring Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint and Emma Watson, was released roughly 19 years ago, in 2007. Here's why the adaptation works better than its source, where it still falls short, and what it adds to my running list of reasons Hogwarts is unsafe.
Order of the Phoenix went into filming with a new director, no Steve Kloves and its stars unsigned for the final films
Going into production on Order of the Phoenix, there was plenty of uncertainty. After Goblet of Fire, Warner Bros. approached director Mike Newell about returning for the next entry. Newell declined, so a new director had to be found. Jean-Pierre Jeunet, Guillermo del Toro, Matthew Vaughn and Mira Nair were all offered the job at one point, and each turned it down. Eventually the job went to David Yates. Warner Bros. liked the more emotional and political films in his filmography and thought he'd be a great fit.
The script was the next question mark. For the first time, Steve Kloves would not be writing the screenplay because of previous commitments. Michael Goldenberg, who had been considered to write Sorcerer's Stone back in the late '90s, was brought on to replace him.
Most of the main cast returned, and new actors joined: Evanna Lynch as Luna Lovegood, Helena Bonham Carter as Bellatrix Lestrange and Imelda Staunton as Dolores Umbridge. Even so, there was doubt about the main trio's future, because Radcliffe, Grint and Watson had not yet signed on for the final movies. Emma Watson herself has stated that she was very close to leaving the franchise, feeling the fame was too much and feeling a sense of loneliness and loss of identity. Principal photography began in January 2006 and wrapped in November 2006, with nobody sure how the new director and writer would work out, or whether the final movies would even be made.
July 2007 was the biggest month the Harry Potter franchise ever had
In 2007, things turned for the better. The main trio all committed to completing the series. David Yates was announced as returning for Half-Blood Prince, which gave the franchise some stability at director for the first time since Chamber of Secrets.
Maybe most importantly, J.K. Rowling announced the release of the final book, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. It came out on July 21, 2007, just 10 days after the Order of the Phoenix movie opened on July 11, 2007. Warner Bros. rode that momentum all the way to release, and I think it's fair to say July 2007 was the biggest month the franchise ever had.
David Yates is a competent director who loses the warm feeling of Hogwarts
David Yates is a controversial name in the Harry Potter fandom. He didn't only direct Order of the Phoenix; he went on to direct Half-Blood Prince and both Deathly Hallows films. He's clearly a competent director, and there are sequences in his Harry Potter movies that prove it, especially in this one. But for the most part, I feel he was unable to accomplish the single most important thing a Harry Potter director needs to do: capture the feeling of Hogwarts.
Harry Potter is so successful because of how it makes audiences and readers feel, and I think Chris Columbus captured that feeling well in the first two movies. Yates, for the most part, fails to. His directing choices make Hogwarts feel cold and distant, a place I definitely wouldn't want to be. Half-Blood Prince is the biggest offender. Still, his style does work at times. He perfectly captures the Ministry of Magic and Grimmauld Place, places I imagine feeling cold and unwelcoming. The highlight has to be the Department of Mysteries, which is exactly how I pictured it in the book. I also think he does a great job at directing action, and the Dumbledore versus Voldemort fight is maybe the best fight in the franchise. Seeing those two master wizards fight was electric. "This fight has the sauce."
You could argue the cold feeling is the point of this movie, since Harry feels alone and the Ministry is invading Hogwarts. But considering his choices in the later films, I don't think that was his intention. The clearest example is the Dumbledore scene at the end. Compare it to the similar scene at the end of Chamber of Secrets, where Harry and Dumbledore also talk about Voldemort and the future. In Chamber of Secrets, Dumbledore's office is filmed with so much life that it draws you into the emotional conversation. In Order of the Phoenix, it's dark and depressing. I'd be miserable if my office always looked like that, and I don't care if it looks more cinematic.
Again, you could argue the darker color grading fits the darker information Harry receives. However, I think this is a writing mistake as well. The movie wants to end on an uplifting message: Harry has friends and people he loves, and that's what will let him defeat Voldemort. So the scene shouldn't only be about the prophecy; it should highlight that too. There are many scenes like this, but this is the most glaring example of why I don't love his directing.
The Order of the Phoenix book is slow and overstuffed, which makes it ideal to adapt
If I dislike the director so much, why do I think the movie is better than the book? That's more a reflection of the book than the movie. To me, Goblet of Fire and Order of the Phoenix are complete opposites. They're both very long, and that's the only similarity. Goblet of Fire is a long book but a good one, and adapting a good 750 page book is hard; I don't think Mike Newell did a good job. Order of the Phoenix is even longer, at nearly 900 pages, and it isn't a good book.
The book is so slow, and so many plot lines that aren't important get far too much attention. Hermione's S.P.E.W. storyline is unnecessary. Too much time goes to Quidditch and to Malfoy goading Harry. Cho isn't cut from the movie, but she's much worse in the book, where all she does is cry and make Harry feel awful. The Department of Mysteries climax, in my opinion, has too much going on, and it takes the characters forever to get there.
Because the book is so long and slowly paced, it's the perfect novel to adapt. It's impossible to faithfully fit nearly 900 pages into two and a half hours, so the writers are forced to cut the unnecessary and improve the pacing. The story doesn't need 10 different subplots. There's even a decent character arc for Harry that the movie conveys better because it's better paced. That said, the movie isn't perfect. Beyond the length, I hate the plot and the way most things unfold, so the film's biggest problems stem from the book, while most of its biggest strengths are improvements on it.
The movie tells Harry's arc of isolation more efficiently, helped by Daniel Radcliffe
One directing choice I love is the newspaper montages. So much of the book can be streamlined, and using montages to do it was a clever idea. We don't need to see every new educational decree issued; the montages are more than enough.
The main thing the movie does more effectively is Harry's arc. So much of this story is about his impatience, loneliness and hopelessness. He's left out of the loop at the start, which makes him feel isolated and frustrated. At school, some classmates don't believe him, and Dumbledore is ignoring him. Umbridge's educational decrees isolate him further, and more and more drives him to a breaking point. You could argue the book does this better because we see into his mind. I'd argue the movie is more efficient. The book's subplot where Malfoy goads Harry until he's kicked off the Quidditch team is another instance of isolating him, but at some point it's diminishing returns. We get it: Harry is lonely and miserable.
Credit to Daniel Radcliffe. A big reason the arc works is his performance. I can feel that frustration and impatience without seeing inside his head. The scene where he yells at Dumbledore to look at him is so unlike Harry, but Radcliffe sells it. Maybe I would have liked a bit more of the Room of Requirement training, since Harry is put in a position of authority for the first time, but the movie does enough to show why getting caught is arguably his breaking point. All of this builds to his reckless decision to go to the Ministry of Magic to save Sirius. The book takes forever to get there; the movie sells me on that beat in less time.
Sirius, Luna, Neville and Umbridge work better on screen
Smaller moments mostly found in the movie complement the arc. The Harry and Sirius moments are much more touching on screen. In the book, Sirius is more impatient and frustrated, and that's dropped in the movie, which I like. The scene of Harry and Luna meeting the Thestrals, I don't believe was in the book, and seeing them bond was sweet. There are also nice Harry and Neville moments where they bond over making their parents proud.
The movie can also deliver excellent performances. Umbridge is an excellently written villain, but Imelda Staunton takes her to the next level with nuances a book can't capture. Her Umbridge and Jack Gleeson's Joffrey are the two pinnacle examples of performances so good you can't help but hate every ounce of the character. I'd argue Helena Bonham Carter's Bellatrix is in a similar category. These are arguably the most important parts of the story, and improving on them is the biggest reason I like the movie more.
No adaptation can fix the Ministry's denial of Voldemort's return
No adaptation can fix how much I hate the plot of Order of the Phoenix. I get that it's a story about misinformation and fear, and I like that it's more political, but the Ministry's staunch denial of Voldemort's return is maddening. It should be incredibly easy to prove. I get so frustrated every time Harry is painted as someone seeking attention, because anyone who remotely knows him knows he wouldn't lie about this.
Fine, the Ministry is so terrified that it convinces itself Harry is a liar. I still have two problems. First, was the fallout of Goblet of Fire not discussed? Barty Crouch, someone who I believe was an important person in the Ministry, was killed. Barty Crouch Jr. was caught and confessed to putting Harry's name in the Goblet of Fire, and Dumbledore, McGonagall, Snape and the real Mad-Eye Moody can all vouch for it. He also killed his father. Is the Ministry ignoring all of this? Second, and most importantly, truth serum exists. They use Veritaserum on Cho to get the truth about Dumbledore's Army, so why not use it on Harry or Crouch Jr.? I've looked up fan explanations, and frankly they don't hold up. At some point the Ministry's incompetence becomes comical.
You could say the Ministry isn't well-meaning and is covering things up. But then why does Fudge believe everything once he sees Voldemort with his own eyes? If he were truly covering up the truth, that wouldn't change anything. The idea that Dumbledore would raise an army is also ridiculous, since people think he's weak and a bad leader for Hogwarts. And Dumbledore has no right to tell Harry he's ignoring him to protect him, after using Harry as bait in Goblet of Fire. I passionately hate these parts of the book, and the movie has to adapt them, so I hate them there too.
The movie misses that Harry was manipulated and Sirius was never at the Ministry
There's one critical part the movie gets wrong: the ending to Harry's arc. We buy his reckless decision to save Sirius, but the film misses that Sirius was never at the Ministry and Harry was being manipulated. Watching the movie alone, Harry can't find Sirius, then Sirius shows up minutes later, so it'd be fair to assume he was there all along. In truth, Harry was tricked by Voldemort, and more specifically by Kreacher the house elf, into coming so he could give Lucius the prophecy. Only once Harry was in trouble did Sirius and the Order show up, and then Sirius dies. Harry's impatience and frustration led to Sirius's death. Harry suffered the consequences of his actions.
The final Dumbledore scene was supposed to be mostly about Harry breaking down after realizing how badly he'd messed up, with Dumbledore comforting him and telling him the truth about everything. That develops their relationship, which matters because they spend so much time together in Half-Blood Prince. Instead, we get Dumbledore telling Harry he overcame Voldemort because he has friends and people he loves. It's a fine arc, but I like the book's version much more. This is the first time Harry loses; the Ministry confrontation was a net negative for him. Him losing and feeling responsible is far more interesting than learning the value of love, which earlier entries covered plenty of times. The movie missing that is a real shame.
Two more reasons Hogwarts is unsafe: Umbridge's punishments and sabotaged defense lessons
I've been keeping a list of reasons Hogwarts is unsafe, and it stood at 15. Much of this movie happens outside Hogwarts or anything Hogwarts sponsored, unlike the Triwizard Tournament, which Hogwarts promoted. Everything at the Ministry can't count, so I'm adding only two. Number 16: teachers can torture students. The series takes place in the '90s, but there's no excuse for Umbridge making students cut themselves in detention. That's leagues worse than getting hit with a ruler. If my kids were forced to engrave on their hands that they must not lie, I wouldn't consider taking them out of school. I would do it.
Number 17: the school may sabotage your self-defense. The Ministry doesn't want students practicing Defense Against the Dark Arts because it fears Dumbledore raising an army. There are rumors the Dark Lord has returned, and even if they were false, an army of dark witches and wizards attacked some 15 years earlier, so the class is necessary. Imagine a high school women's self-defense class where the board of education banned physical practice because it feared an army of women rising up. That would be comical and awful. It doesn't matter that the Ministry forced this; if it has that power once, it can happen again.
Order of the Phoenix reception and my ranking
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix scored 78% on Rotten Tomatoes with an 81% audience score. On IMDb it scored 7.5 out of 10, tied for the lowest rated of the first five films. It grossed $938 million at the box office, making it at the time the second highest grossing entry in the franchise and the second highest grossing movie of 2007.
Despite how much it improves on the book, I still don't think it's a great movie. It sits at number four in my ranking of the Harry Potter movies.
What other creators are saying
More on Harry Potter →Hermione is the smarter, more knowledgeable witch, but I think Harry has the edge in a straight duel every time thanks to his natural talent for defensive magic and combat experience. J.K. Rowling herself said Hermione would win early on, but Harry would win from Prisoner of Azkaban onward.
Neville stays put when I hoped he had moved, and his glow up makes him my low key favorite character.
I really hoped Neville wasn't still standing there in Harry Potter, and his glow up won me over →
With the show and The Game Awards both arriving in December, a sequel reveal then makes sense, and if that happens a 2027 release would too, though the Paramount takeover raises questions.
Hogwarts Legacy 2 reveal: could it land with the HBO series? →
Watch the original
@thegoldman25 · YouTube
Adapted with AI from The Gold Man's video of 21 November 2026 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections
More from @thegoldman25
All →Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.
We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.
Become a SubPlotter →

